29 OCTOBER 1932

Page 1

The Third Round Table The appointment of the Indian delegates

The Spectator

to the new and restricted Round Table Conference, with the intima- tion that the conference will assemble about the middle of November with the idea of finishing its work by...

The Fight for the White House All the leading American

The Spectator

issues are being sharpened in the last stage of the presidential campaign, and the election in consequence is far more realistic than any contest of the past twenty years. Mr....

The Spectator

News of the Week

The Spectator

T HE promulgation of the French disarmament plan will be by far the most important development in the disarmament field since the Hoover Plan was launched at Geneva in June. It...

Page 2

The Manchurian Issue' and the World The guarded message from

The Spectator

the Tokyo correspondent of The Times on Monday regarding a possible revolt of the northern provinces of China from Nanking, involving the restoration of the Manchu' dynasty in...

Sir Walter Layton and the Cabinet.

The Spectator

Sir Walter Layton's resignation of his position as British member of the Preparatory Committee for the World Economic Conference leaves a vacancy which no one who may be...

German Election Prospects As the date of the German election,

The Spectator

fixed for the first Sunday in November, approaches, the situation become s increasingly complex. In one respect, it is true, the air is cleared. The Chancellor has declared...

* * * * Misguided Marchers The marches of the

The Spectator

unemployed. on London are a deplorable business, and as the Minister of Health observed in the House of Commons, throw a heavy respon- sibility on those who organized them....

A Letter from Lambeth The letter which has emerged from

The Spectator

the discussions between Anglican and Free Church leaders at Lambeth last week appeals for general co-operation between all Christian Churches while a fuller scheme of " actual...

Page 3

The Police Pay Cuts The Government intends to save £1,000,000

The Spectator

by making the second reduction, foreshadowed a year ago, in the pay of the police. The ordinary constable, from November 1st, will thus lose another 4s. 3d. per week. The...

The Means Test .

The Spectator

In the House of Commons last week the Minister of Labour stated that according to the estimate of his Ministry the Means Test, or as it is now being rather more happily termed...

" Punch's " New Editor Right-minded persons, properly jealous for

The Spectator

the reputa- tion of established institutions, will learn with unfeigned satisfaction of the appointment of Mr. E. V. Knox to the editorship of Punch. Under Mr. Punch's aegis "...

Mr. Norman's Caution When the Governor of the Bank of

The Spectator

England, speaking at the Mansion House last week, expressed his inability to see the end of the world-wide depression, his speech caused something of a panic on the -New York...

" The Government thus had, in Mr. Maxton's words, a

The Spectator

`happy day' and were not called upon for any fuller explanation even of the proposed changes in the Means Test. These changes will probably be confined to a larger allowance...

Parliament at Work Our Parliamentary correspondent writes : " The

The Spectator

vote of censure debate in the House of Commons on Tuesday was a surprising affair. Originally intended by the Opposition to be an attack on the ' Means Test,' it developed into...

Postal subscription to the SrneTATOR 30e. per annum, to any

The Spectator

part of the world. Postage on this issue : Inland Id., Foreign I Id., Canada ld.

Page 4

Pigs and Prices N OT much fresh light has been thrown

The Spectator

on the Ottawa agreements by the debates in the House of Commons, though Sir Herbert Samuel elucidated one obscure point by extracting from Mr. Malcolm MacDonald the statement...

Page 5

Ten Years of Fascism T EN years ago the political and

The Spectator

economic experiment known as Fascism began its constructive phase with the peaceful capture of Rome by Mussolini's Black- shirts, and the Duce's • speech at Turin on Sunday, to...

Page 6

I was glad to hear Mr. Malcolm MacDonald make such

The Spectator

an excellent impression on the House of Commons on Monday. The meat quota scheme, which he was com- missioned to defend, is very imperfectly understood and still less perfectly...

Anticipation of the new laws of Auction and Contract Bridge,

The Spectator

to be promulgated next week, is, I gather, causing some stir in circles where bridge is taken seriously (and where, I regret to say, I do not move). As things stand, Bridge as...

• * * * The importance of Mr. Norman Davis'

The Spectator

conversations with the Prime Minister this week is not what a good many papers, who erroneously describe Mr. Davis as head of the American Delegation at the Disarmament...

Having had the opportunity of seeing and hearing the protagonists

The Spectator

at the Peace Conference myself over a period of months, I went with rather more than ordinary interest to see Dr. Ludwig's play Versailles. Of the dramatic side of it I say...

A Spectator's Notebook

The Spectator

T HE new Asquith biography, in its relentless analysis of the events of that fevered first week in December, 1916, brings to light one document on which I should like to add a...

The sooner the mystery . of Mr. Sastri's absence from the

The Spectator

new Round Table discussions is cleared up, the bette r . The official explanation is that the state of . his health makes it undesirable that he should take so long a journey...

The amnesty to political prisoners announced by Signor Mussolini at

The Spectator

Milan on Tuesday represents no sudden impulse, though little or nothing was said about it in advance. But one of the Duce's closest confidants told me more than twelve months...

Denmark, so I learn from the Pig Commission's report, is

The Spectator

happy (if there be in fact happiness in such a lot) in the possession of more pigs than people. No country in the world, I suppose, can approach that record. At any rate we,...

Page 7

Manchuria : The Next Step

The Spectator

The League as Life-Line of Civilization . BY THE EARL OF LYTTON. T HE terms of reference given to our Commission by the Resolution of the Council of the League of Nations, on...

Page 8

Russia As I Saw It V.-" Prepared for Labour and

The Spectator

Defence "- BY F. YEATS-BiOWN, A T Bolshevo, near Moscow, there is a Labour Colony -devoted to the reform of young criminals. Like our Borstal, it is a " road to life " on which...

Page 9

Modern Youth :

The Spectator

A Summing Up . . By NOWELL SMITII (late Head master of Sherborne School). A NYONE reading the four articles under this title in the last four numbers of this paper will...

Page 10

America Faces the Winter

The Spectator

T HERE is apparent in America a new attitude. Through May and June one could discover only the blackest pessimism among all classes. While it has slight justification in current...

Page 11

The Fairies

The Spectator

BY J. E. S. T HE approach of winter is being heralded in the usual manner. Its advance guard is already on the wing. Those drifting flecks of thistledown which seem to come from...

Page 12

Poetry

The Spectator

Invocation YE hills collected mutely to observe The less than snail's progression of a star ; Who watch each mothlike comet's reckless swerve Nigh the great magnet bending...

D IRECT subscribers who are changing their addresses are asked to

The Spectator

notify the SPECTATOR office BEFORE MIDDAY on MONDAY OF EACH WEEK. The previous address to which the paper has been sent and receipt reference number should be quoted.

The Theatre

The Spectator

" Tins play," writes Mr. Dunlop in a note to the published edition, " is more than a historian's chronicle of the Peace Treaty, far more than political satire, the sardonic...

Page 13

Correspondence

The Spectator

A Letter from Scotland SCOTTISH HOME RULE [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—It is quite clear now, I think, that the chief issue in Scotland at the next general election...

Page 14

There are few pigs, there are no gleaners, and there

The Spectator

is little grain in the neighbouring fields either of wheat or barley, so the mill wheel will never revolve again except in times of flood when the water may need a double...

His last successor, an equally good man in his way,

The Spectator

is now deprived of the work for which he was trained, but a miller's man can do anything. His very last job of work before leaving the mill was not without pathos. The miller's...

Progress was made by the very poorest against every difficulty.

The Spectator

The oldest worker in this discarded mill, whose career is in present memory, attended school for exactly half a day. He was then seven and the sudden offer of a job put an end...

What craftsmen these old workmen became ! It is still

The Spectator

remembered of one of them that he would sit for hour after hour with a pointed iron, roughening, with apologies for the word, the wheat stone (of an entirely different sort from...

Country Life

The Spectator

Tan LAST OF TILE Alms. The wheel of a water-mill that is recorded in Domesday and has plied ever since has just gone out of commission. One after another such mills have been...

Any of the four pair of stones could be set

The Spectator

in action by the raising or lowering of rough heads of cogs ; but this was not enough. A shaft was prolonged and the water was made to actuate a device which looks inordinately...

We cannot, of course, wish for the return of those

The Spectator

days when boys had half a day of schooling, went to work at seven and rejoiced when wages rose to 11s. a week. The present is better. Nevertheless, that is true which a country-...

" Who killed Cock Robin ? " ' Was it

The Spectator

the ship that brought its cheap cargoes of grain from America to Liverpool, where the immense modern mills give imported grain advantages quite refused to the home product ?...

Page 15

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

[Correspondents are requested to keep their letters as brief as is reasonably possible. The most suitable length is that of one of our " News of the Week " paragraphs.—EL...

Page 16

PLEDGES TO INDIA

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—In a note headed " Pledges to India," in your issue of October 15th, occurs the following passage : " The Govern- ment's position is...

;ITo of lite- SPECTATOR.] SIR, Major Yeats-Brown is undoubtedly right

The Spectator

in saying that conclusions , reached regarding Soviet Russia depend largely on the way of approach. As . .one who until the last two years took the -futility of the Soviet...

MAJOR YEATS-BROWN IN RUSSIA [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sin,—As one of Major Yeats-Brown's fellow-travellers in Russia, may I be allowed to make a few comments upon the articles he has written to the Spectator ? He tells us that his...

Page 17

PUBLIC EXECUTIONS IN UGANDA [To the Editor of the Sencrsroa.]

The Spectator

your issue of October 22nd Mr. E. D. King endeavours to justify the recent execution of two natives in the Hohna district of Uganda. He speaks of the Cruel and often unjust...

ECONOMY AND EDUCATION

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] do not think your readers will have seen any scorn or heat in my letter. I only told the - truth. which charge arouses 8s gry passions in those...

THE IRISH ARISTOCRACY

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the 8n:cc ATon.] - SIR,—I could scarcely credit my eyes, when I read the fol- lowing remark by Mr. Seim O'Faolkin in his letter on the State of Ireland. " The...

THE FATHER WHO IS NOT A PARENT [To the Editor

The Spectator

of the SPECTATOR.] Sir.,—In a case recently heard by him, Mr. Claud Mullins, the magistrate, has subjected our law to two severe criticisms, to which there does not appear to be...

Page 18

The present worthy Mayor of Liverpool is very low in

The Spectator

stature : his two Bailiffs are very tall men ; the one rather thin, the other realizing Dryden's description of one of his poetical rivals- " A tun of man in his large bulk is...

A Hundred Years Ago THE "SPECTATOR," OCTOBER 27TH, 1832.

The Spectator

The King of Holland has put an end, by a decree, to the Concession made to the English manufacturers in May last. The duty on cotton goods imported into Java was then fixed at...

A CLEAR CASE FOR ECONOMY

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —When " Economy " is a question of such urgency. it is important to call attention to the enormous cost of Lunacy administration with its...

" TRUST THE PRIME MINISTER"

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIB,—In your " Letters to the Editor " of October 8th, T. Didymus, referring to disarmament states, "British , expenditure on armaments is far...

"JANE AUSTEN CORRECTED"

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,,-L--May I beg for space in the ,Spectator to comment on a few points in your interesting review of my book, Somehow Lengthened : A...

Page 19

Education and the Social Order

The Spectator

Education and the Social Order. By Bertrand Russell. (Allen and Unwin. 78. 6d.) Muss those teachers who never speak to us " without a parable "—or rather spoke, for they are...

A Liberal Whip

The Spectator

Herbert Gladstone. A Memoir by Sir Charles Mallet. (Hutchinson. 18s.) 'flue sons of the great have many advantages but also some disabilities when they follow the public life....

Page 20

African Native Policy

The Spectator

TRE title of Mr. Barnes' book is somewhat cryptic. Ile seeks to emphasize the sharp antagonism between British and Boer ideas on the native question in Africa. If his title...

Page 21

A Truant 'Peacemaker .

The Spectator

sporting Interludes at Geneva.. By Anthony Buxton. (Country Life. 10s. 6d.) WATCHING birds is surely theanost dmiable as well as the most alluring of hobbies, though recently I...

Virginia Woolf Virginia Woolf. By Winifred Holtby. (Wishart. 63.) IT

The Spectator

is of the dead that we usually write our critical studies, and this is easy enough : we can say what we choose of those aloof, unheeding ghosts, already sated with compliments...

Page 22

Real Letter-Writing Ten Letter - Writers. By Lyn L. Irvine. (Hogarth Press.

The Spectator

• 8s. Bd.) EACII of these capable essays is complete in itself and yet they are linked together by the quick perceptions of a mind that is aware of the unity of European...

Victorian Poets The Pleasures of Poetry. Third Series. By Edith

The Spectator

Sitwell. (Duckworth. 6s.) THE final cause of this anthology, the metaphysical reason' for its existence, is hard to discover. The stars in Miss Sitwell's poetic firmament are...

Page 23

Hungry England

The Spectator

Hungry England. By A. Fenner Bniekway. (Gollanez. 2s. ad.) MR. PENNER BROCKWAY has paid flying visits to the textile towns of Lancashire, to the Black Country and Birmingham,...

Page 24

Fiction

The Spectator

BY L. A. G. 9ramici. Apples by Night. By H. A. Manhood. (Cape. 7s. 6d.) Mess MARGARET KENNEDY'S new novel centres round a query. If it were a detective story, it might be...

Page 26

Travel

The Spectator

[We publish on this page articles and notes which may help our readers in . their plans for travel at home and abroad. They arc written by correspondents who have visited the...

Page 27

FINANCIAL SUPPLEMENT

The Spectator

BANKING AND INSURANCE No. 5,444.] WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, OCTOBER 29, 132 irR.ATiS

Page 29

Centenary of Joint Stock Banking

The Spectator

The National Provincial IT was in the early part of the nineteenth century that developments in Banking occurred which may be said to have marked the commencement of the joint...

THE DEED OF SETTLEMENT.

The Spectator

These preliminaries were followed by the publication of a prospectus on April 6th, 1833, and on September 28rd , of that year a Deed of Settlement was drawn up which provided "...

DEMAND FOR JOINT STOCK BANKS.

The Spectator

In March of 1830 it was resolved to take the necessary steps to form such an establishment as had been proposed and resolutions were passed accordingly. A prominent member br...

GROWTH IN PROFITS.

The Spectator

At one time and after the absorption of the Union Bank of England the Bank bore the somewhat unwieldy title of National Provincial and Union Bank of England Limited,- but in...

Page 31

THE MIDLAND.

The Spectator

The Midland Bank which was destined to become the largest bank in the country and, indeed, at one time the largest bank in the world, was founded in Birmingham in 1836, as the...

Remarkabl e Progress

The Spectator

Ix view of the fact that the National Provincial Bank celebrates its centenary in the coming year, and because the details of its origin and progress apply to the progress of...

EXTENSION OF BANKING ACTIVITIES.

The Spectator

The years following 1846 were characterized by con- siderable activity in commercial enterprise, and there can be no question that this period of prosperity was due in no small...

BARCLAYS.

The Spectator

Barclays Bank falls into the rank of those institutions whose early beginnings are veiled by the newer title. More, perhaps, almost than any of the other banks, Barclays is the...

LLOYDS.

The Spectator

As in the case of Barclays so with Lloyds, the business was founded on some of the most important of the old private banks of the country and especially those in the Birmingham...

Page 33

EFFECTS OF DEPRECIATION.

The Spectator

Depreciation clearly affects the distributable profit. The mode and time of dealing with it has also a consider- able bearing on the theoretical rate of interest earned. If...

MARTINS.

The Spectator

Last, but by no means least, must be mentioned the evolution of the old-established business of Martins Bank, which, in its old form was among the oldest of our banking...

APPRECIATION AS A RESERVE.

The Spectator

Should this appreciation be written up ? To do so would be to reduce the apparent rate of interest on their investments and to start a new series of changes in the reverse...

SOURCE OF BONUSES.

The Spectator

Never before, owing to the course of financial affairs in the last year or two, and the sudden reduction in interest rates brought about by the conversion of War Loan, has it...

Selecting a Life Office

The Spectator

To participate or not to participate in the profits should be one of the first points to be considered by a proposer for life assurance. If a non-profit policy be chosen the...

Page 35

The Scottish Banks and Trade

The Spectator

(BY A SCOTTISH CORRESPONDENT.) IN Scotland, as elsewhere, the year 1931 will be remem- bered as a period of quite exceptional difficulty, but not- withstanding the adverse...

BEST KINDS OF LIFE INVESTMENTS.

The Spectator

Knowledge of the investments is of assistance in gauging bonus prospects. Detailed lists of these are not, as a rule, published, but rough classifications are given in the...

As regards the Note Circulation of the eight banks in

The Spectator

Scotland, the total over the past eight or nine years has been steadily round about £21,000,000. In 1920 the total was higher by nearly 50 per cent. The decrease over the...

LOANS AND ADVANCES.

The Spectator

For some considerable time past, banking loans in Scotland have shown a decidedly downward tendency, and a long continued depression in trade has altered the distribution of...

Page 37

Relations Between Banker and Customer

The Spectator

" TUE relation of banker and customer is simply the ordinary relation of debtor. and creditor." Aye, and there's the rub. For although the accuracy of this quotation from a...

OVERDRAFTS.

The Spectator

But, even if B has succeeded in his efforts and has placed A in the position of being his creditor, there is still the possibility of relations being strained. (An extended,...

THE POSITIONS REVERSED.

The Spectator

But now let us turn to the consideration of the associa- tion where relations are more often strained ; when the bank, er is creditor and the customer debtor. In this case A had...

THE CUSTOMER AS CREDITOR.

The Spectator

Let us therefore first consider the customer as creditor and the banker as debtor. In this case let A be the customer and B the banker. As W. S. Gilbert said, " A is happy "...

PLEASANT RELATIONS.

The Spectator

The relations of banker and customer arc personal for, though it may be a Joint Stock Bank on one side and a Limited Liability Company on the other, the meeting of their...

Page 38

London: ranted by IV. SPCAIGUT .s-so SON it, LTD., 98

The Spectator

and 99 Fetter Lane, E.C. , t, and published by Tsar svrCrsr0s,LTD:, at . their OffiCeS; No: 99 Gowet Street, London, W.C. 1-- - Saturday, October 29, 1932

Page 39

BANKERS' CHARGES.

The Spectator

As a result of this great fall in Money Rates the pub- lished rate of interest on banking deposits has fallen to per cent., and inasmuch as the published nominal rate of bankers...

A CHANGED FRONT. .:This cartoon appeared at the moment when

The Spectator

fears of the Piogramme of the Labour Party and the remembrance of the financial crisis during its period of office and its result on taxation ' 'and' the Old statidard had so...

DISSEMINATING FALSE IDEAS.

The Spectator

It is not, however, merely because unwise and un- worthy attacks upon the banks play into the hands of Socialist politicians that I deprecate them, but because I believe that...

The Quarterlies The Quarterly opens with an article on Mr.

The Spectator

Gladstone by Lord Crewe, developed out of an address given at St. Deiniol's Library, Hawarden. As the son and son-in-law of two close friends, and himself a minor colleague in...

Finance—Public & Private

The Spectator

A Foolish Vendetta THERE are two main reasons why the attacks made by the Socialist Party and by a section of the stunt Press upon our banking system and our banking policy are...

How BANKERS' RESOURCES ARE USED.

The Spectator

If all, or even the greater part of the deposits were used in long-dated advances such assurance most cer- tainly could not be given and certainly not with industry in its...

Page 40

CAUSES OF THE FALL.

The Spectator

It soon became apparent, - however,. that other influences than those I have just mentioned were also operating. If the reader recalls for a moment the events of the late summer...

THE REAL OWNERS OF BANKING RESOURCES.

The Spectator

.I have left myself little space in which to refer to the misrepresentation of those who refer to the banks and the bankers as though they were a species of capitalist immensely...

* * * *

The Spectator

CONTINENTAL FEARS. During the past few weeks Foreign markets, and especially Continental markets, have been alarmed by distorted reports of certain developments here. The...

Bank Rate 2 per cent., changed from 2} per cent.

The Spectator

on June 30th, 1932.

Financial Notes

The Spectator

FALL IN THE THE sharp reaction which has occurred in British Funds and kindred securities during the past week has clearly demonstrated two facts, the first being that markets...

Page 42

A Radio Review .

The Spectator

critics. Why is it that book reviewing by radio seems to put such a deadening hand on a critic ? Even Mr. Forster is already failing to live up to expectations: His talk last...

Radio Vaudeville stands pretty much where it stood six years

The Spectator

ago ; and the recent efforts to brighten things up by following the craze for non-stop entertainment are not much of an improvement. I think Mr. Filson Young gets more or less...

Do not fail to make a point of listening to

The Spectator

the new. Miracle Play which is to be broadcast from St. Hilary Cornwall, on Tuesday night next. This little Cornish village has jumped into fame entirely on the strength of its...

Of chief interest in next Wednesday's programme of the B.B.C.

The Spectator

Symphony Concert is William Walton's Balshazzar's Feast," a modern oratorio to a text by Osbert Sitwell based on the Biblical story. Mr. Walton is undoubtedly the most original...