7 DECEMBER 1907, Page 9

With Airship and Submarine. By Harry Collingwood. (Blackie and Son.

6s.)—No reader can complain that there is any lack of marvels here. The "airship " and " submarine " are one and the same, a most wonderful invention which can put a " girdle round the earth" almost as quickly as could Ariel. Perhaps there might have been something more of a plot. We go on from wonder to wonder, but there is none of that suspense which the reader of tales is apt to think his due. But no one can possibly say that With Airship and Submarine is dull.