12 OCTOBER 1956

Page 3

BRITAIN IN EUROPE

The Spectator

T HE Mansion House dinner to the bankers and merchants of the City of London is an outstanding event in the economic calendar. It is the occasion for the Chancellor of the...

SPECTATOR

The Spectator

ESTABLISHED 1828 No. 6694 FRIDAY, OCTOBER 12, 1956 PRICE 9d.

Page 4

GIVING HIM THE RUN-AROUND

The Spectator

BY J. E. M. ARDEN K HRUSHCHEV is flying to Yugoslavia these days with all the regularity of Neville Chamberlain hopping over to Ger- many in 1938. The last trip, with the visit...

NEW MODEL ARMY

The Spectator

T HE reservists recalled over Suez may have become restive —it would be surprising if they had not—but there is no evidence that they are mutinous. In some cases individual...

Page 5

Portrait of the Week

The Spectator

As the Security Council proceeds with its debate on the As crisis, whether in open or in secret session. it is becoming increasingly apparent that results are to be looked for...

THE BECHUANALAND PROTECTORATE

The Spectator

By A. SILLERY* HAVE just come back from the Bechuanaland Protec- torate, a country I last saw in 1950, when it was convulsed by the Seretse affair: the Bamangwato tribal...

Page 6

Political Commentary BY CHARLES CURRAN

The Spectator

Llandudno I WRITE as the Tory Party assembles here for its annual conference. This is the most self-critical gathering in the party's history since 1946. The list of...

Page 7

THE PARTY ON the stage of the Royal Opera House

The Spectator

after the first performance of the Bolshoi Ballet reminded me painfully of the entertainment provided after the Queen's Coronation. There was the same determined rush for food...

A Spectator's Notebook

The Spectator

I' M WILL BLAME and many will sympathise with Mr. Nigel N icolson, one of the most eloquent Tory abolitionists, for w ithdrawing his support from the Silverman Bill. As MP for...

A FRIEND WHO thinks I am unduly harsh on commercial

The Spectator

tele- vision suggested I should watch the BBC's latest serial, David C oPperfield—praised by the critics—and ask myself what Would have been said about it if it had appeared on...

COMING OF AGE INTELLIGENCE

The Spectator

ROCK 'N ROLL at Duke's 21st birthday party.—Daily Mirror, October 10. No ROCKING. Duke's party is so sedate.—Daily Express, October 10.

PLEASED THOUGH I was at the idea of Lord Hailsham

The Spectator

as a new broom for the Admiralty, I hope any dust he sweeps up is not going to get into his eyes. At a press conference last week he said : 'It is being seriously suggested that...

I HAVE ALWAYS agreed with the thesis that the State

The Spectator

and its offshoots will have to take over the patronage of the Arts from others from whom it has taken the means of patronising anything. The clause in the 1948 Local Government...

Page 8

The Conservatives' Future

The Spectator

BY ANGUS MAUDE, MP T HE practical measures of Tory policy needed today can be briefly and generally summarised. Overseas, policy should deviate only for the most compelling...

Page 9

Roads: The New Philistinism

The Spectator

BY CHARLES WILSON T HERE are two ways of looking at the normal bonhomie of English politics. You can, on the one hand, regard it as superior to the Continental habit of...

Page 10

The Legacy of Bevin

The Spectator

BY IAN GILMOUR M R. BEVAN' said a few months ago that the Tories had become bloody-minded over Cyprus; and the ..- Manchester Guardian agreeing with him thought that they were...

Page 11

Church and Trade Union

The Spectator

BY SIMON PHIPPS T HE greatest challenge to the churches in Britain today is the yawning gulf between themselves and the mass of industrialised society. To realistic Christians...

Page 12

The Lorcha Arrow and the Second China War

The Spectator

BY E. W. R. LUMBY T HE lorcha Arrow, which was the occasion of a train of events with momentous consequences, owed her generic name to the Portuguese—`lorcha' being their name...

Page 15

City and Suburban

The Spectator

BY JOHN BETJEMAN N N unceasing battle goes on in the Church between Hymns Ancient and Modern (first published 1861) and The Eng- lish Hymnal, which is fifty years old this week....

Page 16

The Thruster

The Spectator

T HE One That Got Away, by Kendal Burt and James Leasor (Collins and Michael Joseph, 16s.), is a fascinat- ing story and will find many readers; but some of them. I suspect,...

Page 18

BEWARE THE JABBERWOCK

The Spectator

SIR,—By now it should be clear to all that Mr. Kingsley Amis reviews books the way he does more to air his meticulously malicious views on Eng. Lit. and his fellow-men than to...

SECRET POLICE POWERS

The Spectator

SIR,—Whether the readers of your tradition' ally independent weekly gain any advantage when the 'Political Commentary' is regularlY written by someone so adhesively committed to...

COMPREHENSIVE EDUCATION

The Spectator

Sitt,—I have never previously taken exception to an unfavourable review. Any reviewer needs and deserves to have considerable latitude— but there are accepted limits, and I fear...

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

Oxford Divided Robert Blake, Renee Haynes, Paul Ries Collin Comprehensive Education Robin Pedley Beware the Jabberwock A. B. Stables Secret Police Powers Peter Benenson Murder...

Sm,—I cannot help feeling some sympathy for Dr. Sharpe, however

The Spectator

small the mercies for which he gives thanks; for Mr. Sandys in his predicament; and for the heads and members of all colleges in the High. But that is at least partly because 1...

SIR,—I am not, and could never have been, a member

The Spectator

of what T. C. W. Stinton calls `Mr. Blake's College'; but, with many other mem- bers of the university to which both your correspondents belong, I agree with every- thing that...

99 Gower Street, London, W.C,1

The Spectator

Euston 3221

Page 20

Contemporary Arts

The Spectator

The Bolshoi Ballet THE long-awaited, almost-abandoned, thunder- ously acclaimed, opening performance of the Bolshoi Theatre Ballet in London on October 3 provided ammunition for...

MECHANISED BRIGADE

The Spectator

SIR,—Mr. Guest should no' imagine that the motor-car is a business expense. Licentiates of the oldest profession are respected by tax gatherers, reputedly the second oldest and...

MURDER MOST FOUL

The Spectator

SIR,—Oliver Edwards writes of Thomas Mann, in a recent review : 'Perhaps it was that touch of insensitivity that allowed him, the great artist, to murder our sweet English...

Page 22

Alien Corn

The Spectator

ANOTHER birthday to be celebrated : this time the English Opera Group's, which has reached the age of ten, having done valiant work and proved itself truly English by...

Medicine Men

The Spectator

THE DOCTOR'S DILEMMA. By George Bernard Shaw. (Saville.) AT the time of the Shaw centenary I thought of any number of Shaiv's plays which could be revived with success in the...

Bigamy in Bedlam THE BIGAMIST. (Curzon.)---FERNANDEL THE DRESSMAKER. (Cameo-Polytechnic.)

The Spectator

I ONCE saw the silvery tie Sica in a film where, dubbed rather unsuitably in French, he defended Gina Lollobrigida, accused of mar' dering her husband, on the grounds, quite...

Page 24

Cold Steel

The Spectator

THE large retrospective exhibition at the Whitechapel Gallery by Merlyn Evans rep- resenting a career of twenty-five years places me in a predicament. I have a deep respect for...

Set-Sellers

The Spectator

I ASKED two people who came round for a drink the other night if they minded listening to the last twenty minutes of the play on ITV. They were old enough friends to cry 'For...

Mkt Oprrtator

The Spectator

OCTOBER 15, 1831 DAME PARTINGTON.—"The attempt of the House of Lords to stop the progress of reform, reminds me very forcibly of the great storm at Sidmouth, and the conduct of...

Page 25

BOOK

The Spectator

A Lamp for Labour BY GRAHAM HUTTON S OCIALISM and Conservatism have become too much alike to please Socialists and Conservatives; and they are in a bad way. While the Tories...

Page 27

Blood to the Head

The Spectator

THE GERMAN SCENE. By Edmond Vermeil. Translated by L. J. Ludovici. (Harrap, 25s.) EDMOND VERMEIL, whose earlier work, Germany's Three Reichs, belongs to the standard literature...

New Accessions

The Spectator

MODERN ENGLISH PAINTERS. VOL II: Lewis to Moore. By Sir John Rothenstein. (Eyre and Spottiswoode, 35s.) THE two volumes which the Director of the Tate Gallery has devoted to...

Page 28

Sombre Prophet

The Spectator

OF all the Socialists, Communists and anarchists who skirmished and bickered throughout the greater part of the nineteenth century Proudhon still seems the most sympathetic and...

Quest For Certainty

The Spectator

I T may be said without malice that Mr. Hugh Ross Williamson's greatest service to the Church of England has so far been this autobiographical account, sincerely and...

Page 30

Ladies' Day

The Spectator

THIS FEMININE WORLD. By Mrs. Robert Henrey. (Dent, 18s.) SUNSHINE AND SHADOW. By Mary Pickford. (Heinemann, 25s.) IN her latest book Mrs.. Robert Henrey has elected to lavish...

Captain's Prize

The Spectator

ME STORY OF THE R. AND A. By J. B. Salmond. (Macmillan, 28s.) `I was alone with my wife and we drifted towards Wimbledon Park.' Lord Brabazon is one of the few men living who...

Page 32

Into the Cosmos

The Spectator

AN APPROACH TO MODERN PHYSICS. By E. N. da C. Andrade. (Bell, 25s.) AN APPROACH TO MODERN PHYSICS. By E. N. da C. Andrade. (Bell, 25s.) the science of flashes and bangs, stands...

Eight to Fourteen

The Spectator

THE TRAIL OF THE BROKEN SNOWSHOE. By Margaret Goven. Illustrated by Donna Little. (Dent, 10s. 6d.) THE AQUALUNG TWINS FIND CHINESE TREASURE. By Frederick Falkner. Illustrated by...

Page 34

New Novels

The Spectator

ON the back of the title-page of Andersonville, by MacKinlaY Kantor (Allen, 20s.), is the announcement, 'Asterisks in the text denote words and passages which have been deleted...

Page 35

Country Life

The Spectator

BY IAN NIALL HARVEST continues here in October, as we expected, with wind and rain that make the gathering more difficult. The wind dries out the stooks but it is not easy to...

Chess

The Spectator

BY PHILIDOR No. 71. L. WOODWARD BLACK (6 men) WHITE (lb men) WHITE to play and mate in two moves: solution next week. Solution to last week's problem by Goethart. R–R 31...

RAIN AND SHINE

The Spectator

John Moore, whose work I have always admired, has written another excellent country book. It is called Come Rain, Come Shine (Collins, 18s.) and it is a meandering, delight- ful...

THE CRIPPLE

The Spectator

The wounded jackdaw hopped out of the Shrubbery across the road while I stood look- ing out of my bedroom window. Four others, Perched on the iron railing, watched the progress...

LEEKS AND CELERY

The Spectator

Final earthing up of leeks and celery should be done in a dry spell. If the latter have not been grown in a trench with this in mind they should be earthed by hoeing up in order...

Page 36

ADVICE TO MR. MACMILLAN-WHEN TO EASE

The Spectator

Ry NICHOLAS DAVENPORT THE question now being hotly debated in the City, as to when Mr. Macmillan should ease his disinflation policy, is not one which is likely to receive an...

COMPANY NOTES

The Spectator

BY CUSTOS, THIS was a good time to take a holiday from the City, for trading on the Stock Exchange has rarely been so idle. The market in industrial ordinary shares is reluctant...

Page 38

SPECTATOR CROSSWORD No. 909

The Spectator

ACROSS 1 Got a hair-cut on election day? (6) 4 'We are - down the ladder, rung by rung' (Kipling) (8). 9 June 14, 1645 (6). 10 Accommodation that doesn't seem sufficient for...

Pars for the Month

The Spectator

The usual prize was offered for a paragraph for October, 1956, on the lines of the well- known advertisements of one of the 'Big Five' banks, and parodying: Stephen Potter, J....

SPECTATOR COMPETITION No. 348 Set by Barbara Smoker Premium bonds

The Spectator

will be on sale /rot'? November 1. The usual prize is offered for a letter from the appropriate Civil Service department to citizens who with' draw their bonds-on similar lines...