30 APRIL 1892, Page 11

The Valley Council. By Percy Clarke. (Sampson Low and Co.)

—This is the first Australian story we remember in which the existence of an unknown State in the middle of a savage desolate country forms the chief feature of the narrative. There is nothing improbable about the origin of the Valley community; it is when its civilisation is described that, as usual in such cases, the author gives the reign to his imagination. This particular vein of the marvellous has been well worked lately ; yet The Valley Council is not wanting in freshness of treatment, and the situation and isolation of the " Valley " by means of which its existence is preserved unknown, reads naturally, and the mystery attaching to the unknown people and their punishment of intruders is sufficiently impressive. One peculiarity of the " Valley" people, their magnified sensitiveness to sound, however, imparts an element of absurdity to the story. As for the elements of Australian bush-life, they form a capital background to the adventure, and with the steady flow of narrative, make the book a readable and attractive story for people of all ages.