26 OCTOBER 1929, Page 3

Although he knew all Europe intimately he had a particular

sentiment for India, and his advice was much valued by Lord Morley when he was introducing his reforms. The libel suit which was brought against Chirol by Mr. Tilak on account of statements in .Chirol's well-known book Indian Unrest is well remembered. Chirol might have saved himself much trouble by a formal withdrawal, but he could not permit himself to abandon statements which he felt to be true. He put himself to years of trouble and to much expense in collecting evidence for his defence. The result of the trial was a triumph for him, and the judge congratulated him on his very courageous public service.