23 OCTOBER 1971

Page 3

NO MANDATE

The Spectator

Nothing in all the known world of politics is so intractable as a band of zealots, conscious that they are in a minority yet armed by accident with the powers of a majority. —...

Page 4

NOT NECESSARY AND NOT WANTED

The Spectator

The House of Commons now debates as a matter of principle whether, on the terms negotiated, the United Kingdom should accede to the Treaty of Rome by an irrevocable decision and...

Page 5

Free Enterprise-the new battle of ideas

The Spectator

A message from Sir John Reiss, B.E.M. chairman of Aims of Industry: T HE battle of ideas between those who believe in a State society and those who believe in a free economy is...

Page 6

The Socialists were happier at Brighton than the Tories and

The Spectator

h ave grown fonder of their leader. The Conservatives think their con ference was rigged. They wanted to debate immigration. This year, as in previous years, The Spectator...

Page 7

ei THE CASE AGAINST 1. Standards of living

The Spectator

correctly compared Douglas Jay One of the most notable examples in recent times of the Goebbels Big Lie is the oft-repeated statement that Britain's standard of living is now...

Page 8

2. The EEC end of the beginning

The Spectator

A Conservative The battle is about to begin. Supposing the Government is still determined to proceed with the business when the current debate is over, it is now clear that the...

Page 10

MARKET ARITHMETIC Etc Hugh Macpherson

The Spectator

7g11557 1 ..17M1791!Tr-!!!!!!!!! !IMii! 111111111111 11$1111111e1111 11111111!1111111111111! I! !!!!! ill! II ! I 1 I!JHll !I!! As the Parliamentary Labour party faced the...

Page 11

TORY NOTE BOOK

The Spectator

n some respects the Prime Minister has never looked better than at the Tory conference this year. At one and the same time he seemed remote from the minor troubles and...

Page 12

THE SPECTATOR REVIEW4BOOKS

The Spectator

Patrick Cosgrave on The poetry of J. V. Cunningham Though this short volume* contains his entire published output in verse, and though — judged by his own standard — the...

Page 14

Auberon Waugh on Murdoch and Raven

The Spectator

An Accidental Man Iris Murdoch (Chatto and Windus £2) Sound the Retreat Simon Raven (Blond £2) I shall read the other reviews of Miss Murdoch's latest novel with great interest...

Fish tank

The Spectator

His lover's room is high above the sea Exposed to wind and every noisy storm That soaks her window with congealing spray; To him she says that only bed is warm — From where,...

Page 15

Alaska and Orkney

The Spectator

Clive Wilmer The Stone Harp John Haines (Rapp and Whiting £1.25 and 80p) Fishermen with Ploughs George Mackay Brown (Hogarth Press E1.25) Poems New and Selected George Mackay...

Page 16

Offa's kingdom

The Spectator

Barbara Hardy Mercian Hymns Geoffrey Hill (Andre Deutsch £1.75 and £1.00) Offa's Dyke and his English kingdom were made by skill s and violence. Geoffrey Hill's skilful and...

Page 17

Bookend

The Spectator

Jonathan Raban's* new book is as lively and interesting as his reviews. It is very much a reviewer's book, in fact, full of generalities, witticisms, sharp insights and scathing...

Page 18

THE ARTS

The Spectator

THEATRE Troubled times Nicholas de Jongh This has been no fortnight for impenitent reactionaries and though the tearoom advocates of revolution may have gathered to exult at...

Page 19

CINEMA

The Spectator

Getting involved Tony Palmer I suppose it's odd that no one has thought of making a film about the absurdities of party political conferences such as those which have recently...

ART

The Spectator

Trade secrets Evan Anthony It would be strange if regular readers of art columns did not occasionally wonder what antic chance decides which shows — of the dozen or more that...

BALLET

The Spectator

History repeated Robin Young After summer holidays the Royal Ballet is welcome back. The Royal Opera House is a big, expensive place to leave ' dark ' through the height of...

Page 20

Will Waspe's Whispers

The Spectator

Trouble up at t'Beeb. Attentive Shepherd's Bush monitors may have noticed that whereas the season's TV drama and music plans are usually announced simultaneously, music came out...

Page 21

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

The Spectator

Triumph and disaster at Foulness Sir: Mr Walker continues to hail the choice of Foulness as an environmental triumph. What foolishness. He should know that it is as disastrous...

Crimes against humanity

The Spectator

Sir: Those who oppose the death Penalty for callous murder must surely imply that the culprit is capable of reform; yet the very frightfulness of such a crime plainlY indicates...

Who is who? . . .

The Spectator

Sir: I cannot help wondering what qualifications Mr Michael Calvert (Letters, October 16) has, other than academic, and specifically how well he knows all the places he mentions...

. . . and why

The Spectator

Sir: I am appalled to see that The Spectator has adopted that pointlessly snobbish convention of heading some of the Letters to the Editor by such unnecessary information as...

Sexy us

The Spectator

Sir: Let me hasten to smooth down poor Edward J. Bander's ruffled little conscience (Letters, October 16). Yes, The Spectator is a bigoted sexist publication, but if he reads it...

Page 22

Japs again!

The Spectator

Sir: 'A sense of nausea' is the only way I can describe my feelings on reading your editorial on the visit of the Emperor Hirohito. This kind of hysterical outburst may satisfy...

Heath and Europe

The Spectator

Sir: The answer to the riddle of Mr Heath's pledge not to take Britain into the Common Market without the wholehearted support of Parliament and the people lies, I suspect, in...

Sir: "During the week beginning on Monday, October 25, there

The Spectator

will be a debate on a motion to approve the entry of the UK into the European Common Market." — Orders of the Day, House of Lords. It is therefore of the utmost importance that...

Sir: Britain now faces one of the gravest crises in

The Spectator

her history. In return for hypothetical and nebulous economic gains, the Government, led by self-styled ' internationalist ' Edward Heath, is willing to sign the irrevocable...

Sir: UCS has been occupying so much headline space recently

The Spectator

that the plight of Clydeside in general has been lost sight of. In fact unemployment is extremely high; not only UCS but also many other companies (including Plessey, Babcock...

Help

The Spectator

Sir: I wonder whether your readers can help me with a little research. I'd like to hear of any novel that mentions the birth-date of one or more of its characters. The nature of...

Sir: I am preparing for publication an illustrated book concerned

The Spectator

with German military helmets and headdress, 1871-1918. It is a difficult task embracing as it does all branches of the services of the twenty-five various kingdoms, dukedoms and...

A case for hanging

The Spectator

Sir: It was most heartening to observe the spontaneous reaction of the crowd which assembled to witness Sewell's entry into the police station at Blackpool. In the...

Gilding the lilies

The Spectator

From Humphrey Brooke CVO Sir: Owing to chance I have only just seen Bryan Robertson's 'Keeping ahead with Portaiture.' I must certainly challenge his statement that Bryan...

Page 23

MONEY

The Spectator

What holds up the Tory boom? Nicholas Davenport The Brighton conferences did not send the City either wild with joy or sick with apprehension. The Labour lurch to the left was...

Juliette's Weekly Frolic

The Spectator

MY unhappy love affair with the ' flat ' never quite got of the ground, but when Cossall burst through the driving rain to lead the Cesaretyltch field into its final two...

Page 24

SKINFLINT'S CITY DIARY

The Spectator

The Government has been forced to allow the Conservatives a free vote on October 28 on Britain's entry into the Common Market. Until history is written you will have difficulty...