7 NOVEMBER 1970

Page 4

THE POLITICS OF INTERVENTION Radical change: words or deeds?

The Spectator

Every action of a government is an inter- vention, an intrusion into what would otherwise be private. There is no point in calling, therefore, for an end to govern- mental...

PORTRAIT OF A WEEK

The Spectator

A•disastrous fire in a village dance hall near Grenoble in France killed 144 young people. The emergency exit doors were locked. Sir Alec Douglas-Home, Foreign Sec- retary,...

Page 6

POLITICAL COMMENTARY

The Spectator

PETER PATERSON A chilling moment occurred last Thursday evening in Committee Room No 10 at the House of Commons, chilling, that is. for all of us who are aware of the...

Page 7

THE SPECTATOR'S NOTEBOOK

The Spectator

note that Dr Ralph Bunche has been adding his small voice to those raised by, or from, the Foreign Office against George Brown. Foreign emissaries no less than other men can be...

Page 8

NATIONALISED INDUSTRIES

The Spectator

The centralising tyranny of London MERVYN JONES (THE GAS) Parliament must soon decide the proper future structure of the nationalised gas industry. The Gas Act 1948 set up...

Page 9

Our foreign correspondence

The Spectator

SWITZERLAND On the wing RICHARD KILIAN Geneva The only thing worse than anti-hijacking measures in Switzerland is actually being hi- jacked. The Swiss have carried airport...

Page 10

AMERICA

The Spectator

On political indecency JOHN GRAHAM Washington DC No one expected the political campaign to be a tea-party, but some of the things that have been said and done in the last...

TRANSATLANTIC

The Spectator

The non-future of the iron horse DENTS BROGAN It was with a sense of shock that I read in Saturday's newspaper of a sudden strike of the crew of the 'France' which stranded...

Page 11

AFRICA

The Spectator

Bantu stances MOLLY MORTIMER 'Every nation has the right to self-determina- tion, to choose its allies ... and we don't need the United Nations to help us.' So said Chief...

Page 12

IRELAND

The Spectator

Jack Lynch on his crisis Ian Lyon talks to the Irish Prime Minister Is the North dragging its feet? 'I believe that the right-wing element in the North is very much opposed...

Page 13

IRELAND

The Spectator

Blaney's hard line STAN GEBLER DAVIES Now there is no one in the Republic of Ireland better entitled to the description hard-liner than Neil Blaney. The govern- ment has gone...

Page 14

AS I SAW IT

The Spectator

The men on the Clapham omnibus SALLY VINCENT SATURDAY EVENINGS at 52 Clapham High St, 5W4. 31 Oct. 'Spotlight on Aircraft Industry'. Open discussion. 7.30. Buffet at 9.30. The...

Remember, remember ...

The Spectator

We are the child-dervishes of the Chilterns, We whirl, We roll in chalk, We strike sparks from flint, 2 The fire is a roaring red giant. Beacons echo him everywhere We look. The...

Page 15

PERSONAL COLUMN

The Spectator

Bad taste ROGER BARNARD Last Remembrance Sunday at the Ceno- taph. Whitehall, a group of people courag- eously voiced their objections to British government policy in Nigeria....

Page 16

MEDICINE

The Spectator

Red taping drugs JOHN ROWAN WILSON It isn't so often, these days, that the British can claim to have devised a method of doing something very much more efficiently and cheaply...

The Press and the winter

The Spectator

by 'another Conservative' On seeing the advertising claim that `when the Times speaks, the world listens' one is aware of a tone that cannot easily be dis- regarded. One feels...

Page 17

COMMUNICATION

The Spectator

The PIB report on ITV BILL GRUNDY Never having been much of a fan of Mr Aubrey Jones and his Prices and Incomes Board, I was not surprised to find that his swan-song, last...

Page 18

Homes fit for horses

The Spectator

Sir: I was horrified to read your entirely unwarranted attack on horses and their accommodation (31 October). It is time we realised that horses have hearts and feelings similar...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

The Spectator

Dealing with kidnappers Sir: Your recent editorial approv- ing the strong stand taken by the Canadian government against the FLQ was appreciated here. It is always nice to be...

Royal boot hunt?

The Spectator

Sir: It should not be thought that hunting the 'clean boot' by a blood- hound pack is peculiar to Germany (Clive Gammon, 24 October). This form of sport is enjoyed in En - gland...

More on Marcuse

The Spectator

Sir: In your Personal Column last week you published a review by me of Professor Paul Robinson's The Sexual Radicals. Had I seen a proof of the review. I would have deleted...

Death by merger

The Spectator

Sir: 1 hope that Dr Bernard Øi (Letters, 31 October) doesn't CIF that I was criticising either hini New Scientist, on the contrary, I have the greatest admiration for both. The...

Gardener gagged From the Queen's Press Secretary Sir: You commented

The Spectator

in list week's Notebook on the decision which prevented the retired head gardener at Sandringham from capitalising on his years of service with the Queen by publishing his...

Bacon and Dr Rowse

The Spectator

Sir: With reference to Mr Weid- berg's letter in your issue dated 21 October, I would ask him to remember that 'contempt' is no substitution for discussion on the Shakespeare...

Mr Crosland's small talk

The Spectator

Sir: Your extremely funny story of my post-general-election dinner with Mr and Mrs Michael Clark gave great pleasure. But, alas for accuracy, such a dinner never oc- curred. (I...

Gossipy Spectator

The Spectator

Sir: I doubt if I am the only reader whose delight in the new sFEcrarna was marred by the intrusion of two nauseating examples (Notebook : 31 October) of the one really use-...

Fearless Spectator

The Spectator

Sir: With compliments and warm congratulations to the writer of Notebook (24 October) on his truly magnificent and fearless piece on `the great Common Market Swindle'. Henry...

Nixon defended

The Spectator

Sir: In his article `Mr. Nixon's Crime Bill' (24 October), Louis Claiborne makes inappropriately snide remarks about precautions taken to protect the life of Presi- dent Nixon....

Page 19

Moral armament

The Spectator

Sir: Although I was horrified by the notion that the Government should be inluenced in its decision over South African arms sales by a desire for 'a useful exercise in public...

ICI in India

The Spectator

Sir: May I draw attention to an error in Kuldip Napes article, India Estranged, in your edition of 10 October. He contrasts the British Govern- ment's attitude on preferential...

India defended Sir: Taya Zinkin's cavalier treat- ment of Neville

The Spectator

Maxwell's India's China War does less than justice to a first-class historical work. Mr Maxwell writes from close obser- vation of the events described in his book (he was the...

Arms and the Club

The Spectator

Sir: The sale of arms to South Africa is not the ideal issue on which to test how far the (British) 'Commonwealth' can withstand contemporary international poli- tical stresses....

Powell and the `NY Times'

The Spectator

Sir: Having been away from London for several weeks my attention has only just been drawn to the correspondence conducted by Mr Peregrine Worsthorne and Mr Anthony Lewis in the...

Page 20

Mea culpa

The Spectator

Sir: A momentary aberration led me to describe Mr William White- law, the Lord President of the Council, as Lord Privy Seal in my Political Commentary last week. Mr Whitelaw, in...

The other side of :Ararat Sir: The gust of wind

The Spectator

which blew the two unfortunate us generals across the artificial frontier divid- ing western Armenia from the Soviet Republic would presumably be described as an 'act of God'....

Human rights in Israel

The Spectator

Sir: I do not see what is to be gained by such articles as that from 'Israel Amos' on the one country in the Middle East that understands human rights. Israel is equivalent to...

Blackpool snobs '

The Spectator

Sir: Blackpool may be an abomina- tion to Mr Bernard Levin, but a lot of people go there knowing what it has to offer, and because this is what they like. Would Mr Levin bundle...

Malthusiana

The Spectator

Sir: I am writing a life of Thomas Robert 'Population' Malthus (1766-1834). You may be surprised to learn that no full-length bio- graphy of him exists, and I find that many...

COMPETITION

The Spectator

No. 629: Desdichado The news that the Consumer Coun- cil has lost its grant—and Des Wil- son his prospective job as chair- man—has been rather over- shadowed by the rest of Mr...

Page 21

Liberator of France

The Spectator

ENOCH POWELL Memoires d'Espoir, Vol. 1: Le Renouveau Charles de Gaulle (Plon 52s 6d) There was something instantly familiar about de Gaulle's memoirs, the moment I opened them...

A hundred years ago

The Spectator

From the 'Spectator,' 5 November 1870—Bad news seems to act on Frenchmen like acid on an alkali. The moment it falls there is a splutter. The news of an armistice was received...

Page 22

Hero of France

The Spectator

DOUGLAS JOHNSON Marshal Main Richard Griffiths (Constable £4) It has often been said that what most bewil- dered Winston Churchill in the catastrophe of 1940 was his inability...

Page 23

The day thou gayest

The Spectator

PETER HAWKES Last Things C. P. Snow (Macmillan 55s) When we came in. I found an urgent message from St Peter: 'G. would like a word with St Lewis as soon as possible'. I handed...

Page 24

NEW NOVELS

The Spectator

Broken rules AUBERON WAUGH Like Men Betrayed Frederic Raphael (Cape 45s) The Marriage of a Young Stockbroker Charles Webb (Andr6 Deutsch 30s) Four golden rules should be...

Pop-eyed

The Spectator

FRANK LIPSIUS Revolt into Style George Melly (Allen Lane The Penguin Press 50s) Lots of people make money in the music business, but none of them seem to be the right people....

Page 25

De Valera-the unasked questions and the ungiven answers

The Spectator

E. R. NORMAN Eamon de Valera The Earl of Longford and Thomas P. O'Neill (Hutchinson 80s) Whatever may be said about de Valera, one thing is certain: his long pursuit of an an-...

Page 27

Those were the Sixties, were those?

The Spectator

CHRISTOPHER BOOKER What really happened to Britain in the Six- ties? A year ago, I published a book called The Neophiliacs, which could at least claim the dubious distinction...

Page 30

Throwing up from an Ivory Tower

The Spectator

TOM HUTCHIN SON What a fun time it has been at the Royal Court! My bronchial tubes have been ignited by smoke bombs. I have been spattered by vomit. My mind has been bludgeoned...

Wilted plume

The Spectator

KENNETH HURREN To anyone unacquainted with its anteced- ents, the version of Cyrano de Bergerac that Patrick Garland has adapted and directed for the National Theatre Company...

CINEMA

The Spectator

Hybrid dinosaur PENELOPE HOUSTON Hollywood's recent decision to take a more parsimonious approach is probably hardly worth the paper it wasn't written on. No doubt it would...

Page 31

TELEVISION

The Spectator

Evolution Patrick Skene CATLING Pets and Vets (Bac 2) is a sensible, straight- forward, informative series on domestic animals and the people who care for them. As pets in...

ART

The Spectator

Bobbery pack FRANCIS WATSON Between the amiable ferocity of Tipu's Tiger and the ivory vacancy of a throne presented to Queen Victoria by a Travancore rajah, the curious may...

Page 32

OPERA

The Spectator

Spry old timers RODNEY MILNES There can scarcely be two hardier perennials in the opera repertoire than The Marriage of Figaro and La Boheme, and the fact that both make a...

BALLET

The Spectator

Noble creatures CLEMENT CRISP When Sir Frederick Ashton surveys the Royal Ballet he must see a group of beings whom he, like Viganei's Prometheus, 'civil- ised . . . by giving...

MUSIC

The Spectator

Voice of the past GILLIAN WIDDICOMBE How mediaeval man would disport himself in mirth at the sober attention we pay his music nowadays. How he would envy us, too, being able...

Page 33

MONEY Being beastly to Barber

The Spectator

NICHOLAS DAVENPORT The reception given to Mr Barber's mini- budget—from the press to the pub, from the Bank of England to the Stock Exchange— has been unfair, ungenerous, mean,...

Page 34

PETER QUINCE

The Spectator

At this time of year everyone seems to be busily noting the signs of the changine season and no less busily pointing them out to anyone who will listen. It's odd, because autumn...

SKIN FLINT'S CITY e f t DIARY

The Spectator

If you like building pyramids (now called conglomerates) you will before long be asked to sell a large block of shares on behalf of a major shareholder who will probaby have got...

Page 35

CLIVE GAMMON

The Spectator

Now their weapons are Long-bowes and forked Arrowes, Swords and Targets, Ear- quebusses, Muskets, Durks and Loquhabor Axes. . . all the Valley on each side being way-lay'd with...

THE GOOD aft LIFE

The Spectator

Pamela Vandyke Price 'The season', as far as writers on wine are concerned, has just opened. Invitations to tastings crowd each other and, as one scuttles from a presentation...

Page 36

NOTES FROM THE UNDERGROUND_

The Spectator

TONY PALMER Last Monday work began in Wales on a new film of Macbeth. 'Utilising the text of Shakespeare's famous play', as it is officially described, this version will be the...

Page 40

The Spectator

Crossword 1454

The Spectator

DAEDALUS A prize of three guineas will be awarded for the first correct solution opened on 16 November. Address solutions: Crossword 1454, The Spec- tator, 99 Gower Street,...

Page 43

Umbrella boom

The Spectator

ANDREW WHITTAKER From the viewpoint of the businessman— particularly one from outside the country— it must have seemed in the past ten years that in setting up an enterprise in...

Inside Ireland

The Spectator

The most fervent pride comes from the past. The Constitution is quite explicit: 'The Irish l a nguage is the first official language. The English language is recognised as a...

Page 45

A new Jerusalem

The Spectator

TIM PAT COOGAN Normally when people talk about changes in Irish attitudes they are overlooking the fact that the biggest change in Irish attitudes took place some years ago....

There are other well-informed voices be- sides those of businessmen,

The Spectator

urging change in the Republic. The relaxation of the censor- ship of books is one of their victories. In the old days. when a book was banned, it was banned for ever. Now a ban...

Page 47

Who are the moderates?

The Spectator

GARRET FITZGERALD After the split in Sinn Fein over acceptance of the Anglo-Irish Treaty of December 1921, which conceded Dominion status to the greater part of the island,...

Page 48

All hail to Mr FitzNixon

The Spectator

LIAM HOLTRICAN Two days before President Nixon's arrival in Ireland (3 October), Simon Dee failed to appear at the official opening of a Dublin shopping centre. He had agreed...

Page 50

Where potatoes are optional

The Spectator

IRWIN STEWART My personal gastronomic map of the Irish Republic is heavily weighted in favour of the Dublin area. The blank areas do not necessarily represent gastronomic...