7 SEPTEMBER 1872, page 18

A Hard Case!

[TO THE EDITOR OF TUE"SPECTATOR.'] Stn.—Your review on my volume of poems might be fair enough, if you had neither received my two first volumes or my pamphlet -on "Free-Will,"......

Dr. Macivor's "religious Progress." [to Thn Editor Of The...

SIR,—Let me thank you for a notice of my volume on "Religious. Progress" which I feel to be, on the whole, quite as favourable as it deserves. For, unlike others, your critic......