28 FEBRUARY 1958

Page 3

EXPIATING THE CRIME

The Spectator

T HE bombing of the Tunisian village of Sakiet .by French planes was worse than a crime; it was a mistake, and it is surprising that the compatriots of Talleyrand should not...

THE

The Spectator

SPECTATOR

Page 4

The Balloon Goes Up

The Spectator

By MICHAEL WINNER T HE Conservative Association of Holborn and St. Pancras had gone to some trouble to prepare the hall for Housing Minister Henry Brooke. Union Jacks streamed...

RIGHT INCLINE

The Spectator

T HE report of the three wise men is written with a clarity and lucidity rare in such docu- ments. What it has to say is for the most part sensible; had it appeared in some...

Page 5

Taper is on holiday. 'Westminster Com- mentary' will be contributed

The Spectator

next week by Roy Jenkins, MP for Stechford.

Westminster Commentary

The Spectator

BY ANGUS MAUDE, MP Twenty years ago Chamberlain, commenting more in sorrow than in anger on the resignation of both his Foreign Office Ministers, said plain- tively that the...

Page 6

A Spectator's Notebook

The Spectator

SINCE HIS RETURN from his Com- monwealth tour the Prime Minister has broadcast four times—three of them on television. The contrast with his earlier, fumbling appear- ances has...

IN A POLL recently conducted at Oxford and Cambridge among

The Spectator

undergraduates in their third year, one of the questions was 'Which periodical do you prefer?' The results, published in Gemini, reveal that the Spectator heads the list at...

I AM NOT trying to suggest that the Prime Minister

The Spectator

has abused broadcasting's hospitality; on the con- trary, I shall be very pleased if his recent appearances have finally destroyed the old notion of time 'balance.' It is absurd...

MR. VITTORIO DE SICA recently took a full page in

The Spectator

a Hollywood newspaper to pay a tribute to yet another film version of Hemingway's A Farewell to Arms. It is, he writes, 'a masterpiece. Jennifer Jones is revealed as one of the...

I SEE from the News Chronicle that, according to a

The Spectator

Gallup Poll, the proportion of electors who say they would vote Liberal at a general election has risen to 15 per cent. (nine months ago it was 6 per cent.). Any further rise in...

A STATEMENT in the Defence White Paper about which several

The Spectator

journals, including the Spectator, expressed concern was the threat of retaliation with nuclear weapons if the Russians launched a major attack with conventional weapons only....

Page 7

' SHOULD A SOCIALIST,' Tom Driberg asked in Reynolds News last

The Spectator

Sunday, apropos Time and Tide, 'regret the death of a reactionary newspaper or periodical? When the Socialist Common- wealth is established, presumably such publica- tions will,...

I DO NOT ENVY Mr. Edwin Muir his task in

The Spectator

deciding which three unknown British poets are to be hauled from obscurity, in order that their works may be published in a book by Eyre and Spottiswoode; I imagine that he will...

The Spectator

John Bull's Schooldays

The Spectator

City Ways By KINGSLEY AMIS S T. HILDA'S was a place where they had big girls and little girls, but little boys only. All categories appeared to be heavily represented. My...

Page 9

The Reason Why

The Spectator

By HENRY KERBY, MP Last week Christopher Hollis urged, in an article, 'What shall we do next titne?,' that 'the most important task for the electors at the moment is to smash...

Page 10

Russians 'at Play

The Spectator

By J. E. M . ARDEN T is possible for the ordinary English reader Ito be reasonably well informed about the high- lights of Soviet politics. And he usually, too, has a pretty...

Page 11

The Day the Lama Came to Tea

The Spectator

By JOHN IRWIN M Y first thought on reading The Third Eye was, 'Can this be true?'; my second, 'I hope it is.' Here was a tale of magic powers, born of strange experience; here...

Quail at Querryton

The Spectator

By STRIX I N most of his compatriots, and many of mine, the first-hand accounts of Mr. Eisenhower setting out for a day's quail-hunting seem to have aroused disapproval...

The Opettator

The Spectator

MARCH 2, 1833 IRELAND A NUMEROUS body of the inhabitants of Dublin assembled on the 20th February, to take into con- sideration the proposed measures of coercion for Ireland....

Page 13

Consuming Interest

The Spectator

The Kitchen Stove By LESLIE ADRIAN rrntz. old-fashioned kitchen stove, the kind that 1 bakes bread, heats the kitchen and provides hot water, is coming back into fashion. The...

Page 14

Horrors Beyond Art

The Spectator

Carve Her Name with Pride. rt , (Leicester Square Theatre.) Carve Her Name with Pride (direc- tor: Lewis Gilbert) is a story of courage, the courage that sent a young London...

Contemporary Arts

The Spectator

Poets Are Out AFTER the tawdry revelations of last week's opening performance, even the gossip writers felt it their duty to massacre the Sagan- inspired ballet, Le Rendez-vous...

Page 15

Cubism for Squares

The Spectator

CAN a painter successfully trans- form his vision and talent? I can only think of one instance in the history of art to challenge a belief that he cannot; when one remem- bers...

Mr. Lear's Tragedy

The Spectator

THAT tiresome old saloon-bar comedian Charles Lamb was right about one thing—King Lear is un- actable. Though it is not fashion- able now to say so aloud. Shake- speare is...

Page 16

'DEAR SIR OR MADAM' SIR,—Taper is misinformed. The Prime Minister's

The Spectator

message to Mr. Parkinson was addressed from Can- berra and began with the words `Dear Councillor Parkinson.'—Yours faithfully, R. E. SIMMS Chief : PUblicity Officer...

REPORTING BISHOPS

The Spectator

heard the Wolfenden Report debate on December 4 last from the Strangers' Gallery in the Lords. The Bishop of Rochester used the expres- sions reported by the newspapers—if not...

SIR,—How can I adequately express my gratitude to Mr. Howard

The Spectator

Wyce? 'Be honest, courageous and generous, and never let yourself be deceived by phoney values?' This simple injunction, he says, is based on his own mature experience. It comes...

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

Side Lines of History Professor Desmond Williams Photographs in Munich William Gregory `Dear Sir or Madam' R. E. Simms Railway Safety H. Brebner Science and the Philosopher's...

SCIENCE AND THE PHILOSOPHER'S STONE SIR,—Dr. Magnus Pyke in his

The Spectator

review of Professor Read's book Through Alchemy to Chemistry seems to overestimate the difference between the modes of thinking in what we may loosely call scientific and...

RAILWAY SAFETY

The Spectator

SIR,—May I assure Mr. Henry Kerby, MP, whose article Progress in Safety' appeared in your issue of January 31, that there, is no lad( of urgency in the constant search for...

PHOTOGRAPHS IN MUNICH

The Spectator

SIR,—I was amazed to read the suggestion in A Spectator's Notebook' that I smuggled my camera in a cake tin into the Munich hospital in order to get the picture of the birthday...

`POP' FICTION

The Spectator

SIR,-1 was very interested in your article on 'pop' fiction by Vittor Anant in your issue of the Spectator • on February 14. That the love stories we do give are acceptable to...

The Spectator

Page 18

THE GERMAN 'MIRACLE' SIR,—The tragedy of T. Balogh lies not

The Spectator

in that he thought (correctly) that Dr. Erhard's measures of 1949 would result in 2,000,000 unemployed in 1950, but that he would deny, with vigorous voice and clenched eyes,...

THE NEW COLONIALISTS SIR,—While acting as host to the President

The Spectator

of Indo- nesia, Mr. Nehru called for the abolition of the last vestiges of colonialism. The Indonesians have never had any contact with Irian, by trade, conquest or travel. The...

SOFT SOAP SIR,-1 feel that Yvonne Tomes's remarks (February 14)

The Spectator

reflect a fallacious basic assumption about ad- vertising in general—and soap powder/detergent ad- vertising in particular—which is all too prevalent today. The 'washing...

STALKY AND CO.

The Spectator

SIR,—I have just seen your issue of January 3 in which Strix states that we are not told what any of the Christian names of Stalky and Co. were. This is true of 'Beetle,' but...

NATIONAL SERVICE

The Spectator

SIR,—If it is 'obnoxious in principle' to attract recruits to the services by means of exorbitant pay increases , is it not even more so to compel every fit young man to serve...

Page 19

BOOKS

The Spectator

The Tragedy of John Ruskin By PETER QUENNELL N , o wreck is so frequent, no waste so wild, as the wreck and waste of the minds of men devoted to the arts,' announced John...

Page 20

Dynamic Provincialism

The Spectator

IT would be instructive to chart the varying status of the 'provincial.' The medieval provinces were as powerful and creative as the capital : later, one man armed with only a...

Insiders

The Spectator

The Search for Good Sense. By F. L. Lucas. (Cassell, 25s.) MR. LUCAS has picked four eighteenth-centurY characters : Johnson, Chesterfield, Boswell and Goldsmith. Mr. Lucas...

Page 22

The Dog That Did Not Bark

The Spectator

The Addled Parliament of 1614. By Thomas L. Moir. (0.U.P., 30s.) ADDLED: it is not a nice reputation with which to go down to posterity. But almost all that most of us know...

Amazonians and Others

The Spectator

Wai-Wai. By Nicholas Guppy. (Murray, 28s.) TROPICAL scenery, except by a palm-fringed beach, can be profoundly boring. You cannot see the wood for the trees, the form of the...

We recommend two new editions : Macdonald and Co. have

The Spectator

brought out No. 37 in their Illus- trated Classics, price 12s. 6d., an edition of Sense and Sensibility (with Lady Susan and The Wat- sons), which follows the text of the second...

Page 23

Brave Old World

The Spectator

Brave Men: A Study of D. H. Lawrence and Simone Weil. By Richard Rees. (Gollancz. 18s.) MORE nostalgia. This is an essay on the modern World, an essay in entire dislike. The...

Miscarriages of Justice

The Spectator

Not Guilty. By Judge Jerome Frank and Barbara Frank, in association with Harold M. Hoff- man. (Gollancz, 18s.) MOST people are vaguely aware that justice. occasionally, can...

Page 24

Damnable Equations

The Spectator

The Crime of Galileo. By Giorgio de Sa ntillana. (Heinemann, 30s.) ONE usually thinks of Galileo as a victim of Church cruelty and of the sort of Church idiocy that takes the...

Sea Cruel

The Spectator

The Cassell Miscellany 18484958. Edi ted by Fred Urquhart. (Cassell, 30s.) THIS massive volume is an anthology from a hundred years of publishing by the house of Cassell. In...

Page 25

New Fiction

The Spectator

THE reviewer of novels is always, and sometimes rather desperately, on the look-out for anything which might be called a 'trend'; it was, for example, a purely journalistic...

Mafeking at Romano's

The Spectator

ARNOLD BENNETT, writing in his Journals, put down one day: Romano's. This restaurant is quite different at lunch time from dinner. Theatrical people entering, mutually known, a...

Page 26

A Doctor's Journal

The Spectator

The Common Cold Y ou would think that the common cold should be easy enough to study; but it is not so easy as it looks. Colds often seem to spread from one person to another,...

Page 28

COMPANY 'NOTES

The Spectator

By CUSTOS THE gilt-edged market opened the week with a fit of the Cohen Com- mittee blues, which is not surprising. Some recovery followed on further reflection that money...

COHEN ECONOMICS

The Spectator

By NICHOLAS DAVENPORT MY criticism of the Cohen Com- mittee's report will be confined strictly to the field of economics, but I must say at the outset that its exposition is...

Page 29

Buying the Shareholder

The Spectator

By JACK MALLOCH T HE name of Mr. Hugh Fraser has become widely known in recent years because of his increasing capacity to absorb drapery and allied businesses. In the major...

Chess

The Spectator

By PHILIDOR No. 142. Specially contributed by J. AIZIKOWICZ (Haifa, Israel) BLACK (7 men) WHITE (10 men) WHITE to play and mate in two moves: solution next week. Solution to...

Page 30

Cathode to a Doughnut

The Spectator

Zeta is Greek to most people. Competitors were therefore asked to compose• an in baffled praise of the new contrivance. ode To judge from the entries, Zeta is to do with six...

SOLUTION OF No. 979 ACROSS.-1 Castle Rising, 9 Antiquity 10

The Spectator

Grope. 11 Carrot, 12 Pintados, 13 Darwin. 15 Ignition. 18 Parietal. 19 Offers. 21 Fatalist. 23 Arnica, 26 Event. 27 On the mend, 28 Repercussion. DOWN.-1 Chanced. 2 Satyr. 3...

Since .juveniles are now able to buy expurgated editions of

The Spectator

some of the more forthright .adult novels, competitors are invited to get their own back. The usual prize of six guineas is offered of an extract from any well-known children's...

SPECTATOR CROSSWORD No. 981

The Spectator

ACROSS 1 From Our Aeronautical Cor- respondent, perhaps (6, 6). 9 Has toucan developed spines? (9) 10 The craft of the draughtsman (5). 11 If you want a change of cash, see...