20 NOVEMBER 1942, Page 20

The Raft and Socrates Asks Why. By Eric Linklater. (Macmillan

4s. 6d.)

Two more conversations in the style of The Cornerstones. The first is carried on in mid-Atlantic by six survivors from a torpedoed ship: the conclusion they reach, that the British are still sound, active and enterprising, is rather spoiled by their high-flown language, which embellishes rather thin thinking In the second,

Socrates in Elysium cross-examines two late arrivals (in the presence of Voltaire, Johnson and Lincoln) on the war and peace aims of the Allies ; and Beethoven intervenes with a reminder of the peace that can be found in the heart of the conflict. Mr. Linklater has a good ear for the style of his different talkers, and he allows his American Sergeant of Marines and Scottish Piper their natural voices ; but again this conclusion seems more hoped-for than fully realised.