31 MARCH 1923, Page 21

Dismiss. By Hilton Brown. (Methuen. 78. 6d. net.)

Though Mr. Hilton Brown is obviously well acquainted with Civil Service conditions in India, he does not know how to write a novel. As a report on the anti-Montagu case, Dismiss has considerable value ; but as a story it is not well constructed and is difficult to read. The book is auto- biographical and covers the whole youth and official career of the principal character, Andrew Allan ; but the author has not the art, which is essential in a novel of limited length which covers a number of years, of selecting the most inter- esting episodes and presenting them in detail. The result is a book containing a superficial account of a great number of events. The character-drawing is poor, and it is, there- fore, difficult to convince the reader of the truth of the pictures presented.