7 FEBRUARY 1931, Page 28

The title of Sir David Harris's Pioneer, Soldier and Politician

(Sampson Low, 8s. 6d.) is rather more alluring than the contents justify. The author's pioneering mainly consisted in a rapid achievement of a good living as a diamond-broker in the early days of Kimberley, and with the diamond trade he remained intimately and prominently associated throughout his life. His soldiering was of the slightest. But as a politician he was very well known in the Cape Colony in that he repre- sented-both before and after the Union various constituencies in Griqualand West for thirty-two years, and he has thus been able to introduce into his book character-sketches of such leading political figures as Merriman, Jameson, Botha, Hertzog, Smuts and Rhodes. His estimation of the last that he " was one of the most grateful men in the world "will not command universal assent, or his assertion that at Kimberley " such a thing as a colour bar does not exist." Nor can one agree with General Smuts' appraisement in the foreword of the book that " here is the real stuff for history." This volume neither casts

any new light on nor makes any striking addition to South Africa's story, but as a contribution to a South African self- help series it could hardly have been surpassed, even by the late Dr. Samuel Smiles himself. * * * *