10 JUNE 1865, Page 22

A Review of the "Vie de JOsus " of M.

Renan. By J. B. Paton, M.A. (H. J. Tresidder.) —The contents of this volume, which have already appeared in The London Quarterly Review, comprise discussions on the doctrine of miracle, the mythical theory, and the authenticity of the Gospels. It is among the best of the more solid refutations of M. Renan's theories, and is written with a moderation and temper which seem, we regret to say, much more common among the Nonconformist clergy than those of the Established Church. The great fault of the book is that it comes too late. The least thoughtful and most violent writers are of course the most rapid ; they occupy the market, and dis- credit the better works which follow them. Besides, men will not go on reading refutations for ever.