17 JANUARY 1914

Page 1

At Belfast on Friday week Mr. Charles Craig announced that

The Spectator

the Ulster Indemnity Fund already exceeded the million pounds for which the Ulster Unionist Council had asked. He added that the Force now numbered almost 100,000 men. We notice...

As our readers know, we believe that resort to a

The Spectator

Referendum would be the best solution of the difficulty. Whether Ulstermen would accept an adverse verdict we tannot say, but at all events if they were bereft of the support...

As we have often said, exclusion goes to the heart

The Spectator

of tl,e matter because it is a demand founded on the Governments own principles—the principles on which the Bill is based. The Government cannot withstand the argument for...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

T HERE was nothing in Mr. Bonar Law ' s speech at Bristol on Thursday night which could surprise the country, for it had already been freely rumoured that the negotiationa...

A proposed compromise of the Irish difficulty, which is attributed

The Spectator

to Mr. Thomas Lough and is supported by Professor Mahaffy, has attracted some attention during the week. The proposal, in brief, is that for twenty years in the Irish Parliament...

The Syndicalist strike in South Africa is in process of

The Spectator

collapse, thanks to the unexampled promptitude and thorough. nesa of General Botha ' s Government. Directly it was clear that the railway strike would develop, unless it were...

After saying that his conversations with Mr. Asquith could lead

The Spectator

to nothing, Mr. Boner Law went on to declare that it was necessary now to assume that the Government meant to carry out their policy to the bitter end. "On that assumption it...

%. The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript in any

The Spectator

ease.

NOTICE.—With this week's number of the " SPECTATOR" is issued, gratis,

The Spectator

an Eight-Page Supplement, containing the Hatf.Yearly Baer and Title-Page—i.e., from Italy 5th to December27th, 1913, inclusive.

Page 2

On Tuesday at Johannesburg an attempt was made to arrest

The Spectator

Mr. Bain, the secretary of the Federation of Trades. The strike leaders with the help of their bodyguard resisted and barricaded themselves in the Trades Hall. There was street...

With regard to the islands occupied now by Italy, Italy

The Spectator

repeats her assurance that they will be banded back to Turkey when the obligations of the Treaty of Lausanne have been carried out. It remains to be noticed that the replies,...

On Tuesday the Daily Chronicle followed up its interview with

The Spectator

M. Caillanx by publishing one with M. Briand. IL Briand, when asked how his policy differed from that of AL Caillaux, said that it was a difference of manner as much as...

The Daily Chronicle of last Saturday published an interview with

The Spectator

M. Caillaux, the Minister of Finance and the chief figure in the French Government. M. Caillaux said that he was so much misrepresented by his enemies that he was not surprised...

The new year has opened disastrously for Japan. In spite

The Spectator

of the reticence of officials and of the people affected, it is now clear that widespread distress—due to a failure of the rice crop and the fisheries—is prevailing in Hokkaido,...

The replies of Austria, Germany, and Italy to the British

The Spectator

Note on the Aegean Islands question were received by the Foreign Office on Wednesday. The proposal that all the islands occupied by Greece, except Imbros and Tenedoe, shall be...

A determined attempt was made to murder Sherif Pasha in

The Spectator

Paris on Wednesday. Sherif Pasha, formerly Turkish Minister at Stockholm, having fallen out with the Committee of Union and Progress, has since lived in Paris and has un-...

Page 3

The statement with regard to the cure of cancer cases

The Spectator

at the Middlesex Hospital, supplied by Dr. Lazarus-Barlow, published by the Times of the 8th inst., and summarized in our last issue, has elicited a letter of remonstrance from...

We have it on Mr. Churchill's authority that the Navy

The Spectator

Estimates are still being considered by the Cabinet. Apparently the process of consideration will not be an easy one, for Mr. Lloyd George's pronouncement has thrown Ministers...

The Leeds strike, which lasted for more than a month,

The Spectator

has ended in unconditional surrender on the part of the workmen, On December 10th the Corporation workmen struck for an all-round increase of two shillings a week. Over three...

The fact is that readers of the interviews with M.

The Spectator

Caillaux and M. Briand must bear in mind the wise reticence and the courtesy of French statesmen in discussing English affairs, and not try to discover in their sentiments a...

The Army Council began on Thursday an experiment in making

The Spectator

known, by means of full-page advertisements in news- papers, the advantages of the Army as a career. We heartily welcome this new scheme. The Army has, of course, for a very...

We are very glad indeed to notice that the Westminster

The Spectator

Gazelle has changed its captious tone in writing about the meeting which Adeline Duchess of Bedford is organizing on behalf of the political prisoners in Portugal, and now...

Mr. Balfour delivered the first of his Gifford Lectures at

The Spectator

Glasgow on Monday. The subject had not been revealed, and was only declared in the course of the lecture. Mr. Balfour began by admitting the failure of philosophy to solve the...

If his statement seemed to savour of anthropomorphism, he hoped

The Spectator

to commit worse crimes than that "If the modern man's idea of God was descended from ancient and corrupt myths, the very permanence of that idea was proof that it could not be...

The Spectator

Page 4

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

THE RIGHT OF THE COMMUNITY TO EXIST. N IVE have placed at the head of this article the words with which M. Clemenceau once summarized the justification of the State in...

THE GERMAN MILITARY DESPOTISM.

The Spectator

W HILE admiration for the overwhelming vote by which the Reichstag at the beginning of Decem- ber expressed its indignation at the events at Zabern was still fresh on the lips...

Page 6

WHAT IS SLAVERY?

The Spectator

Q IR ROBERT PEEL stated some seventy years ago that no sound opinions on currency questions could be formed unless a clear and comprehensive answer were given to the question, "...

Page 7

SENSATIONALISM IN PROFIT-SHARING.

The Spectator

ITIIIE announcement of the sensational profit-sharing 1 scheme which the Ford Motor Company of Ohio pro- poses to establish opens up a number of interesting economic questions....

Page 8

A WISE MAN OF THE EAST.

The Spectator

"Men hope, And see their hope frustrate, and grieve awhile, And hope anew." B ROWNING'$ words can hardly fail to occur to the thoughtful reader as he turns over the pages of...

Page 9

THE CASUAL READER.

The Spectator

O UR dependence on one another not only for society but even for keeping body and soul together is recog- nized by all thinkers. Robinson Crusoe, after the most critical...

Page 10

FEATHERS AND FISHERMEN.

The Spectator

D ISCUSSION of Bills before Parliament strays often into unlikely channels, and few, perhaps, who have watched the progress of the Plumage Bill, which is designed to prevent the...

Page 11

[To ram Noma OF 1.■ •Tracr■roa..1

The Spectator

SIR, —It is little wonder that we despair of the Republic in these days when the defence against State Socialism takes the line of such letters as you published last week. When...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

NATIONAL AFFORESTATION. I . To vas Earroa or Tea .'13racr■roa.1 SIR, —In a country where an industry is ill-managed nothing is easier than to prove that it will not pay. The...

Page 12

[To in Roma or vs. .13racrvroo.1 Sin,—" The Truth about

The Spectator

Deer Forests" is your own heading to an article in your issue of January 10th. Party recrimina- tion is one thing, actual history is another. Will you per- mit a few words in...

[To rue Ernest or 7Z11 &scrams."' SIR,—May I, claiming to

The Spectator

be a qualified and unprejudiced observer, be permitted to add my testimony towards the attainment of sound views on this much-debated topic P For fifty years past I have been...

THE SUTHERLAND CLEARANCES.

The Spectator

[To ono EDITOR or en .firocuaron."11 SIR, —It is astonishing to us Scottish people who know the story of our own land to see it practically made out that there were no such...

Page 13

THE NEW FOOD TAX.

The Spectator

[To TRH Eerros or rex "SPecrwrs.."] Sin,—When the 1909 Budget was being discussed in the House Mr. Harold Cox and others pointed out the danger of Undeveloped Land Duty being...

.[TO THE EDITOR se roe •' Sesersros."]

The Spectator

am not a party politician, but surely it must be obvious to anyone who takes note of polities at the present time that the "catching of votes" is (to a very great extent)...

FARMERS AND THE VOTE.

The Spectator

[To ass Emma or TOE "8racravea."1 SIN,—Reading the last London weeklies as I jolted over a South Indian road in a bullock waggon, it was only yesterday that from your columns I...

THE ROYALIST PRISONERS IN PORTUGAL.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF TH. " SPECT/TOR."1 Sin,—I have only now seen your leading article under the above beading in the Spectator of December 20th, in which you say, " What is now...

Page 14

MEXICO AND CENTRAL AMERICA.

The Spectator

[To run Ernes or raw "Brectrrox."1 Sra,—May I suggest a reservation or two to your definition of the Monroe Doctrine in your editorial in the issue of January 3rd on Mexico P...

THE MEXICAN SITUATION.

The Spectator

[To BBB Bares or Tao arrrrar3s...j SIB,—Your interesting article on the Mexican situation left off just at the most thrilling point. The United States bad willy-nilly extended...

Page 15

[To THE EDrroa or Tel "SpEcrwrox.”] trust Mr. Cole's letter

The Spectator

in your columns (January 3rd) about the traffic in old live horses will give many readers a fresh impulse to oppose that traffic. I have been a chaplain in France for ten years....

OLD ENGLISH HORSES AT ANTWERP.

The Spectator

[To Ter Eamon or THE SPECTATOR."' Sus,—On Monday, January 5th, we again met the old English horses at the Antwerp Docks. Only the Hull and Newcastle boats had arrived, bringing...

Page 16

CHEAP COTTAGES.

The Spectator

[To vas Eamon or sax ..87111CTATOIL.1 SIR,—With reference to the letter on "Pied Buildings" in your issue of November 22nd, the method employed by the Galicians in this country...

ERNEST ARTHUR EDGRILL.

The Spectator

ITC vas Roma or ran "Brecraroa.m1 Era,—Mr. Palmer's letter in your issue of January 3rd on the subject of "The Edghill House" must have sounded in many ears like a veritable...

[To ma Enna or rev esmerova."!

The Spectator

Sre,—May I bring to your readers' notice a book called The Under Dog. which is published by the Animate Guardian? This book gives a great deal of information on the subject of...

Pat BUILDINGS.

The Spectator

[To ran Eons. or raz "Bract/moo:1 Sin,-1 think you are wrong in your oonception of the meaning and construction of "Pied Buildings" (November 22nd, 1913). Although the term is...

Page 17

" WILL-O'-THE-WISP."

The Spectator

[To V. E0170l or Tex •. Srscrsrosi"1 Srs,—The phrase " Will-o'-the-wisp " corresponds with the term Jack-o'-Lantern." In Johnson's Dictionary, how- ever, it is found as " Will...

[To Ton EMSOS or 'Me "SPECTATOR." J wish to correct

The Spectator

an error in the interesting notice of my cousin, Miss Julia Wedgwood, which appeared in your last issue. Frances Julia Wedgwood was the daughter of Hensleigh Wedgwood and...

THE ART OF SIENA.

The Spectator

ITO TIM EMT. or 150 ••SPECTA7011.”) Stu,-.-A French edition of my History of Siena has been asked for, and will shortly be published. I am anxious to make the chapters dealing...

THE LATE MISS JULIA WEDGWOOD.

The Spectator

[To THE Emma OF MI . Sractsma.") SIR, —It may interest some of your readers if I supplement the sympathetic end critical sketch of the late Miss Julia Wedgwood which Dr....

LI HUNG CHANG AND THE PURCHASE OF HONOURS.

The Spectator

[To Ton EDITOR OF TIM " SFECF/VFOL.' SIR,—In connexion with some of the current New Year topics your readers may be interested by a quotation from the recently published diary...

TILE "INDIAN SPECTATOR."

The Spectator

Its ens Emma or ens .. Srscraron."] Sin,—To the list of Spectators on p. 66 of your last issue permit me to add the late Bebramji Malabari's Indian Spectator, which • after a...

A CHRISTMAS TREE FOR THE BIRDS.

The Spectator

Its run Eniron or ens " SeErrAro a.") Sur,—Instead of relegating the family Christmas tree to the attic or bonfire after its one night of splendour, as in Hans Andersen's...

Page 18

BOOKS.

The Spectator

'MARIE ANTOINETTE AND BARNAVE.* DURING the years 1791 and 1792 events in Paris were hasten- ing to their tragic end. The spirit which eventually found expression in the...

THE ISLINGTON SKILLED EMPLOYMENT COMMITTEE. fro.ves Earroa or me ''Sracraroa."]

The Spectator

Snr,—Thanks to the publicity given by the publication of my letter in your issue of the 3rd inst., we have received several offers from !mike and gentlemen who are willing to...

POETRY.

The Spectator

THE ROMAN ROAD IN- MID-ALBANIA. t • • [To MEMAET BEY.] • A mien sinites through the mountains like the thrusting of a It glitters through green forests and shines above the...

. NOTICE.---When "Correspondence" or Articles are signed with the writer's

The Spectator

sonic or initials, or with a nsendontm, cr ore marked "Cciamunicated," the Editor must not necessarily be held to le in agreement with the tires therein repressed cr with the...

KORP.A.—Rev. S. T. Smith desires to thank a Grimsby friend

The Spectator

for the Spectator, and begs to announce change of address to Kang Wba, Korea.

Page 19

THE LION AND THE ELEPHANT.*

The Spectator

IT is not without a reason that both of the books before ui appear under the auspices of Mr. Roosevelt, who contri-; butes to the first a letter of good wishes and to the...

Page 21

GOOD AND BAD TRADE.*

The Spectator

TEE phenomena known as " trade fluctuations" seem to have beset the development of industry since the time when exchange by means of " tokens " began to take the place of the...

Page 22

A CONFEDERATE GIRL'S DIARY.*

The Spectator

THE American Civil War yielded less written evidence by noncombatants as to the experiences and conditions of those terrible years than might have been expected. At all events...

ALEXANDER AGASSIZ.*

The Spectator

WHEN Alexander Agaesiz died three years ago at the age of seventy-four, his friend Henry Adams wrote: " We did one first-rate work when we produced him, and I do • Letter. ond...

Page 23

THE FRANCO-GERMAN WAR INDEMNITY AND ITS ECONOMIC RESULTS.*

The Spectator

THERE is a perennial interest about the indemnity that France had to pay for her share in the war of 1870. De enormous amount, over two hundred millions sterling—a suni which...

Page 24

THE NEW WORLD OF THE SOUTH.*

The Spectator

THE first volume of The New World of the South was Australia is the Making. It dealt with sea adventure and discovery, the beginnings of settlement and inland exploration, and...

NAVAL WARFARE.*

The Spectator

In this little book Mr. J. R. Thnrsfield sets forth with much clearness and precision the principles which should govern the conduct of war at sea. The theory presented is...

Page 25

FICTION.

The Spectator

CHANCE.* Iv is a red-letter day in the life of a reviewer when a new novel by Mr. Conrad falls to his lot. It is another matter altogether when be endeavours to fulfil his...

MILTON'S COSMOGONY"

The Spectator

Ir would surely be an interesting task to trace the gradual evolution of the poets' cosmogony, from Homer to Tennyson. To the Greeks the earth itself provided ample space for...

Page 26

Ris Magnificence. By A. J. Anderson. (Stanley Paul. Gs.)-111r. Anderson,

The Spectator

with his last story, which is concerned with one of the most difficult periods of European history— the end of the fifteenth century in Italy—has made the average historical...

Page 27

Dedications : rat .dnthology. Compiled by Mary Elizabeth Brown. (G.

The Spectator

P. Putnam's Sone. 10s. 6d. net.)—Tbis enter- taining volume is the fruit of is pleasant excursion in one of the bypatbs of literature. The practice of dedicating books has...

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

[Undo. this heading les sours ouch Books of Um nub as ha. not bran roma for resins In other forms.] Religion at Home. By L. H. M. Soulaby. (Longmans and Co. 2d. net.)—The...

READABLE NOVSLEL—The Thunderhead Lady. By Anna Fuller and .Brian Read.

The Spectator

(G. P. Putnam's Sons. Se. 6d. net.)—This little romance is told by means of letters, some gossiping, some of criticism of books and art; they are dainty and attractive enough,...

The Banana. By William Fawcett. (Duckworth and Co. 7e. 6d.

The Spectator

net.)—As Mr. Lewis Harcourt lately said in Parliament it was no small service to the poor of this country to have made the banana the common object of the coster's barrow."...

A Handy Book of Curious Information. By William S. Walsh.

The Spectator

(J. B. Lippincott Co. 12s. 6d. not.)—Mr. Walsh deals with numerous subjects that admit of no general classifi- cation. All is fish that comes to his net—or rather to his...

The Thing in the Woods. By Margery Williams. (Duck- worth

The Spectator

and Co. 6s.)—This is an American story of a doctor who becomes locum tenens for a friend in a country district of Pennsylvania. The mystery as to" The Thing in the Woods" which...

The Eternal Maiden. By T. Everett Barre. (Duckworth and Co.

The Spectator

6s.)—In spite of the poetry which Mr. Barre puts into his account of the long night of the Arctic Circle, most readers will close this book with fervent gratitude that they were...

Page 28

Booze of REFERENCE.—The International Whitaker, 1914. (J. Whitaker and Sons.

The Spectator

2s. net.)—This work, now in its second year, promises to become as much of an institution as the older Whitaker; and what could we say stronger than that P—The Co-operative...

The Place-Names of Nottinghamshire. By Heinrich Mutschmann. (Cambridge University Press.

The Spectator

7s. 6d. net.)— The Place-Names of Somerset. By James S. Hill. (Bristol : St. Stephen's Printing Works.)—The study of the names of places, their origin and meaning, leads one...

In the Old Paths. By Arthur Grant. (Constable and Co.

The Spectator

8s. 6d. net.)—The literary pilgrim not only has a pleasant time himself, but is frequently moved to communicate his pleasure to others. When we cannot—or will not—go our- selves...

Royal Spain of To-day. By Tryphosa Bates Batcheller. (Longmans and

The Spectator

Co. 25s. net.)—The author of several highly successful hooks on Italy, Mrs. Batcheller has now turned her attention to a less trodden field. Her new work describes a journey...

A Year-Book of Mary Queen of Scots. By A. A.

The Spectator

Methven. (T. N. Penns. 2s. 6d. net.)—Mary Queen of Scots. By Walter Wood. (Hodder and Stoughton. 6s. net.)—Mary Queen of Scots diffused so mesmeric a charm that all the cold...

Garden Trees and Shrubs. By Walter P. Wright. (Headley Brothers.

The Spectator

12s. 6d. net.)—Gardeners have been separated into three classes—those who have begun with flower-beds, those who have gone on to the stage of rock-gardening, and those who have...