3 MARCH 1928

Page 1

4. 41

The Spectator

. We have watched with interest the public discussions in the Naval Affairs Committee, as reported here, with the earnest deputations from religious bodies, women and business...

EDITORIAL AND PUBLISHING OFFICES : 13 York Street, Covent Garden,

The Spectator

London, W.C.2.—A Subscription to the SPECTATOR costs Thirty Shillings per annum, including postage, to any part of the world. The SPECTATOR is registered as a Newspaper. The...

At Washington the new Naval Bill was introduced into -the

The Spectator

House of Representatives on Tuesday by the Chairman of _the Naval Affairs Committee. It provideS for fifteen cruisers and one aircraft carrier, to be constructed during the...

The League of Nations Committee on Arbitration and Security has

The Spectator

continued its session at Geneva. On Thursday, February 23rd, at the public sitting the merits of a general treaty as against bilateral or regional treaties were discussed. Lord...

* * We would never decry these "moral values and

The Spectator

we appreciate the view of M. Politis expressed on Friday when the Finnish Delegate brought up a report on forms of arbitration. M. Politis said that these would have a...

News of the Week IR JOHN SIMON'S Commission is going

The Spectator

steadily S On its *ay in India, and, we believe, improving its hope's of ultimate success. In the Council of State on Thursday, February 23rd, Sir Sankaran Nair made another...

Page 2

On • Tuesday Lord Haldane brought about a useful debate

The Spectator

in the Upper House on the administrative changes lately announced 'by the War Office. His aim was to find out the expected results and to urge that they should be tested in...

The Army Estimates, as published last week, show a reduction

The Spectator

from the current total of £41,565,000 to about £41,000,000. According to the White Paper issued on Saturday the Civil Estimates for 1928 are expected to fall from £231,000,000...

The rest of the day was given up to Supplementary

The Spectator

Estimates. The Secretary of State for Scotland explained that in his country National Health Insurance had cost more than had been expected ; part of the cost could be made up...

* * * * On Tuesday the Dutch delegate pursued

The Spectator

the line of proclaiming the possibilities of security already available under the Covenant. The representative of Yugoslavia went further in asking for estimates of the...

In the House of Commons on Thursday, February 24th, the

The Spectator

question was raised of compensation said to be due under the Treaty of 1921 to two Irish retired civil servants. Any deliberate injustice by a Government to a subject would stir...

* * * On Friday, February 24th, the House gave

The Spectator

a second reading to Mr. Somerville's Empire Settlement Bill. This proposed a permanent Board of Administrators and the creation of training centres for a three-months intensive...

The House of Commons began the discussion of the Bill

The Spectator

promoted by the L.M.S. Railway Co. The Prime Minister had earlier stated the intention of the Government to pass the Road Traffic Bill and to investigate the whole subject of...

Page 3

For the moment the news from China has a more

The Spectator

satisfactory appearance. Seventeen of the foreign Inspectors of the Salt Gabelle, including four British, have been reinstated in various widely distant posts. This should be a...

Many people will deeply regret the death of Sir Albert

The Spectator

Gray. He was a useful and able public servant as Counsel to the Chairman of Committees in the House of Lords. He was also chairman of " Scapa " and a keen worker for the...

The Civil Service Board of Inquiry appointed by the Prime

The Spectator

Minister to inquire into statements made in the case of Ironmonger v. Dyne affecting Civil Servants issued a long Report on Monday. They found that Mr. Gregory, Mr. O'Malley,...

Prince Lichnowsky, who died on Monday, deserves, as Lord Grey

The Spectator

said in , generous tribute to him on Tuesday, our gratitude for his efforts to preserve the peace of Europe. After living on his estates in Silesia for several years in...

The by-election in the Ilford Division, caused by the death

The Spectator

of that popular and excellent member, Sir Fredric Wise, resulted last week as follows :— Sir George Hamilton (Con.) .. • • 18,269 Mr. A. S. Comyns Carr (Lib.) • • 13,621 Mr. C....

* * * * France has been active in her

The Spectator

policy of trade agree- ments and treaties. Her Belgian Commercial Treaty is now signed. It brings in Luxembourg which, it will be remembered, left the German Zollverein after...

* * * * A General Election took place in

The Spectator

Japan last week and the results were known here on Saturday. The Minis- terial Party, on which Mr. Tanaka's Government relies, has a majority of seven over the Liberal...

Bank Rate, 41 per cent., changed from 5 per cent.,

The Spectator

on April 21st, 1927. War Loan (5 per cent.) was on Wednesday 101# ; on Wednesday week 10141 ; a year ago 1011. Funding Loan (4 per cent.) was on Wednesday 834; on Wednesday week...

Page 4

The Nurse Cavell Film T HE banning of the Nurse Cavell

The Spectator

film, Dawn, by the British Board of Film Censors has directed our thoughts to larger issues than the fate of the production in question. Many issues are involved, and the...

Page 5

The Distress in South Wales T ELE Rhondda. Valley was one

The Spectator

of the most, prosperous coalfields. in the world in X913. It is now on the verge of ruin. . To explore causes which led to this result can serve no useful purpose now ; but to...

Page 6

The Civil Service

The Spectator

THE severe punishment meted out by the Secretary • of State for Foreign Affairs to two members of the Foreign Office, with milder treatment towards a third, has come with no...

Page 7

How to Deal with Unemployment

The Spectator

[Sir Herbert Samuel, in this important article, suggests setting up a Committee of the Privy Council to deal with the whole question of national development. ' We hope to give...

Page 8

The Week in Parliament

The Spectator

0 /si Friday of last week Mr. Somerville introduced a Bill designed to expedite and to increase emigration from this country to the Dominions. The Bill itself has little chance...

.. - _Passenger to Mo§cO* T O-DAY the journey from London to Moscow

The Spectator

takes just . sixty-six hours, travelling by the . Hook -of Holland, Berlin, Warsaw, Minsk, Moscow. The most convenient way of going is to leave Liverpool Street Station at 8.80...

Page 9

On Planting Flower-Pictures

The Spectator

T HE old-fashioned plants which flourished a century ago, and nearly disappeared during the era of ribbon bedding, are now once more so firmly rooted in our soil and in our...

Page 10

The Lost Manuscript

The Spectator

[This is another story from our recent Short Story Competition. We would call the attention of our readers to an offer made to our contributors, from the Northern Newspaper...

Page 11

Art

The Spectator

THE SAVILLE GALLERY, STRATFORD PLACE, OXFORD STREET. THE pictures now on show at the various galleries within a short distance of Bond Street are pleasantly varied. One has the...

Page 12

Tim WALKER GALLERIES, BOND STREET.

The Spectator

The two exhibitions at the Walker Galleries are both of water-colours, and although the " Pastoral " label is not strictly true, yet it gives the right idea. Here are views from...

Roving Sailor*

The Spectator

ROVING Sailoz, whence do you hail, Sir ? " " From a far country, away to the South I " " What is your race, and what is your name, Sir ? "A long strange name, that is soft in...

Poetry

The Spectator

Prophecy for Lovers SPRING will not walk the windy ways Ever again, nor tread the sward As once, when she had Youth for lord. Spring will not gather sixty days Into the...

ST. GEORGE'S GALLERY, HANOVER SQUARE.

The Spectator

At St. George's Gallery, four young Chelsea artists, Mr. Blair Hughes-Stanton, Mr. William M'Cance, Miss Gertrude Hermes, and Miss Agnes Millar-Parker are exhibiting. Mr. Blair...

Correspondence

The Spectator

A LETTER FROM MELBOURNE. [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sra,—The economic outlook at the present time is far from promising. Although there has been no drought in the...

Page 13

The League of Nations

The Spectator

A Crowded Six Weeks at Geneva THE -AGENDA. 'The League of Nations Council will begin its forty-ninth meeting on Monday, with the representative of Colombia, Senor Urrutia, in...

Page 14

Sir Horace Plunkett, the greatest of the pioneers, who through

The Spectator

co-operation completely resuscitated Irish agricul- ture, and all who are of his school cannot but regard such an attitude as retrograde and of less use to •the farmer than the...

* .

The Spectator

UNIVERSITY CO-OPERATION. The two UniVersities of Criford and Canibridge never entered into a better form of co-operation than when they agreed to share farming science between...

In Oxfordshire I was advised to drive along a road

The Spectator

where I should see farms -left utterly derelict, already returning to thorns• and briars, almost alongside a farm on which a small fortune had been spent, and cultivation was...

Country Life

The Spectator

TAILLESS PIGEONS. Many of those who hate the pigeon shooting at-Monte Carlo —about which many questions are asked-7-wonder why the , birds are robbed of their tails before...

THE N.F.U. AGAIN. -

The Spectator

It is deeply regretted by many-of those interested in the land that the National- Farmers' Union has definitely come out egainst - Aile-agalinciple of co-operation. In their...

* * * * WicenE FARMERS Loan.

The Spectator

A very persistent effort has been made by the School of Agriculture at Oxford to discover, -so far as-may be,..exactly why farming has ceased to pay ; and one very important...

ENGLISH BIRDS IN INDIA.

The Spectator

• Some paragraphs on bird thigration,and on the introduction, of goldfinches into Australia, have brought letters from readers of the Spectator in various districts of Arilea...

* * * *

The Spectator

The point maY perhaps be driven home - by a personal experience:" Again and again I have found that the successful farmer of a district has been the best engineer. The man who...

One of the very oldest of country sayings is that

The Spectator

" March is the month that blooms the whirs ; and the whins, the furze, the gorse, is already in very gorgeous bloom on Midland commons. On one popular golf links you may....

Page 15

"LITTLE MOSCOWS " IN SOUTH WALES [To the Editor of

The Spectator

the SPECTATOR:] Sitt,—In your •last issue Mr. F. Yeats-Brown draws a tragic picture of the conditions of `.* semi-starvation that existin the mining area of the 'Rhondda-...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sur„—As the Spectator has

The Spectator

so whole-heartedly championed the cause of slum dwellers it may net be without interest to some of its readers to hear of a small effort that has been made in Dublin to grapple...

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

SOLVING THE SLUM PROBLEM [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] have read with great interest and sympathy the articles and correspondence appearing in the Spectator during the last...

Page 16

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Would it not be

The Spectator

better if in the Spectator some sympathy was shown for those unfortunate persons, some of them of very small means, who have put money into the coal, steel, and iron companies...

[TO the Editor of the SPEcrexon.] Sra,—The article in the

The Spectator

Spectator of February 18th, by Mr. F. Yeats-Brown, is most poignant. I cannot refrain from asking you and your readers whether a community of 7,000 workless people might not...

HOMECROFTING FOR MINERS

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the &smarm:Li- 'Snr,—Those whti have lived in the district so sympathetically treated in the article, " A Visit to Little Moscow," will realize the urgency of...

Page 17

PRAYER BOOK REVISION

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Six, —Lord Hugh Cecil in his admirable letter writes : " The rubric at the end of the Communion Service certainly does prohibit Reservation,...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.1

The Spectator

SIR,—To such subtlety as that of Lord Hugh Cecil nothing is so attractive as the defence of the indefensible : but how conscious of the weakness of his case must so much...

THE COTTON TRADE

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Would you permit me, as a Lancashire man born and bred, to criticize quite bluntly your article on " The Parlous State of the Cotton...

Page 18

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

Sra,—Sir William Beach Thomas has so vividly described the revolting practice of pigeon shooting at Monte Carlo in your issue of February 18th, and its effect on the civilized...

BRITISH RELATIONS WITH RUSSIA

The Spectator

'To the Editor of the SeucrAron.] SIR,—It saddens me almost beyond words to find the Spectator advocating the resumption of diplomatic relations with a Government which is...

PIGEON SHOOTING AT ITS WORST

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Snx,—Most of us as we grow older become more humane, perhaps because we see things from a different angle and in truer perspective. Years ago,...

Page 19

THE. STEEL TRAP

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sra,—Those who have followed the recent correspondence in the Spectator may be interested to know that there is now being circulated a petition...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sia,—Correspondence from the original

The Spectator

letter on " My Ideal School," and to my second letter stating that I had found the school, is still reaching me day by day, and I must say the type of correspondent is rather a...

THOMAS HUGHES

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] S1R,—May I correct an error in Mr. Alfred Everson's most interesting letter on " H. H. Asquith as a Contributor to the Spectator" ? (P. 265,...

" MY IDEAL SCHOOL"

The Spectator

[To the Editor of - the SPECTATOR.] Sra,—It may interest your correspondent, " BM/B02L," not perhaps as a practical solution to his perplexity, but rather as a matter of...

SHORT STORIES

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sia,—We -should be greatly obliged if you could put us in touch with the short story writers in your Competition. Many of them are probably...

THIRD-CLASS SLEEPERS

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sm,—When Colonel Applin suggested in the House of Commons that the British railway companies should provide sleepers for third-class...

HUMANE SLAUGHTER OF ANIMALS FOR FOOD

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—On behalf of this Society, and at the direction of my Directors, I desire to express, as the Royal S.P.C.A. has already done, our very...

Page 20

* * * *

The Spectator

The fashionable world at the time of the American war was stirred to its shallow depths by the Trial of the Ducheris of Kingston. (Edited by Lewis Melville. William Hodge. 10s.....

We have long regarded The Short History of the World

The Spectator

as a fascinating abridgment of Mr. H. G. Wells's most inspired work. A new edition by Heinemann at 3s. 6d. is to be welcomed. Another, and this a complete illustrated edition;...

The third edition of Ultra-Violet Rays in the Treatment and

The Spectator

Cure of Disease, by Dr. Percy Hall, with introductions by Doctors Sir Henry Gauvain and Leonard Hill (Heinemann, 12s. 6d.), is a work for the practitioner, but it will, however,...

Lady Emmeline Stuart-Wortley and her daughter Victoria were the Wanderers

The Spectator

about whom Mrs. Cust writes (Cape, 12s. 6d.). They both had a passion for travel, though the little girl was not yet in her teens when in 1849 they set . out for New York....

* * * *

The Spectator

We welcome a new magazine, The University, published by the National Union of Students, 3 Endsleigh Street, and wish it all prosperity.. There is a good article on " The Woman...

The March number of Air (Is.) contains an important article

The Spectator

by General Groves, pointing out that while we are spending £100,000,000 on the supposition that war may recur, we are neglecting to provide for the essentials of adequate air...

We would again call attention to the programme of Talks

The Spectator

and Lectures issued by the B.B.C., and to the booklets which' have been prepared to accompany their educational courses. Professor Campbell is speaking on Greek Plays this week,...

Some Books of the Week

The Spectator

Dunr:a the past month the books most in demand at " The Times Book Club " have been :— Nox-Fic-noN : The Day After . To-morrow, - by Sir Philip Gibbs ; New York Nights, by...

* * * *

The Spectator

Dr. Rudolph Kircher, correspondent of the Frankfurter Zeitung, whose previous book, Englander, was such an original and remarkable survey of English life, has now written a...

Hermes, or The Future of Chemistry, by Dr. T. W.

The Spectator

Jones (To-Day and To-morrow Series, Kegan Paul, 2s. 6d.), is not as attractive as some of this series of sparkling books ; but it is'a sound survey of modern chemistry, more...

General Knowledge Questions

The Spectator

OUR weekly prize of one guinea for the best thirteen Questions submitted is awarded, this week to Mrs. Cruse, 48 Fernleigh Road, Winchmore Hill, N. 21, for the following :—...

Page 21

he 5p e ctator

The Spectator

FINANCIAL SUPPLEMENT BANKING AND INSURANCE [G RATIS. No, 5,201.] WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, MARCH 3, 1928.

Page 23

Regulating the Country's Credit

The Spectator

A Corning Problem IF the expectations held in some quarters are fulfilled, the advent . of the next Spring Financial Supplement of the Spectator will see the British Treasury...

Banking in 1927

The Spectator

An Abnormal Year—Deposits Higher—Trade Demands DOUBTLESS the moment will at some time arrive when; in surveying the Banking developments over the preceding twelve months, it...

Page 27

Banking Profits and Bank Shares

The Spectator

Wrrn the exception of the Midland, all the banks in the group known as the Big Five show a small reduction in profits for the past year. A year ago it was Barclays which was the...

Page 31

"What is Left"

The Spectator

Some Insurance Considerations " IF one attempted to provide by insurance against the majority of ills to which one _ is heir, there would-be nothing left to live on," is the...

Page 35

Schemes for Insurance of School Fees

The Spectator

Hints to Parents " How I wish I could have afforded to give my boys and girls a better education ! " This is the lament of many an anxious parent, especially when the time...

Page 38

1..g000ti; .Printed by W. SPEAICUT AND SONS, LTD., 98 and

The Spectator

99 Fetter Lane, E.C. 4, and Published Iv ,TIIE SPEcTATOR, LTD., at their Offices, No. 13 York Street, Covent Garden, London, W.C. 2:—Saturday March 3, 1928.

Page 39

Johan Bojer

The Spectator

THE genius of Johan Bojer is so beautiful and unusual that criticism of it must necessarily be diffident. It is distinguished by a simplicity that is sometimes_ childlike, an...

Page 40

W. B. Yeats

The Spectator

The Tower. By W. B. Yeats. (Macmillan. 6s.) A raw years ago, turning his back on England, Mr. Yeats „ . sang:— " Much did I rage when young, Being by the world oppressed, But...

The German Case

The Spectator

The Mirage of Versailles. By Hermann Stegemann. Trans- , :lated by B: T. Clark. (George - Allen and Unwin. 12s. 6d.) The Mirage of Versailles' is a disappointing and pretentious...

Page 41

Our Modern World

The Spectator

Reputations. By Captain B. A. Liddell Hart. (Murray. 12s.) ALTHOUGH the least considerable of the three volumes before us, Mr. Wells's is undeniably the most - interesting....

Page 42

An. Enchanted Cigarette

The Spectator

Memories of Books and Places. By J. A. Ilammerton. (Sampson Low. 12s. 6d.) Amotio Mr. Hamznerton's most engaging " Memories " appears a friend of his boyhood, an old journalist...

Page 43

Beati Pauperes

The Spectator

IT is a part of the wholesome discipline of historical studies, that they perpetually correct our conceited belief in the unique character of modern thought, modern problems,...

Two German Sea-Dogs

The Spectator

Count Luckner, the Sea Devil. By Lowell Thomas. (Doubleday, Page and Co. $2.50.) READERS of Mr. Lowell Thomas's preliminary chapter may possibly be irritated by the statement...

Page 44

Getting Value for Money

The Spectator

Your Money's Worth. By Stuart Chase and F. J. Schlink, (Cape. 8s. 6d.) " A sTunv in the waste of the consumer's money " is the sub-title of this book, written by two American...

Page 45

Fiction

The Spectator

Varieties of Human Experience Wife to John. By Barnaby Brook. (Gerald Howe. 7s. 6d.) MR. BRE'Pr YOUNG has accustomed us to expect from .hirri a psychology both delicate and...

Subversire Septs

The Spectator

Secret Societies, Old and New. By Herbert Vivian, M.A. (Thornton Thitterivorth. 10s. 6d.) Secret Societies, Old and New. By Herbert Vivian, M.A. (Thornton Thitterivorth. 10s....

Page 46

BLACK GALLANTRY. By Val Gielgud. (Constable. 7s. 6d.) We are

The Spectator

delayed for some considerable time (to be precise ninety-three pages) before we reach the living run of this story, but once we get there it is with a vengeance, and blood,...

By Mrs. Alfred Wingate. (Crosby Lockwood. 10s, 6d.)—Again we are

The Spectator

transported to. the Far East of the Middle Ages. This book' requires - to be read with a map and a study of the genealogies at the end ; but those readers who will take this...

JARNEGAN. By Jim Tully. (Brentano's. 7s. 6d.)— This novel is

The Spectator

said by the publisher to describe the " real Hollywood." If this is true, it explains a good deal as to the mentality and presentation of American films. The language in which...

Current Literature BIG GAME SHOOTING IN THE INDIAN EMPIRE. By

The Spectator

Lt.-Col. C. H. Stockley, D.S.O. Illustrated. (Constable. 18s.)—Designed primarily for the information of sportsmen of limited means, this is before all things a practical book,...

WARE WOLF ! By E. Lascefles Forester. (Cassell. 7s... - -6ii.)--The author

The Spectator

of this :book tries to reconcile the old Were Wolf legend with modern science and constructs a romance on this subject which' has as a background the con- spiracy for a world...

Page 49

PLAYHOUSES AND PLAYERS OF EAST ANGLIA. By T. L. G.

The Spectator

Burley. (Jerrold. 5s.)-This is a well-written well-produced book by a Norwich author, who has applied his live interest and ripe experience io the recording of the history of...

A HISTORY OF ENGLAND. By Hilaire Belloc. Vol. HE (Methuen.

The Spectator

15s.)-The third volume of Mr. Belloc's English History covers the later Middle Ages from the Black Death to the eve of the Reformation. It is so interesting and suggestive in...

JAN STEEN. Forty Reproductions in Photogravure. With a Critical Study

The Spectator

by F. Schmidt Degener and Notes on the Illustrations by Dr. H. E. Van Gelder. - Translated by G. J. Renier. (John Lane. 52s. 6d.)-Art critics outside Holland have been slow to...

MAGIC LADAKH. By " Ganpat " (Major M. L. A.

The Spectator

Gompertz). Illustrated. (Seeley, Service. 21s.) - The State of Ladakh lies in Eastern Kashmir, and, if not exactly on the roof of the world, at all events occupies a...

THOMAS CHIPPENDALE. A Review of His Life and Origin. By

The Spectator

Edwin J. Layton. (John Murray. 10s. 6d.)- Mr. Layton, who is joint author with J. Penderel-Brodhurst of A Glossary of English Furniture of the Historic Periods, is an authority...

THE FRENCH RIVIERA. By A. R. Bonus. (Methuen. 6s.)-Visitors to

The Spectator

the Riviera may be seeking just such a handy little guide as this if, in spite of the motor car, they keep the use of their legs, for it is intended for walkers. Mr. Bonus has...

A Library List

The Spectator

BIOGRAPHY :-Louis XIV. : King of Navarre and France. By C. S. Forester. (Methuen. 10s. 6d.)-Sir Walter Raleigh. By Milton Waldman. (The Bodley Head. 12s. 6d.)-Dostoevsky : The...

Page 50

Finance—Public and Private

The Spectator

Sir Josiah Stamp on the Railway Position FROM the moment that Sir Josiah Stamp's appointment, first as President of the Executive, and subsequently as Chairman of the London...

Page 52

Financial Notes

The Spectator

QUIETER MARKETS. THE Stock Markets during the past few days have been slightly affected by a rather firmer tendency in the Mony Market. That tendency has been mainly due to the...

AN EXCELLENT INSURANCE REPORT.

The Spectator

The annual Report of the Pearl Assurance Company is a good one, showing progress in all directions. In the industrial branch there was an advance in the premium income to...

UNDERGROUND RAILWAY GROUP.

The Spectator

Interest in Lord Ashfield's periodical statements at the meeting of the Underground Railway group always extends considerably beyond the actual stockholders of those under-...

* * *

The Spectator

Sem-mu Wmows' FUND. The Scottish Widows' Fund is now so near another quin- quennium that good results seem to be almost a foregone conclusion, and Lord Kinross, who presided at...

ESTONIAN INDEPENDENCE.

The Spectator

In congratulating the Estonian Republic upon the tenth anniversary of its independence, it is satisfactory also to emphasize the extent of the country's economic recovery during...

It is interesting to note how, hi spite of its

The Spectator

extended use, electricity has failed to disturb the profits of gas companies. Not only have the reports; of eaeh - leading gascompany published recently been of. a ry...

Answers to Questions on Choosing a Wife—in Fact and Fiction

The Spectator

1. Sir Thomas More, because " he considered that it would be both great grief and some shame also to the eldest to see her sister in marriage preferred before her " (Thomas...

For reports of company meetings, see pp. 338 to 343.

The Spectator