12 NOVEMBER 1937

Page 1

NEWS OF THE WEEK

The Spectator

R AMSAY MACDONALD may have been a controversial figure, but he was a great figure. Starting life with no single .advanrage in his . favour; he achieved in 1924 and 193i...

Contacts with Germany - The statement made by Lord Halifax

The Spectator

regarding a possible visit to Berlin, together with the German and Italian comments on the Prime Minister's speech at the Lord Mayor's banquet on Tuesday ; bring the question of...

The Chinese Retreat The attempt of the Chinese at Shanghai

The Spectator

to hold the Soochow Creek was decisively 'frustrated this week, largely through the landing of 30,000 Japanese at Chapei, which turned the Chinese lines from the South. Though...

Page 2

The Films Bill The second reading of the Government's Films

The Spectator

Bill was taken last week ; and Parliament has little time to give the measure its final form, as important provisions of the existing Act expire next March. The new Bill is...

Danzig_ Over a week ago Herr Forster, the Nazi leader

The Spectator

and virtual ruler of Danzig, announced that the " Free City " would be completely assimilated to Germany ; and indeed Danzig is already in fact a completely National Socialist...

The Air Raid Precaution Controversy The long-drawn controversy between the

The Spectator

Government and local authorities over the division of the cost of air raid precautions is cut short by the Government's decision to introduce a Bill into Parliament next week...

A New Turkish Cabinet The resignation of General Ismet InOnii,

The Spectator

announced several weeks ago by Kemal Ataturk, from the post of Prime Minister of the Turkish Republic has given rise to many rumours ; it is asserted especially that...

The Commons and Finance The House of Commons on Tuesday

The Spectator

debated a question of procedure whose technicality somewhat obscures its importance ; for it affects both the House of Commons' control of the executive and the Crown's right of...

Page 3

Five years ago Mr. Clement Davies, K.C., having attained membership

The Spectator

of that select band known to newspaper readers as " eminent counsel," abandoned the Bar for the board- room. As he himself has been known to express it, he is now engaged in...

The desire having been expressed in different quarters that the

The Spectator

article " Nationalism and God," which appeared in The Spectator of October 22nd, should be reprinted, arrangements have been made for that to be done. Reprints are obtainable...

The lawyers have had two field days. Last Friday on

The Spectator

Mr. Holmes' Inheritance Bill no fewer than eight barristers (practising and dormant) and one solicitor succeeded in catching the Speaker's eye. On Monday, when the House...

The Unemployment Figures The increase of over fifty thousand in

The Spectator

the number of the unemployed in October is not surprising, and should certainly not necessarily be taken as a signpost pointing to depression. The change is almost wholly...

The Week in Parliament Our Parliamentary Correspondent writes : The

The Spectator

underlying unity of the House, of Commons is always most apparent on the death of one of its leading members. Even those who had no personal acquaintance with the dead man, and...

The Christmas " Spectator " Next week's i s sue of The

The Spectator

Spectator will be a special Christ- mas number of 120 pages, containing in addition to all usual features a series of articles on the general theme " Reaching the Public." The...

It was probably a mistake on the part of the

The Spectator

Labour Party to spend so much time attacking the decision to send commercial agents to those Spanish territories which are now under the control of General Franco. Even under...

Family Inheritance Many will probably sympathise with the Attorney-General's definition

The Spectator

of the attitude of the Government to the Inheritance (Family Provisions) Bill—as one of " strict non-intervention." The object of the Bill, which received a second reading last...

Page 4

FROM AXIS TO TRIANGLE

The Spectator

W HAT change, if any, does Italy's adhesion to the anti-Comintern Pact concluded a year ago between Japan and Germany make in the international situation ? If the document is to...

Page 5

PRISON AND PUNISHMENT

The Spectator

T HE series of articles on prison conditions which have been published in the last six issues of The Spectator may, whatever their faults or virtues, claim at least to be...

Page 6

One thing must be added. It would be very unfair

The Spectator

to judge Ramsay MacDonald by his third and last Premiership, particularly by its closing days. For most of that time he was an ill and worn-out man. It was very different in...

A SPECTATOR'S NOTEBOOK

The Spectator

N O one, I imagine, however critical of Mr. Ramsay MacDonald, could fail to be attracted by some sides of him. Many were attracted by many sides. I have seen him in a variety of...

The adventures of a rare volume. (True ; it happened

The Spectator

last week.) Bought on Friday by A. for £2 los. Sold on Saturday by A. to B. for £3 los. Bought back on Monday from B. by A. for £4 ros. Sold on Tuesday by A. to C. for £6 los....

MacDonald was very human—no one can doubt that who has

The Spectator

read his moving biography of his wife—both in his weaknesses and his virtues, and the vicissitudes of his career meant the breaking of many friendships. There was a time when...

A competition for examples of compressed inaccuracy would be well

The Spectator

worth organising. My own entry would consist of seventeen words from Zigzag, the autobiography of W. F. R. Macartney : " Colonel Hyam, a Canadian railroad man. now head of the...

How many stern unbending teetotallers listened in to the "

The Spectator

wine " broadcast last Saturday there is no means of knowing. But not many of them, I imagine, sent in protests. There was nothing to protest about, except a most abysmal...

A good deal of interesting information about conditions in Germany

The Spectator

came my way the other day through a channel which I need not specify. It includes, among other things, a remarkable testimony to the efficiency of the Moscow radio, which...

Page 7

RAMSAY MACDONALD

The Spectator

By MARY AGNES HAMILTON D RAMA was, although he would never admit it, the breath of MacDonald's nostrils. He loved movement, pageantry, colour, crisis. To the last he expected,...

Page 8

A NUTRITION POLICY

The Spectator

By VISCOUNT ASTOR T HE world is beginning to be educated in the matter of nutrition ; but beginning only. No doubt two or three generations ago medical men accepted as satis-...

Page 9

THE IMMORTAL HERITAGE

The Spectator

By SIR ARNOLD WILSON, M.P. T WENTY years have passed since the Imperial War Conference accepted a proposal, drafted by Sir Fabian Ware and placed before it by the Prince of...

Page 10

THE VOICE OF UNDER THIRTY-V

The Spectator

[The writer, whose age is 25, took up professional work in London after coming down from Oxford but decided to take orders, and has since done so.] W E belong to an age which...

Page 11

THE CARLISLE WAY WITH DRINK

The Spectator

By J. 'J. MALLON O N the coming of age of the experiment in Public Ownership of Liquor in the Carlisle area this month, Mr. Lloyd George in an impressive letter has called...

Page 12

RATS AND WEEDS

The Spectator

By S. L. BENSUSAN T T seems a pity that, while the Government is giving whole- hearted hearted consideration to the problems of Agriculture and has attempted with certain...

Page 13

ROOF TOPS

The Spectator

By MICHAEL LANGLEY I WAS once in a town in the heart of Turkey where one could walk for miles over the roofs of the bazaars by a network of paths which corresponded to the...

Page 14

MARGINAL COMMENTS

The Spectator

By A. L. ROWSE W HAT an extraordinary institution the Public Record Office is ! I do not mean from the point of view of the general public. To the ordinary man in the street I...

Page 15

Commonwealth and Foreign

The Spectator

SOUTH AMERICA'S INDIANS By SYBIL VINCENT " W HAT are you going to do about your Indian problem?" Interview a South American statesman and this is the one question he hopes you...

Page 16

STAGE AND SCREEN

The Spectator

THE THEATRE Forbes-Robertson OF all the actors I have followed, Forbes-Robertson most consistently revealed in every part his peculiar quality. That does not mean that he was...

THE CINEMA

The Spectator

"The Spanish Earth." At the Acidealy FEW films of fact have ever surpassed the nobility and dignity Of The Spanish Earth. As its majestic panorama of human suffering, human...

Page 17

INTERNATIONALE JAGDAUSTELLUNG

The Spectator

[Von einem deutschan Korrespon1entea] DIE letzte Jagdausstellung fand vor 27 Jahren, also noch im tiefsten Frieden, in Wien statt. Kehler der damaligen Tell- nehmer hat wohl...

MUSIC Toscanini and Boulanger

The Spectator

IF I do not add my full measure to the superlatives that have been heaped at Signor Toscanini's feet since his performances of Beethoven's first and last Symphonies last week,...

Page 18

COUNTRY LIFE

The Spectator

November Blooms A neighbour of mine has Cultivated the habit of making a census of flowers in the first week of November. The list usually contains about fifty names. This...

Decorative Nightshade

The Spectator

The nightjar suggests the nightshade. An account reaches me from a correspondent in Winnipeg, where newspapers comment yearly on the vanloads of the woody nightshade that are...

Waiting for Frost The wild flowers are like the tame,

The Spectator

you could pick a barrow, load of bladder campion and white dead nettle.; and in one spot where garden flowers have strayed the bank is bright with evening primrose. I do not...

A Saved Headland

The Spectator

It was cheering to hear this week that the approaches to Morte Point in North Devon have been permanently saved, through local generosity and the National Trust. Some of us have...

The Nesting Nightjar A discussion has been in progress over

The Spectator

the nesting habit of that attractive bird, the nightjar (whose song incidentally has been admirably recorded for the gramophone). The bird stays in England a very short time. It...

A Parental Fox An ex-soldier, with whom I was discussing

The Spectator

the opening of the hunting season and the excessive earliness of the cubbing season, told me a strange and moving tale of a pair of foxes in the Great War. The unhappy . vixen...

A Poetic Month

The Spectator

Under the inspiration of the recent beauty of the weather prizes have been offered for a poetic address to November in eight lines. The sort of response will perhaps be...

Page 19

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR, —Major Adult's artieles have

The Spectator

given much fOod for thought: I should like to lay stress on the need that 'prison industries should be of economic Value. When last I visited • young prisoners, the "...

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR,—I have read with

The Spectator

profound interest the series of articles written by Mr. Athill. Any ex-prisoner knows that in spite of Prison Commissioners being personally humane, the system itself is so...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

The Spectator

[Correspondents are requested to keep their letters as brief as is reasonably possible. The most suitable length is that of one of our " News of the Week " paragraphs. Signed...

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Whilst I do not

The Spectator

wish to deny Mr. Charles Prior's criticism.; about certain prison visitors, may I beg him and those who read his letter not to believe that all prison visitors are either sexual...

Page 20

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—May " Twenty " reply to " Twenty-four " ? There are various explanations of the general conditions in which Fascism arises, but none of these are sufficient to explain...

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] Sta,—The writer of the

The Spectator

third article in this series is stated to be a director of a London business firm, aged 24. Would it be presumptuous to enquire whether in his capacity of director, i.e.,...

THE VOICE OF UNDER THIRTY

The Spectator

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Pagc 737 in your issue of October 29th naturally attracted my attention, and copies of it have been sent me by a number of members of Toc...

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

you allow a brief paraphrase of your third con- tributor's article ? He was brought up in the traditional English respect for religion, but it never went very deep, and...

Page 21

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR, — Your " Under Thirties

The Spectator

" may be young in age, bu: are certainly antique in thought. Here is " No. IV " declaring her belief in a God " who is the totality of the universe," and advocating as a guide...

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sta,—I admit I was asking for it ! Even the clumsy sabre- rattling of the incumbent of Bodham Rectory has been able to prick my skin in one place. Judged by my article—" The...

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR, — As it is quite

The Spectator

obvious to all that there are good and bad., wise and foolish, intelligent and stupid amongst those both- under and over thirty, it is difficult to see what possible interest...

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sta,—I am in profound sympathy with the woman who wrote " The Voice of Under Thirty—IV." I suspect that she will come in for criticism in your next issue, and so I wish to...

THE PRICE OF BACON

The Spectator

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR, — The article on " The Price of Food " in your issue of October 22nd, states that " bacon is dear very largely because Danish supplies...

Page 22

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sta,—The sentiments expressed in the article under the above heading are worthy of sympathetic hearing, but there are one or two points that may bear a little further scrutiny...

THE RIGHT WAY WITH DRINK

The Spectator

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR,—It is difficult to understand on what grounds, social, material, or ethical, the writer of the article in your last issue on " The Right...

NATIONAL PARKS

The Spectator

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Sir Francis Acland was evidently in a somewhat skittish mood when he wrote the letter which you published on October 29th. I doubt...

Page 23

AIR RAIDS AND THE PUBLIC

The Spectator

' [To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] _ Sm,—With one clause of your Special Correspondent's grave article I find myself in cordial agreement ; when he says " so far much too...

" BY ORDER OF THE SHAH "

The Spectator

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR —My attention his been called to the review of a book, By Order of the Shah, contained in your issue of October rsth, _ 1937. This review...

WILL GOLD DEPRECIATE ?

The Spectator

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] Sta,—I am glad to find that Dr. Einzig and I are at least in agreement that expansion is not always and inevitably the best policy for the...

OVERWORKED BOYS

The Spectator

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] Sm,—Mr. Butcher, the Liberal National Member for Holland- with-Boston, is to be congratulated upon his maiden speech in the Debate on the...

Page 24

BOOKS OF THE DAY

The Spectator

Ends and Means (Honor Croome) . 85i _ Science and Music (C. E. M. Joad) . . .. 853 A.E. (J. M. Hone) .. .. 854 Von Hugel and Tyrrell (Evelyn Underhill) .. 854 The Colonial...

Page 25

SOUND

The Spectator

IF you strike a dozen single notes at random on the piano, they produce effects of which the sciences of physics and physiology between them could in theory give an exhaustive...

Page 26

A. E.

The Spectator

A Memoir of A. E. By John Eglinton. (Macmillan 7s. 6d) - The Living Torch. By A. E. Edited by Monk Gibbon. (Mac- millan. its. 6d.) Mn. JOHN EGLINTON, the Irish essayist and...

PROPHET AND SEER

The Spectator

THE surviving personal friends either of Baron von Hugel or of Father Tyrrell, and all who were in any way concerned in the religious crisis in which they played so great a...

Page 28

AN AUSTRALIAN APPRAISES DOWNING STREET

The Spectator

The Colonial Office. A History. By Henry L. Hall, Ph.D. (Longmans. its. 6d.) DR. HALL'S history of the Colonial Office, which he brought to completion as a Research Scholar of...

Page 30

ENGLAND SURVEYED ONCE MORE

The Spectator

An Irishman's England. By J. S. Collis. (Cassell. 7s. 6d.) MR. COLLIS comes from a casual, impulsive, religious, ignorant, naturally cultured country to a country businesslike...

OXFORD IN TRANSITION

The Spectator

Oxford Limited. By Keith Briant. (Michael Joseph. Pas. 6d.) MR. BRIANT has only recently come down from the University. He edited The his in 1936, and of the people who were up...

Page 32

CORNO DI BASSETTO

The Spectator

London Music in 1888-89, as heard by Como di Bassetto (later known as Bernard Shaiv). With some further Autobiographical Particulars. (Constable. 75. 6cl.) HE never missed...

Page 34

ROOF-TOPS OF CAMBRIDGE

The Spectator

The Night Climbers of Cambridge. By " Whipplesnaith." (Chatto and Windus. 7s. 6d.) IT is generally supposed that the colleges of our two great university cities are no more than...

BALZAC OUT OF LOVE

The Spectator

The Unpublished Correspondence of Honore de Balzac and Madame Zulma Carraud. (Bodley Head. iss.) THIS is not one of the great romantic letter cycles of the world, "bin for that...

Page 36

FICTION

The Spectator

By FORREST REID (Golden Cockerel Press. 8s. 6d.) RALPH Fox was killed fighting in the International Column before Madrid. He had already published three or four Books —among...

Page 38

A DIPLOMATIC HISTORY OF THE UNITED STATES By Samuel Flagg

The Spectator

Bemis This book (Cape, 25s.) is especially timely, since President Roosevelt has seemed to betray hankerings after Wilsonian idealism and intervention in world affairs....

A PLAIN TALE FROM THE BOGS By Rearden Conner

The Spectator

Mr. Rearden Conner has had rather a wretched time and wants to tell everyone about it. He was persecuted by his schoolfellows in Dublin because his father was a Government...

IRAQ : A STUDY IN POLITICAL DEVELOPMENT By Philip Willard

The Spectator

Ireland, Ph.D. Dr. Ireland has made a most pains- taking and elaborate study (Jonathan Cape, 15s.) of the highly involved series of events connected with Iraq since the War,...

CURRENT LITERATURE

The Spectator

SOCIALISM VERSUS CAPITALISM By A. C. Pigou Professor Pigou's contribution (Mac- millan, 4s. 6d.) to the debate summarised in his title is less academic, but not less...

THE FIRST AMERICAN REVOLUTION By jack Hardy This interesting little

The Spectator

book (Lawrence and Wishart, 3s. 6d.) is a Communist exposition not only of the course, but of the lessons of the American Revolution. Although the lesson is not rubbed in, one...

Page 40

INVESTORS AND U.S. TRADE On the war risk question I

The Spectator

must leave investors to make up their own minds. Informed City views are still hopeful, although nobody can pretend to be sure. The trade risk is scarcely less difficult to...

Venturers' Corner

The Spectator

It is surely a grim commentary on the state of speculative markets that so excellent a report as that of John I. Thorny- croft, the shipbuilders, marine engineers and commercial...

OVER 5 PER CENT.

The Spectator

If our thesis is correct that interest rates are likely to remain low and internal trade is not likely to suffer any really severe recession, it follows that industrial...

• A DEBENTURE LIST Meantime, it may safely be assumed

The Spectator

that the search will be intensified for good stocks in the fixed interest group which offer ample cover, but something more generous in the way of income yield than the meagre 3...

WISE INVESTMENT

The Spectator

FuLt marks for the gilt-edged market, but Gamma minus for commodities and most of the speculative groups of equity shares. It is good to see the Cheap Money flag flying so...

Page 42

FINANCE

The Spectator

THE RALLY IN GILT-EDGED SECURITIES THE slump in Atherican securities and in commodities and, indeed, the general depression in the City during the last few weeks, have been...

Page 43

COMPANY MEETING

The Spectator

LONDON MARITIME INVESTMENT SIR F. VERNON THOMSON ON THE SHIPPING POSITION THE Fortieth Annual Ordinary General Meeting of London Maritime Investnient Company, Limited, was...

Page 44

* * * * THE New CAPITAL.

The Spectator

The new capital is to consist of 2,000,000 LI 5 per cent. Redeemable Cumulative Preference shares, the issue being made to pay for very large extensions to buildings and plant...

A GOOD INDUSTRIAL REPORT.

The Spectator

To the many satisfactory industrial reports issued during the past week may be added the preliminary figures published by John I. Thomyca-oft and Co., the marine and motor...

A WELCOME RECOVERY.

The Spectator

The material rise in profits of Brown, Bayley's Steel Works, noticeable a year ago, has made further progress and enables the company, after a lapse of something like sixteen...

FINANCIAL NOTES

The Spectator

HAWKER SIDDELEY PROGRESS. JUDGING from the latest report of Hawker Siddeley Aircraft Company, I should say that the new capital for which the company is shortly seeking powers...

KENT ELECTRIC ISSUE.

The Spectator

It is indicative of the keen demand for high-class investment securities that although the issue recently announced of £2,000,000 in 31 per cent. Debenture stock at 96 per cent....

SHIPPING PROSPECTS.

The Spectator

At the recent annual general meeting of the London Maritime Investment Co., Ltd., Mr. Percy Cross, in the absence through indisposition of the Chairman, Sir F. Vernon Thomson,...

SOLUTION TO CROSSWORD NO. 267

The Spectator

IGI BI I IL MAI L T/T1 El Till 131 NI I' HI AI Eat! R NI AI T LILTI XI 14 71 1 1 . ..S. SRI I I N DI El P R E LI AINI CI AI SI TI - R AhiTh A A NI CI I EI E NI , S 1"CII...

" THE SPECTATOR CROSSWORD No. 268

The Spectator

Br ZENo to . prize of a Book Token for one guinea will be given to the sender of the first correct solu tionof this week's crossword puzzle to be opened. Envelopes should be...