25 MAY 1934

Page 1

OFFICES : 99 Gower St., London, W.G. 1. Tel. :

The Spectator

MUSEUM 1721. Entered as second-clais Mail Matter at the New York, N.Y. Post Office, Dec. 23rd, 1896. Postal subscription 30s. per annum, to any part of the world. Postage on...

There is, moreover, one new factor which may modify the

The Spectator

situation substantially. M. Litvinoff's recent move- ments have inspired a good deal of undependable rumour, but it is safe to assume that Russia is more disposed to collaborate...

The Arms Embargo The prompt response of President Roosevelt to

The Spectator

the League of Nations Council's resolution regarding an embargo on arms for Bolivia and Paraguay is encouraging. By a slip, resulting from unwise reliance on a work of...

NEWS OF THE WEEK

The Spectator

T HE Disarmament _Conference meets on Tuesday to take the most critical decisions of its existence— decisions, in fact, which may end its existence. No progress of any...

Page 2

Silver in America The United States make a tentative move

The Spectator

in the direc- tion of bimetallism in the Bill which has been submitted to Congress with the blessing of President Roosevelt. It directs the executive authority to make purchases...

The Old Deal for Iron and Steel The iron and

The Spectator

steel duties, which were due to expire next October, have now been extended indefinitely on the recommendation of the Import Duties Advisory Committee. The industry has enjoyed...

The Bulgarian Coup The coup d'etat in Bulgaria has been

The Spectator

carried through without bloodshed, and has not been followed by political proscriptions. The new Ministry, headed by Colonel Kimon Gheorghieff, appears on the whole to have been...

Mr. Gandhi and Swaraj While the drafting of the report

The Spectator

of the Select Committee on India is in its final stages the situation in India itself has been sensibly modified as result • of the• decisions of the Indian National Congress at...

The Popularity of the Schools The case for the raising

The Spectator

of the school-leaving age has been fully made out both from the educational point of view and in the interests of an overcrowded labour market. A further reason for hastening...

Page 3

Sir Henry Betterton did well to reverse the decision he

The Spectator

had arrived at, after consultation with British Equity, to prohibit the appearance of the Viennese chorus at Covent Garden. The representatives of the artists take a very...

Mr. Buchan at Edinburgh Mr. John Buchan is among the

The Spectator

relatively few speakers of today who can always be counted on to say something worth listening to, and his address to the Church of Scotland on Tuesday deserves the attention of...

• * * A Great Statesman The election of President

The Spectator

Masaryk for the third time to the highest office in the Czechoslovak Republic is, and promises to remain, a unique event, for under the con- stitution of the country no future...

* * Herr Streicher and Herr Hitler As reference was

The Spectator

made in these notes last week to the scandal of the continued circulation of the mon- strous " ritual murder " issue of Der Stiirmer, it is only just to give equal publicity to...

* * * Problems of a Plebiscite It was a

The Spectator

pity that the League of Nations Council could not get so far as to fix the date of the plebiscite in the Saar at its last week's meeting, but an adjournment of eleven days—the...

New Factories in Greater London The figures relating to new,

The Spectator

closed, or extended factories given in the Survey of Industrial Development for 1933 are admittedly not an adequate guide to the volume of production, and not a sufficient clue...

Page 4

A SOCIALIST FIVE-YEAR PLAN

The Spectator

W HATEVER doubts there maybe about the policy of the Labour Party in the event of victory at the polls, at least we know exactly the plans of that section of it which belongs to...

Page 5

OCCASIONAL BIOGRAPHIES : I.-DR. BENES

The Spectator

D R. EDUARD BENES, Foreign Minister of Czecho- slovakia, will be fifty on Monday, and the event is to be suitably celebrated in his own country. Some time ago I was talking...

Page 6

* * * * The League of Nat ions Union

The Spectator

has thrown itself into some- thing formidable in undertaking, as I believe it has decided to, a national referendum on various questions connected with the League of Nations....

It is rather unfashionable in these days to be going

The Spectator

about with an appendix inside one. But it is only a comparatively recent fashion. Most laymen, . if asked, when the first operation for the removal of an appendix was carried...

It really looks as though -Covent Garden were more bent

The Spectator

on irritating than on gratifying the public. There must, I suppose, be some profound reason why the programme should never be announced for more than a week ahead, if that. The...

The. decision of Vassar to allow its students to marry

The Spectator

and continue as students raises a good many interesting questions. The avowed reason is the number of secret marriages (and possibly of less regular unions) contracted as things...

A SPECTATOR 'S NOTEBOOK

The Spectator

T HE death of Willis Abbot of. the Christian Science Monitor is a loss to journalism of the highest type everywhere. After an apprenticeship on various American papers—the...

" Japanese Foreign Office officials say that the formal recognition

The Spectator

of Manchukuo by the Republic of Salvador —which is a member of the League of Nations—eon- stitutes one of the high lights of international ' history, and is worthy to be long...

Page 7

GERMAN IMPRESSIONS : PEACE OR WAR ?

The Spectator

By H. WILSON HARRIS I T is no use pretending that the question whether Germany means peace or war is superfluous. Every German, of course, will laugh at it. But the rest of the...

Page 8

OUR GREATEST BENEFACTOR I

The Spectator

By SIR CHARLES GRANT ROBERTSON [The biographer of a certain distinguished man wrote of him : " He is the greatest benefactor of mankind whom any age has known." THE SPECTATOR...

Page 9

THE PTOMAINE-POISONING MYTH

The Spectator

By W. A. BREND F EW people have any doubt as to the reality of ptomaine-poisoning. Coroners' juries find that it is a cause of death, Courts of Law award damages for sickness...

Page 10

A SKYE DROVING

The Spectator

By GEORGE SCOTT MONCRIEFF T HE -true Highland cattle, as you will see them in Skye and the West, are far smaller beasts than those that decorated the pictures of a school of...

Page 11

DEUTSCHE HERINGE

The Spectator

[VON EINEM DEUTSCHEN SORRESPONDENTEN] VON alien deutschen Fischen, die an deutschen Kristen darauf warten, gefangen und gegcssen zu werden, ist der Hering der haufigste und...

Page 12

THE OUTLOOK FOR THE CHURCH SCOTLAND By The Rev. D.

The Spectator

P. THOMSON T HE Church of Scotland occupies today a position of quite exceptional privilege• and opportunity. Re- presenting as it does some two-fifths of the population of the...

Page 13

YOUTH . SERVICES IN SCOTLAND SERV ICES

The Spectator

By LIEUT.-COLONEL J. M. MITCHELL • The Scottish - National Council of Juvenile Organiza- tions was formed in 1919 by the Secretary of State for Scotland. For the past fifteen...

Page 14

THE FUTURE OF SCOTTISH AGRICULTURE

The Spectator

By SIR ROBERT GREIG T HE Scottish farmer is not happy. Quotas, tariffs and marketing boards have not yet brought him the relief that he expected. To what extent they have eased...

Page 15

UNIVERSITIES AND CAREERS IN SCOTLAND

The Spectator

By J. R. PEDDIE I T is unnecessary for anyone who would write on education in Scotland to emphasize the strength of the country's University tradition. For centuries there has...

Page 16

SCOTLAND AND HER TOURISTS

The Spectator

By LADY WHITSON T WO catch-phrases appear frequently in the Scottish Press and public speeches today. They are " southward trend " and " lighter industries." The brains of...

Page 17

STAGE AND SCREEN The Theatre

The Spectator

" Touch Wood." By C. L. Anthony. At the Theatre Royal, Haymarket Tat scene of Miss Anthony's new play is Set in a small hotel on the coast of Scotland. Its main theme is of...

" As You Like It." By William Shakespeare. At the

The Spectator

Open Air Theatre, Regent's Park THE sun gave his fitful patronage, and the stage, if a little too well-kept for Arden, had all the trim formality which one associates with...

The Cinema " The Scotland Yard Mystery." At the Rialto

The Spectator

THE part of Chief Inspector Stanton, in this British Inter- national picture, is played by the late Gerald du Maurier. It was his last leading part, though shortly before his...

" Flying Down to Rio." At the Regal Goon light

The Spectator

musical films are rare—as rare as good light music. It is far easier to make some sort of an impression with a strong dramatic subject. And the best light musical films, so...

Page 18

Art

The Spectator

The Stage and the Frame ARE there many artists liciw for who'lm the theatre has the fascination it had for Degas, for Watteau, for Sickert in his j - outh ? It seems not r but...

A Broadcasting Calendar

The Spectator

FRIDAY, MAY 25th 18.3o Old English Music : Northern Studio Orchestra .. N.R. 19.10 Flower Shows : Beverley Nichols .. .. N. 19.30 Along the Roman Road : G. M. Boumphrey. An...

Page 19

the Perfect Green

The Spectator

On May 30th a special conference on "greens" is to be celebrated. Now " green" as a substantive belongs technically to golf, bowls and villages ; but we may make it generic and...

* * *•

The Spectator

Nesting Zeal By a 'cottage in the same county the bird-loving owner always reconditions the old nest for a fond pair of swallows, and three years ago, by helping the pair to...

* * The Way of a Swallow

The Spectator

Here is a curious tale of the nest-building zeal of a pair of swallows on a - Hertfordshire house. The dis- tinguished owner is now waiting for the sequel. The larder is outside...

COUNTRY LIFE

The Spectator

A Highland Gateway North is north and south is south ; but I believe that the two will meet in exceptional rivalry at the Scottish National Show which is to be held just a...

Ribbon Bungalows

The Spectator

In a lovely county, 'otherwise Completely unspoilt by car, shack, or advertisement, I saw, last week, one example of the ribbon type- of bringalitis that had every disadvantage,...

The Bloody Turk

The Spectator

Can anyone trace a " Bloody Turk " ? The question is neither idle nor offensive. The adjective is a compliment, and this particular Turk is much wanted to make good a company...

Zoo Ideals

The Spectator

Thousands visited Whipsnade this Whitsuntide, and one hopes that they observed the special virtues of this most beautiful Zoo. It is right and proper that Whipsnade (which...

Page 20

LETTERS TO TIM EDITOR

The Spectator

(Correspondents are requested to keep their letters as brief as is reasonably possible. The most suitable length is that of one of our " News of the Week" paragraphs. Signed...

GERMANY TODAY

The Spectator

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR,—As a German who happened to spend a few days in England and to read Mr. Wilson Harris? " German Impres- sions " I wish to congratulate you...

THE CHURCHES, SECURITY AND PEACE [To the Editor. of THE

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.] Sut, — I submit, with the deepest respect, that _ the Arch- bishop's letter leaves Christians as much as ever in a state of desperate obscurity as to what they- are...

THE SOUTH AFRICAN PROTECTORATES

The Spectator

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] Sin,—Mr. Frank Melland, in his letter to The Spectator published on May 11th, on the subject of the South African Protector- ates, states that...

Page 21

FIRST THINGS FIRST !

The Spectator

[To the Editor of TIIE SPECTATOR.] 'wrote, on April 20th : " In our mad (voting) system, nobody's vote is worth a jot, unless it is cast for a winner. . . . In every election,...

. WILD LIFE IN THE HOME COUNTIES

The Spectator

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] Sin,—For the first time, for at least 20. years, a buzzard, or buzzards, have reappeared in this district, where West Sussex, Surrey and...

A • UNITED ARTS SOCIETY

The Spectator

'[To the Editoi of THE Si2ciiCat:] Sni,—During the period of my association with the Camaro Ballet Society-from its 'inception until the achievement of its artistic, zenith—it...

LAND, NATIONALIZATION

The Spectator

[To the Editor_ of THE SPECTATOR.] . Sin,—The Socialist League, of which Sir , Stafford Cripps is President, has made clear that the policy of the Labour Party, in power, would...

Page 22

THE PROBLEM OF GOVERNMENT [To the Editor of Tim SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR, —While Sir John Fischer Williams' scheme of proportional representation as a panacea for our is'excellent in theory, it cannot fail to produce complete chaos in practice....

THE STEEL TRAP

The Spectator

[To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR,—I should be very grateful if any of your readers could give me information on the following two points. • (I.) It was pointed out in...

FOOTBALL IN THE UNITED STATES [To the Editor of THE.

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.] Sia,—In The Spectator of April 13th is a brief comment on the visit of the Cambridge University Rugger XV to the Eastern States, where your contributor Janus...

" THE LATCHSTRING IS • OUT . [To the Editor

The Spectator

of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR,—I have never seen or heard the above expression before it appeared in The Spectator, but to me, at least, the meaning of it is perfectly obvious. In my...

INDUSTRIAL INSURANCE [To the Editor of THE SPECTATOR.] SIR, —Absence in

The Spectator

Germany has prevented me from answering earlier Mr. Harrison's letter in your issue of May 11th. If he will also study the evidence given before the Committee he will find what...

CALUMNIATING . MARX [To the Editor of TI:m SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sta,_—No finer example of the workings of petty prejudice could be provided. than a sentence in Mr. Ensor's review of Mr. E. Carr's biography of Karl ,Marx. Mr, Ensor says " he...

MATRIMONIAL DISPUTES [To the Editor of . Tug SPECTATOR.] SIR S Lovers

The Spectator

of justice will be grateful for the prominence given in the columns of .The.Spectator to the need for reform in the• matrimonial jurisdiction of the Police Courts. Lord...

Page 23

India and the British Raj

The Spectator

By SIR FREDERICK WHYTE IT has been said that the Indian problem is not one of institutions but of temper. This is not the whole truth, nor the essence of it ; but it is so near...

Page 24

Lord Curzon as Man. and Minister Curzon. The Last Phase,

The Spectator

1919-1925. By Harold Nicolson. (Constable. 18s.) Ma. HAROLD NICOISON'S new book, like his biography of his father, Lord Carnock, is at once the study of a personality and the...

"Story

The Spectator

Ix 1931 Whit Buinett and Martha Foley published the first number of Story, in Vienna. The edition consisted of eighty copies, mimeographed. The magazine was devoted entirely to...

Page 25

Honest Autobiography

The Spectator

Forty-four Years a Public Servant. By C. A. Kincaid, C.V.O., I.C.S. (Blackwood. 12s. 6d.) Ax honest autobiography may not ; ;be the noblest work of man, but it is at least his...

Page 26

Fiction

The Spectator

By H. E. BATES Mellory's Yard. By Cecilia Willoughby. .(Cape. 7s. 6d.) • The Captain Hates the Sea. By Wallace Smith. (Heinemann. • 7s. 6d.) The Unexpected Guest. By...

Page 27

Scottish Books

The Spectator

Literature in Scotland IT is now about ten years since the Scottish Renaissance began to be talked about. There was no sign of a renaissance at the time except in the work of "...

Page 28

Collected in Tranquillity

The Spectator

• TuEsu ,books, of journalistic gleanings inevitably challenge comparison with:the work of Neil Muni°, more 'kiarliefilarly with The Braiv Days and The LoOker-on, earlier...

Scotland's Economic History

The Spectator

The Economic History of Scotland. By L F: Grant. (Long-. • mans. 58.) SOME years ago Miss Grant published an impressive and useful volume on the economic history of Scotland...

Page 30

Scotland on Foot and by Canoe THE most singular feature

The Spectator

of Scotland's physical structure is the huge cleft called Glenmore, which cuts the mainland from Loch Linnhe to the Moray Firth—sixty miles—as clean and straight as if marked...

The Kilmarnock Burns

The Spectator

FOR the benefit of " the genuine Burnsian bibliophile'" Dr. Ross has soilght to' bring together all. the information bearing upon a famous first edition. He ranges from contem-...

Page 32

Scottish Poetry

The Spectator

IN Squared Circle Mr. Montgomerie shows a considerable advance on his first volume of poems, Via. He is not so consistently didactic ; his thought is clearer, and his imagery...

Shorter Notices

The Spectator

A SHORT HISTORY OF THE CLAN ROBERTSON By J. Robertson Reid There are bulky . Histories of the MacDonalds, Macleods, Cameron and other clans, but the Clan Robertson (Clans...

Page 34

LOVAT OF THE FORTY - FIVE . By W. C. Mackenzie Recent

The Spectator

interest in Prince Charlie has induced Mr. W. C. Mackenzie to give us in Lovat of the Forty-Five (The Moray Press, 5s.) an abridged and up-thdate version of the lengthy study...

Travel

The Spectator

Fishing in Scotland SCOTLAND contains. within - its boundaries as fine a variety of angling as can be-found in all Europe, and-it is not difficult to arrange an inexpensive...

SAINT ANDREW OF SCOTLAND I By R. K. Hannay How

The Spectator

-did one of the Apostles come to be the national saint nf Scotland 1' In this-little book, Sak Andrew' of Scotland (The Moray Press, 2s. 6d.), which contains the substance Of...

THE ROAD TO NOWHERE -

The Spectator

By Maurice Walsh - Mr. Walsh's latest book (W. and R. Chambers, 75. 6d.) is a tale of Irish tinkers, in .which the hero is a Scot, who joins them for a while, as many...

f , A Scottish Book List" will be found on page xiv.

The Spectator

Page 36

Scottish Golf Hazards

The Spectator

" MEBBE ye'd better tak ycr niblick wi' ye when ye dee," said Andra to the Bishop. So the story, a story, of course, of Kirkcaldy, the late professional to the Royal and Ancient...

Page 38

Scottish Roads in June

The Spectator

WHEN Ji'me_ comes it is high time to go to - Scotland again. It is time_ to see the sun setting over the en- chanted waters _of Loch Linnhe, to . climb up the Devil's Elbow...

Page 41

Finance

The Spectator

Scottish Banking and Agriculture I SUPPOSE that if one were asked to define the outstanding c haracteristic of British banking at the present day, one would say that it was an...

Page 42

LIVERPOOL AND LONDON AND GLOBE INSURANCE.

The Spectator

The latest report of the Liverpool and London and Globe Insurance Company is an excellent one. It is true that the premium income in the Underwriting Department was lower, but...

SUN INSURANCE.

The Spectator

Most of the Insurance Companies seem to have done well during last year in the matter of Fire profits, and in the case of the Sun Life Assurance Society, the results are ahead...

This Company has issued a very satisfactory report covering the

The Spectator

operations for 1933, - The ; profit from. the Fire account was particularly good, amounting tii£501,64`eoniAred with only .1281,000 in the preVious yearimhile from4heAccident...

Financial Notes

The Spectator

CHEERFUL MARIEE14. THE tone of the Stock Markets after the Whitsuntide holidayi has been a fairly cheerful one, and in spite of the unsettled outlook in many foreign countries,...

* * * •

The Spectator

v.b.c. • Although the final dividend of Venezuelan Oil Concessions for the past year was 10 per cent., agairist 121 per cent., the market had looked for the reduction, and...

-* * -* — . On. DIVIDENDS.

The Spectator

During the past *reek, the Royal;Dulehand Shell Transport and Trading Companies announced their dividends for 1933. As anticipated they dhow no change from a.. year ago; the...

Page 44

, The favourable impression created by the Annual Report of

The Spectator

the. British, Match. Corporation, was _strengthened by the statements at the recent annual meeting, a notice of which appeared in our last issue. In the course of his remarks,...

* * *- *

The Spectator

HAMBROS BANK. At the recent meeting of Hambros Bank, the Chairman, Mr. Olaf Hambro, made some shrewd and interesting observa- tions concerning the general financial situation....

The Imperial and International Communications, Ltd., has published its report

The Spectator

showing that the Company made a larger profit than in the previous year. The gross revenue was £400,000 lower, but owing to a reduction in working expenses of over £650,000, the...

ARE YOU GOING TO 'SCOTLAND ?

The Spectator

The Travel Mabager of THE SPECTATOR, who has recently returned from Scotland, will be glad to reply to inquiries from readers wishing to spend a holiday in. Scotland during the...

Page 46

SOLUTION TO CROSSWORD NI?. 86

The Spectator

si RI I I AI sl itt 011.4.84-XI AI : KI 01K1•01M1 AINIIITI;0191 SI__SIIIL:FI AI RI . XI 0 f% LI SFr ITVI-FIN LIIIIW Sil:.II: 1.Y.,1_;t11' AIOI s I! .A A Lr17/11I4NI NINIAIP I...

"The Spectator" Crossword No. 87

The Spectator

By XANTHIPPE. IA prize of one guinea will be given to the sender of the first correct solution of this crossword puzzle to be opened. Envelopes should be marked " Crossword...

A Scottish Book List

The Spectator

Spring and Summer Books GENERAL. Scottish Scene. By Lewis Grassi° Gibbdn and Hugh Macdiar- mid. (Jarrolds. 7s. 61) - - The Trial of Guy Fawkes and Others. By Donald Carswell....