15 MARCH 1873, page 13

[to The Editor Of The "spectator:?

SIR,—It would occupy much more space than you can afford me, and it would take more time than I can well spare, were I to give an exhaustive answer to Mr. Malcolm Maccoll's......

What Mr. Arnold's Analysis Involves.

[TO THE EDITOR OF THI1 9PSO2.43011.1 Sin, —I think we have great reason to be thankful to Mr. Arnold for his " Literature and Dogma." He has not done what he intended to do, but......