5 JANUARY 1951

Page 1

INDEX FROM JANUARY 5th TO JUNE 29th, 1951, INCLUSIVE.

The Spectator

NEWS OF THE WEEK A IR FORCE Americas, The 402 Arab League .. 98 Argentina : " La Prensa", 298 ; meat agreement 542 Army New territorials, 167 ; rival 802 Australia :...

Page 5

Retreat in Korea

The Spectator

Very large forces of Chinese infantry, with a little support from artillery but none from armour or the air, have attacked the 8th Army, which has been allowed several weeks in...

Towards a Four-Power Conference

The Spectator

Movement in negotiations with the Soviet Union has to be measured by inches, not feet or yards, and it is fortunate if it is movement forwards at all. The rejoinder to the...

NEWS OF THE WEEK

The Spectator

E ARLIER meetings of Commonwealth Prime Ministers have proved so useful that there was in no quarter any reluctance to accept the expense of time and energy which the current...

Page 6

Coal By Exhortation

The Spectator

The Government presumably wished to express in quantitative terms their concern with the fuel situation when they allocated no fewer than five Ministers to Wednesday's meeting...

Dr. Adenauer's Problems

The Spectator

The New Year faces the West German Federal Government with a number of difficult problems. The situation is confused and dan- gerous. The internal demand for unity is growing...

Pakistan's Mistake The decision of Mr. Liaquat Ali Khan, the

The Spectator

Prime Minister of Pakistan, not to attend the Commonwealth conference in London, while intelligible, is thoroughly unwise. Les absents ont toujours tort, and to leave the field...

A Role for Japan ?

The Spectator

It is presumably in his capacity as United States Commander-in- Chief in Japan, and no other, that General MacArthur, in the course of one of his periodical incursions into...

Page 7

NEW YEAR'S RESOLUTION

The Spectator

AL L thoughtful people have known for months that a new time of effort and hardship was at hand, but neither Government nor the governed have been quite ready to put the new...

Page 8

Let no one say there is not such a thing

The Spectator

as the official type of mind. Someone made the sensible suggestion that instead of one long queue for taxis behind one long barrier at Waterloo there should be several openings...

A SPECTATOR'S NOTEBOOK

The Spectator

W ITH Australia's celebration of the first half-century of her existence as a federation, and New Zealand's of the centenary of the Canterbury settlement, it it perhaps relevant...

The King's reference to Pilgrim's Progress in his Christmas broadcast

The Spectator

has, I am interested (but not surprised) to find, stimulated substantially the sales of a classic which has always been a steady seller. King George spoke of a book " much loved...

Moving with that considered deliberation proper to a staid monthly

The Spectator

review, The Nineteenth Century and After has decided, in this first month of the second half of the twentieth century, to call itself—nothing less than The Twentieth Century. I...

" MR ATTLEE ON TESTS OF 1951." — The Times.

The Spectator

And he didn't so much as mention cricket. JMus.

Having always held that there should be room for an

The Spectator

inter- university journal, which should at a reasonable price deal with the activities, aims and problems of undergraduates everywhere, I shall watch with interest the future of...

I warmly support the Lancet's appeal to hospitals with "

The Spectator

alarming " names to get themselves re-christened. As it happens, a few days before I read the Lancet's comments I was passing the Hospital for Incurables at Putney, as I...

From the latest issue of that widely-circulated American weekly News-week

The Spectator

may be gleaned information about King George and Queen Elizabeth which will (appropriately enough) be news to most of Their Majesties' subjects. The King, it seems, is a member...

Page 9

China's Price

The Spectator

M R. ATTLEE has been to America and returned ; General Wu Hsiu-chuan has been to America and returned to China ; but whatever object these journeys had, it is becoming plain...

Page 10

Athletics: 19o1-195o

The Spectator

By HAROLD ABRAHAMS A s. sit down on the last day of the first half of the twentieth century to write this article, I cannot help imagining . what I should have said fifty years...

Page 11

New Old Town

The Spectator

By EDWARD HODGKIN T HE rebuilding of old towns on new sites is an activity usually associated with such names as Alexander the Great, the Caliph Mansur and Sir Edwin Lutyens....

Page 12

Doctors and Drugs

The Spectator

By M. E. IAMPARD, M.D. N July 5th, 1948, the doctors were given a blank cheque to draw on the nation's bank-4ccount to any extent that they considered advisable in the...

Page 13

Culture in Chi cago

The Spectator

By ROBERT WAITIIMAisl T WAS In receipt of a telegram the other day from my friend, Mr. C. V. R. Thompson, the eminent chief correspondent of the I London Daily Express. It was...

Page 14

UNDERGRADUATE PAGE

The Spectator

The Customer is Always Right By JOHN DAVY (Trinity College, Cambridge) HERE are two great festivals in December each year. The first is celebrated by the Christian world and is...

6pectator," Januarp 40, 1851

The Spectator

At home, the half century has greatly changed the aspect of society: where all was Tory suppression at the beginning, all is thrown open now. We have gained freedom, political....

Page 15

MARGINAL COMMENT •

The Spectator

By HAROLD NICOLSON I T is with self-reproach that, as year succeeds year, I notice that it becomes increasingly difficult to think out Christmas presents and increasingly easy...

Page 16

SPECTATOR COMPETITION No. 47

The Spectator

Set by J. M. Cohen Riding over the plain of La Mancha, Don Quixote catches sight of a line of pylons in the distance. A prize of £5, which may be divided, is offered for a...

The Quarry

The Spectator

ALONG the green banks by the waterside the anglers sit and idle summer through, gazing at their floats that nod ,end ride above the gleaming cool where fishes slide elusive...

SPECTATOR COMPETITION No. 44

The Spectator

Report by Daniel Parson A prize of £5 was offered for the concluding paragraph of a amous novel, assuming that the hero or heroine has married the runner-up—e.g., June Eyre and...

Page 17

CONTEMPORARY ARTS

The Spectator

THEATRE 44 Point or Departure." By Jean Anouilli. Translated by Kitty Black. (Duke of York's.) M. ANoulurs contemporary version of the Orpheus and Eurydice legend, now...

CINEMA

The Spectator

,, So Young and So Bad." (London Pavilion.)—"Born to be Bad." (Odeon, Marble Arch.) THE film-industry in America has of late become so aware of the world's callousness, notably...

MUSIC

The Spectator

IN J. M. Robertson's New Essays Towards a Critical Method there is a suggestion that " the perfect scientific critic, the critic of the future perhaps, might be conceived as...

Page 18

In the Garden

The Spectator

During two weeks of almost unbroken black frost (that horrible, greasy kind of cold which kaves clots of ice like stale mutton-dripping about the ground) 1 have found that a row...

CHAMBER Music.—Dinu Lipatti's recording of all Chopin's waltzes (Col.) proved

The Spectator

to be his swan-song, and these records will provide a fitting memorial for a pianist who, though young, was already in the very front rank of his profession. Backhaus records...

Vocat..—For H.M.V. Gigli has recorded twelve Italian arias of the

The Spectator

seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, most beautiful singing only marred by very few feature.; of questionable taste. Mascia Predit's Mussorgsky songs 1 found disappointing,...

RECENT RECORDS

The Spectator

ORCHESTRAL—Heifetz's playing of the Elgar violin concerto with the L.S.O. is quite magnificent, outstanding in interpretation and breath- taking in technical finish. Bantock's...

Economics and Sentiment

The Spectator

This half-mystical approach to the country scene 'may enrage many contemporaries, who are impatient of any discussion, or any activity, that does not further the urgent need of...

COUNTRY LIFE

The Spectator

WHEREVER one may be, and in whatever circumstances, the few minutes during which both hands of the clock pass from the old year into the new are awe-inspiring. When this...

THE SPECTATOR

The Spectator

readers are urged to place a firm order with their newsagent or to take out a subscription. Newsagents cannot afford to take the risk of carrying stock, as unsold copies are...

Distant Bells

The Spectator

Solitude has no greater revelation. To hear from across meadows, over hills or through valleys, the bells of a village church, chiming muffled, then at the stroke of midnight,...

Page 19

The Mind of the Chinese

The Spectator

Sta.—There is no need to resurrect, as Mr. Thompson does, the vision of a Yellow Peril to explain China's recent intervention in Korea. It may safely be said that China acted in...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

The Spectator

The Birth of Christ Snt,—We gratefully acknowledge the valuable contribution which Mr. Wilson Harris is making to theological discussion in the Spectator. More particularly we...

Page 20

Prime Ministers' Biographies

The Spectator

was interested to read Janus's comments about the biographies of our Prime Ministers, and was particularly glad to learn that the life of Lord Baldwin will soon be published....

The Stone

The Spectator

Sta.—Perhaps you will allow me to apologise for my fellow-countrymen, must of whom, as you seem to be well aware, are at one in deploring this outrage. The Earl of Mansfield is....

Franco's Spain

The Spectator

Sia,—Your correspondent, Miss Dorothy Shepherd, has, in common with certain " professional " observers—so-called—fallen into the error of making either unjustified or completely...

Church Unity

The Spectator

SIR,—The Report of the Representatives points out that differences on the questions of the ministry and of the administration of the sacraments, while they are the main causes...

Bishop Henson's Letters

The Spectator

SIR,—Janus finds in the recently published volume of Bishop Hensley Henson's letters the same characteristics as were prominent in the Bishop's Retrospect—" pungent...

Page 22

BOOKS AND WRITERS

The Spectator

W HEN a version of Don Quixote was performed by the Vic-Wells Ballet one or two critics complained that it was not funny. The idea that the story is a comic strip goes back to...

Page 23

Swinburne's Poetry

The Spectator

Selected Poems of Swinburne. Edited with an introduction by Edward Shanks. (Macmillan. Is. 6d.) Swinburne. Selected Poems. Arranged by Humphrey Hare, with an introduction....

Reviews of the Week

The Spectator

What Is Wrong With London ? Royal Borough. By Rachel Ferguson. (Cape. I cs.) Beautiful London. Photographs by H.Gernsheim.(Phaidon Press. t7s.6d.) THERE is a nostalgic,...

Page 24

A Bishop's Barbs

The Spectator

Letters of Herbert Hensley Henson. Chosen and Edited by Canon E. F. Braley. (S.P.G.K. 155.) AFTER three substantial volumes of Bishop Henson's own reminis- cences it might well...

Return Journey

The Spectator

The Face of Spain. By Gerald Brenan. (Turnstile Press. 155.) Mit. BRENAN, who lived in Spain before the civil war, returned there in 1949 for a two months' visit, and has made...

Page 26

The Study of Titian

The Spectator

OF the many exhibitions held in Italy in the years immediately before the war, by far the most impressive was the Titian exhibi- tion organised at Venice in 1935. There arc some...

An English Humorist

The Spectator

Oddly Enough. By Paul Jennings. (Reinhardt and Evans. Is. 6d.) MR. PAUL JENNINGS is one of those rare, delightful and nearly extinct human beings, a thoroughly English humorist....

Page 28

Interior Decoration and Furniture

The Spectator

English Interior Decoration isoo-1830. By Margaret Jourdain. (Batsford. L3 35. od.) English Interior Decoration isoo-1830. By Margaret Jourdain. (Batsford. L3 35. od.) MESSRS....

Morris and his Circle

The Spectator

We are living in a Victorian revival. There is a suspicion of interest in our grandfathers' architecture, an eager collecting of their bric-a-brac, and a flood of Victorian...

Page 30

SHORTER NOTICE

The Spectator

The Story of StratfordLttpcin-Avon. By J. C. Trewin. (Staples. 8s. 6d.) SOMETHING like a million people now visit the Birthplace during every decade. This slender book,...

Fiction

The Spectator

A Woman of Means. By Peter Taylor. (Routledge. 7s. 6d.) LEFT over from the weeks before Christmas are several novels each of which is worth somebody's reading. None deserves to...

Page 33

SOLUTION TO CROSSWORD No, 606

The Spectator

',2 LI '1 . 1- t. r-1 - NI 17111412111 c e . o F. ! gc:tx "i t. T1 A G L 1 0 1 OR Vil C 1111 1114 C CIA■P.TIA'S `14 'kEEPER CO M U:5 L M e 0/1 s s A D ' AM HARLESTON_ RUB C E...

THE " SPECTATOR 9! CROSSWORD No. 608 [A Book Token

The Spectator

for one guinea will be awarded to the sender of the first correct solution of this week's crossword to be opened after noon on Tuesday week, Prudery 16th. Envelopes must be...

Page 34

FINANCE AND INVESTMENT

The Spectator

By CUSTOS IN face of the disappointing war news from Korea and the growing seriousness of the fuel position at home the New Year has opened in the stock markets on a...