15 JANUARY 1960, page 23

Salute In Kind

Honour'd Shade. Selected and edited by Norman MacCaig. (Chambers, I 2s. 6d,) Tuts book of seventy-seven previously uncol- lected poems by twenty-seven living Scottish poets was......

Writing And Writing About

The Critical Quarterly. Volume 1, Nos. 3 and 4. (2s. 6d.) The Kenyon Review, Autumn 1959. ($1.) X. Edited by David Wright and Patrick Swift. (Barrie and Rockliff, Gs.) IN his......

Rednecks And Patricians

(1 °Ivs and Images. By Meriol Trevor. (Mac- k, 15s.) ` a ckberry Wilderness. By Sylvia Berkman. (Gol- lanez, 16s.) . 111 the novels by Robert Penn Warren are re- s1hts At......