24 AUGUST 1929, Page 16

THE EGYPTIAN QUESTION

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—I read with interest your article on the Egyptian Question of August 3rd. Perhaps you will allow me to draw attention to what seems to me to be a valuable feature of the present Treaty Proposals.

It may interest those who are apprehensive of the risk attached to offering the Egyptians such liberal terms to know that these Proposals form an excellent test for Egypt's fitness to enjoy our trust and confidence. As it may almost be assumed that a Treaty based on these Proposals will go through Parliament here, if previously approved by a newly elected Parliament in Cairo, it is clear that, practically, the decision lies in Egyptian hands. If the Egyptians accept these terms, I think it may safely be concluded that Egypt has reached a stage when the risk of such liberal terms is justified ; but if, on the other hand, they reject them, it will show clearly that the present Proposals are premature. The terms them- selves seem to me to provide an ample safeguard against possible misjudgment on our part.—I am, Sir, &c.,

E. W. POLSON NEWMAN. Royal Geographical Society, Kensington Gore, S.W.7.