4 NOVEMBER 1955, Page 34

WRITING FOR TELEVISION. By Arthur Swinson. (Black, 16s.) WRITING FOR

TELEVISION. By Sir Basil Bartlett. (Allen and Unwin, 9s. 6d.)

Ir must be unusual for two books with iden- tical titles to appear on the same publication date. In this case there need have been no confusion; Sir Basil Bartlett's book is mis- titled. It opens with the pronouncement that 'Basically, television is a by-product of the Theatre'—at first sight a ludicrous misconcep- tion, calculated to dispatch his book straight- way to the dustbin. But it turns out that he is not writing about TV in general; he is con- cerned only with TV plays. Why this is not stated in the title is obscure; plays, after all, represent only a small fraction of the TV writer's field. Mr. Swinson's book is of much more general interest. He deals not only with plays, but with features, talks and documen- taries; most of what he has to say is helpful. .

IVOR BRIEN