26 MAY 1883, page 22

The Academy, 1872-1882.*

WE should not review a pamphlet which embodies so many of - the opinions on Art which Mr. Quilter has expressed in the Spectator, did we not think that a criticism even of our......

Old And New Edinburgh.* This Is Not A Perfect Book,

for Mr. James Grant is by no means a perfect writer. Incessant production, for a generation, of novels of the "romantic" kind does not conduce to accuracy of thought or of......