2 MAY 1908

Page 1

It is not necessary to dwell upon Mr. Asquith's short

The Spectator

and felicitously expressed speech. It contained some rhetorical allusions to the citadel of Free-trade—the citadel at whose gates Sir John Brunner had just placed his bag of...

Sir Henry Campbell-Bannerman was buried in Meigle Churchyard, near his

The Spectator

home in Perthshire, on Tuesday. The first part of the funeral service, however, was held in West- minster Abbey on Monday amid every sign of civic and

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

A S we have pointed out elsewhere, we are by no means dismayed by the result of the North-West Manchester election. What., however, does fill us with dismay is the attitude of...

This is either nonsense, and mischievous nonsense, or else it

The Spectator

means that the Liberal Party are advised by their typical representative to abandon the policy of maintaining free exchange and free contract wherever possible, and to enter...

Mr. Winston Churchill has been chosen as their candidate by

The Spectator

the Liberal organisation at Dundee, and has begun his campaign in that city. He is opposed by a strong local Unionist, and also by a popular member of the Labour Party. Those...

The polling in North-West Manchester, announced to the world last

The Spectator

Saturday morning, resulted in the return of Mr. Joynson-Hicks, the Unionist candidate, by a majority of 429 votes. Mr. Joynson-Hicks received 5,417 votes, while Mr. Churchill...

IV The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript, in any

The Spectator

case.

Page 2

M. CLEMENCRAIPS VISIT. T HE unexpected attendance of M. Clemenceau at

The Spectator

the memorial service to Sir Henry Campbell-Bannerman has an importance of its own which, though the visit was welcomed, has perhaps been imperfectly perceived. It may, of...

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

THE MANCHESTER ELECTION. E are not surprised at, nor do we regret, the verdict passed on the policy of the Government by the electors of North-West Manchester, for that verdict...

Page 3

:THE -POSITION OF THE GOVERNMENT.

The Spectator

P it possible for the present Government to escape from the dangerous position in which they are placed owing to the unhappy policy which they have fore- shadowed in regard to...

Page 4

THE INDIAN FRONTIER.

The Spectator

T HEpenetration of the Bazar Valley, and the swift exaction of forfeits and of promises of good behaviour from the Zakka Khel, seemed likely to ensure peace for at least some...

Page 5

M.R. ROOSEVELT ON THE MISUSE OF WEALTH.

The Spectator

1VI R. ROOSEVELT plays an exceptional and a very useful part in the formation of public opinion. The singular fraukness which characterises some of his speeches could hardly be...

Page 6

THE DISCIPLINE OF THE NAVY.

The Spectator

W ITHIN three weeks the Navy has suffered three grave accidents from collision. The third involved the loss of only one life ; but the other two—the wrecks of the destroyer...

Page 7

"THE WORLD FITHIN THE WORLD."

The Spectator

W HOEVER enjoys literary criticism welcomes a new book by Mr. Stopford Brooke, and no one who reads "A Study of Four Poets" (London: Sir I. Pitman and Sons, 6s. net) will be...

Page 8

AN APRIL BLIZZARD.

The Spectator

T HE weather of April deserves, if not a tribute, a record. It was the worst and coldest April known for years. The first three weeks were a succession of bitter winds from the...

Page 9

THZ EDITOR or THE “SpecrAvor..1

The Spectator

do not think that the result of this election must be treated as pointing to any extensive change of opinion in the division on the question of Tariff Reform. I agree with a...

[To THE EDITOR Or THE "SPECTATOR.") SIR,—Judging of the result

The Spectator

of .the North-West Manchester election, I have come to the conclusion that the Free-trade issue on its merits had comparatively little to do with Mr. Churchill's defeat. Those...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

THE MANCHESTER ELECTION. LTO THE EDITOR Or THE "SPECTATOR:2] Sig,—I do not think that the result of the North-West Man- chester election is such a blow to Free-trade as many...

[To TEE EDITOR Or THE " SpEcrATort."

The Spectator

Sin,—.There are few Manchester Free-traders who are not deeply disappointed that Mr. Winston Churchill has oeased to be the representative in the House of Commons of North-...

Page 10

. " THE 'UNREST IN INDIA.

The Spectator

[TO Tile EDITOR OP TRH " Sp gerATore."] SIR,—In the letter you published last Saturday, Mr. Macnicol, of Poona, drags in a sneer at me for reasons of his own. To myself the...

A PLEA FOR THE REFERENDUM.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or THE "SPECTATOR."] SIR, — Liberals and Conservatives alike are trying to explain . the astonishing change of opinion apparently indicated by the recent...

Page 11

[TO THE EDITOR OP THE " S PECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sin,—Your correspondent Mr. Macnicol in the Spectator of April 25th takes alarm at certain aspects of the political movement in India, and seems to prescribe "the association of...

(TO TIIE maven OP THIS " SPECTATOR...1

The Spectator

you allow a brewery investor space to reply to your suggestion (Spectator, April 25th) that we are levying a kind of blackmail by making our gifts to religious and charitable...

THE LICENSING BILL.

The Spectator

(To THE EDITOR OF THE "SrEcrAvos."1 SIR, — I read with great interest your most excellent article on the Licensing Bill in last week's Spectator, and agree heartily with. it,...

THE ASSASSINATION OF COUNT POTOCKI.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECT ATOR." J SIR, — In your issue of April 18th, p. 602, you say : "There is no doubt, we fear, that the Ruthenes have been a good deal oppressed by...

BURNING OF HEATH AND FURZE IN THE NEW FOREST.

The Spectator

['to THE EDITOR or THE SP scrAToR. - .1 • SIR, — Recent roadside burnings in our national park have called forth numerous and well-founded protests from holiday folk who sought...

ITO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR:' J

The Spectator

Sin, — As your correspondent writing over the signature of N. Maw:awl in last week's Spectator points out, there is no physical crisis in India, and, it may be added, there...

Page 12

To Trls RDITOR OF THIC sescraxott:g

The Spectator

Sin,—It is a curious story that of the New Forest for the last sixty years. At the beginning of this period a forest in Hampshire was not of much more value to the Londoner than...

Page 13

THE CUCKOO.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF TH6 .SPECTATOR." J SIR,—Among this week's "records " in the vagaries of Nature, it is perhaps worth noting that the cuckoo has been singing here nearly every...

PARTICULARISM IN FRANCE.

The Spectator

[To nis RPITOR OF TEE " EPZCSATOR.1 SIR,—As a French student of history and politics, allow me to lodge a strong protest against the sweeping statement con- tained in your last...

SHERIDAN ON DIRECT TAXATION.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE SPROTATOR.”.1 SIR,—In your article, "The Budget and the Sugar-Tax," in the Spectator of April 25th you say :—" The only way to bring home to all the...

THE PATH TO RUIN.

The Spectator

"To-Day's MOTTO.= The man who first ruined the Roman people was he who first gave them treats and gratuities:— PLUTARCH:" "Being interrupted with a cry, 'What about old-age...

PROFESSOR HTJXLEY ON MIRACLES.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF " SPECTATOP 'i SIR,—Mr. Cave's quotation (Spectator, April 25th) hardly serves his purpose. Huxley certainly says that the supposed occurrence of miracles...

Page 14

POE TRY.

The Spectator

THE ABLE SEAMAN. "A.B." the papers call him, with a number, But he has a name, the same as you and I, And if you're told he's ornamental lumber Or lives abroad for pleasure...

"A MERCIFUL MAN IS MERCIFUL TO HIS BEAST." iTo run

The Spectator

EDITOR OF THL "SrecieTom") SIR,—Could you kindly inform me where the words, "A merciful man is merciful to his beast," can be found ? Our Band of Mercy is erecting a...

DEAR MR.

The Spectator

In my opinion, the great danger before us is the destruction of the spirit of the people. The risk we are running is that our nation may fall through the weakening of the...

A CORRECTION.

The Spectator

LTO THR EDITOR Of THR " SPRCTAT01.1 SIR,—Your printers last week, in printing my letter, omitted the words that I now print in. italics, and consequently made nonsense of the...

Page 15

ART.

The Spectator

THE NEW GALLERY. Iv has long been a complaint against the Directors of the New Gallery that they have reduced their Exhibition to little more than the anteroom of the Academy....

Page 16

BOOKS.

The Spectator

SEVENTEENTH-CENTURY CRITICISM. * Tim critical work of the seventeenth century deserves more respect and attention than it usually receives, and Professor Spingarn's collection...

Page 17

PROFESSOR CHURCH'S REMINISCENCES.* This very agreeable book of reminiscences could:.

The Spectator

only have been written by a scholar, because. a less well-cultivated mind would have failed to see how much the small things-matter. Aggregations of small things in...

Page 18

KAFIR SOCIALISM.*

The Spectator

THE problem of black and white, or, as it may be, brown and white, is so much the most serious of the questions of the future that we are greatly in the debt of any one who can...

Page 19

BOOKS ON BIRDS.* WE propose to include in one short

The Spectator

notice four books which treat of birds from different points of view. The first before us deals with all British birds. A new handbook of British birds finds many competitors...

PRACTICAL HOUSING.* TrEE workers of the last generation who took

The Spectator

to heart the waste and misery caused by ill housing may rest in thankful- ness that the first great advance towards general improvement has come to pass, for housing is at last...

Page 20

THE CAUSES OF POTERTY4

The Spectator

A REVIEWER must always be grateful to an author who begins by explaining, "in a single sentence," the aim of his • Famous Preach 5oons. Br Fntak MaineL With 90 Lhittritions.....

FAMOUS FRENCH SALONS.*

The Spectator

Mn. HAMEL has written a pleasant and interesting book on an agreeable subject. The history of French society, one may say, is that of the salons ; at least, of the society of...

NOVELS.

The Spectator

FENNEL AND RUE.* STunEwrs of the work of Mr. Howells cannot have failed to notice the points of contact and of divergence which define his relations to the intellectual...

Page 21

Hyde Park : its History and Romance. By Mrs. Alec

The Spectator

Tweedie. (Eveleigh Nash. 15s. net.)—Hyde Park as we see it now may be said to be wholly modern. It has changed greatly even within the memory of living persons. Its...

Oriental Campaigns. By Colonel E. Maude. T. Fisher Vnwin. 75.

The Spectator

6d. net.)—This "Veteran of the Indian Mutiny" went out with a cadetship in 1843, and was put into the Bombay establish- ment. On arriving in India he was attached to a native...

RE&DAELE NOVELS.—A Tangled Web. By L. E. Moberly. (Ward, Lock,

The Spectator

and Co. 6s.)—A tale quite true to its title. With a heroine who suffers from lesion of the brain, a olairvoyante friend, and a bigamist husband, the tangle ia .eensiderable,— An...

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

[Under this heading we notice such nooks of the souk is haw not bug reserved for review in other forms.] Lady Lettice, Vi-countess Falkland. By John Dimon. Edited, with...

Isle Raven. By Owen Rhoscomyl. (Duckworth and Co. Os.)— This

The Spectator

is a story of an exceedingly lawless set of people who take possession of a small island off, we conclude, the coast of Wales. The inoidents are romantic, though they are a...

Page 22

The Influence of Alcohol and other Drugs on Fatigue. By

The Spectator

W. H. R. Rivers, M.D. (E. Arnold. 68. net.)—It might be safer to pass over this volume (reproducing the Croonian Lectures, 1906) with a recognition of the caution, the...

The Complete Cook. By Lilian Whaling. Mustrated. (Methuen and Co.

The Spectator

7s. 6d. net.)—This is a book that we can warmly recommend to intelligent, but inexperienced, housewives. No detail seems to have been forgotten. With one or two curious...

Irish and English. By Robert Lynd. (F. Griffiths. 5s. net.)—

The Spectator

These "Portraits and Impressions" are, as might be expected, of various value. The English part is more pleasant to read, at least to an Englishman. The Irish has the character,...

NEw EDITIONS.—The Wessex of Romance. By Wilkinson Sherren. (Francis Griffiths.

The Spectator

6s. net.)—Mr. Sherren first brought out this book six years ago. It now comes out revised and enlarged. Substantially it is a monograph on Mr. Thomas Hardy, with various...

The Bibliography of Charles and Mary Lamb. Compiled and Annotated

The Spectator

by J. C. Thomson. (J. E. Tatin, Hull. 5s. net.)— Mr. Thomson, helped by the labours of others, notably Alfred Ainger and Mr. E. V. Lucas—an assistance which he amply...

Bt. George for Merrie England. By Margaret Bulley. (George Allen

The Spectator

and Sons. 5s.)—If we have a patron saint, and are disposed to bring his patronage to the front, it is as well to know who he was. "To denounce St: George," writes Miss Bulley,...