6 FEBRUARY 1971

Page 3

The Spectator

The Spectator

Established 1828 99 Gower Street, London WC1 Telephone: 01-387 3221 Telegrams: Spectator, London Editor: George Gale Associate Editor: Michael Wynn Jones Literary Editor:...

Page 4

LET SKILLS FLOURISH

The Spectator

The way some people, more especially some politicians, economists and com- mentators, go on, the public might well be forgiven for concluding that 'growth' in the economy was a...

Page 5

POLITICAL COMMENTARY

The Spectator

Where have all the radicals gone? HUGH MACPHERSON There have been quite a few examples recently of chaps breaking the rules of the Westminster club. Often this can do nothing...

Page 6

Best of his bad job

The Spectator

Geoffrey Rippon, naturally and sensibly enough, is making the best of a bad job, trying to make good news out of what is becoming very bad news. He smiles all around, as if he...

The higher humbug

The Spectator

We print in our Review of Books two dis- cussions of Chomsky and his works. What seems to emerge is that not only has Chomsky's politics nothing to do with his undoubted...

Watch it, propagandists

The Spectator

Special courses (complete with resident devil's advocate) have been run by the Tories' Central Office to accustom their chosen marketeers to apologise well on tele- vision. New...

THE SPECTATOR'S NOTEBOOK

The Spectator

I have been very greatly reassured to learn, from, as they say, some of the very best sources, that my suspicious fears that the crucial Cabinet decision on the Common Market...

Wonderful Noam Chomsky

The Spectator

Noam Chomsky at forty-two is undoubtedly one of the wonders of the age. Everywhere he goes he pronounces and everywhere he pronounces the (student) young flock to listen. They...

A beaut of a party

The Spectator

Des Wilson had a fab do 'last week to mark his departure as Director of Shelter, the charity for the homeless. The Guardian's Peter Jenkins went to Shelter's office in the...

Page 7

VIEW FROM THE GALLERY

The Spectator

Prime Minister's question time SALLY VINCENT When the ex-sergeant major with the golden necklace told me I was not allowed to wear my overcoat in the Gallery on account of it...

Page 8

THE NATION'S WEALTH

The Spectator

Axe, please, Mr Barber By an Economist It is not often that political promises have been quite so rapidly belied by political performance as by the Chancellor of the Exchequer...

DIARY OF THE YEAR

The Spectator

Wednesday 27 January: to everyone's surprise 4,000 BOAC engineering employees voted to aban- don their work-to-rule: firemen too called off theirs after the Government announced...

Page 9

AMERICA

The Spectator

Nine characters in search of a plot JOHN GRAHAM Washington, DC There is no close season for ambition. Although Richard Nixon has been President for only two years, although he...

My Dear Pussy...

The Spectator

No man has a right to imperil his political party and its objectives for the sake of a woman That was what Lloyd George told Miss Frances Stevenson, his secretary and mistress...

Page 10

COMMON MARKET

The Spectator

Beware of dangling goodies NEIL MARTEN, MP `One readily recognises that the British have • three qualities; humour, tenacity and realism. I sometimes think that we are still a...

Page 11

INDOCHINA

The Spectator

Phnom Penh blues RAWLE KNOX Nobody seemed very surprised when war came explosively to Phnom Penh last week; no one sounded much as though he cared. us Defence Secretary Laird...

Page 12

PERSONAL COLUMN

The Spectator

The fate of Nebuchadnezzar DENIS BROGAN 'Stoning the Prophets is ancient news Like Nebuchadnezzar the King of the Jews' Chesterton's unkind lines have been much in my mind in...

Page 13

(':x7 THE SPECTATOR REV1EWofBOOKS

The Spectator

Michael Oakeshott on Marx on Hegel J. Enoch Powell on Americans in South-East Asia Other reviews by Charles Wilson, Hugh Kearney, Angus Maude, John Dunn, Allan Beattie and...

Page 15

J. Enoch Powell on Chomsky and Vietnam

The Spectator

To the distant observer a puzzling f:ature of American history in the last ten years has been the absence of ordinary political opposition to the Vietnam war and the other vast...

Charles Wilson on Malthus

The Spectator

An Essay on the Principle of Population and A Summary View of the Principle of Popula- tion T. R. Malthus edited by Antony Flew Pelican 7s) Malthus was an amiable man,...

Page 16

Hugh Kearney on a new kind of history

The Spectator

Why magic? Or rather why do so many his- torians now find such matters important and interesting enough to write books about them? The answer lies in part in a reaction against...

Michael Oakeshott on Marx on Hegel

The Spectator

In 1843, at the age of twenty-four or so, Karl Marx wrote down in a large notebook his thoughts about some passages of a work known to us as Hegel's Philosophy of Right. What he...

Page 17

Angus Maude on low-income families

The Spectator

Steering the Economy Samuel Brittan (Penguin 12s) Down with the .Poor is a symposium, largely by writers who have accepted the general philosophy associated with the Institute...

Page 18

John Dunn on an African religious order

The Spectator

The Mourides of Senegal: The Political and Economic Organisation of an Islamic Brotherhood Donal B. Cruise O'Brien (Clarendon Press 70s) Among the most bizarre efforts at...

Page 19

Allan Beattie on a critic of appeasement

The Spectator

Mr Colvin's book consists of extracts from recently-released official papers, used to illus- trate a view of British foreign policy in the pre-war period. The documentary...

Crossword

The Spectator

No prize is offered this week. The solution will appear in next week's issue, Across 1 Just like Arthur's lady armourer (10) 6 Bartok in favourite biblical disguise (4) 10 I...

Solution to Crossword No. 1466. Across: 1 Driver 4 Red

The Spectator

Queen 10 Memento 11 Drawing 12 Rude 13 Enticement 16 Leaden 17 Aconite 20 Fevercl 21 Crabby 24 Spy-glasses 25 Wisp 27 Outdoor 29 Crochet 30 Tyneside 31 Monday. Down : 1...

Page 20

Auberon Waugh on new novels

The Spectator

Punctuation Trevor Bowen (Lonsdale 35s) Mr Barry Cole's letter in the Christmas issue of the SPECTATOR proving conclusively that there is still an enormous readership for...

Page 21

THE SPECTATOR

The Spectator

H ARTS • LETTERS • MONEY•LEISURE OPERA Nouvelle Wagner RODNEY MILNES The most significant fact about the new production of Twilight of the Gods by Sadler's Wells Opera at the...

Page 22

CINEMA

The Spectator

Christie done - it CHRISTOPHER HUDSON Richard Fleischer is a moralistic director. In The Boston Strangler he retold the story of the psychopathic murders as simply as pos-...

THEATRE

The Spectator

Critics' cotillion KENNETH HURREN It is a coy old tradition that critics don't knock other critics' plays. I'm not sure whether this is a way of taking out insur- ance in...

Page 23

ART

The Spectator

Shock treatments EVAN ANTHONY Most of my fellow appraisers have had their say by now about the Vienna Secession exhibition at the Royal Academy; they have been rightly...

TELEVISION

The Spectator

All systems 'Go' Patrick SKENE CATLING In the electronic boudoir, all systems were `Go,' and once again I was struck last week by the superhuman impartiality of television....

Page 24

Capital gains tax

The Spectator

Sir: Congratulations to John Biffen on his article (30 January), especial- ly the section about the Common Market. It seems quite incredible that we are making this great effort...

The Gospels and the professor

The Spectator

Sir: Mr Kenney charges me with ignoring the evidence of the papy- rus fragments which, he implies, invalidate my statement that `no Gospel text can be traced, directly or...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

The Spectator

The right of reply Sir: You have seen fit to give a great deal of space to a complaint by Mr Kingsley Amis that I refused to print a letter (which he quotes in full) on the...

Trevor-Roper's review of Dodd's The Founder of Christianity were to

The Spectator

be entirely submerged under the flood of scholarly derision likely to be provoked by some alarmingly basic howlers. May I list a selec- tion, with comment: ' . . . we have no...

Agency ads

The Spectator

Sir: I was very interested to read the replies to Skinflint's article on Employment Agencies (23 Janu- ary). I myself gave up using agencies years ago when I found that time...

Sir: I fancy that all readers will agree with Kingsley

The Spectator

Amis's com- plaint in 'Personal Column' (30 January). It is an abuse of the power of the press if people find themselves attacked or their views distorted and are unable to get...

Two senses

The Spectator

Sir: Peter Quince's remarks (30 January) on the sounds and silences of nature were interesting to read. It always strikes me that the two senses of hearing and touch receive...

Stifling protest

The Spectator

Sir: A sidelight on the Tireless Tory Titan's fight for British in- dependence from She Common- wealth. One wonders whether Mr Heath has provoked the continu- ing row over arms...

Page 25

Sir: I know nothing of the accuracy of Professor Trevor-Roper's

The Spectator

views on the existence of Christ, but I do know something of English grammar and if the Professor's letter (30 January) is indicative of the validity of his article, then Christ...

Sir: Greatly daring, and with due respectful humility, I nevertheless

The Spectator

feel obliged to query some of the remarks in Professor Trevor- Roper's review of Dr Dodd's Life of Jesus (23 January). In his second paragraph the Pro- fessor writes: 'The...

Sir: It is one thing to find Profes- sor Trevor-Roper's

The Spectator

enlightened dis- missal of the Gospels in your pages; another to see an irrev- erent image of the Crucified on your front cover. There must still be a number of His followers...

Page 26

MONEY The shape of the Budget

The Spectator

NICHOLAS DAVENPORT That bold convert to Keynesianism, Presi- dent Nixon, has just presented Congress with a budget having an estimated deficit of $11,600 million. He called it...

Page 27

The Globe Theatre

The Spectator

An American actor, a Mr Sam Wanamaker, 3 s interested in going into profitable property development though the name his game goes Under is Art. We are told this through a deluge...

SKINFLINT'S CITY DIARY

The Spectator

Good simple-minded people of the left, like Tony Miles, new editor of the Daily Mirror, and Paul Foot of Private Eye, are boiling mad, so 1 am told, with the government de-...

London Weekend Television

The Spectator

Mr Rupert Murdoch was writing to a share- holder in October saying he doubted if the 1TA would let him buy any more shares than the 7-1 per cent from the GEC but the latest news...

Tax refunds

The Spectator

Some horrible people at the Confederation of British Industry are telling their member companies to fight strikers by withholding tax refunds from strikers. This is filthily...

Full marks

The Spectator

I congratulate the Government for its refusal to cough up £2 million or so of our money to buy the Velasquez picture of his mulatto friend and its consequent refusal thereby to...

Bernard Levin

The Spectator

No one admires Bernard Levin more than 1, or more than any reader of the SPECTATOR who remembers the venomous sense of in- jury and grievance, and yet the tolerance, of his...

J ULI ETTE'S WEEKLY FROLIC

The Spectator

Two expensive losses at Kempton having devoured my entire profits bar £1, 1 stand in urgent need of a nice, juicy outsider to enliven the account this •weekend, although no...

Page 28

THE GOOD LIFE Pamela VANDYKE PRICE

The Spectator

If you say 'Austria' to someone and ask them what gastronomic associations come to their mind, the answer may well be Wiener schnitzel or .Sachertorte. It was therefore clever...

PETER QUINCE

The Spectator

There is a nice little thatched cottage up for sale in the village, and the other day I came across a couple of prospective buyers ex- amining the property. They had a...

PLACE A REGULAR ORDER FOR YOUR

The Spectator

Spectator Mil MN NM MEI NM NMI NMI ill The Spectator, 99 Gower Street, London W.C.1 Please supply the Spectator for one year 11 1 two years 11] Cheque enclosed three years 0...

Page 29

BENNY GREEN

The Spectator

Anyone emerging from Broadcasting House at dusk on a winter evening has a fair chance of being reproached by the appari- tion of his own athletic past. This visitation takes the...

Page 30

The Judges for THE SPECTATOR'S New Writing Prize 1971 will

The Spectator

be: Short story category: Kingsley Amis, novelist, poet and essayist, the film of whose book Take a Girl Like You is currently on general release. Descriptive reporting: Brian...

THE SPECTATOR'S £500 NEW WRITING PRIZE

The Spectator

An annual prize of £500 will be awarded by the SPECTATOR to whoever In the opinion of the Judges, submits the best piece of original, unpublished, new writing of not less than...

TONY PALMER

The Spectator

The universal praise accorded to Barbara Loden's film Wanda, now showing at the Academy Cinema in London, raises some curious questicins about the growth of the underground...

Page 32

Spectator Hotel Guide

The Spectator

England CAMBRIDGESHIRE Garden House Hotel**** CAMBRIDGE Cambridge 55491 Royal Cambridge Hotel**** CAMBRIDGE Cambridge 51631 CORNWALL Meudon Hotel**** NEAR FALMOUTH Mawnan...