16 MAY 1914

Page 1

Meantime the fourth British officer, whose name is not dis-

The Spectator

closed, had, with the help of a chowkidar, carried in Captain Brown, and, though himself unarmed, had again gone out and assisted Major Dodd into safety. Both Major Dodd and...

The papers of Tuesday published the results of the second

The Spectator

ballots in the French elections. The Socialists will have • hundred and two members in the Chamber, as against sixty- seven in the last Parliament. This increase of Socialist...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

T HERE is little to record in foreign affairs, except that Friday morning's news indicates that Tampico has at last fallen into the hands of the Constitutionalists. The fight...

Full details of the terrible affair at Tank, on the

The Spectator

North- West Frontier, when three British officers and three natives were killed by a native orderly, are given in the _Englishman of April 22nd, and reproduced in the Morning...

The French advance to Taza, in Morocco, has been success-

The Spectator

fully accomplished, and the Times, when reporting this affair on Tuesday, also published from its correspondent at Tangier a review of French progress in Morocco. The French...

Speaking at Auckland, New Zealand, on Tuesday, Sir Ian Hamilton

The Spectator

said that Australia and New Zealand were taking extraordinary precautions for defence, because distances were being shortened every day, and the Pacific was "the meeting....

' The Washington correspondent of the Times said in Thurs-

The Spectator

day's paper that refugees from Mexico are anxious about the Panuco and Touila oilfields at Tampico. They fear that the wells for want of attention may soon begin to pour oil...

*: The Editors cannot undertak to return Manuscript ir. any

The Spectator

case.

Page 2

We have dealt elsewhere so fully with the Irish situation

The Spectator

that we shall do no more here than chronicle the movement amongst a section of Liberals which boa been pompously described as a Liberal" revolt" On Thursday a deputation of the...

Mr. G. H. Roberts, the Labour Member for Norwich, opposed

The Spectator

the measure as "unwarrantably interfering with the just liberties of a great class of deserving citizens," maintain- ing that the real impulse behind the Bill was prohibition....

On Tuesday in the Commons Mr. Asquith made an important

The Spectator

statement of his intentions. He moved to dispense with the Committee stages of the Home Rule, Welsh Church, and Plural Voting Bills. He abandoned all notion of amend- ing the...

In the Commons yesterday week Mr. T. Davies moved the

The Spectator

second reading of the Sunday Closing Bill, which sought to reduce the hours of sale of intoxicants to four in London and three outside, to increase the minimum distance for the...

In the House of Commons on Thursday the Government had

The Spectator

an unpleasant reminder of the precarious nature of their position. There was under discussion the. Prime Minister's motion to suspend the eleven o'clock rule in regard to the...

Mr. Bonar Law has been blamed for being unsympathetic, but,

The Spectator

in our opinion, most unfairly. The operative part of his speech shows that he has no sort of intention of wrecking an Exclusion settlement, provided, of course, that it Will do...

We are glad to see that the British Weekly stands

The Spectator

firmly to its previous declaration on the subject of the time-limit. That declaration has been ignored by most of the Liberal Press, but the Star sought to discount it as...

Sir Thomas Whittaker contributes an interesting footnote to the inner

The Spectator

history of the Bill in a letter to the Westminster Gazette, which had described the proposals as " drastic," and owned to feeling no regret at the rejection of the second...

On Monday in the House of Commons Mr. Lloyd George

The Spectator

announced two changes in the Budget. The tax on unearned incomes between £300 and £500, instead of being raised from Is. 2d. to ls. 4d., is to remain at Is. 2d.; and on unearned...

Page 3

Cobbett's views on economics and the freedom of the indi-

The Spectator

vidual are much at a discount just now, but the following remarks—to be found on the last page of a cheap reissue of the Rural Rides just published by Nelson and Sons (6d. net)—...

Monday's papers publish the Report of a deputation, consisting of

The Spectator

four Unionists and four Liberals, which left Manchester for Cork on the 2nd inst. and returned on the 10th. The deputation, who visited Cork, Youghal, Queens- town, Bandon,...

Much interest has been caused during the week by the

The Spectator

working model of a "flying train" which the inventor, M. Bachelet, is showing in London. Primarily it is intended for conveying postal packets, and it is suggested that a speed...

Whatever doubt may be cast on the credentials of these

The Spectator

four Manchester Liberals, the facts on which the Report they have signed is based are unassailable. An even more notable sign of the awakening of the Liberal conscience comes...

The vacancy at Grimsby caused by the death of Sir

The Spectator

George Doughty has been filled by the return of the Unionist candidate. Polling took place on Tuesday, the figures being: Mr. T. G. Tickler (U.), 8,471; Mr. A. Bannister (L.),...

Bank Rate, S per cent., changed from 4 per cent.

The Spectator

Jan. 29th. Consols (20 were on Friday 74—Friday week 74g.

The question of the relation of the Press and gambling

The Spectator

was discussed at the Dublin Yearly Meeting of the Society of Friends. From the report which appears in the Friend of the 8th inst. we learn that the subject was introduced by...

Page 4

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

A TRIANGULAR WAR. Fro the dull, commonplace mind of the Saxon the notion 1 of a triangular battle has always presented con- siderable difficulties. He is inclined to think that...

Page 6

THE MARK OF THE TYRANT.

The Spectator

filHERE is an infallible mark by which you may know 1 tyrants and men of tyrannical temper. It is the blind rage into which they fall when their will is crossed— when they find...

Page 7

THE LIMITS TO THE POWERS OF GOVERNMENT.

The Spectator

W E have already written at too great length on the theme of Mr. Ward's gasconading pamphlet. We must, however, before we leave the train of thought which it has set in motion,...

THE WAR RISKS OF SHIPPING.

The Spectator

O N Wednesday in the House of Commons the familiar but important subject of the dangers run by merchant shipping in war, and the consequent risks to the whole food supply of the...

Page 8

THE " DEAD HAND" OF 'flit STATE.

The Spectator

Times is to be congratulated on the series of JL articles it is now publishing upon the manner in which the " dead hand' of the State has arrested the development of the...

Page 10

ARGUMENT IN VERSE.

The Spectator

I N his singularly interesting address to the English Asso- ciation on Friday week Mr. Balfour discussed the value of poetry as a vehicle of argument or controversy. It is not...

THE PRIME OF LIFE.

The Spectator

T "" prime of life" is one of those elastic terms which literature does not help us to make definite. Swift spoke of a man of twenty-eight as already past his prime. George...

Page 12

DISFIGUREMENT BY PICNIC.

The Spectator

T HE Surrey County Council deserve the thanks of all England. They have shown the way to other Councils in a matter affecting the comfort and enjoyment of thousands of English...

Page 13

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

A COMMON-SENSE SETTLEMENT. [To oRm Eames or Fill .. SPIICTAT011."] am loth to trouble you with another letter, and nIthough I venture to think that your description of my...

THE NONCONFORMIST ATTITUDE.

The Spectator

LTO rle EDITOE or Till " Serentoe."J Sra,—As a Nonconformist, I shall be glad if you will allow me to protest against the sentiments of the Rev. J. Pugh Perkins, as expressed in...

[To ill EDROZ Or THE .. SPECTA70/21 Sia,—In Mr. Ratteubury's opinion

The Spectator

(Spectator, May 2nd) Home Rule will be a positive advantage to Protestantism, a positive disadvantage to Homan Catholicism. This may be so, but it is not a sufficient reason for...

Page 14

CROMWELL OR ROBESPIERRE P [To ono TIMOR or 555 ..Srsoratos.-]

The Spectator

Sin,—Will you allow a citizen and elector to utter his indignant protest against the astounding audacity of Mr. Lloyd George in threatening the country with "a revolution" if...

MR. ARTHUR PONSONBY AND THE NAVAL AND MILITARY SERVICES.

The Spectator

[To TEN Minos or TH1 ..Srscrarox."] SIR,—I see in your last issue that you have " Common- Sense " on your side in condemning as •' monumentally inept" a passage from an article...

1111, FRIENDS AND NATIONAL SERVICE. ran E717011 07 rim "Srmoraros.").

The Spectator

Sin,—An organization called the Australian Freedom League has lately been busily engaged in the North of England sowing a plentiful crop of misrepresentations on the working of...

AUSTRALIAN COMPULSORY MILITARY TRAINING.

The Spectator

[To ass EDITOR or vs. "Snakrsr."7 SIB,—Captain Crosfield in his letter to your paper of May 2nd accuses use of making "wild, misleading, and gravely exag- gerated statements"...

Page 15

THE BOY SCOUTS: A GOOD INVESTMENT FOR EVERYONE.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOH or THE " SFECTATOH.".1 SiE,—Thirty millions are spent by our nation every year on training the rising generation in reading, writing, and arithmetic, plus a...

THE BOYS' COUNTRY WORK SOCIETY.

The Spectator

[To nis EDITOR or ass .. Brecr,tro..1 SIR, — The Spectator is always ready to support any sane scheme for doing good, whether in town or country; nor are its readers backward in...

Page 16

SOCIALISM IN THE POSTAL SERVICE. [To rag Boma or rex

The Spectator

nSPECT.LT011."] SIP"—I deplore, as you, the growth of Socialism in the postal service, but I am afraid I must charge you with an attitude towards the claims of postal servants...

THE HIGHLAND HOST.

The Spectator

[To TIRE Eorroin or rws .iiirscrwrox."] SIB, —In the Spectator of May 9th your reviewer, in his notice of Mr. Elder's monograph on the Highland Host of 1678, expresses the...

UNREPORTED EPIGRAMS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOZ OF THE " STECTATON.."] SIB, —It often happens in speeches that the words which really touch the heart go unreported. Permit me to rescue from oblivion the...

THE OAK AND WESTMINSTER HALL.

The Spectator

[To THE Lone. or Tax n'Srecraros.."1 SIB, — It is meet and right that the law-makers of England, from whence arms are stretched across the seas to the ends of the earth, should...

Page 17

THE ALLEGED ATROCITIES BY EPIROT INSURGENTS.

The Spectator

[To TH. EDITOR or THII •• SreCTaTOR"] Sin,—I have received the instructions of my Government to offer the most unqualified contradiction to the news which appeared in your...

[To TER EDITOR Or THE • 'Sreeraroa."] SIR, — With your correspondent of

The Spectator

last week, Mr. L. E. Steele, I always thought the roof of Westminster Hall was Irish oak, and cherished the tradition that no spiders would snake webs on it! This, surely, could...

THE CHURCHMEN'S UNION.

The Spectator

[To TEM EDITOR Or Tea ••Sermaor.".1 SIR,—I cannot exaggerate the pleasure and satisfaction I felt at reading in your issue of May 2nd the notice you gave of the petition of the...

NOTICE.—When "Correspondence" or Arlic:es are signed with the writer's name

The Spectator

or initials, or with a v reodonytn, or are marked "Communicated," the Editor must not necessarily be held to be in agreement with the views therein expressed or with the mode...

ADVERTISING HEALTH RESORTS.

The Spectator

[7'o roc EDITOR or THE •' Betenroa.'9 SIR,.--Will you kindly allow me to reply to Mr. Kilburn (Spectator, May 9th) ? surely be and the residents to whom he refers do not desire...

POETRY.

The Spectator

SONG OF THE HAPPY RHYMESTER, I AM the happiest of men : I live (just barely) by my pen. I rise at sev'n, and on till one Fulfil the tale of labour done. And then from...

[To TIM EDITOR OF TH. "SPECTATOR •• ] SIR,—In Sir Frederick Falkiner's

The Spectator

Foundation of the Hospital and Free School of King Charles n, the oak in the roof of "the great hall of William Rufus" is given a different origin. The author, referring to the...

THE GEOGRAPHY OF THE NIGHTINGALE. (To /la Eons. OF TH•

The Spectator

•• SPECTATOR " l SIR,—I have just read your interesting article in your issue of the 2nd inst. I must, however, take exception to the statement that the nightingale is not to be...

Page 18

1300R.S.

The Spectator

THE INSCRUTABLE PEOPLE.* A CURSORY study of the long list of English works on China published since the Revolution of 1911 suggests several interesting reflections. Imprimis,...

ART.

The Spectator

ART IN SCOTLAND. TEE discriminating sense of scale which is the particular - charm of Edinburgh architecture (a legacy, perhaps, from Robert Adam) is seen in the Scottish...

Page 19

THE CONFEDERATION OF EUROPE..

The Spectator

Anises PHILLIPS has unquestionably performed a most meritorious public service. He has afforded to the historical student a clue by the use of which he may guide his footsteps...

Page 21

THE METHOD OF SCIENCE.* HENRI POINCARE, who died two years

The Spectator

ago, was, according to Mr. Bertrand Russell, by general agreement the most eminent scientific man of his generation. In physics, astronomy, and, above all, in mathematics, he...

Page 22

THE VATICAN.*

The Spectator

Tam exposition of the work and organization of the Holy See, written by a devout son of the Roman Catholic Church, will be as interesting to readers who are not members of that...

Page 23

SPENSER'S SONNETS IN FRENCH.*

The Spectator

ALL poetry suffers in translation: at the best for the actual words of a poem we can only find substitutes, approximations; we cannot find equivalents. As tin example of the...

HABLOT K. BROWNE.•

The Spectator

Ma. EIXidE BROWNS has written a very pleasant account of his father, who is chiefly known to fame as the illustrator of Dickens. The connexion between the writer and artist was...

Page 24

FICTION.

The Spectator

THE WORLD SET FREE.* Mg. WELLS'S new story of the emancipation of humanity is. marked by many of the merits and all the limitations which characterize his periodic excursions...

NEW LIVES OF THE POETS.*

The Spectator

THESE pleasant little volumes contain a blend of biography and criticism, slightly differing in proportions from the ordinary critical study. The writer in each case approaches...

Page 25

The Fortunate Youth. By William J. Locke. (John Lane. 6s.)—The

The Spectator

fortunate youth improves with advancing years. It is just possible to believe in the existence of Paul Savelli, actor, and a charming fellow into the bargain, and in his life as...

SOME BOOKS 01? THE WEEK.

The Spectator

Nader this heading as retie. such Boas el th e treelt .a lays wol kA re...rya for mica in other forms.] The Campaign Guide. (National Unionist Association. 5s. net.)—This...

Full Swing. By Frank Denby. (Cassell and Co. 6s.)— The

The Spectator

extremely cheerful name of this novel is entirely belied by its contents. The whole story is occupied with the series of mistakes made by Agatha Wanstead, afterwards Lady...

READ.A.BLE NovaLs.—Trader Carson, By John Barnett. (Ward, Lock, and Co.

The Spectator

6s.)—A story of adventure in which each chapter is what is called in serial magazines "complete in itself "; and although the episodes are somewhat unequal, many of them are...

Page 26

We have received the first number of a sixpenny journal

The Spectator

called the Indianan, "a weekly link with India.". The new journal, in which the Overland Mail and the Homeward Mail will be merged, defines its aim as to enlighten the ignorance...

Napoleon in Exile Elba. By Norwood Young. (Stanley Paul. 21s.

The Spectator

net.)—lt is just a hundred years since Napoleon was forced to shift his Empire from France to Elba, and Mr. Young's conscientious piece of work thus makes a timely appearance,...

NEW Etanoxs.—Chambers's Concise Gazetteer of the World. By D. Patrick

The Spectator

and W. Geddie. (W. and It. Chambers. Ga. net.)—This new edition of a handy and accurate work gives statistics in most cases as late as 1911. British Year-Book of Agriculture,...

The Small Rock Garden. By E. H. Jenkins. (Country Life

The Spectator

Library. 2s. 6d. net.)—A valuable feature is the lists of plants suitable for the different kinds of gardens described—wall, rock, bog, moraine, and so on. But should not the...

Russia. By Karl Baedeker. (T. Fisher Unwin. 18s. net.) —This

The Spectator

guide-book for Russia, now issued in England for the first time, is up to the standard long set by the firm of Baedeker—from the average tourist's point of view there could be...

Java and her Neighbours. By Arthur S. Walcott. (G. P.

The Spectator

Putnam's Sons. 10a. 6d. net.)—In these respectable but some.. what pedestrian pages Mr. Walcott has "written up" the notes of three months' wanderings in Java, Celebes, the...

A Handbook to Rome. (Ward, Lock, and Co. 2s. 6d.

The Spectator

net.)—. This addition to a well-known series of " Continental Hand- books " gives a clear and trustworthy—though necessarily a very condensed—account of the things worth seeing...

A Pocket Dictionary of the English and French Languages : English-French.

The Spectator

By Henri Sabersky. (H. Gravel and Co. 2s. net.)—This handy dictionary—of which the second or French-English part is in preparation—gives the English pronunciation according to...

The German Lyric. By John Lees. (J. M. Dent and

The Spectator

130115. 4s. 6d. net.)—Dr. Lees tells us that in England there are still two fairly strong preconceived notions about the German lyric—one that it is unduly sentimental, the...

An Unknown Son of Napoleon (Count Leon). By Hector Fleiechmann.

The Spectator

(Eveleigh Nash. 10s. 6d. net.)—The hero of this book is not " unknown " in the strict sense of the word. It has long been known that Napoleon bad three acknow- ledged sons,...