17 MAY 1930

Page 1

His famous ship, the Fram,' was - built to his own desi gn

The Spectator

and under his own supervision to withstand the pressure of the ice, and when she was held, fast in . the pack she drifted almost exactly along the course • which he had...

News of the Week

The Spectator

Dr. Nansen W E greatly regret to record the death, on Tuesday, of Dr. Fridtjof Nansen, at the age of sixty-nine. If Charles Kingsley had lived into this century he would almost...

* * After the War the League accepted the responsibility'

The Spectator

of repatriating hundreds of thousands of prisoners, many of Whom had no 'country left to which they could return. Dr. Nansen was invited to do the work, and his success was a...

As we confidently expected, the constructive side of the Viceroy's

The Spectator

policy has not been neglected. On Monday Mr. Wedgwood Benn was able to announce in the HOUSe of Commons the dates of publication.of the Simon:Report. The first part giving a...

* * * The Indian Situation - The week in

The Spectator

India has been marked by further tragic rioting, but it is clear that Lord Irwin's policy has pre- vented the " revolution of India " frOm reaching the proportions of an...

EDITORIAL AND PUBLISHING OFFICES : 99 Gower Street, London, W.C.

The Spectator

1.—A Subscription to the SPECTATOR costs Thirty Shillings per annum, including postage, to any part of the world. The SPECTATOR is registered as a Newspaper.; The Postage on...

Page 2

We shall knoiv how many of the moderates and Liberals

The Spectator

are ready to rally to the piogressive policy of the Viceroy when the proceedings of the All-Parties Conference which began in Bombay on Wednesday are known in detail. The object...

Lard Carson, also speaking in the debate of May 8th,

The Spectator

hysterically described the Naval Treaty as a " surrender of British naval supremacy," and applied all the old arguments about safety. Apparently for Lord Carson the world has...

The League of Nations and " Security " The -fifty-ninth

The Spectator

session of the Council of the League of Nations opened on Monday at Geneva. Mr. Marinkovitch (Jugoslavia) presides• over a gathering that includes the Foreign Ministers of all...

* The Coal Bill in the House of Lords In

The Spectator

the Committee stage_of the Coal Bill in the House of Lords on Tuesday the Government accepted an amend- ment by. Lord .Gainford, which, allows coalowners weeks instead . of four...

* * * *

The Spectator

The Naval Treaty In the House of Lords on Thursday, May 8th, Lord Bridgeman, criticising the Naval Treaty, protested that the Navy had been reduced below the limit of national...

We publish elsewhere a persuasive article by Mr. Law, son

The Spectator

of Mr. Bonar Law, which emphaSizes the extent to which public opinion here holds the key to the situation. We would refer our readers also to an article by Mr. H. G. Alexander...

The statement of Mr. Stimson on the Naval Treaty to

The Spectator

the Foreign Relations Committee of the American Senate proved not only that he is- a very firm believer in the Treaty, but that he was much impressed by the sincerity of the...

Lord Dudley • carried an amendment • •for ensuring that

The Spectator

the maximum output for a district .shall•Aot-be less than the total amount of coal - consumed in'thaVtliStrici. Lord Melchett also carried an amendment providing that the quota...

Page 3

The Totalisator The Racecourse Betting Control Board has issued its

The Spectator

first annual Report. After some me early difficulties the work of installing the Totalisators has gone forward rapidly, and it has had very much the result expected. Attendance...

* * * * The Daily News has .pointed out

The Spectator

that when the Official Secrets Bill was passing through Parliament Lord Hewart ridiculed the complaint that the Bill would affect the Press. " That," said Lord Hewart, " seems...

The Liberals and Electoral Reform We have already mentioned the

The Spectator

rumours that Mr. Lloyd George had promised Liberal support to the Government . M exchange for the Alternative Vote. The Manchester Guardian has recently, published letters from...

Mr. John Wheatley The death of Mr. John Wheatley, M.P.,

The Spectator

on Monday, removes a commanding but somewhat disturbing figure from the Labour benches in the House of Commons. The ex-Minister of Health, as a Roman Catholic, no doubt had some...

Miss Amy Johnson's Flight Few feats in the air, since

The Spectator

long flights became normal, have 'earned more admiration than that of Miss Amy Johnson, who is only twenty-two years old and is flying to Australia alone. By reaching Calcutta...

* * * * Mr. Baldwin's Campaign Mr. Baldwin's opening

The Spectator

speech, at Sheffield, was remark- able for two points. The first was the definite promise that a Unionist Government, ".the moment we get in," would restore all the Safeguarding...

• * * Bank Rate, 8 per - cent., changed from

The Spectator

31 per cent. on May 1st, 1930. War Loan (5 per cent.) was on Wednesday 1011; on Wednesday week, 101 1 7 , 7 ; a year ago, 10011x.d.; Funding Loan (4 per cent.) was on Wednesday...

The Government and Official Secrets The invocation by the Government

The Spectator

of Section 6 of the Official Secrets Act against the political correspondents of three news - papers has caused great surprise and con.: siderable concern. These correspondents...

Page 4

The Anglo-Egyptian Breakdown

The Spectator

T HERE is only one reasonable explanation of the most regrettable refusal of the Egyptian delegation to sign the draft Treaty. Nahas Pasha and his colleagues were doubtful of...

Page 5

Anglican Church Life Overseas

The Spectator

Introduction (The writer of this Introduction to the series of articles on " The Anglican Church Overseas " has been Secretary of the Universities Mission to Central Africa...

An All-Party Policy for Agriculture

The Spectator

; THE statement of Mr.. Buxton, the Minister .1- for Agriculture, in the House : of Commons on , Monday was intensely disappointing. There were un- doubtedly bright points in...

Page 6

India and British Public Opinion

The Spectator

[The author of this article, which will be followed next week by a second, has lately returned from a four months' visit to India. Mr. Law; a son of the late Mr. Bonar Law, is...

Page 7

" The Week in Parliament" will not appear this week.

The Spectator

Parliamentary happenings are recorded and discussed in the " News of the Week" and in a leading article. Next week's issue will contain the first of a new group of articles...

Page 8

The Poet Laureate

The Spectator

T HE laurel has not far to travel. Boar's Hill is to remain the seat of the official Muse. In his choice of " the King's poet," Mr. MacDonald has shown wisdom. If we have no...

Fagging

The Spectator

T HE question of fagging at the public schools has been brought into prominence by the tragic suicide of a young public school boy who, it is thought, killed himself rather than...

Page 9

The New Germany and Great

The Spectator

T HE magnitude of the new Germany's achievements in political reconstruction commands respect. The finished work of Weimar shows strong traces of the influence of a careful...

Page 11

Orchards

The Spectator

S RELY nowhere is it pleasanter to be living in spring than in an orchard. Some almost Hesperidian orchard perhaps, a grove of apple-trees on a lonely islet in the peacock blue...

A Hundred Years Ago

The Spectator

There is much that will be objected to in the book : the slang, the depravity, the grossness of the persons introduced, and represented to the life, may be expected to produce...

Page 12

A protest which, doubtless, will find sympathy in England, is

The Spectator

voiced by Mr. A. Lawrence Kocher, chairman of the Ameri- can Institute of Architects' committee on Preservation of His Monuments. Mr. Kocher objects strongly to the practice,...

AMERICAN SHIPPING. _

The Spectator

- In an attemp t to confine grants under the Merchant Marine Act of 1928 to entirely American-owned - companies, a Bill now before Congress proposes that no contracts shall be...

THE BURDEN OF. WAR.

The Spectator

Proposals for the conscription of men, money and industry in time of war have again had lengthy consideration ,by. Congress. In various forms the subject has occupied the...

* ' * * * THE BUSINESS PosrrioN.

The Spectator

President Hoover's position has not been made easier by the fact that the business recovery has not developed to vindi- cate the official predictions. Last week's sharp fall in...

American Notes

The Spectator

(By Cable) THE POLITICAL SITUATION. The political waters at Washington are decidedly troubled. The long-drawn out Tariff wrangle continues, with increasingly discordant...

Concern for the amenities of the countryside—not always a conspicuous

The Spectator

characteristic of our politicians—has been shown recently by the Legislatures of three States—New Jersey, New York and Kentucky. New Jersey has enacted perhaps, the most...

Page 13

Pleiades

The Spectator

Opetav rye lleX.eici8co9 Et;) rt)X6Bev'napirova vdcrlitat. (PINDAR) PERHAPS the time of the spring-call of the curlew to his mate, along the hills of Arran, is already...

Page 14

. • * * * *

The Spectator

A recent visit to another sanctuary adds impetus to my plea that the R.S.P.B. will be strongly supported in its endeavour to secure Romney Marsh as a sanctuary. Great Britain,...

* * What forms of produce, through the bad times

The Spectator

of the last few years have consistently paid the producer ? Dairy produce, especially milk and, rather surprisingly, cheese ; sugar beet (of which much the largest acreage in...

NIGHTINGALE AND CUCKOO'S MATE.

The Spectator

If there is anyone who desires to hear a nightingale and has failed, now is the chance. I never remember to have heard so many. They are almost as common as chiffehaffs in my...

CLOSE SEASON EXTENDED.

The Spectator

I believe that a particular reform, for which I have often pleaded, has already begun to spread from some of the estates where birds are protected or half protected. Shooting is...

* * * POULTRY OR WHEAT ?

The Spectator

In my neighbourhood, on farm land, rented very low and perhaps paying no dividend either to landlowner or farmer, have recently appeared over a very wide acreage a crop of...

Country Life

The Spectator

A SQUAD SETTLEMENT. Among minor endeavours to restore farming to popularity " Hughes' Settlement " is worth some attention. Land was bought—at the absurd price of £6 an acre—at...

* * * * BEES AND COLOUR.

The Spectator

Do bees judge chiefly by sight or scent ? Lately, in one garden, at any rate, they were peculiarly busy on two highly coloured flowers : the aubretia and the ribes or wild...

* * * A SPOTTED CRAKE.

The Spectator

From time to time accidental discoveries in natural history suggest to us that in spite of the many observers some animals may be much commoner than we suppose. For example,...

Page 15

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

WAR BOOKS AND WAR 1 [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —M _ ay I be permitted to make a few remarks on your article on this subject ? I agree with a great deal of this...

THE TRUTH ABOUT INDIA [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,— Between pragmatism and idealism it seems.slifficult to tell the truth about India without leaving any loophole for misconceptions to leak through, and yet it is the truth...

INDIA AND THE BRITISH COMMONWEALTH [To the Editor of the

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.] SIR,—A careful reading of the English printed press in India has convinced me that, apart from the constant social and psychological issue in India to which you...

Page 16

ABOLITION OF BATTLESHIPS [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] -

The Spectator

- SIR, — The Naval Conference; when it agreed that no more battleships should be kid' doWn before 1936, made a big Step forward toward their eventual complete abolition. It is...

THE NEW HOUSING BILL [To the Editoi of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIE,—I am charged in a friendly manner by Mr. A. T. Pike with having been carried away by the success of my own schemes, so that I see in Clauses 4 and 6 of, the Housing Bill a...

THE PUBLIC SCHOOL ON TRIAL [To the Editor of the

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.] SIR,—A recent tragedy has caused a stir and added to the Uneasiness, growing in recent years, as to whether all is well with the public school system so complacently...

Page 17

STAG _ HUNTING [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —Your

The Spectator

correspondent Mr. Hendy may be a competent naturalist, but his arithmetic is weak. He expresses horror at the prospect . of a humanitarian holocaust of four hundred stags. 'He...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sia,—It amuses me in

The Spectator

a way to come home from Canada and read letters in all kinds of papers re hunting, as if there is a doubt if it less cruel to hunt an animal to death or shoot it. I have worked...

THE CHURCH OF ENGLAND AND . REUNION [To the Editor

The Spectator

of the SPEcraTon.] Sm,—Unfortunately the particular issue of the Spectator containing my letter, to which Dr. Sydney Carter takes exception, was lost in the post ; and, as I...

Page 18

THE ROMANCE OF NAVIGATION [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—In your issue of March 29th,- which has just reached me, your reviewer writes with reference to the above : " It is odd, by the way, that Captain Whall uses the solecism...

Grace Before Beer

The Spectator

For what this house affords us, Come, praise the brewer most, Who caught into a bottle The barley's gentle ghost ; And may - our praise be sweeter— When we're beneath our...

THE MODERN POINT OF VIEW [To the Editor of the

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.] Sut,—I am glad to see that one of your readers who signs himself " Twentieth Century," not only lives in this century but is prepared to throw himself into the...

ANOTHER COUNTY STORY [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—I

The Spectator

regret having missed the opportunity of con- tributing to your County Story Competition. The County of Durham is rich in good stories. Although too late, the 'following one may...

We are glad to note that Professor - Scott is to

The Spectator

speak at the fourth annual meeting of the National Homecrofting Association, to be held, at.3.45 next Thursday afternoon, on " Homeciofting and the New Schools." The present...

Page 19

LITERARY SUPPLEMENT

The Spectator

Spatator 18211 No. 5,316.] WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, MAY 17, 1930. [GRATIS

Page 21

Serene Autumn

The Spectator

Mits. HARDY has done her work with such modesty and self- effacement that heroics from a reviewer would be out of place. She sets the key of her narrative thus : " the subject...

Page 23

European Educational Systems The New Education in Europe. Frederick - WIMani Roman.

The Spectator

. (Routledge. 18s.) Second Edition enlarged. TEN years after the establishment of the League of Nations it is beginning to be widely realized that education is the surest road...

A Bourbon Pretender

The Spectator

MR. ROGER MADOL has chosen one of the major riddles of history for the subject of his book. The question of whether in fact the luckless Dauphin was smuggled from the Temple and...

Page 25

Religion and Art

The Spectator

FORTUNATELY this is not a work which primarily demands consideration as a study in aesthetic criticism.- Mr. Spearing's Alternative title, The Ascent of Man, and his sub-title,...

Page 27

Sanctuaries for Scenery

The Spectator

National Parks and the Heritage of Scenery. By Dr. Vaughan Cornish. (Sifton. ]freed.. 5s.) THE raising of the great question of National Parks and the existence of Dr. Vaughan...

The Discovery of Australia

The Spectator

IT is well known that the northern coast of Australia was first sighted in 1606 by a Spanish ship sailing from the East and liy a Dutch ship sailing from the West, and that the...

Page 29

Dower subscribers who are changing their addresses are asked to

The Spectator

notify the SPECTATOR Office BEFORE MIDDAY OS MONDAY OF EACH Rags. The previous address to which the paper has been sent an receipt reference number should be quoted.

Behaviourism on its Best Behaviour

The Spectator

The Foundations of Experimental Psychology. Edited by Carl Murchison. (Oxford University Press. 27s.) Tux mass production of psychological works must rank high among the...

Page 30

London : Printed by W. SraArcur Aro SONS. LTD., 98

The Spectator

and 99 Fetter Lane, E.C. 4, and Published by T E SPECTATOR, LTD., at their Offices, No. 99 Gower Street, London, W.C. 1.—Saturday, May 17., 1930,

Page 31

The coastal fishery of the eastern seaboard of Scotland is

The Spectator

in a bad way—possibly in danger of disappearing altogether. But whatever its fate, its memory will be imperishably preserved by Mr. Peter F. Anson's Fishing Boats and Fisher...

The Mutiny and the World War are the main episodes

The Spectator

of the stirring pages of King George's Own Central India Horse, by Major-General W. A. Watson (Blackwood, 21s.). The author joined the regiment in 1882, and is now its honorary...

* * * *

The Spectator

Some Books of the Week fr is a long time

The Spectator

since we have read so fascinating a book as Tent Folk of the Far North,: by_ Ester Blenda Nordstrom (Jenkins, 12s. 6d.), and let us say at once that the translation by Miss Gee...

That great surgeon, Sir John Bland-Sutton, looking back over the

The Spectator

seventy-five years of a well spent life, has made The Story of a Surgeon (Methuen, 12s. 6d.) interesting alike to the practitioner and the layman. His father was a naturalist...

Mrs. Millin is not at her best throughout Men on

The Spectator

a Voyage (Constable, Os : ).. It consists, apparently, of jottings from - a notebook arranged under separate headings. They are mostly on abstract subjects, and it is only...

Mr. Edwin Muller, Jr., in the preface to his book,

The Spectator

They Climbed the Alps (Cape, 10s. 6d.), writes : " Apparently one can have an ardent liking for golf, gin and bitters, the music of Stravinsky, the works of Mencken or the ways...

The Competition

The Spectator

Tax Editor offers a prize Of five guineas :for the competitor whose selection of the five best brains in Great Britain most nearly accords with the majority verdict. The...

Page 32

J. X. Merriman

The Spectator

THE, late Mr. J. X. Merriman, known to all his political contemporaries as " J. X.," was a man of complex and fascinating personality. He was probably the greatest Par-...

The Diplomacy of Courts

The Spectator

Sir Charles Hanbury Williams. By D.. B. Horn. (Harrell. lbs., WERE this book no more than a life of Sir Charles Hanbury Williams, it would perhaps be superfluous in view of...

Page 33

A Great Humanist

The Spectator

PROFESSOR ULRICIi VON Wri.ane0WITZ-MOELLENDORFF carries his recollectioni no fiirtherthan 1914, because, as he says :=— " I hesitated fora lOng tinie whether I would allow the...

Page 34

The Mormon State

The Spectator

Brigham Young. By Susan Young Gates. (Jarrolds. The Kingdom of St. James. By Milo M. Quaife. (Milford. 18s.) FILIAL piety has always been an obstacle to appreciation of...

Page 35

Some Books on India India : a reprint of the

The Spectator

. Special India Number of the Times. (Times • Publishing' Co. 7s. 6d.) - To review the compendious and brilliantly written series of essays contributed by the foremost- living...

Fiction

The Spectator

Interpretations Cecile. By F. L. Lucas. (Chatto and Windus. 8s. 6d.) . . . and Co. By Jean-Richard Bloch. (Gollancz. 7s. 6d.) The Stranger. By Godfrey Elton. (Constable. 7s....

Page 36

* * * *

The Spectator

There is only one of the Sixteen Letters from Oscar Wilde (Faber and Faber, 21s.) which is of any importance : it was written in June, 1897, after his release from prison, and...

General Knowledge Questions oux weekly prize of one guinea for

The Spectator

the best thirteen Questions submitted is awarded this week to C. J. T. Mackie, " Alfriston," Swanley, Kent, for the following :- Questions on Dickens' Minor Characters 1. Who...

Neither of the two biographies issued for the birthday of

The Spectator

President Masaryk would appear to be entirely _satisfactory. Masaryk of Czechoslovakia, by D. A. Lowrie (Oxford University Press, 3s. 6d.) is somewhat puerile though...

Readers of detective stories need no longer feel even a

The Spectator

tinge of shame on account of this popular pursuit, for we arc told in The Crime Club Bulletin that Cabinet Ministers and even Bishops read detective stories ! But the market is...

* * * *

The Spectator

Plato and His Contemporaries (Methuen, 12s. 6d.) is described by the author, Professor G. C. Field, as " a preliminary or supplementary essay to a study of the philosophy of...

More Books of the Week

The Spectator

(Continued from page 833.) Many people have talked about and walked about Dartmoor (and got soundly wet in the process), but com- paratively few have written about it in a...

A Library List

The Spectator

REFERENCE Booxs :-The Dunlop Guide to Great Britain, (E. J. Burrow. 5s.)-The Directory of Directors for 1930. (Thomas Skinner and Co, 330 Gresham House, Old Broad Street, E.C....

Page 39

Travel

The Spectator

[We publish on this page articles and notes which may help our rc sders in their plans for traver in home and abroad. They are written by correspondents who have visited the...

Page 43

THE DUNLOP REPORT.

The Spectator

Having regard to the general trade position, the results of the Dunlop Rubber Company for the past year are not unsatis- factory. The actual net profit was £1,576,585, against...

Financial Notes

The Spectator

NEW CAPITAL. ACTIVITY. GENERAL business on the Stock Exchange has been somewhat restricted during the past week, and in places the tone has been rather dull. This has been due...

* * *

The Spectator

AN ABLE SPEECH. At the annual meeting a very able speech was delivered by the chairman, Sir Eric Geddes, in which some sound observations were made with regard to the damage...

PLAIN SPEAKING.

The Spectator

Towards the end of his speech Sir Eric Geddes said : " No business can succeed in the long run unless it has funds with which to keep its prOductive capacity up to date, and...

Page 44

* * * * PROFTTS FROM WHISKY.

The Spectator

The Ordinary shares of Buchanan-Dewar are, of course, held mainly by the Distillers' Company, and in all respects the margin or security which is possessed by Preference share-...

* * * * DEPRESSION IN SEWING COTTON. The continued

The Spectator

depression in the textile industry is reflected in the latest profit statement of J. and P. Coats, the total, of profits for the past year being £3,179,574, after allowing for...

LIVERPOOL AND LONDON AND GLOBE RESULTS.

The Spectator

The Report of the Liverpool and London and Globe Insur- ance Co. for last year shows that notwithstanding a decrease of-238,331 in the Single Premiums, the new new Life...