24 NOVEMBER 1967, Page 24

It's a crime

MAURICE PRIOR

The Case of the Reluctant Model by Erle Stanley Gardner (Heinemann 18s). Perry Mason solves tricky case concerned with true- or-false painting. A blonde witness involved in subsequent slander lawsuit disappears and her disappearance presages murder. Cleverly con- ceived and compact with usual caustic exchanges between Mason and Lieutenant Tragg. Mr Gardner's typical story format and manipulation of plot-execution well up to standard.

The Man Who Died on Friday by Michael Underwood (Macdonald 18s). Very studied and calculated murder mystery in which enthu- siastic young lawyer is briefed to defend Jewish businessman framed for stabbing of middle-aged civil servant. Locale switches from Israel to Old Bailey with realistic trial enact- ment. Tense, absorbing and emphasising Michael Underwood's close acquaintanceship with legal processes. A good read.

The Cat Who Could Read Backwards by Lilian Jackson Braun (Crime Club 16s). Rather implausible but highly original story in

which unoriginal American crime reporter solves, with aid of extremely gifted Siamese cat, murder of his paper's art critic plus two other killings. Accent on cat but well-devised and entertaining. No doubt will appeal to all cat-lovers and even feline-haters might show tolerance.

Smiling the Boy Fell Dead by Michael Delving (Macdonald 16s). Young American dealer in rare hiss arriving in England to make offer for rare script owned by odd Gloucester- shire widow is initiated into bucolic English customs and is suspected of killing yobbo. Falls in love and proceeds to sort out intricate murder puzzle with assurance and skill. Colour- ful, intelligent and fluent writing.

Madrigal by John Gardner (Muller 25s). The cowardly Boysie Oakes is sent to East Berlin to assassinate double agent but is captured by Russians, recruited for them against Chinese, caught by the latter but escapes. Action, diverse characters and situa- tions, some chuckles, and the mixture when taken provides a delectable and stimulating tonic.

The Paris Bit by Irving Marder (Crime Club 16s). Quite a promising debut by this author in which American journalist and gourmet stationed in Paris investigates death of no-good pop singer. Feel story a little too character- laden and author overlooked more vital relevant plot details. French atmosphere apposite and well-maintained.

Justice on the Rocks by Bill Knox (John Long 21s). For the ninth time Thane and his sidekick Moss are associated -with crime- solving. It is gang warfare in Glasgow,

murder with a new weapon, and a new racket introduced. The two tees are quickly on the scent and the case is satisfactorily resolved. Lively, good characterisation, not too much blood-spilling and overall a brisk, workman- like job.