11 OCTOBER 1913

Page 1

We must add a line of postscript as to Mr.

The Spectator

Churchill's repeated use of the word " temporary." He speaks, for example, of "the temporary absence of the representation of North-East Ulster" from the Dublin Parliament. This...

We must apologize for insisting so strongly upon the point

The Spectator

just made, but if Unionists do not bear it in mind, and get involved in a general discussion of Home Rule, we may find the door of escape from civil war, which has now been...

Mr. Roosevelt, just before sailing for South America, was entertained

The Spectator

at dinner in New York on Friday week by his Progressive supporters. He explained that he was going to visit Brazil, the Argentine, and Chile, because "the three great...

The Brunswick controversy has broken out again in Germany owing

The Spectator

to the Concerted action of Hanoverian newspapers in asserting that Prince Ernest Augustus, who is now the husband of the Emperor's daughter, has not renounced his rights to the...

At the same time, Liberals who want to avoid civil

The Spectator

war must remember that the Unionist leaders have also a most difficult task before them. Many of their supporters will not quite understand what is being done, and will talk...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

O N Wednesday Mr. Winston Churchill addressed his con- stituents at Dundee in a speech which we trust will prove to be of historic importance. We have dealt at length elsewhere...

We have quoted elsewhere verbatim the most important part of

The Spectator

Mr. Winston Churchill's speech in regard to Ulster. We shall not say anything about the rest. We could not do so with- out controversy, and controversy at the moment is what we...

*,* The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript in any

The Spectator

case.

Page 2

Sir Bampfylde Fuller has a striking letter in Tuesday's Times

The Spectator

on the connexion between the unrest in Bengal and the position of the Indian Civil Service. The attempts now being made to disestablish the Service and break up its solidarity...

Mr. McKenna, in a speech at Pontnewynydd on Tuesday, explained

The Spectator

the nature of an excellent measure which he hopes to pass next session. This will enable poor prisoners who, under existing conditions, are sent to prison in default of paying a...

The unreality of the Portuguese amnesty is exposed in a

The Spectator

despatch from the Lisbon correspondent of the Daily News in Monday's issue. He points out that the liberty, granted to the two hundred and sixty-eight prisoners who took but a...

The trial of a Russian Jew named Beiliss on the

The Spectator

charge of murdering a little Christian boy to obtain blood for ritual purposes opened at Kieff on Wednesday. The indictment is based chiefly on indirect and contradictory...

The Inland Revenue Report for 1912-13 was issued on Friday

The Spectator

week. The failure of the land taxes is by far the The Inland Revenue Report for 1912-13 was issued on Friday week. The failure of the land taxes is by far the most noticeable...

Yuan Shih-kai, who has acted as Provisional President of the

The Spectator

Chinese Republic for nearly two years, was formally elected President for five years on Monday at Peking. Though twenty candidates, including Sun Yat-sen, were voted for, the...

Lord Robert Cecil, addressing a Unionist meeting in North-West Manchester

The Spectator

in support of the candidature of Mr. Hubert M. Wilson, dealt with the controversy between Mr. Lloyd George and members of his family on the Marconi question. The various charges...

Page 3

We are delighted to see from a quotation in the

The Spectator

Daily Mail of Monday that Lord St. Aldwyn, in a letter to the Tewkes- bury Record, has shown, as, of course, we knew he would have no difficulty in showing, how grossly unjust...

Faced with this situation, the Chancellor of the Exchequer began

The Spectator

by suggesting to the War Office that they should buy in another part of England. When they refused, and said in effect that they must have his estate, Lord St. Aldwyn did the...

Note that we are not relying upon the words "unless

The Spectator

the Rouse of Commons direct to the contrary," but upon the use of the word " passed." We hold that the word " passed " in this context means passed through the House of Commons...

Dr. Clifford made a vehement attack on Roman Catholicism at

The Spectator

the meeting of the Baptist Union at Manchester on Thursday week. We quote from the report in the Daily News of Friday the 3rd inst. :— ""The Romanist is asserting,' he cried,...

We publish to-day a remarkable article by Lord Cromer— the

The Spectator

first notice of the Life of Lord Lyons—which is in effect an apology for diplomacy by one who was himself among the ablest of diplomatists. With that apology we are in general...

Sir George Hayter Chubb, the President of the Noncon- formist

The Spectator

UnionistAssociation, asks very pertinently in the Times of Monday whether this is "a reference to the Roman Catholic Nationalists of Ireland who, by the help of Dr. Clifford and...

The Westminster Gazette of Monday, in its most " school-

The Spectator

masterish " tone, reproves the Spectator for its " inexcusable" carelessness in saying that a general election might take place between the passage of the Home Rule Bill for the...

The Spectator

Page 4

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

MR. CHURCHILL'S SPEECH. " When we were drifting into a quarrel with the Boers, Liberal minds sought to understand their point of view, and many—I daresay there are some in this...

Page 5

THE TRIPLE ALLIANCE.

The Spectator

N O student of foreign politics could fail to have his fancy engaged by the analysis of the origin, the intention, and the working of the Triple Alliance which Dr. Friedjung has...

THE COUNTY PALATINE OF BELFAST.

The Spectator

I F Mr. Winston Churchill's offer to exclude North-East Ulster in order to avoid civil war is accepted in principle by the Unionist leaders, as we cannot doubt it will be, it...

Page 6

STRIKES AND SOFT SAWDER.

The Spectator

S IR GEORGE ASKWITH has achieved a remarkable - public reputation throughout the kingdom as an industrial pacifier, but that reputation will hardly be enhanced by the report...

Page 7

THE PROBLEM OF RECRUITING. T HE problem of recruiting for the

The Spectator

regular Army is a subject of eternal discussion, for the authorities are never able to get all the men they want, and are perpetually dissatisfied with a large proportion of the...

Page 9

OLD PHOTOGRAPHS.

The Spectator

O NE of the most envied accompaniments of high birth in the past is becoming almost universal. Almost every- one nowadays is possessed of family portraits. That is, they are...

Page 10

THE BURDEN OF PRESENTS.

The Spectator

AN enterprising shopkeeper issued a catalogue some years ago—and still does so, for all we know—in which lie attempted to make the choosing of Christmas presents easy. Perhaps...

Page 11

OCTOBER IN THE GARDEN.

The Spectator

T HERE is not much difference between the gardens of September and August, but in October the seasons meet. The summer flowers are not all of them over; the winter flowers are...

Page 12

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

ULSTER AND THE UNION. [TO TEE EDITOR OF TILE " SFRCTATOR.1 SIR, —One fact emerges clearly from the more recent speeches of the Unionist and Nationalist leaders in Ireland. Sir...

PEERS AND THE PARLIAMENT BILL.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR. "] Sin,—In your issue of last Saturday Lord Ebury challenges the last paragraph of my letter in the Spectator of this previous week as being...

THE PROBLEM OF CIVIL WAR.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR."] Stn,—I have read with great interest the article in your current issue headed " The Problem of Civil War." I fear that our views do not...

COERCION OF ULSTER BILL.

The Spectator

[To TIE EDITOR OP THE "13PRCTATOR."] SIR, —Radicals are constantly quoting the Union of South Africa as a precedent for and as being analogous to Home Rule for Ireland....

Page 13

THE GOVERNMENT AND MONEY.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or THE "SPECTATOR. "] Sin,—Many Liberals agree with the Spectator that the uneasy suspicions generated by the Marconi affair can only be dis- pelled by measures...

THE LIBERAL INVESTMENT IN RAILWAY SHARES.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SFECTATOR."1 Stn,—I do not accept as a fact the latest amazing financial scandal which Mr. Maxse claims to have unearthed. We have yet to bear from the...

THE DANGER IN THE NEAR EAST.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR. " ] SIR,—The policy of the Young Turks towards the Christians in Turkey was the cause of the first. Balkan war ; that of the Bulgarians towards...

Page 14

THE ABSENCE OF WHEELS IN NATURE. [To THE EDITOR OF

The Spectator

THE " SPECTATOR. "] Sin, — An interesting point is raised by a remark in your article on " Fancy Flying. " " Nature has not put any of her brute creatures on wheels, nor given...

HORACE ' S ADVICE TO TURKEY. [To THE EDITOR OF THE "

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.] Sia,—The following Sorg Horatiana seems appropriate to latest demands of Turkey :— " interfusa nitentes Vites aequora Cycladas," which a Greek has thus translated...

THE LAND UNION.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR. " ] Sia, — The Land Union has up to the present, in spite of repeated applications, considered it undesirable to define its attitude in regard...

Page 15

THE OPIUM VICE IN JAVA.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF TEE " SPECTATOR."1 Sin,—A few facts on this subject might be of interest to your readers. The chief vice of the inhabitants of Java is opium-smoking. The...

ON CRIBS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF TEE "SPECTATOR. "] SI11, — A man's social standing may be judged with tolerable accuracy by the cut of his clothes, and the same is true, in some degree, with...

" TOTTENHAM IN HIS BOOTS."

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or THE "SPECTATOR.") Sin,—As a connexion, by marriage, of the family of "Tottenham in his boots," perhaps I may be allowed to contribute an exact version of the...

CANALS AND THE STATE.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE "Sesorwroit."; Sin,—Mr. Acworth has written to you a letter on " Canals and the State," and, quoting the example of the Manchester Ship Canal, doubts the...

Page 16

CHARLES LAMB INSTITUTE. [To THE EDITOR OP THE "SPECTATOR."] SIB,—About

The Spectator

five years ago an influential committee was formed for the purpose of inaugurating a memorial to Charles Lamb, the essayist and author, who lived and died in Edmonton, and lies...

A " MAGPIE " BLACKBIRD.

The Spectator

[To Tag EDITOR OF TER " SracTATon."] Stn,—In his letter on "A Village School Competition," I. E. Page speaks of a white blackbird which came under the heading of things not...

SONGS, NAVAL AND MILITARY.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR "] BIR,—As the writer of the article on " Songs, Naval and Military," which appeared in your issue of September 20th, I wish to express my...

HIGH PHEASANTS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE "SPECTATOR."] SIR,—In the review of Sir Ralph Payne-Gallwey's " High Pheasants in Theory and in Practice" which appeared in your issue of October 4th, the...

APHAERESIS.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR Or THE "SPECTATOR. "] SIR,—The interesting instance of aphaeresis in your columns a week or two ago (amore) might have finished with " e corde pleno : wth full...

NOTICE.—When "Correspondence" or Articles are signed with the writer's name

The Spectator

or initials, or with a pseudonym, or are marked "Communicated," the Editor must not necessarily be held to be in agreement with the views therein espreered or with the mode of...

Page 17

ART.

The Spectator

SPANISH PAINTING AT THE GRAFTON GALLERY. THE activity of the National Art Collections Fund has enabled us to survey Spanish painting from the thirteenth to the nineteenth...

POETRY.

The Spectator

A BALLAD OF PLACE-NAMES. I'vz stood beneath the fall of Glora ; I've roamed amid the bents at Brora ; I've seen the level meads expand At Matlaske and at Irming- land ; But...

Page 18

BOOKS.

The Spectator

LORD LYONS.* [FIRST NcyncE.] LORD LYONS was not a man of 'genius. It cannot even be said that he possessed any very conspicuously brilliant talents. But he was a great...

Page 20

THE EMPRESS FREDERICK.*

The Spectator

• The Empress Frederick : a Memoir. With 6 Illustrations in Photogravure, London : James Nisbet and Co. [15e. net.] IT was a happy thought of the anonymous author of this work...

Page 21

LIVINGSTONE AND NEWSTEAD.*

The Spectator

THE principal object of this volume is to tell the peaceful story of the eight months which David Livingstone spent at Newstead Abbey during the years 1864 and 1865. Living-...

Page 22

THE NATAL REBELLION.* OAPTAIN STUART, who, in addition to his

The Spectator

military experience, bad served as tin Aesistant-Secretary for Native Affairs, wag instructed by the Natal Government to prepare a history of the Zulu Rebellion of 1906. When...

Page 23

SOME QUESTIONS OF THE DAY.*

The Spectator

NOT only the Evangelical party, of which the Dean of Canterbury is a veteran leader, but the whole Church of England, owes a debt of gratitude to the writer of this volume for...

Page 24

SWISS CHALET INSCRIPTIONS.*

The Spectator

IN spite of the great and increasing number of Englishmen Who visit Switzerland yearly, and must feel at least a passing interest in the carved inscriptions with which houses,...

THE GADFLY AT WORK.*

The Spectator

" LIBERTY is the right to be in the wrong." Mr. Norman calls this the finest definition of liberty. Why then does he so impartially blame everyone for differing from him? The...

Page 25

FICTION.

The Spectator

THE LODGER• STORIES concerned with mysterious crimes for the most part focus the interest of the reader on the efforts to detect the perpetrators, the really prominent roles...

THE FAILURE OF AMERICAN LAW.*

The Spectator

THERE have just appeared two books by American writers which almost justify the Englishman in taking up the attitude of the Pharisee and expressing thanks that be is not as...

Page 26

Pierrot in. Town. By Helen Ashton. (Sir Isaac Pitman and

The Spectator

Sons. 6s.)—It cannot be denied that Miss Ashton has an unusual sense of the poetic. The central idea of her book is far from prosaic: so is the figure of Anatole (Pierrot) the...

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

[Under this heading we notice such Books of the week as have not beef► reserved for review in other forms.] Cecil Rhodes : the Man and his Work. By Gordon Le Sueur. (John...

READABLE NOVELS.—The Lure of the Elate Drum. By Margaret Peterson.

The Spectator

(Andrew Melrose. 6s.) — A rather unpleasant story of Indian' life, with a melodramatic native villain, a multitude of adverbs, and a young man who, "plunging both hands in his...

Hoofeng Lao Jen : Letters on the Chinese Constitution. By

The Spectator

Sir Francis Piggott. (Butterworth and Co. 3s. net.)—This, little volume contains a series of letters contributed by Sir F. Piggott, late Chief Justice of Hong Kong, to Chinese...

The Ireland of To-day. (John Murray. 10s. 6d. net.)—We welcome

The Spectator

the reprint in a permanent form of the eontents . .of the " Special Irish Number '•' of the Times, which appeared-on March 17th of this year. Two or three articles have been...

The Plain Man and His Wife. By Arnold Bennett.. (Hodder

The Spectator

and Stoughton. 2s. 6d. net.)—It is a little difficult to understand why Mr. Bennett thinks it worth while to- publish these uninspiring though well-intentioned little sermons....

Histoire de Canada. By Francois Xavier Garnean, revue et annotee

The Spectator

par Hector Garneau. Tome I. (Librairie FeliX Alcan, Paris. 10fr.)—M. Garneau's grandson has revised and brought up to date this well-known work and secured an interesting...

Buddhist Stories. By Paul Dahlke. Translated by the Bhikku Silacara.

The Spectator

(Kegan Paul, Trench, and Co. 3s. 6d. net.)—It is a pity that the translator of Mr. Dahlke's collection of Buddhist stories should here and there have attempted to reproduce the...

Page 27

BOOKS OF REFERENCE.—Mtemay's Handbook for Travellers in Scotland. Edited by

The Spectator

Scott Moncrieff Penney. (Edward Stanford. 10s. 6d.)—It is ten years since the last edition of the Guide was published, and the present one, which is the ninth, shows signs of a...