7 NOVEMBER 1903, Page 18

On Wednesday night Mr. Chamberlain addressed an audience of ten

thousand people at Birmingham. His speech, which was the longest he has yet made in his campaign, was a remarkable example of his great powers of popular appeal. He began with an historical retrospect. He denied that the days preceding the repeal of the Corn-laws were days of scarcity, or that the inauguration of Free-trade had ameliorated the condition of the people. He maintained that in the years from 1830 to 1841 the country was in a better position relatively to other nations than it now occupies. The undoubted popular discontent he attributed to Chartism, a creed which was absolutely opposed to Cobdenism. "The riots were directed, not in favour of Free-trade, but against the Manchester manufacturers and others who were at that time supporters of Free-trade." It was true that after 1841 the country entered upon a long period of unexampled prosperity; but those who attributed this to the repeal of the Corn-laws were guilty of the old fallacy of post hoc ergo propter hoc. Let us get rid of the idea that prosperity inevitably follows Free-trade and starvation Protection; and having got rid of this idea, let us consider the matter soberly as a business proposition. Have conditions so changed that a policy which may have been good policy in 1841 is now wholly unfitted to meet the case P