4 JULY 1925, Page 34

THIS is one of the series of Studies in Church

History, and will be welcome because so little has yet been printed about

the Black Friars, while their rivals, the Grey Friars, have long been a favoured subject for historical essays. Unhappily the records of the English province have been completely lost, and Mrs. Formoy has had to make her bricks without straw, except in so far as the records of the Order as a whole are 'concerned with English affairs. It is interesting to learn that the English province showed a marked leaning to indepen- dence and nationalism in the late fourteenth century, in spite of the rigidly international organization of the Order. Mrs. Formoy attributes this to the national character, but it -may

reasonably be attributed to the political isolation of England during the Hundred Years' War, 'which determined its adher- ence to the Roman obedience, while France and the Dominican

Order as a body favoured Avignon. The author is at her best in describing the nunnery for Dominican sisters at Dartford,

and explaining how the nuns, who could hold property, were used by Edward HI. as trustees for the brethren at King's Langley who could not: The proof-reading, especially of proper names and of documents in-Latin, leaves much to be desired, and the book is rather loosely put 'together.