17 MARCH 1906, Page 2

Mr. F. E. Smith, in a brilliant maiden speech, did

nob deal with the Resolution, but with the electioneering methods of the Government. Phrases such as "that tabernacle, furrow, or whatever is the temporary rendezvous of the party" did something to lighten a somewhat dull debate. The debate was concluded by Sir Edward Clarke, who warned the Opposition of the danger of an adherence to the policy of Tariff Reform, and declared that he would sooner vote for Home-rule than for a tax on food. With the bulk of his speech we are in hearty agreement, for its underlying inten- tion was distinctly Free-trade. At the same time, we cannot wonder that the Tariff Reformers who supported Sir Edward Clarke at the polls feel somewhat indignant that he did not make his position more clear before the election. It is also a wonder to us how Sir Edward Clarke, feeling as he does, could support Mr. Balfour's candidature in the City. These, how- ever, are matters of private concern, and need not interfere with our satisfaction in welcoming so valuable a recruit to the Free-trade cause.