3 JULY 1920, Page 23

[To TEE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."]

have read with interest not unmingled with amusement the irrefutable arguments by which certain of your corre- spondents have proved that "Egret Farms " do not and cannot exist in Sind. In the spring of 1914 I had occasion to vieit_ a small village on the banks of the Indus some 40 miles above Sukkur. - It was a cluster of fishermen's huts of reed and thatch; most of the huts were "Egret• Farms," half the but being the family living room, the other half the egret pen.

Once seen, it formed a picture to live in the memory; the contrast between the dinginess and poverty of the man and his family, and the snow-white plumage of the birds, each worth many rupees. Each pen seemed to contain from thirty to forty birds.

I was informed that the plumes were taken twice yearly, only once a year were they at their best, and then they fetched their weight in gold from the'" bunnies " (Hindu tradesmen) of the market town of Shikarpur.

One or two plumes were removed for my benefit; the birds, tame as chickens, did net object very strenuously, but no doubt their finer feelings were deeply hurt. I shall await with anxiety your correspondents' pronouncement (a) as to the reality of my existence, (b) whether I am a liar, or merely a knave, (c) what percentage of trade profits I receive from the Shikarpur bunnias.—I am, Sir, &c.,

CIVIL SURGEON.