18 MAY 1985, Page 23

Unsparing

Sir: Colin Welch's remarks on punishment (Centrepiece, 4 May) recall a cartoon in the Spectator many years ago: Convicted prisoner: 'Your Honour, spare me. I am merely a product of my environment.'

Judge: `So am I. Hang him.'

W. S. Brownlie

Orchard Cottage, Law Brae, West Kilbride