24 OCTOBER 1952

Page 1

NEWS OF THE WEEK

The Spectator

HE present Government completes its first year of office this week. On the whole it can claim to have justified itself. It inherited difficulties some of which were inevitable,...

Ups and Downs in Indo-China

The Spectator

A rigid censorship makes it difficult to assess the gravity of the reverses suffered by French Union forces in the Thai territory to the northwest of Hanoi. The post of...

Sudanese Solution?

The Spectator

Optimistic suggestions that a solution of the Sudanese problem may be just round the corner have been coming out of Cairo. It would be comforting to believe them, but at the...

Page 2

Italian Electoral Reform

The Spectator

The Christian Democrats of Italy and their allies are seeking (in their own interests, it is true, but also for the _sake of ensuring stability of government) to avert the...

The United Nations Waits

The Spectator

The United Nations Assembly, while waiting for Mr. Eden and M. Schuman, who are waiting for the United States elections, has made a lethargic beginning. Nothing impressive has...

French Doubts

The Spectator

The best feature of the proposal for a European Defence Community has always seemed to be that Such an organi- sation could effect a fusion of two fundamental aims in the...

Mr. Shinwell's Private War

The Spectator

There is one grain of sense in the campaign which Mr. Emanuel Shinwell is-conducting for the reduction of the period ' of conscription. Mr. Shinwell is right in saying that,...

Page 3

After the Rail Smash .

The Spectator

Exhaustive as the enquiry into the Wealdstone railWay disaster has so far been, nothing has happened to allay the grave disquiet which the travelling public must still feel.-...

The Iceland Fishery Trouble

The Spectator

When the International Court of Justice decided last Decem- ber that Norway was entitled to fix a four-mile limit, instead of the generally-accepted three-mile limit, for...

AT WESTMINSTER

The Spectator

T HIS has been a restless_ week in Parliament. Members of both House§, fretted perhaps by the continuation in force of the £25 travel allowance, seem to have been under special...

Page 4

THE MAU MAU THREAT

The Spectator

i s no longer any question about the weight and determination behind the offiNal measures to deal with the Mau Mau threat in Kenya. The declaration of a state of emergency, the...

Page 5

When John (Viscount) Morley was alive—he died in 1923—there was

The Spectator

considerable mystery about his wife, and a good deal of doubt as to whether he was in fact married. Mrs. Morley never appeared in public." A Liberal official who had to arrange...

Mr. Butler relents and does not relent. The Tate Gallery

The Spectator

regains the two or three attendants it was required to dismiss in the interests of economy—surely a shabby kind of economy —but the English traveller abroad is still restricted...

* * The death this week of Theodore Taylor, of Batley,

The Spectator

at the age of 102 will be noted with interest as well as regret by those who remember the article he contributed to the Spectator two years ago in the week of his hundredth...

Mr. John Braithwaite is a popular and efficient chairman of

The Spectator

the London Stock Exchange, but he has not—assuming the remarks attributed to him in a New York message to be authentic—realised how unwise it is for an Englishman to intrude...

A SPECTATOR'S NOTEBOOK

The Spectator

C OMMENThas been made on the strength of theBevanites in workers with the hand—the hand that taps , the type- writer or drives the pen. Quite apart from Mr. Bevan's wife and her...

Two Westminster M.P.s, both Conservatives, are at variance over the

The Spectator

advertisements in Trafalgar Square. It will be objected that there are not two M.P.s for Westminster. Strictly speaking there are not. But Sir Harold Webbe, who wants to keep...

Page 6

What I Expect From A Sermon

The Spectator

By MARY B. BRUCE S a Scot, I was brought up in the belief that I went to church in order to listen to a text and a sermon. After„, the service was over, no one ever asked what...

Sermons Right and Wrong TiE adjudicators,"Canon Edward Carpenter: of Westminster

The Spectator

Abbey, Dr. S. M. Berry, Secretary of the International Con- gregational Council, and the Editor of the Spectator, have now considered the papers submitted on the two subjects of...

Page 7

In Basic Conflict J OE LOUIS, ex-heavyweight champion of the world,

The Spectator

is for Governor Adlai Stevenson, on the ground that Eisen- hower's , policies now, and certain discriminatory practices permitted under his command in war-time Europe, do not...

Page 8

M. Pinay's Second Round T the beginning of September M.

The Spectator

Auguste Lecoeur, one of the secretaries of the Communist Party, paid M. Pinay a most unusual compliment. In the course of a review of the political situation before the Central...

Page 9

King Charles's Plate

The Spectator

By J. P. W. MALLALIEU, M.P. I STOOD by the finishing-post and looked along the course, that wide, straight strip of turf which eases itself into a hollow, then climbs until it...

Page 10

UNDERGRADUATE PAGE

The Spectator

Tenpence Return By MARGARET E. Sill/EN (University of Edinburgh) 1 CAUGHT it—just. The last one flew past heedless - and full: the one before sated itself with the first two...

El Alamein Cemetery

The Spectator

TEN years have passed since frantically they dug Their careful holes , in sand and history; They wrote their 'airmail letters which proclaimed How much they missed their wives...

The Spectator

Page 11

MARGINAL COMMENT

The Spectator

By HAROLD NICOLSON p LUTARCH was wont to interrupt his .tales of .glory and disgrace by inserting moral reflections upon the manners and customs of his - time. It would be a...

Page 12

MUSIC

The Spectator

Concert de Musique Francaise. (Wigmore Hall.) WE can allow ourselves some self-congratulation: Toscanini and Cantelli have come and gone, lauded sky-high as they should be - but...

CONTEMPORARY ARTS

The Spectator

THEATRE The Apples of Eve. By Allen Berthal. (Comedy.) " Doctor, have you got a hypodermic ? " ." Yes, of courser " OF course the doctor has a hypodermic. This, truly, is a...

ART

The Spectator

IT was the accident of time and place and comradeship (with Matisse) that brought Marquet into association with the Fauves. Though for a time a certain free vitality and rhythm...

Page 13

CINEMA

The Spectator

The Gentle Gunman. (Odeon, Marble Arch.)—Julie de Carneilhan. (Studio One.)—The Young Caruso. (Rialto.) EALING has now turned its brisk eye towards Ireland and the acti- vities...

The Fisher

The Spectator

He used to stand there daily, Hunched like a heron on the touchline, Peering abstractedly into some private River of thought. Then one day, Addressing no one in particular, He...

Page 14

Moonlight Encounter

The Spectator

Meeting R. on • the moonlit road, I stopped to talk. He had a mongrel pup at his •heel, a lively little animal that he was already bringing into the way of rabbiting. It was too...

Buzzard and Grouse

The Spectator

My brother and I were tramping home on the second half .of an eighteen-mile walk, and hurrying before the rain, when a buzzard rose in the rough ground Jo our right. He rose so...

Salmon-Poachers

The Spectator

" Salmons, man. The river wass full of them," he said: " The poachers got more than them that owned the water. They knew every pool, every hole and every salmon that wass comin'...

COUNTRY LIFE

The Spectator

IT was one of those autumn evenings when the light made the scene look unreal. It was an orange light, touching the underside of a great black bank of cloud and the tops of...

Anemones It is not too late to put in anemones

The Spectator

even-yet. Both the Caen and St. Brigid need a well-drained, sunny situation, and, unless the soil is light, they should be lifted each season. They are, I think, one of the...

Page 15

Working to Rule

The Spectator

Suit,—Will you permit me to call attention to one aspect of the situation on the railways extremely disturbing to the mind of the ordinary layman, namely the admitted fact that...

Prison Officers

The Spectator

SIR,—No ex-prisoner (except myself), and certainly not " Ex-Prisoner," seems capable of rational appreciation of prison officers save as composite Egyptian taskmasters,...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

The Spectator

Tito and Mihailovk SIR,—I would like to comment on a point which may be of some interest to historians in Miss Wiskemann's review of Mr. Zilliacus's Tito of Yugoslavia in your...

Page 16

I walked into the Library and what do you think

The Spectator

I saw ? In the section marked Biography twelve books on Bernard Shaw. 0 happy Uncle Bernard ! 0 enviable fate ! Was ever any dramatist so truly up to date ? No wonder that...

Closing the Abbey

The Spectator

Sot,-1 share the surprise of Janus and Mr. John Satterly that it should be necessary to close Westminster Abbey for six months to make it ready for the Coronation; but I hope...

"Shaw's Corner"

The Spectator

Snt—Derek Hudson, in a review of Shaw's Corner, states that Bernard Shaw " listed a number of serious errors" in my previous volume. Perhaps your reviewer may care to let me...

The Lapps' Survial

The Spectator

Sut—My attention has just been drawn to Mr. Michael Graham's article, Extinction of the Eskimo ? • (October 3rd). Cultural fatigue is becoming an increasing sociological problem...

Shaw's Reputation

The Spectator

Snt—Janus asks in your current issue why Shaw's reputation should go into eclipse. Is it not because he expressed so well and an long the spirit of an age which came filially to...

Bevanite Broadcasting

The Spectator

Sot, — In his article on the controversy within the Labour Party, Mr. Gaitskell omitted to mention another sphere of propaganda in which -the Bevanites excel. He is certainly...

Silt—Derek Hudson is rather severe on Stephen Winsten's Shaw's Corner,

The Spectator

in spite of the author's frank admission that it is a series of memories and not reports. One cannot help wondering whether Johnson's comments on Boswell would not have been...

Page 18

Re-establishing the Tradition

The Spectator

Snt,—I was pleased to see Mr. Berger's protest against your learned critic's employment of the term " middle of the roaders," There seems to be an idea prevalent in London (and...

Titillating Dramatic Critics

The Spectator

SIR, —Mr. Martin Cooper is indeed unfortunate in his choice of operas for the titillation of dramatic critics. Any -playgoer knows that as a play Traviata is an extremely...

Llanfair Pwll Gwyngyll

The Spectator

SIR, —This pleasant little village has groaned long enough under the oppressive weight of the monstrous and fictitious name . Llanfairpw11-...

Younger Poets

The Spectator

Snt,—For some time past, we have been gathering material for an anthology of work by younger British poets, which we hope to bring out next year. Since the emphasis of the...

Carl Nielsen Defended

The Spectator

SIR, -1 fear that, in voicing What is a fairly widespread astonishment at the very great esteem now enjoyed by 'Nielsen's music in some circles in this country, I have...

Anti-Alcohol Advertising

The Spectator

Sm,—I feel it a public duty to ask for your publicity for a denial of freedom imposed not by any Governmental body but at the instance of commercial notions of what is popular...

Religious Jargon

The Spectator

was most interested to read Sir William Hamilton Fyfe's article " Religious Jargon," in a recent Spectator. With another parish priest I have recently transliterated the 1928...

Page 20

SPECTATOR COMPETITION No. 141

The Spectator

Set by D. R. Peddy " After twelve years of smoking I smokedfifty cigarettes a day. Now, six months later, thanks to X, I actually find them offensive." A prize of £5 (which may...

4 SPECTATOR COMPETITION No. 138

The Spectator

Report by Frank Evelyn Competitors were invited to submit excerpts from the autumn lists of imaginary publishers, and the usual prizes were offered for the most hateful...

Tbe ispettator, October 23rb. 1852

The Spectator

BUT if war is to fall upon the world, what does it involve ? What are the main things at stake, if Europe should be involved in a general contest ? . . . The first thing that...

Page 21

BOOKS OF THE WEEK

The Spectator

Success Story of a Novelist , A. E. W. Mason.- By Roger Lancelyn Green. (Parrish. 21s.) Wnii an engaging personal modesty and in a spirit of affectionate admiration, Mr. Roger...

In next week's " Spectator " Sir Norman Birkett will

The Spectator

review ' ord Macmillan's " A Man of Law's Tale " ; R. J. Cruikshank Spectator Harvest ; and Sir Ronald Storrs " The Travels of lbn Jubayr," translated and edited by R. J. C....

Amphibious Operations

The Spectator

Generals and Admirals. By John Cresswell. (Longmans. 18s.) AN island Power can only exert its military strength against an enemy by first gaining command of the sea and then...

Page 22

William IV and His Times

The Spectator

- Tun reign of William IV has never attracted from posterity even one-tenth of the curiosity aroused by the lives and reigns of his predecessor, George IV, or his successor,...

Page 24

A Colonial Officer in the Pacific

The Spectator

A Pattern of Islands. By Arthur Grimble. (John Murray. 18s.) As instructive as it is entertaining, this loosely-knitted book of recollections of the author's early career as a...

Plant Communities

The Spectator

Downs and Dunes. By Sir Edward Salisbury. (Bell. 45s.) Tins book is an expanded and much enlarged version of two courses of lectures delivered -by Sir Edward to the Royal...

Page 26

A Wireless Aeneid

The Spectator

The Aeneid of Virgil. Translated by C. Day Lewis. (Hogarth Press. 21s.) THE popularity of the Penguin prose translations, especially Mr. Rieu's Odyssey, has shown that, with...

The Story of Archaeology

The Spectator

THE sub-title of this book is the story of archaeology." The story which archaeology has taught us in the last hundred to hundred and fifty years is twofold. First it has told...

Page 28

TO ENSURE REGULAR RECEIPT OF

The Spectator

THE SPECTATOR readers are urged to place a firm order with their news- agent or to take out a subscription. Newsagents cannot afford to take the risk of carrying stock, as...

New Novels

The Spectator

Venables. By Geoffrey Wagner. (Murray. 12s. 6d.) - Where Nests the Water Hen. By Gabrielle Roy. (Heinemann. 12s. 6d.) BUT why have so many reviewers called Venables a Gothic...

" Fictions Onely and False Hair "

The Spectator

A Reading of George Herbert. By Rosemond Tuve. (Faber. 25s.) GEORGE HERBERT, has always been considered an easy poet.- Alone of the metaphysicals he was enjoyed and reprinted...

Page 30

FINANCE AND INVESTMENT

The Spectator

By CUSTOS THERE is something very like a stalemate in the stock markets. Against the background of gradual recovery—at least in what may be termed our basic economic conditions—...

Page 31

THE "SPECTATOR" CROSSWORD No. 701 i Book Token for one

The Spectator

guinea will be awarded to the sender of the first correct ,elution opened after noon on Tuesday week November 4th, addressed Crossword. bearing NUMBER of the puzzle to 99 Cower...

Solution to Crossword No. 699 Solution on NoNemtur 7 The

The Spectator

winner of Crossword No. 699 is: Mrs. F. J. BURNLEY, Hutton-Le- Hole, York.