24 SEPTEMBER 1910, Page 26

The Man's Case against 1,000,000 Votes for Women ; The

Man's Case for 1,000,000 Votes for Women. (Hodder and Stoughton. ls. each.)—In these two pamphlets we have the speeches delivered in the debate on the second reading of the "Parlia- mentary Franchise (Women) Bill." We will be content with giving the names of the speakers :—For : D. J. Shackleton, Sir J. Rolleston, E. B. Haldane, A. Lyttelton, Lord Hugh Cecil, Sir A. Spicer, W. H. K. Redmond, E. A. Goulding, J. Keir Hardie, W. McLaren, H. G. Chancellor, A. J. Balfour, Sir Alfred Mond, W. Runciman, and P. Snowden. Against : F. E. Smith, Walter H. Long, Hilaire Belloc, J. Annan Bryce, E. Haviland-Burke, W. E. Guinness, C. H. Lyell, S. H. Butcher, Winston S. Churchill, H. H. Asquith, Arnold Ward, and Austen Chamberlain. These

sides are not unequally matched. •