4 APRIL 1952

Page 1

The Spectator

Page 3

NO SECURITY YET

The Spectator

It was, of course, part of General Eisenhower's duty as a soldier to place the , first emphasis on that major proportion of the task of defence that still remains to be done. He...

Russia, the West and Germany

The Spectator

Some of the West German criticism of the Allied reply to the recent Soviet Note on a peace treaty with Germany is curiously perverse. (East German criticisms were too inevitable...

SPECTATOR

The Spectator

Page 4

Truman Out

The Spectator

So far the Presidential election manoeuvres in the United States have produced of themselves a fair quota of the drama that the party managers usually like to inject into them....

Tunisian Gamble

The Spectator

French policy in Tunis will be justified only if it comes off. The gamble is that M. Baccouche will be able to sponsor reforms which will go at least part of the way to satisfy...

Two Views of Trieste

The Spectator

It is hardly surprising that the term " blackmail " has entered into Yugoslav cominent on moves for an extension of Italian control over the city of Trieste. Within a fortnight...

The Twisters

The Spectator

Mr. Arthur Deakin said last week that the Budget would give " a savage twist " to the spiral of wages and prices. The T.U.C. General Council, in its official statement on the...

Page 5

Dear Travel—By Order

The Spectator

There is a distinct air of the madhouse about the Minister of Transport's order for the withdrawal of the road service provided by Northern Roadways Ltd. from Edinburgh and...

Steel Skirmishing

The Spectator

As usual, it is, necessary to look beyond the question of steel prices, which the Commons were supposed to be debating on Monday night, to the question of the control of the...

AT WESTMINSTER

The Spectator

HE House of Lords still keeps some of its fallen day about it. There are occasions—the debate on Seretse Khama was one—that fill the peeresses' gallery, with women of a grace,...

Page 6

THE SERETSE PROBLEM

The Spectator

W HATEVER final conclusion may be reached on the action of the Government in deciding that Seretse Khama, the lawful chief of the Bamangwato, shall be deprived permanently of...

Page 7

A SPECTATOR'S NOTEBOOK

The Spectator

D ILIGENT and well-intentioned authors so often get much less than their,due that I am glad to be able to indicate how a gentleman from Dayton, Ohio, regards a recent article by...

A deal The Times has brought off with the Daily

The Spectator

Mail a little surprises me. The two final volumes of that notable publica- tion The History of the Times are to be published on April 23rd. Review copies were sent out about a...

As to the Boat Race, Cambridge was, of course, beaten

The Spectator

by chicken-pox (with perhaps a little of Davidge thrown in). Mr. H. R. Rickett, as everyone knows, is a genius at tuning crews up to concert-pitch in the last fortnight before...

A week or two ago I raised the question whether

The Spectator

the B.B.C. News Department was acting on some hitherto undisclosed principle in refusing to call Dr. Adenauer anything but Herr Adenauer. I am glad to find it is so, for I am a...

"My status is quo and my quo is status," said

The Spectator

Governor Stevenson of Illinois on Monday. This is a pronouncement of such profundity as to transcend my comprehension. I must leave it to better Latinists than myself to...

I have referred more than once to those fantastic organisa-

The Spectator

tions, if they are separate organisations, the Acaddmie et Universitd Internationale, " Founded 1880, Reorganised 1937, Chartered 1947, Affiliated with the Pacific International...

As a footnote to my earlier observations on the National

The Spectator

Anthem, I reproduce an extra verse devised for current con- ditions some 240 years ago. God grant that General Wade May by Thy mighty aid Victory bring. May he oppressors hush...

Page 8

The B.B.C.'s Future

The Spectator

By MARY STOCKS * HE B.B.C. is in a most unhappy position and seldom if ever has a public service deserved its tribulations less. For close on two years it was probed and...

Page 9

C. B. Fry

The Spectator

By. NEVILLE CARDUS C B. FRY will be eighty on April 25th, according to Wisden, a witness to which he will pay a certain • respect. But he is not likelier to count eighty years...

Page 10

Political Arithmetic

The Spectator

By D. W. BROGAN U NECONOMIC nylons are being dumped on New Zealand, and steps have been taken to secure that these necessities are profitably manufactured in that pair of...

Page 11

The Chaff Bed

The Spectator

By IAN NIALL TRACTOR pulled the mill into place, and in a little while, when they had thrown the thatch on one side, they began threshing the rick. I studied the situation. It...

Song from a Play

The Spectator

Whirls now the wind with winter snow, And trout-sweet brook is hard as glass ; Old bones full well that rigour know ; They pine for the South, but—let it pass. " Why this...

Page 12

Two Phlox, One Flock

The Spectator

By WILFRID BLUNT HE librarkan of one of the Bavarian municipal libraries (I quote from a German newspaper), distressed at the trash that the public demanded, decided to make a...

Page 13

Bows and Arrows

The Spectator

By PETER FLEMING I RECEIVED last week an invitation to become president of a local society devoted to the sport of archery, and as I sat down to write a suitable letter of...

Page 14

Presidential Timber

The Spectator

.HIS seems to be a moment when observers of the American Presidential elections, both those at home and those abroad, cannot do better than remind themselves that they are in...

Page 15

Football Business

The Spectator

By J. P. W. MALLALIEU, M.P. E VERY Saturday afternoon during the season a million or so men and women watch professional football. Many more, perhaps with one eye on their...

Page 16

To the Nine

The Spectator

Oh, ye Muses nine defend us In a noisy age benighted, Your lost grace and beauty lend us, • Whom hexameters delighted, Who set thought with metre blending, Matching truth with...

"TO avettator," aprit 3rb, 1652.

The Spectator

Tim period at which the incorporating act of the East India Company falls to be renewed is almost close at hand, and the prospect of a satisfactory preliminary inquiry grows...

Page 18

MARGINAL COMMENT

The Spectator

By HAROLD NICOLSON FRIEND of mine has passed on to me a strange little object presented to her, a year before his death, by the well-known mathematician and writer Mr. Charles...

Page 19

Hard on Jerseys Jersey cattle are stoutly' defendedby the secretary

The Spectator

of the English Jersey Cattle Society. He draws attention to a note of mine on the hardy breeds of cattle found on the hilly farms of North Wales, and points out that Jersey...

Shepherd Dog

The Spectator

As I went along the footpath, I over-looked the rickyard, and noticed a collie pup trotting around a chicken coop in a very deliberate way. I stopped and watched him. A...

Onion - Planting A little late perhaps, but after digging in a

The Spectator

suitable fertiliser, such as wood ash, tread the bed fairly solid and put in your autumn- sown onions. Plant in rows ab.put sixteen inches apart. Make sure that the young plant...

Clamour in the Rookery If the rookery was quiet and

The Spectator

deserted before the new year, it is far from it now. The clamour that goes on all day must weary the birds themselves. The young are hungry. The parents go to and fro in search...

COUNTRY LIFE

The Spectator

TIM farm was once the dower-house of the estate, and consequently it has features that neighbouring places have not. Twb fine yew trees stand before the farmHouse itself. The...

Page 20

THEATRE

The Spectator

Uncle Vanya. By Anton Chekhov. (Arts Theatre.) UNEMPHATIC plays like this one defy all but the most emphatic productions. Vanya is unmanageable, and much given to sprawling :...

CONTEMPORARY ARTS •

The Spectator

CINEMA Five Fingers. (Leicester Square.)—Tall Headlines. (Gaumont.)--- Singin' In the Rain. (Empire.) Operation Cicero, Mr. L. C. Moyzisch's book relating the incredible but as...

MUSIC

The Spectator

How is it possible to write about Schubert's music ? Words—the right words, if they exist—have failed even the most eloquent writers. We have mostly technical analyses of his...

Page 22

ART

The Spectator

IT is always rash to speak of national characteristics in art, especially in Europe where the strands are inextricably woven. One thinks of the " elegance " of the French, or...

Nil Nisi Bonum

The Spectator

Bone idle, Idyllically bone, I shall mock the fidelity Of the angels in stone That watch the dead. Bone idle, soon Too lazy to turn in my grave, To get up at twelve, To go down...

Page 24

SPECTATOR COMPETITION No. 109

The Spectator

Report. by Guy Kendall A prize of £5 was offered for an extract from a poem called " The IT ew Town," in the manner and metre of Goldsmith's " The Deserted Nage," by one who...

SPECTATOR COMPETITION No. 112

The Spectator

Set by Richard Usborne A prize of £5, which may be divided, is offered for a ten-line love- lyric, of which the last. three lines arc In the wailing-room Of the branch-line On...

Page 26

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

The Spectator

A Member's Allegiance SIR— Professor D. W. Brogan, in his article The New Pocket Boroughs. builds up his case on an inifial misconception. He speaks of the Railway Review as"...

,outh Africa

The Spectator

Stit,—The fiftieth anniversary of the peace treaty which closed the Boer War falls on May 31st, 1952. Within a week or so of that historic event a service of thanksgiving was...

The - British Council SIR,—Tho Marginal Comment in your issue of

The Spectator

March 28th has given pleasure and encouragement to the staff of the British Council. I write to express our !thanks for such generous recognition of the service which wo try to...

Page 28

SIR,—How refreshing to read D. C. Somervell's defence of our

The Spectator

National Anthem, and how much 1 agree with each adjective applied to " Land of Hope and Glory." My present object is to say a good word for the second verse of " God Save the...

The National Anthem

The Spectator

SIR,—In your issue of March 28th Mr. D. C. Somervell writes: " The National Anthem is very good music. It is not great music nor beauti- ful music, but strictly good " ; and...

Old Deeds

The Spectator

Snt,—A short while ago I too received a parcel of old deeds, and I was therefore most interested to read Mr. C. Henry Warren's article on this subject. My oldest deed was...

Doctor or Mister

The Spectator

SIR,—In the Sunday Press a claim was recently made by " a consulting physician " who dogmatically said, " Let it be known once and for all that the proper way of addressing a...

Taxation in France

The Spectator

Sm, —I have read with great interest the comments by M. Cohen on my previous letter. M. Cohen is entirely correct in his description of the French income-tax system as applied...

Jersey Cattle

The Spectator

SIR,—My attention has been drawn to Ian Niall's comments in " Country Life," in your issue of March 7th. It ft quite obvious that Mr. Niall has little or no knowledge of the...

Page 30

Let's Be Fair to Mr. Bevan

The Spectator

In Place of Fear. By Aneurin Bevan. (Heinemann. 10s. 6d.) WHEN Mr. Aneurin Bevan complains of the excessive interest taken by the popular Press in his private life he obviously...

SPRING BOOK SUPPLEMENT

The Spectator

The World of Robert Ross Robert Ross, Friend of Friends. Edited by Margery Ross. (Cape. 30s.) To those who were friends of Robbie Ross this book is tenuous and tantalising. The...

Page 32

The- Crucial Age

The Spectator

INTEREST in the seventeenth century continues to grow, the more it is realised that here was the turning point of our civilisation, more important, certainly for this country,...

Page 33

Coleridge's Letters

The Spectator

The Letters of Samuel Taylor Coleridge. Selected and with an Introduction by Kathleen Raine. (Grey Walls Press. 12s. 6d.) IN 1895 E. H. Coleridgeedited many of his celebrated...

Page 34

Twentieth-Century Fashions

The Spectator

English Women's Clothing in the Present Century. By C. Willett Cunnington. (Faber. 31 guineas.) PARADOXICALLY enough the student of fashion finds it easier to inform himself...

Page 35

A New British Flora

The Spectator

THE need of a completely new flora of the British Isles has for long humiliated botanists, who have had to resort to Continental hand- books. For many years we have told both...

Page 36

Russia's Great Purge

The Spectator

Conspiracy of Silence. By Alex Weissberg. (Hamish Hamilton. 21s.) I BELIEVE it is the duty of every COmmunist to subordinate himself to the necessities of the political...

Page 37

Mountain, Moor and Water

The Spectator

The Highlands of Scotland. By Seton Gordon. (Robert Hale. County Books Series. 18s.) IT may be wondered why a series which assigns two separate volumes to the Inner and Outer...

Political Power

The Spectator

IT is a pity that the B.B.C. has, intentionally or wantonly, surrounded the Reith Memorial Lectures with so portentous an atmosphere. The enterprise of commissioning each year a...

Page 38

An Archbishop on Our Times

The Spectator

In an Age of Revolution. By Cyril Garbett, Archbishop of York. (Hodder and Stoughton. 20s.) In an Age of Revolution. By Cyril Garbett, Archbishop of York. (Hodder and Stoughton....

Page 39

Poetry

The Spectator

The Submerged Village. By James Kirkup. (Oxford University Press. 7s. 6d.) MR. KIRKUP holds a poetry fellowship—the only one in the country— et Leeds University. That it should...

Page 40

Vichy Pro-Consul .

The Spectator

" IF the British come with four divisions, I shall fire on them ; if with twenty, I shall welcome them." This epigram of General Weygand on his policy as Delegate-General of...

Page 42

An Eton Headmaster

The Spectator

Dr. Balston at Eton. By Thomas Balston. (Macmillan. 12s. 6d.) ALTHOUGH there is not very much that is actually new in this short life of Edward Balston compiled by his...

Page 44

Verse Translations

The Spectator

Poems of Francois Villon. Translated to the original verse-forms by Norman Cameron. (Cape. 10s. 6d.) AT a moment when the translation of verse into prose—or alter- natively into...

Travelling Lear

The Spectator

Edward Lear's Journals. A Selection Edited by Herbert van Thal. (Barker. 21s.) EDWARD LEAR'S reputation as a versifier is secure ; his place as a water-colourist in the great...

Page 46

Fiction

The Spectator

A Step to Silence. By P. H. Newby. (Cape. 12s. 6d.) A Place to Live. By George Buchanan. (Faber. 10s. 6d.) Now Barabbas, one might say, was a cipher. He is described variously...

Monteverdi Wrapped Up

The Spectator

" THE superb details of workmanship in the compositions of 1610 have been fined down to a more schematic ` blanc-et-noir ' style of buoyant tutti—and concertante ' solo...

Page 48

New Books

The Spectator

As in other years the spring's book-list contains much biographical material, most of it concerned with the present or immediate past. Biographies are often written before the...

Page 50

FINANCE AND INVESTMENT

The Spectator

By CUSTOS IN face of the bleak provisions of the Finance Bill markets are putting up a brave show. Under the lead of gilt-edged stocks prices appear to have acquired some...

Page 54

THE "SPECTATOR" CROSSWORD .No. 672 , fA Book. Token for one

The Spectator

guinea will be awarded to the sender of the fi rst correct solution opened alter noon on Tuesday week. April 151h. Envelopes must be received not later than first post that day...

Solution to Crossword No. 67o

The Spectator

Gardens, Solution on April 18 The winner of Crossword No. 670 is: Mss. M. E. RILEY, 23, Daleham London. N.W.3.