4 JULY 1908

Page 2

INDEX.

The Spectator

FROM JULY 4th TO DECEMBER 26th, 1908, INCLUSIVE. TOPIC'S OF THE DAY. A DVERTISEMENTS and Lotteries ... 396 -La Africa, South, the Federation of... ... 531 Agriculture and the...

Page 9

In the French _Chamber of Deputies on Monday the Socialists

The Spectator

opposed the grant of £16,000 for M. Fallieres's visit to Russia. M. Valliant, who was their spokesman, used language of the utmost violence in speaking of the Czar. M. Brisson,...

M. Scbollaert, 'the Belgian Prime Minister, concluded on Thursday his'

The Spectator

discourse,in the Chamber on the Congo. The territories of that State censtituted, he declared, "a source of wealth which surpasses the imagination." M. Schollaert went on to...

On Friday week in the House of Commons there was

The Spectator

a debate on the Report stage of the Bill to repeal the law which forbids tobacco-growing in Scotland. The Bill had passed the Standing Committee without amendment. Sir F....

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

W E have dealt elsewhere with the Persian crisis, and will only say here that the latest telegrams state that the Shah is for the present pursuing his policy with apparent...

While noting these facts, we desire to point out that

The Spectator

a good deal of the pessimism prevailing about the state of India just now is both unworthy and unnecessary. No doubt individual members of the Civil Service are exposed to a...

During the week the French Chamber has been busy dis-

The Spectator

cussing the Income-tax Bill. One of the clauses in the measure at which the Chamber " shied " was, the proposal to force business people to show their books in declaring their...

The news of the unrest in India has no new

The Spectator

features. The editor of the Hind Swarajya, a Bombay paper, has been sentenced to two years' and one year's imprisonment for publishing two seditious articles, the sentences to...

* * * The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript, in any

The Spectator

case.

Page 10

On the same day the Commons debated the Bill which

The Spectator

is intended to reverse the effect of a recent deciiion of the courts, and to establish the right of the Press to attend the meetings of every local authority. An important...

The House of Commons has spent the middle part of

The Spectator

the week in galloping through the Committee stage of the Old- Age Pensions Bill. We are no friends of dilatory discussion, but we are bound to say that we never remember a worse...

Timid Members of the House of Lords will perhaps say

The Spectator

that the risk inherent in the course we recommend is too great. The Government's reply to the House of Lords, it is urged, would be an instant Dissolution, and an appeal to the...

It is not worth while to attempt to summarise day

The Spectator

by day anything so unsatisfactory as these truncated debates, but we should like to record our approval of Mr. Balfour's protest against setting up the Excise officer to...

We note in the Westminster Gazette, and in the writings

The Spectator

and speeches of other advocates of the Bill, a curiously illogical argument used to defend some of the patent injustices caused by exclusions under the Bill,—injustices to which...

The Bill will be read a third time next Thursday,

The Spectator

and will, we presume, immediately be sent to the Peers. We most earnestly trust that the Lords will do their duty by the Bill, and not be afraid of dealing with it on its...

Page 11

The Times of Monday publishes a letter from Sir Robert

The Spectator

Anderson on the danger of a rapid growth of low-class drinking-clubs under the licensing legislation of the Govern- ment. At Scotland Yard Sir Robert Anderson had to decide year...

A Convention of women suffragists was held at Caxton Hall

The Spectator

on Tuesday, when a. depntation was chosen to go to the House of Commons and see the Prime Minister. At the House the members of the deputation were informed that Mr. Asquith...

We record with no small satisfaction that a compromise has

The Spectator

been reached in the matter of the denominational Training Colleges. It provides that half of the places may be reserved for the denomination and half thrown open ; and that...

The Report of the Select Committee on the Daylight Saving

The Spectator

Bill was issued on Thursday, and is, we are glad to say, favourable to the principles of the Bill. The Bill as it stood would have made eight changes in time necessary during...

An influential meeting was held at the Mansion House on

The Spectator

Friday week to establish the Association of Subscribers to Charities. A letter was read from Mr. Burns earnestly sup- porting the objects of the meeting. Lord Lichfield made out...

The Report of the Royal Commission on the Metropolitan Police

The Spectator

was issued on Tuesday. After a long inquiry, which took particular notice of some notorious cases, the Commie- sioners have come to the conclusion that the discipline of the...

Lord Desborougb, the President of the British Olympic Council. has

The Spectator

a letter in the Daily Mail of Thursday appealing for funds to entertain the numerous foreign visitors who are coming to take part in the Olympic Games. The Council have so far...

The Spectator

Page 12

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

PARLIAMENTARY GOVERNMENT AND OUR INDIAN EMPIRE. T HE full - dress debate upon Indian affairs which took place in the House of Lords on Tuesday cannot be described as...

Page 13

THE TURMOIL IN PERSIA.

The Spectator

• T HE first thought which comes into the mind on .1 reading the daily reports of the political chaos in Persia is a profound thankfulness for the existence of the Anglo-Russian...

Page 14

THE " GUILLOTINE " AND ITS CONSEQUENCES.

The Spectator

I N spite of all the publicity under which proceedings in the House of Commons are conducted, it is to be feared that the general public never sufficiently realises the serious...

Page 15

GERMAN AND ENGLISH WORKMEN.

The Spectator

I N spite of epigrammatic contradictions, the production of figures is one of the most useful functions that Governments can perform. More and more, in all countries, they find...

Page 16

SMALL LOANS FOR POOR •PEOPLE.

The Spectator

W E publish to-day in our correspondence columns as letter—by Mr. Herbert Batty—which makes a very interesting and, we believe, useful suggestion. After noting the rapacity of...

Page 17

MILTON.

The Spectator

T HE tercentenary of the year of Milton's birth, which is being celebrated at Cambridge by an Exhibition of portraits and manuscripts, to be followed later by a perform- ance of...

Page 18

LORD CROMER'S ADVICE TO BOYS.

The Spectator

T HE best advice is generally the oldest. And the oldest things in the world are always the simplest. It follows that good advice is always simple. Can any one doubt that ? Did...

Page 19

CHILDREN ON THE SANDS.

The Spectator

I T is a rather curious thing that Stevenson, in the "Child's Garden of Verses," has hardly a dozen lines about children at the seaside. The air and the sunlight of the sands,...

Page 20

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

OLD-AGE PENSIONS AND THE LORDS. pro TEE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR:] SIB,-Sir William Chance's letter in your last issue on the subject of old-age pensions is a most opportune...

Page 21

OLD-AGE PENSIONS.

The Spectator

LTO TEl EDITOR OF TEl "8rscrxroa.1 SIR,—A large number of letters have been received in reply to my letter which appeared in various London and provincial newspapers a few days...

DUNMOW FRIENDLY SOCIETY.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF TUB "SPROTATOR.1 SIR,—Replying to your note to Mr. Hart-Davis's letter in your issue of June 20th as to the progress of this Society since 1884, and as to the...

[TO TRU EDITOR OF TIM "SPICTATOR."]

The Spectator

SIR,—Your correspondent " Sigma " (Spectator, June 27th) refers me to the case of a Friendly Society giving old- age pensions, which is, I think, the Stoke and Melford Union...

[To Till EDITOR Or TOR "Sr sarAroa."] SIR,—Your correspondent "M.

The Spectator

L." (Spectator, June 27th) confirms my point. He reminds us that Mr. Chamberlain, after being the sole begetter of the scheme, abjured the principle of contributory pensions. I...

Page 22

SMALL LOANS FOR POOR PEOPLE.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SricorATog."] Sia,—From several cases recently reported, it appears that County Court Judges regard 60 per cent, as a not unreason- able rate of interest...

[To THE EDITOR OF TEL "SPEHTATOIL1 SIR,—Mr. Stanley Auderton complains

The Spectator

in your last issue that the Pan-Anglican Congress has not proposed to throw open the doors of the Church of England to Nonconformists by admitting them to her Service of Holy...

A NATIONAL CHURCH.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR Or THE " SPECTATOR:1 should like your correspondent (Spectator, June 27th) to know that in one Anglican archdeaconry—and I doubt not in many mere—the principle...

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " &mangos."] SIB,—If people are

The Spectator

to be admitted to Holy Communion without having "renewed the solemn vow made in their name at their Baptism," what security have the clergy that "they acknowledge themselves...

CANON HENSON ON CHURCH AND STATE.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or THE " SPECTATOR."] Sin,—You will, I know, acquit me of any intention to complain of your reviewer's fair, and even kindly, review of my book, "The National...

Page 23

THE DISPUTE IN THE AMERICAN BOOK.

The Spectator

SELLING TRADE. [To THE EDITOR Or THE "SPECTATOR.") SIR,—Your article of June 6th entitled "Publishers, Book- sellers, and the Law" is evidently based upon misinformation as to...

THE BAGHDAD RAILWAY.

The Spectator

LTO THE EDITOR or TER " SPECTATOR:1 SIR,--Arollr able article on "The Baghdad Railway" in last week's Spectator scarcely touched upon the political aide of the question,...

Page 24

THE NATIONAL WOMEN'S ANTI-SUFFRAGE MOVEMENT.

The Spectator

LTO THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR." J SIR,—I do not often write to newspapers, but the subject on which I address you is exceptional, and the Spectator an exceptional channel in...

WOMEN'S COUNTRY HOLIDAY FUND.

The Spectator

[To TRH EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR." J SIR,—The letter you very kindly inserted last year on the subject of the Women's Holiday Fund bore such good fruit that I venture to plead...

Page 25

" CADAVEROUS " OBEDIENCE.

The Spectator

1.7 . 0 THE EDITOR 07 THE " SPECTATOR.”) SIR,— Latin words from the" Constitutions" of Ignatius of Loyola, quoted in the Spectator, June 20th, 1908. Perin& ac cadaver....

PERSONAL REPRESENTATION.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE "SPECTATOR."] SIR,—In view of the revival of the excellent movement for what is now called "proportional representation," I should like to make two...

"EXPLAIN HER AWAY."

The Spectator

(To THE EDITOR OF TUE " SPECTATOR:1 SIR,—The comments of the Protectionist Press upon the official statements of the Board of Trade as to the comparative position of the...

BIRDS IN THE STRAWBERRY NETS. I.TO THE EDITOR or THE

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.") SIR,—Will you allow me to suggest to the bird-lovers among your readers that during the summer season they should make a practice of periodically visiting their...

EGRETS AND LEGISLATION.

The Spectator

LTO THE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR.") SIR,—A reply to one of the comments upon Lord Avebury's Bill made by your correspondent Whanghee " in last week's Spectator will perhaps...

1' 0 E '1' It Y.

The Spectator

THE MIDDLE MARCHES. (" Posuit fines tuos pacem." — Psalm xlvii.) No Warden keeps the marches From Tyneclale to the Tweed ; Broad winds the road to Scotland Beside the streams...

PRACTICAL PATRIOTISM.—SIXTEEN THOUSAND MILES.

The Spectator

LO THE EDITOR 07 THE "SneerAroa."] have received several generous contributions towards a Spectator Tent* at Risley (August 8th-17th) for our primary boys' camp from your...

NOTICE.—When Articles or "Correspondence" are signed with the writer's name

The Spectator

or initials, or with a pseudonym, or are marked "Communicated," the Editor must not necessarily be held to be in agreement with the views therein expressed or with the mode of...

Page 26

BOOKS.

The Spectator

LORD MORLEY'S LATEST ESSAYS.* THESE latest miscellanies of the writer and statesman who may be considered our foremost living critic are, in the words of the prefatory note,...

Page 27

CONFESSIO MEDICI.*

The Spectator

THE doctor's is the most human of professions. It treats human beings morally as well as physically, and one might even say that it is a spiritual agency too. It receives as...

Page 28

MR. SWINBURNE AND OTHERS.* THE greatest of living poets gives

The Spectator

us so little from his store nowadays that we are thankful for small mercies. The dramatic poem of four scenes which is his latest gift is only a small mercy, but it is stamped...

Page 29

DRAWINGS BY THE OLD MASTERS AT OXFORD.* SINCE 1903 at

The Spectator

intervals have been issued six parts of this memorable work. Now with the last instalment come the general and special introductions, and directions for binding the whole in...

Page 30

MR. STUART JONES'S "ROMAN EMPIRE." *

The Spectator

THE series of "The Story of the Nations" was commenced in 1885 by a volume which bore the title of Borne, and carried on the story as far as the "End of the Republic." The last...

Page 31

HUMPHREY, DUKE OF GLOUCESTER.*

The Spectator

Mn. VICKERS is not one of the fraternity of historical "white- washers." His book is as admirable for its impartiality as it is for the thoroughness and the intelligence of its...

ROUND ABOUT THE NORTH POLE.*

The Spectator

IT is recorded that many centuries ago the. Icelander Gunnbiorn, driven westward in a gale, sighted the strange land he called White-Shirt from its snowfields, which Eric the...

THE MAGAZINES.

The Spectator

THE places of honour in the new Nineteenth Century.— the beginning and the end—are given to two articles on the: international position of Britain. Mr. Ellis Barker, who writes...

Page 33

NOVELS.

The Spectator

BURIED ALIVE.* THE author of this very entertaining work is not the Arnold Bennett who writes of The Grim Smile of the Five Towns, but rather the Arnold Bennett who delighted...

Page 34

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

[Under this heading we votice such Books of the week as have not been reserrood for review in other forms.] Pleasure and Problem in South Africa. By Cecil Harmsworth, M.P. (John...

READABLE NOVELS.—Chateau Royal. By J. H. Yoxall. (Smith, Elder, and

The Spectator

Co. 6s.)—The story in its earlier part is a little, in fact more than a little, hard to understand ; any one who struggles on will be repaid.—The Shadow of a Vendetta. By...

The Pour Gospels in the Earliest Church History. By Thomas

The Spectator

Nicol, D.D. (W. Blackwood and Sons. 7s. ed. net.)—" The first line of defence [of the credibility of the Gospel history]," writes Professor Nicol in his preface, "it seems to...

The Advent of Arthur. By Enid Leigh Hunt. (Sampson Low,

The Spectator

Marston, and Co. 6s.)—Though this is a story of common life, no one can complain that it is wanting in the romance which the title seems to suggest. That Joyce, aged sixteen,...

Raw Edges. By Peroeval Landon. (W. Heinemann. 6s.)—In this series

The Spectator

of short stories Mr. Landon exhibits a talent for depicting things grim and terrifying. It is not too much to say that there is not one of these stories which does not leave the...

Page 35

The Oxford University Press. By Falconer Madan, M.A. (The Clarendon

The Spectator

Press. 2s. 6d. net.)—Mr. Madan rightly calls this a "brief account." The brevity is absolutely austere. The six chapters of the "Short History" occupy twenty-one pages ; the...

Precious Stones. By W. Goodchild, M.B. (A. Constable and Co.

The Spectator

6s. net.)—" The different gem stones are here considered," says the author, "in a mineralogical sequence." This is a plan which is certainly scientific, though it produces an...

Ladies' Logic. By Oswald St. Clair. (Digby, Long, and Co.

The Spectator

Is.) —In this "Dialogue between a Suffragette and a Mere Man" the ultimo& ratio, the superior physical fore* of mere man, is put forward in a forcible way. The "dialogue" is...

Through Finland to St. Petersburg. By A. Maccallum Scott. (Grant

The Spectator

Richards. 2s. 6d. net.)—" The average British reader," says Mr. Scott," still associates Finland in his mind with Lapland and the Arctic Ocean Finland is Arctic only in the...

Christian Biographies through Eighteen Centuries. By the Rev. F. St.

The Spectator

J. 'Thackeray. (S.P.C.K. 35. 6d.)—We could not have a better illustration of the advantage of presenting history by means of biography than is to be found in this volume. Mr....

John Newton. Compiled and Edited by the Rev. S. Callis.

The Spectator

With Introduction by Eugene Stock. (S. W. Partridge and Co.)— John Newton died on December 21st, 1807, after holding for twenty-eight years the rectory of St. Mary Woolnoth. In...

International Arbitration as a Substitute for War between Nations. By

The Spectator

Russell Lowell Jones, M.A. (Simpkin, Marshall, and Co. 5s. net.)—Mr. Audrow Carnegie offered five prizes for essays on this subject, and to that now published was adjudged the...

Page 36

Plains,. Fare and Less of it. By Alice Braithwaite. (Richard

The Spectator

J. James. 35. exl. net.)—We accept ex animo the aphorism which Miss Braithwaite has taken for the title of her book. Most people eat too much, and eat things which they would be...