29 NOVEMBER 1884, Page 22

Sunday Reading for the Young. (Wells Gardner, Dorton, and Co.)—The

title of this volume, which contains a year's issue of this magazine, sufficiently describes its object. Now and then we observe some slovenliness or inaccuracy, which an editor's hand should have removed ; but, as a whole, the result may be considered satisfactory.

Aunt Judy's Annual Volume. Edited by H. K. F. Gatty. (Bern. roseand Sons.)—This magazine keeps up its quality to its old high

average. ess bulky than some of its rivals, its quality is always excellent. We renew the wishes for its prosperity which it has been our pleasure, as our duty, to express for many years.