7 OCTOBER 1911

Page 3

BOOKS.

The Spectator

NAPOLEON I.* Ds. AUGUST FOURNIER'S biography was first published in 1885, and was immediately acknowledged to be a most valuable contribution to Napoleonic literature. It found...

Litcrarp Ouppinunt.

The Spectator

LONDON: OCTOBER 7th, 1911.

Page 4

FIFTY YEARS OF CATHAY.* HALF a century ago China was

The Spectator

in the throes of the great Tai-ping Rebellion. The most fertile and populous parts of the Empire had been laid waste. Huge areas had been almost depopulated. The outlook for the...

Page 5

MR. AUSTIN ON HIMSELF.*

The Spectator

Ma. AUSTIN begins his Autobiography with a question: " Wh A t is egotism ? " It cannot, he thinks, " be the recital of what has happened to oneself, for we all do that every...

Page 6

THUCYDIDES.*

The Spectator

JOWETT, in the preface to his translation, commits himself to the sweeping assertion that Thucydides "stands absolutely alone among the historians, not only of Hellas but of the...

Page 7

AN ECONOMIC INTERPRETATION OF INVESTMENT.* "INVESTMENT," says Mr. Hobson, "is

The Spectator

. . . the process of the distribution of productive energy over an ever-widening area of activity, the movement of capital which it primarily • a) An Economic Interpretation of...

Page 8

AN IMPERIAL VICTIM.* IN the bizarre and ill-organized Court of

The Spectator

the First Empire Marie Louise of Austria was the most incongruous figure. Yet, if rightly to be described as the victim of her father's • An Imperial Victim: Marie Louise,...

EDUCATIONAL DOCUMENTS.*

The Spectator

THE documents illustrative of English educational history which Mr. Leach has here collected cover a period of fourteen centuries. It will be interesting to see how they are...

Page 9

A DICTIONARY OF CHRISTIAN BIOGRAPHY.*

The Spectator

IN the year 1877 Dr. Wace's name appeared, in conjunction with that of Dr. William Smith, on the title page of A Die- tionary of Christian Biography, in four volumes. We may be...

COMMODITIE, FIRMENES, AND DELIGHT.* THESE, according to Sir Henry Wotton,

The Spectator

are the "conditions of well-building," and the definition is one which it would be hard to better. The quality of " delight " is not perhaps essential to building as distinct...

Page 10

RECENT ETON HISTORY.*

The Spectator

IT is more than thirty-five years since the first edition of the best of the histories of Eton was published, and here is the fourth. Sir Henry Maxwell Lyte, in his preface,...

SOME LESSONS FROM JAPAN.*

The Spectator

AT a meeting of the Royal Statistical Society earlier in the year Mr. C. V. Sale read a paper on Japanese statistics, which has recently been reprinted. Statistics are not very...

Page 11

CURRENT LITERATURE.

The Spectator

AN HISTORICAL RELATION OF CEYLON. An Historical Relation of Ceylon. By Robert Knox. (James MacLehose and Sons, Glasgow. 12s. 6d. net.)--Robert Knox, born in 1641, took to his...

LADY CHARLOTTE SCHREIBER'S JOURNALS.

The Spectator

Lady Charlotte Schreiber's Journals. Edited by her Son, Montague J. Guest, with annotations by Egan Mew. 2 vols. (John Lane. 42s. net.)—This book is certain to interest...

TWO FAMILY HISTORIES.

The Spectator

The Oliphants of Gask. By E. Maxtone Graham. (J. Nisbet and Co. 21s. net.)—A very interesting story is this of the Oliphants of Gash. There is what may be called the public side...

TWO NAVAL WORKS.

The Spectator

In Famous Sea Fights (Methuen and Co. 6s. net) Mr. John R. Hale brings out by his selection of battles on sea some, points of importance. When he describes for us such fights as...

Page 12

THE RECORDS UNROLLED.

The Spectator

The Records Unrolled. By E. S. Buchanan, M.A. (John Ouseley. 2s. 6d. net.)—Mr. Buchanan is an energetic champion of the old Latin version as against the Vulgate and of the...

WITH UNCLE SAM AND HIS FAMILY.

The Spectator

With Uncle Ham and His Family. By Mr. and Mrs. Grattan Grey. (Francis Griffiths. 6s. net.)—The authors of this volume are Australians who have already taken occasion to tell us...

HISTORY OF FRANCE.

The Spectator

History of France. Told to Boys and Girls by Mary Macgregor (T. C. and E. C. Jack. 7s. 6d. net.)—Miss Macgregor has accom- plished a difficult task with the success which her...

THE CHURCH OF THE NATIVITY AT BETHLEHEM.

The Spectator

The Church of the Nativity at Bethlehem. By W. Harvey and Others. Edited by R. Weir Schultz. (B. T. Batsford. 30s. net.) —Mr. Harvey is responsible for the particular...

LETTERS TO A MINISTERIAL SON.

The Spectator

Letters to a Ministerial Son. By a "Man of the World." (James Clarke and Co. 2s. 6d. net.)—" Political preaching should be left to the politically established Church." Very...

Page 13

Great Soldiers. By George Henry Hart. (Grant Richards, 3s. 6d.

The Spectator

net.)—We have no fault to find with Mr. Hart's choice, nor, in general, with his treatment of his subjects. Henry V.'s march from Harfieur to Calais should, we think, have more...

A HANDBOOK OF THE TSETSE-FLIES.

The Spectator

A Handbook of the Tsetse-Plies. By Ernest Edward Austen. With 10 Coloured Plates and Illustrations in the Text. (Printed by order of the Trustees of the British Museum. 5s....

ENGLISH DIALECTS.

The Spectator

English Dialects. By W. W. Skeat. (Cambridge University Press. ls. net.)—This little volume, one of the "Cambridge Manuals of Science and Literature," gives in a concentrated...

HISTORICAL AND GEOGRAPHICAL DICTIONARY OF JAPAN.

The Spectator

Historical and Geographical Dictionary of Japan. By E. Papinot, M.A. (Regan Paul, Trench and Co. 21s. net.)—The task of the reviewer is simplified by the declarations which we...

The New Art of Flying, By Waldemar Kaempffert. (Sir Isaac

The Spectator

Pitman and Sons. '7s. net.)—This book, which comes from the other side of the Atlantic, tells us something about the past and much about the present condition of aerial...

FOUR VOLUMES OF "THE POETRY OF LIFE" SERIES.

The Spectator

Four volumes of " The Poetry of Life " Series, edited by William Henry Hudson (G. G. Harrap and Co.), are before us. The idea is to develop the connexion between a poet's work...

We have received another volume of Descriptive Sociology by Herbert

The Spectator

Spencer, Edited by Henry Tedder. (Williams and Norgate. 3s.) This volume is devoted to "Chinese," and the compilation and arrangement are the work of Mr. E. T. C. Warner, who...

"This Church of England." By George A. Cobbold, B.A. (A.

The Spectator

R. Mowbray and Co. ls. 6d.)—There is no need to notice in detail the four "Addresses" which make up the contents of this volume. Past, present, and future are viewed from the...

Page 14

Stammering and its Permanent Cure. By Alfred Appelt. (Methuen and

The Spectator

Co. 3s. 6d. net.)-We cannot give any opinion on the theory set forth in this volume. We feel bound, however, to give some notice of it. Mr. Appelt writes from personal experi-...

My Life. By William Mair, D.D. (Hodder and Stoughton. 6s.)-Anyone

The Spectator

who wants to know the actual working of eccle- siastical matters in Scotland cannot do better than read Dr. Mair's autobiography. He tells us of his parochial experience, and he...

In the Victoria History of the Counties of England," edited

The Spectator

by William Page, F.S.A. (Constable and Co., £1 lls. 6d. net each volume), we have Vol. IV. of Hampshire and the Isle of Wight. The volume is devoted to accounts of twenty...

Page 16

Loknow Printed by L. UPCOTT GILL, at the London and

The Spectator

County Printing Works, Drury Lane, W.C.; and Published by joint Beam% for the " SPEOTATOD," (Limited), at their Office, No. 1 Wellington Street, in the Precinct of the Savoy,...

Page 17

Meanwhile the Turkish Cabinet was forced to resign by the

The Spectator

weight of popular opinion, and Said Pasha succeeded Hakki Pasha as Grand Vizier. Said Pasha had great difficulty in forming a Ministry, and did not succeed till Wednesday....

Last Saturday Germany's reply to the previous French communication on

The Spectator

Morocco was handed to the French Am- bassador in Berlin. All accounts agree that this reply brought the two countries much nearer to an agreement. On Tuesday the French...

We may now take such events as are worth putting

The Spectator

on record in the order in which they happened. The period allowed by the Italian ultimatum to Turkey expired at 2.30 p.m. on Friday week, and since the Turkish reply to the...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

T HERE is curiously little news to record of the war between Italy and Turkey, because the absence of serious naval strength on the side of the Turks has made it impossible for...

The result of the General Elections in Sweden has been

The Spectator

greatly to strengthen the Liberals. In the Chamber they now command 100 votes, the Conservatives, who lost 20 seats, and the Social Democrats, who won 10, each numbering 65. It...

On Tuesday the Italian Government formally announced the blockade of

The Spectator

Tripoli to the Powers. At half past three on the same afternoon the bombardment of Tripoli began, as the Turkish commander had refused to surrender. The Turkish fire from the...

The Turkish garrison at Tripoli appears to have satisfied honour

The Spectator

by enduring the bombardment almost passively. Turkish movements at home have been marked by extra- ordinary restraint; evidently a policy of delay has been thought most likely...

NOTICE.—With this week's "SrEcTaroa" is issued, gratis, a

The Spectator

LITERARY SUPPLEMENT.

* a * The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript in any

The Spectator

ease.

iron. TEl

The Spectator

No._ 4,345,] [REGISTERED A I PRICE 6n. POSTAGE ABROAD 2D.

Page 18

The annual conference of the Amalgamated Society of Railway Servants

The Spectator

opened at Carlisle on Monday. Mr. Bellamy, in his presidential address, alluded sympathetically, though guardedly, to the growth of the idea of the sympathetic strike and to the...

On Tuesday the Conference declared unanimously in favour of nationalization

The Spectator

and of an eight-hour day on the railways. In this context we are glad to note the timely warning of the Westminster Gazette, which reminds us of the ready tool which...

The Church Congress opened on Tuesday at Stoke-on-Trent. At the

The Spectator

services held in the morning the Bishop of London and the Bishop of Carlisle were the preachers. The former set himself to answer the question, Why has organized labour so...

In this connexion we note with interest the manifesto issued

The Spectator

on Thursday evening by the Executive Committee of the Associated Society of Locomotive Engineers and Firemen condemning the principle of the sympathetic strike, and expressing...

The Bishop of Lichfield in his presidential address alluded in

The Spectator

feeling terms to the death of Archdeacon Emery, the founder of the Congress, and dwelt on the need of dividing the diocese. Turning to questions affecting the Church as a whole,...

The Bishop of Carlisle, while insisting on the great work

The Spectator

done by the Church in the past, maintained that it was the privilege and duty of every Churchman to take his share in the grand and blessed enterprise of cleansing the Church...

The Irish railway strike, which lasted 1S days and inflicted

The Spectator

serious loss on the trade of the country, ended on Wednesday in a complete victory for the companies. The directors of the three Irish railway companies affected offered to...

Page 19

We have received a remarkable letter on " Betting News-

The Spectator

papers and Quakerism " addressed to members of the Society of Friends by Sir Edward Fry. He sets forth the facts as to the ownership and character of the four papers concerned—...

On Wednesday Sir Frank Lascelles, lately our Ambassador in Berlin,

The Spectator

spoke at length on our relations with Germany. Admitting the existence of ill-feeling, he declared that a war between England and Germany would be one of the greatest calamities...

The tying up of profits for the Rowntree Social Service

The Spectator

Trust only shows that the evil has not been committed from the desire of personal gain. "But the moral and spiritual ruin, the poverty and crime that are produced remain the...

The papers of Friday week contained the account of the

The Spectator

first instance of the Court of Criminal Appeal setting aside a conviction for murder. But the Court declared that the con- viction was set aside only for technical...

Mr. Walter Long, who spoke at the great Unionist meeting

The Spectator

at the Free Trade Hall in Manchester on Tuesday night, said that during the last few weeks a great deed had been done for the Empire. But the battle of Empire had not been...

Mr. Churchill opened the autumn campaign in his con- stituency

The Spectator

at Dundee on Tuesday night. After dealing with the situation on the Continent, he said that we had a full share of unrest in our own islands. Very few people realized how...

The statueto Mr. Parnell executed by the late Mr. St.

The Spectator

Gaudens, the American sculptor, and erected at the north end of Sackville Street, Dublin, opposite the Rotunda, was unveiled by Mr. John Redmond on Sunday in the presence of a...

Professor Dicey concluded his valuable series of letters on the

The Spectator

Parliament Act in Tuesday's Times. The fatal vice of that Act, he insists, is not that it diminishes the power of the )House of Lords and virtually establishes Single-Chamber...

Bank Rate, 4 per cent., changed from 3 per cent.

The Spectator

Sept. 21st. Consols (21) were on Friday 771—Friday week 771.

Page 20

TOPICS OF THE DAY„

The Spectator

lith WAR. T HE Turco-Italian War provides a superlative example of the value of sea-power. By means of their ships the Italians are able to rail off, as it were, a certain area...

Page 21

HOME RULE FINANCE.

The Spectator

17 Nineteenth Century for this month opens with an trticle on the " Financial Difficulties of Home Rule," which fully confirms the view the Spectator has consist- ently taken,...

Page 22

11-is, WORK OF THE UNIONIST PARTY.

The Spectator

THE more enthusiastic Tariff Reformers are using the regult of the Canadian elections to try to press their cause rapidly forward. The Canadians are represented as more...

THE CHURCH AND LABOUR.

The Spectator

T HE labour unrest that has been so marked a feature of the summer which has just passed away is laving its counterpart in the Churches. It is natural and right that. this...

Page 24

"THE LIEGE OF LOITERERS."

The Spectator

LAI RS. BYRON has made a very pretty book. It is an anthology of love songs (" The Garden of Love," Mry Byron : Hodder and Stoughton. 3s. Gd.), an offering to the "purblind...

Page 25

A QUESTION OF ANIMAL ETHICS.

The Spectator

H OW it got into the room was a mystery that has never been solved. It might have come down the chimney, or np through the floor; either mode of entrance would have been...

Page 26

CALAIS.

The Spectator

C ALAIS can never again be to English travellers on the Continent what it was to Sterne, to Wordsworth, to Thackeray—the pleasant threshold of a holiday abroad. It was with...

Page 27

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

INDUSTRIAL PROBLEMS. [To ma Eaxms OF TES "SPECT1TOF:] 81n,—Your numerous correspondents have dealt so ably with the questions arising out of the recent strikes that I hesitate...

THE DISTRIBUTION OF WEALTH.

The Spectator

[To THY EDITOR OF THE " SPECTLTOR.1 Sra,—As an individual deeply interested in the wonderful problem of capital and labour I have read with much pleasure the letters in your...

Page 28

TRADE UNIONISM AND THE RAILWAYS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR 011 . TEM "SPECTATOR. "] SIR,—The evidence that has come by the disclosure of the Railway Inquiry Commission teaches a lesson it is well to ponder over. It is the...

THE ROOT OF THE TROUBLE?

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR."] was going a railway journey some years ago with a well-known member of a well-known community of religious, and, as we tried to find room in...

Page 29

ITALY AND TRIPOLI: AN AUSTRIAN FORECAST. [To ma Enrros or

The Spectator

rim " Si.zcrwToE."] Sra,—It may at the present moment be of some interest to remember the statement of that very capable naval strategist, the late Commander Rudolf von...

NATIONAL HEALTH INSURANCE SCHEME. [To ma EDITOR or TEE "SPECTATOR. "]

The Spectator

Sns,—In your article of last week you state that not only is the advocacy of the National Insurance Bill by the Chancellor of the Exchequer immoral, but also that many of the...

Page 30

A GENUINE IRISH GRIEVANCE. (To no EDITOR OF TBE "

The Spectator

SPECTATOR." SIR,—Many of your readers may not be aware that the practice (illegal in England) of dishorning cattle with the saw is in Ireland allowed, or supposed to be...

PUGILISM.

The Spectator

[To ras EDITOR OF TIM " SPECTATOR.") Sin,—In your leader on "Pugilism and Colour" you speak as though a stand-up fight in the ring were no more objection- able than the dancing...

JOWETT AND MARK PATTISON. [To TEE EDITOIt OF TIM "

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.") SIR, —In Mr. Hollings's interesting letter about Jowett (Spectator, September 23rd) there is one point on which I cannot help differing from him. He speaks of...

Page 31

THE SERVANT IN ROMANCE.

The Spectator

[To TM EDITOR Or THE •' SPECTATOR. " ] Sts,—How comes it, pray, that the writer of an article headed " A Secret Service " in your issue of last Saturday can bring himself to say...

LINN2EUS AND THE LAPPS. [To THE EDITOR OP THE "SPECTATOR. " ]

The Spectator

Sin,—The Cambridge Professor of Botany in 1740-41 quoted his friend Linnaeus as having described the felicity of the Laplanders of 1732 in the terms given below. It would be...

A SECRET SERVICE.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR Or THE "SPECTATOR " ] SITC,—It appears to me that the writer of the interesting article in last week's Spectator on " A Secret Service " has missed one...

Page 32

PAINTERS AND MYOPIA.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR 07 THE "SPECTATOR. "] SIR,—From the internal evidence of their pictures it is clear that Turner, Constable, Millet, to quote the first names which occur to me,...

HOUSE-MARTINS.

The Spectator

[To TER EDITOR OP THE "SPECTATOR."] SIR,—During this summer several house-martins built under the eaves of our house. One fine morning we found three slightly fledged youngsters...

THE WORD "RAID" IN ITALIAN.

The Spectator

[To TEE EDITOR or THE "SPECTATOR.`] SIB,—Your correspondent A. Bnlwer seems to be highly amused because the Italians, borrowing the English word " ride," in a special sense,...

SWALLOWS AND MARTINS AND THEIR NEST BUILDING.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR!' _I is the general opinion, I believe, that swallows and martins in building their nests bring little lumps of mud in their mouths, which...

THE REFERENDUM LEAGUE: PRELIMINARY MANIFESTO.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR. "] SIR, —The Referendum League has been formed to promote the following aims :— (1) To obtain a means of ascertaining the real voice of the...

AUTUMN MIGRANTS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE "SPECTATOR. "] SIR, —I was much interested in your article on "Autumn Migrants " in the issue of September 23rd. May I, however, offer an alternative...

Page 33

AN ESSAY SOCIETY.

The Spectator

[To TEE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR.1 SIR, I should be very grateful for an opportunity of bringing to the notice of any of your readers to whom it may be of interest an essay...

WASPS.

The Spectator

[To TEE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.") SIR,—Apropos of the interesting letters concerning wasps in your issue of September 30th, I should very much like to know if it is a general...

BOOKS.

The Spectator

ROBERT LOUIS STEVENSON.* Climax is an influence which the critical faculty can scarcely analyse, for the infinite variety of its expression prevents us from defining it, and we...

POETRY.

The Spectator

THE SECOND OF SEPTEMBER, 1792. BESIDE the red portal, Axe-smitten, he fell : And I deemed him immortal, Immortal as Hell ! Where the slain, by the stone, Made a slippery...

NOTICE.—When "Correspondence" or Articles are signed with the writer's name

The Spectator

or initials, or with a pseudonym, or are marked "Communicated," the Editor must not necessarily be held to be in agreement with the views therein expressed or with the mode of...

Page 34

SIR EDWARD SEYMOUR'S REMINISCENCES.* THIS is a real sailor's book,

The Spectator

and therefore delightful. We often wished as we read that Sir Edward Seymour bad told us more ; he continually leaves his reader unsatisfied merely touching great affairs with,...

Page 35

CELTIC SURVIVALS.* Mn. GEORGE HENDERSON has followed up his valuable

The Spectator

work on the Norse influence in Celtic Scotland with a study of the survivals of primitive belief and custom among the Celts. He casts his net wide, for he includes Scotland,...

Page 36

THE TRIAL OF OUR FAITH.*

The Spectator

A VERY interesting seta of essays has justhesn.published. by Dr. Thomas Hodgkin, The Trial of our Faith. Seme of the papers are historical and some theological -or we should....

Page 37

JOHN CHURTON COLLINS4

The Spectator

THERE is plenty of good reading in this book. Mr. Collins kept a diary, and a clever man who does this and at the same time goes about a great deal and sees famous people must...

A GREAT RAILWAY ENTERPRISE.* Tars is an age of "

The Spectator

records " in things sportive and things serious ; such in the railway line the surveyors, engineers, and bridge builders of the Grand Trunk Pacific may fairly claire to have...

THE ROMANTIC PAST.*

The Spectator

THE English race is not likely to give up either its faith in the advance of civilization or the moral restraints which that faith involves. It is not likely to cease to believe...

Page 38

MAGAZINES.

The Spectator

WE deal in our leading columns with by far the most im- portant of the topical articles in the October Nineteenth Century—Mr. Edgar Crammond's masterly survey of the financial...

Page 40

NOVELS.

The Spectator

DAN RUSSEL THE FOX. "As a matter of fact," observes Ulick Adare to the heroine of Dan Russel the Fox, " there's no such thing in literature as a sporting novel. The two things...

Page 41

The Unknown God. By B. L. Putnam Weale. (Macmillan and

The Spectator

Co. 6e.)—Mr. Putnam Weale describes a Mission in China, and does not surprise us by giving it a very unlovely aspect. The head of the Mission has good• qualities, but is fatally...

The Rajah. By F. E. Penny. (Chatto and Windus. 6s.)—The

The Spectator

Rajah of Shivapet comes to England, and learns at Eton and Oxford English ways. He is called back to govern his native State, and takes with him as his secretary Ted Dersingham,...

SOME: BOOKS OF TIIE WEEK.

The Spectator

[Under this heading we notice such Books of the seek as have tot Leon reeerved for reties:in other forms.] The Eschatological Question in the Gospels. By Cyril W. Emmet, 'M.A....

In the "Revised Version for the use of Schools" (Cambridge

The Spectator

University Press) we have The Revelation of St. John the Divine, edited by G. H. S. Walpole (Is. 6d.). Bishop Walpole takes the date to be the last years of Dornitian, and the...

Beenertrac Novrate.—Crethia Charrington. By Mrs. G. de Horne Vaizey. (Cassell

The Spectator

and Co. 6B.)— A. good story, though the heroine does not interest us as much as does Beth, the lady of all work.— Lord Stranleigh, Philanthropist. By Robert Barr. (Ward, Lock...

Page 42

The History of Gruffydd ap Cynan: Welsh Text with Translation

The Spectator

and Notes. By Arthur Jones, M.A. (Manchester University Press. 6s. net.)—Gruffydd ap Cynan, whose name will not be found in some places where it might be expected, was King of...

The Naga Tribes of Manipur. By T. C. Hodson (Macmillan

The Spectator

and Co. 8s. 6d. net.)—Manipur is a region, some hundred and twenty miles from N. to S. and over eighty from E. to W., lying to the N.W. of Mandalay. Mr. Hodson knows the country...

Adam Mielciewits. the National Poet of Poland. By Monica M.

The Spectator

Gardner. (J. M. Dent and Sons. 10s. 6d. net.)—Poland seems not to have produced her national poet till she had ceased to be a nation. Adam Mickiewitz was born in 1790—three...

What Matters. By the author of "Honoria's Patchwork." (Chapman and

The Spectator

Hall. 6s.)—The author knows how to write an essay, and this knowledge stands high amongst literary achieve- ments. The first three chapters are on "Values," and have suggested...

(For Publications see page 560.)

The Spectator