30 MARCH 1929, Page 42

Those who have been refreshed or instructed by Mr. Punch's

periodical illustrations and expositions of the philosophy and humours of golf will like to find a number of them collected into one volume, entitled Mr. Punch on the Links (Methuen, Os.). Various hands have helped in the making of this joyous little book and " Evoe " edits it. But is he not afraid of provoking the wrath of the captious Scot by allowing a Scottish caddie on p. 47 to allude to golf-clubs as " sticks ' ? The Scot will be regretting that he ever took his national game to England, if it cannot be treated with proper respect there.

* * *