16 SEPTEMBER 1949

Page 1

NEWS OF THE WEEK

The Spectator

I N the election of Professor Theodor Heuss as first President of the West German Republic the Bundestag and the representatives of the Lander, on whom the responsibility was...

Peace and Defence

The Spectator

It is in some sense a victory of realism over idealism that the first meeting, on Saturday, of the Defence Council created by the Atlantic Treaty should have to be rated as...

M. Queuille's Tour de Force

The Spectator

It is such a remarkable feat for any French Government to remain in office for a whole year, that to ask for evidence of its accomplish- ments, other than that of survival, is...

Page 2

More Palestine Plans

The Spectator

Another question designed to cause the United Nations Assembly anxious moments is, once more, Palestine, and that on two grounds. The conference which has so long been sitting...

The Disgusted Railwaymen

The Spectator

The word "disgusted " seems to be very fashionable among members of the National Union of Railwaymen. It appears in a fair number of the resolutions from district meetings which...

Enquiry on Hanging

The Spectator

Considerable weight must attach to the evidence given before the Royal Commission on Capital Punishment at the end of last week; consisting as it did of testimony by the Chief...

Albania's Offences

The Spectator

The attention of the world may before - long be called forcibly to the smallest of the Balkan States, and in some ways the worst conducted, Albania. Her behaviour in the matter...

Page 3

PROGRESS AT WASHINGTON

The Spectator

T HE words success and failure were always a little too crude to be applied to the results, prospective or actual, of the Washington talks on the dollar problem. It was never in...

Page 4

The return of Dr. Inge to the pulpit of St.

The Spectator

Paul's last Sunday was a matter of more than ordinary interest, and it is providential that representatives of the Evening Standard and the Daily Telegraph were included in the...

The news that Unesco (the United Nations Educational, Scientific and

The Spectator

Cultural Organisation) is wanting to increase its expenditure by a million dollars in the coming year is likely to meet with a chilly reception in this country—which would have...

It is a little too soon, no doubt, to conclude

The Spectator

that Ashridge- meaning by that not the institution's formal existence, but all that Ashridge has succeeded in being in the last three orfour years— is finished, but it looks...

* * Not everyone (certainly not I) realised that Cardinal

The Spectator

Manning was once a clerk in the Colonial Office. It was immediately after he came down from Balliol—in December, 1830—and he held the appointment for only two years. The present...

I am assured (by one who has submitted to the

The Spectator

operation) that at a certain London establishment you can have your hair cut by a man who once cut the hair of a man who fought at Trafalgar. Not

A SPECTATOR'S NOTEBOOK T HERE can be no doubt about the

The Spectator

success of the air show which ended at Farnborough on Sunday. It came just when British prestige needed a little tonic, and the tonic and its effects were unmistakable. The...

A headline offered me this week comes from Canada. I

The Spectator

accept no responsilaility for any apparent irreverence in it. That lies with whatever authorities chose to name one girls' school The College of Our Lady and another the College...

Page 6

EXPORTING TO THE U.S.A.

The Spectator

By GEORGE PENDLE I IS Majesty's Minister (Commercial) at Washington reported a few days ago: " The United States can produce enough in four hours' work to pay for everything...

Page 7

U.N.O. BALANCE SHEET

The Spectator

By GILBERT MURRAY, O.M. The Fourth Assembly of the United Nations opens next Tuesday. T HE United Nations has on the whole ibad press ; or at least a much worse press than it...

Page 8

PARADOX IN MALAYA

The Spectator

By DOROTHY CRISP W I IEN the " bandits " at present infesting Malaya are written up in a couple of lines in a history text-book, two great and unrecorded movements now...

Page 9

THE FOUNTAIN THAT GREW

The Spectator

By 0. F. KNUDSEN B OUT fifty years ago most of the citizens of Oslo were in raptures about a fountain which the up-and-coming Norwegian sculptor Gustav Vigeland was to erect...

Page 10

PILLS FOR GROUNDNUTS

The Spectator

By FRANK SYKES I N the report of the last oil-seeds mission to West Africa there was a strong recommendation that superphosphate in pellet form should be distributed to African...

Page 11

"et l e fivritator September 15, 1849 THE Queen and Prince Albert,

The Spectator

with their children, went on Thursday to Braemar, to witness a fate given by the Braemar Highland Society; at which there was a gathering of Highlanders in national costume, and...

Undergraduate Page

The Spectator

PRINCETON. REUNION By DAVID SYMON (Magdalen College, Oxford) T HE summer term was ending when we arrived at Princeton University. Haggard examinees were looking at the results...

Page 12

MARGINAL COMMENT

The Spectator

By HAROLD NICOLSON / N common with all those who believe that education, if it is to remain liberal, must be untainted by any social ideologies or party affiliations, I have...

Page 13

THE CINEMA

The Spectator

"The Hasty Heart." (Warner.)- 4, Dear Mr. Prohack." (New Gallery and Tivoli.)—" You Can't Sleep Here." (Odeon.)— " Le Secret de Mayerling." (Polytechnic.) THE talking film, we...

CONTEMPORARY ARTS

The Spectator

THE THEATRE. " Midsummer Day's Dream." By J. B. Priestley. (St. Martin's.) WHAT can best be described as a sturdy defeatism permeates Mr. Priestley's vision of England in...

MUSIC

The Spectator

IT has been a week of anniversary celebrations. The tercentenary of John Blow's birth was fittingly commemorated by the London Opera Club at Hampton Court with a performance of...

Page 14

RADIO

The Spectator

THE five programmes with which the B.B.C. is telling the story of the war seem to me to have been excellently designed ; and—to judge from the first two—are being carried out...

Matters of Opinion The week before, we had Prelude to

The Spectator

War, as the inaugural pro- gramme of the series ; and here was a harder job. War is a com- paratively simple matter ; diplomacy is tortuous—a matter of shades, doubts,...

Hoppers Also, as I spent some days in a Kent

The Spectator

village, I took a local enter- tainment in Hoppers' Holiday, where Londoners piped up briskly to the microphone from the hop-fields. This was in Hallo Children I which continues...

Controversy Revived I have much enjoyed the D. H. Lawrence

The Spectator

series on the Third Programme, if perhaps for the wrong reasons. It was agreeable, I mean, to be reminded by Mr. Stephen Potter's The D. H. Lawrence Myths of all that hubbub and...

The Pattern of the War This week we had a

The Spectator

revised version of Mr. Chester Wilmot's Battle for Britain, first heard in 1947, but now freshened and made more exact by more recently published documents. The facts of the...

Page 15

PAYMENTS IN HOSPITAL

The Spectator

Ste,—In his article on social service costs Sir Ronald Davison discusses a suggestion that a charge should be made for " hotel expenses" to reduce the cost of providing hospital...

LORD KEMSLEY AND DR. DIRKSEN

The Spectator

SIR,—Lord Kemsley was less than fair to Miss Wiskemann in his letter in the Spectator of September 2nd, where he denied his reported remark to Rosenberg without referring to the...

Sta,—Would Lord Kemsley be willing to tell us whether the

The Spectator

whole of the Dirksen Minute of August 2nd, 1939 (Dirksen Papers No. 23), to which I referred in my article, is incorrect, or whether any of it holds good ? It would be helpful...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

The Spectator

STRASBOURG REFLECTIONS Sta,—Now that the first meeting of the Consultative Assembly of the Council of Europe is over, it may be worth while to record one or two of the...

Page 16

MR. GUNTHER'S FACTS

The Spectator

SIR,—In her review of John Gunther's Behind the Iron Curtain, Elizabeth Wiskemann is critical of his chapter on Italy, on which country she herself, is an authority, but says of...

SEX AND THE SCHOOL

The Spectator

SIR, —It would be impossible to reply briefly to all the interesting points raised by Dr. Essex-Cater and Mr. Rigby in the Spectator of August 26th ; but I hope you will allow...

THOSE PROFESSORS Sin,—May I submit that in his letter to

The Spectator

the Editor, published in the Spectator of September 9th, Mr. A. M. Low entirely evaded the point at issue, and not very skilfully. Only his right to use the title of professor...

" UNDERGRADUATE SPATE"

The Spectator

Sra,—I have before me the plans of a group of 50 boys "graduating" in the class of 1949 of a well-known private (in England, public) school in New England. Qn graduation day the...

BUDAPEST FESTIVAL SIR, —In his article International Youth, Charles Pickthorn infers

The Spectator

that the National Union 4 Students was unaware, beforehand, of the political aspect of certain of tEe demonstrations which took place during the World Festival of Youth and...

SIR,—There is yet one more source of professors than those

The Spectator

mentioned so far in the letters you have had on this matter. I refer to the island of Jersey. When Victoria College was founded in 1865, the statutes provided for two...

Page 18

Danish Examples As I have just returned from Denmark, husbandry

The Spectator

is a subject difficult to avoid. One of the stronger political bodies consists largely of small farmers, and I doubt whether any country has a rural civilisation more pleasant...

COUNTRY LIFE

The Spectator

FOR once in a way the British Association was presided over by a farmer, so to call him ; and no one has a deeper knowledge, at least of the science and theory of farming, than...

Wasps and Hornets It is a very waspish year. Even

The Spectator

apples on the tree—at any rate on one F.11ison's Orange—have been reduced to the state of Chinese lanterns. One of my beehives was attacked by a commando of wasps, but they were...

AFRIKANERS

The Spectator

SIR,—Mr . Calpin's interesting article on the Khama-Williams marriage assumes that the world at large knows what an Afrikaner is. I feel sure I am only one of many who do not....

In the Garden Why does watering, from can or hose,

The Spectator

have less effect than rain ? The strange, unprecedented succession of droughts, or near-droughts, has ruined the potato and carrot harvest, dwarfed the Michaelmas daisies and...

The Bird Trust It is not necessary to belong to

The Spectator

any society in order to extract pleasure and knowledge from the observation of birds ; but the latest report of the excellently organised British Trust for Ornithology (with the...

THE SPECTATOR

The Spectator

SUBSCRIPTION RATES. Ordbutry Edition by post to any part of the world. 52 weeks fl 10s. Od. World-wide distribution by Air : " All Up" service to all countries in Europe...

" ANY OLD WORD "

The Spectator

Sts,—Apropos of the comments of " Janus " on the use or misuse of words. The advocates of the theory " any old word in any old sense" will find their views most aptly expressed...

Page 20

BOOKS OF THE DAY

The Spectator

Byron and the Guiccioli HERE is a fascinating book : I use the much abused word deliberately. Byron " fans " will tumble over each other to buy or borrow it ; and the common...

English Nonconformity

The Spectator

The Claims of the Free Churches. By Henry Townsend, D.D. (Hodder and Stoughton. 15s.) The Claims of the Free Churches. By Henry Townsend, D.D. (Hodder and Stoughton. 15s.) IN...

Page 22

The History of Science

The Spectator

The Origins of Modern Science, 1300-1600. By H. Butterfield. (Bell. 10s. 6d.) " THE first distemper of learning," said Bacon, " is when men study words and not matter." For...

Man of Ulster

The Spectator

Craigavon: Ulsterman. By St. John Ervine. (Allen and Unwin. 35s.) MR. ST. JOHN ERVINE has set out to do three things ; has succeeded brilliantly in two of them and failed in...

Page 24

European Balance, 1878-1914

The Spectator

The Coming of the First World War. By Nicholas Mansergh. (Long- mans, Green. 15s.) PROFESSOR MANSERGH'S book is sub-titled A Study in the European Balance, 1878-1914. According...

Lord Shaftesbury

The Spectator

Noble Lord: The Seventh Earl of Shaftesbury. By Barbara Black- burn. (Home and Van Thal. 15s.) To do this book full justice the reviewer should not have read the Hammonds'...

Page 26

A Great Tenor

The Spectator

John McCormack. By L. A. G. Strong. (Peter Nevill. 15s.) " LEONARD. D'ye know what's wrong with that book ye wrote about me ? " Yes, John.' So do I' His head and shoulder ,...

The Castles of England and Wales

The Spectator

Castles from the Air. With an Introduction and Notes by W. Douglas Simpson. (Country Life. 30s.) THIS book is both delightful and instructive. Aerial photography is particularly...

Page 28

Occupied Japan

The Spectator

Popcorn on the Ginza. An Informal Portrait of Post-War Japan. By Lucy Herndon Crockett. (Gollancz. 15s.) IN Manila about this time four years ago, with all his landing-craft...

Fiction

The Spectator

The Dark Peninsula. By Ernest Frost. (Lehmann. 9s. 6d.) SOME miscellaneous " don'ts," if I may, for novelists:— Don't be possessed by ideas, even by unspoken ideas. To adapt a...

Page 29

tt THE SPECTATOR" CROSSWORD No. 547 [A Book Token for

The Spectator

one guinea will be awarded to the sender of the first correct !Amnon of this week's crossword to be opened alter noon on Tuesday week. September 27th. Envelopes must be referred...

CROSSWORD No. 545 SOLUTION TO SOLUTION ON SEPTEMBER 30

The Spectator

Gardens, Edinburgh, 12. The winner of Crossword No. 545 is: Miss E. C. PATERSON, 42, Murrayfield

Page 30

FINANCE AND INVESTMENT

The Spectator

By CUSTOS INVESTORS' first reactions to the outcome of the Washington con- ference have been appropriately cautious. No hats have been thrown in the air and, apart from some...

Shorter Notice

The Spectator

Popular Art in the United States. By Erwin 0. Christensen. (King Penguin Books. 2s. 6d.) MR. CHRISTENSEN briefly discusses the various European origins of American popular art...