26 JANUARY 1907

Page 3

BOOKS.

The Spectator

TALLEYRAND.* Ow the crowded page of history, which records the names of those who held the fate of modern Europe in their bands, when France was torn by civil feuds and bound...

Ltterarp Ouppitmcnt.

The Spectator

LONDON JANUARY 26th, 1907.

Page 4

PROTECTIVE AND PREFERENTIAL IMPORT- DUTIES.* IN a closely reasoned volume

The Spectator

of one hundred and seventeen pages Mr. Pigon pursues with much industry some of the minor arguments on which the Protectionist cause continues to rely. The contest has been, and...

Page 5

THE PAPACY IN ITS MODERN VICTORIES AND DEFEATS.* Kara CLArrnrus's

The Spectator

assurance to Laertes at the Castle of Elsinore, "You cannot speak of reason to the Dane and lose your voice," has received modern confirmation by this historian's career. The...

Page 6

THE LIFE OF ISABELLA BIRD.*

The Spectator

"On to be beyond the pale once more, out of civilisatioU into savagery ! Anna, I abhor civilisation !!' So spoke Mra. Bishop at the age of sixty, when she had returned from one...

Page 7

CURRENT LITERATU RE.

The Spectator

MEDIAEVAL LONDON. Mediaeval London. By Sir Walter Besant. Vol. II., "Eoelesi- astiold. - (A. and C. Black. 30s. net.)—Though this volume is described as "Ecclesiastical,"...

Page 8

A HUNGARIAN ADVOCATE OF FREE-TRADE.

The Spectator

Students of economic questions would do well to direct their attention to the work of a distinguished Hungarian writer,— Hundert Jahre Zollpolitik, by Professor Louis Ling,...

THE SILVER AGE OF THE GREEK WORLD.

The Spectator

The Silver Age of the Greek World, By Professor Mabaffy. (T. Fisher llnwin. 13s. 6d. net.)—The anther of this volume had a great subject, but has hardly dealt with it in the...

Page 9

ARCTIC EXPLORATION.

The Spectator

Arctic Exploration. By J. Douglas Hoare. Illustrated. (Methuen and Co. 7s. 64. net.)—There are few more interesting stories than that of the gradual extension of our...

PAGAN RACES OF THE MALAY PENINSULA.

The Spectator

Pagan Races of the Malay Peninsula. By Walter William Skeet and Charles Otto Blagden. Illustrated. 2 vols. (Macmillan and Co. 42s. net.)—A rich body of material for the...

SOME REMINISCENCES OF WILLIAM MICHAEL ROSSETTI.

The Spectator

Some Reminiscences of William Michael Rossetti. With Portraits and Illustrations. 2 vols. (Brown, Langharn, and Co. £2 2s. net.)—Mr. William Rossetti has already written much on...

Page 10

AMERICAN FINANCE.

The Spectator

American Finance. Part I., "Domestic." By W. R. Lawson. (W. Blackwood and Sons. 6s. net.)—Though, as above indicated, we do not regard Mr. Lawson as a safe guide in matters...

CAROLINE OF BRUNSWICK.

The Spectator

Lane. 21s. net.)—Mutatis rautandis, we are inclined to say to 1dr. Chapman very much what we have said to Mr. Melville. The ecordid tragedy of the wife of George IV., the...

BANKING AND NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS.

The Spectator

Banking and Negotiable Instruments : a Manual of Practical Lau , . By Frank Tillyard, M.A. Second Edition, Revised and Enlarged. (A. and C. Black. 6s. net.)—The subject-matter...

BRITISH ECONOMICS.

The Spectator

British Economics. By W. R. Lawson. Second Edition, Revised. (W. Blackwood and Sons. Os. net.)—The author, in the preface to this second edition, complains that his work has...

Page 11

CAMBRIDGE FIFTEENTH-CENTURY FACSIMILES.

The Spectator

The Churl and the Bird. Translated from the French by John Lydgate. Printed by William Caxton about 1478.—A lytell treatyse of the horse, the sheep, and the glues. By John...

NOTABLE TRIALS.

The Spectator

Notable Trials Romances of the Law Courts. By R. Storry Deans, Barrister-at-Law. With Illustrations. (Cassell and Co. 6s.)—The craving of the public for stories of battle,...

COUNTRY COTTAGES, OLD AND NEW Old English Country Cottages. Edited

The Spectator

by Charles Holme. (Studio, Leicester Square, W.C. 5s. net.)—Country Cottages and Week End Homes, By J. H. Elder-Duncan. (Cassell and Co. 5s. net.)—These two volumes, both...

THE POULTRY INDUSTRY IN AMERICA.

The Spectator

Report on the Pouitry Industry in America. By Edward Brown. (National Poultry Organisation Society, 12 Hanover Square. Report on the Pouitry Industry in America. By Edward...

Page 12

THE TODAS.

The Spectator

The Tam. By W. H. R. Rivers, Fellow of St. John's College, Cambridge. (Macmillan and Co. Els. net.)—Mr. Rivers's learned book will remain the chief authority on the interesting...

SALMON-FISHING.

The Spectator

Salmon-Fishing. By W. Earl Hodgson. (A. and C. Black. 7s. 6d. net.)—Of books on fishing there is no end, and we desire none. Almost alone among the sports, it allows a man to...

SPORT AND TRAVEL IN EAST AFRICA.

The Spectator

Sport and Travel in Abyssinia and British East Africa. By Lord Hindlip. (T. Fisher Unwin. 21s. net.)—Lord Hindlip has had more sport and pioneering in strange places than...

THE OLD INNS OF OLD ENGLAND.

The Spectator

The Old Inns of Old England. By C. G. Harper. 2 vols. (Chapman and Hall. 42s. net.)—Mr. Harper's account of the inns of England is a poor book on a good subject. Though for some...

'11111 HISTORY AND ART OF THE EASTERN PROVINCES OF THE

The Spectator

ROMAN EMPIRE. Studies in the History and Art of the Eastern Provinces of the Boman Empire. Edited by W. Id, Ramsay, Professor of Humanity in the University of Aberdeen....

is of the highest, and the present edition of The

The Spectator

Birds brings out his best qualities. The play, we know, only obtained the second prize, being defeated by 'The Revellers" of Ameipsias. Nor is this, perhaps, strange, for the...

Page 13

CLASSICAL SCHOLARSHIP.

The Spectator

A History of Classical Scholarship. By Dr. Sandys. Vol. I. Second Edition. (Cambridge University Press. 10s. 6d. net.)— Thin admirable work was reviewed in these columns little...

TWENTY YEARS OF CONTINENTAL WORK AND TRAVEL

The Spectator

Twenty Years of Continental Work and Travel. By Bishop Wilkinson, D.D. (Longmans and Co. 10s. 6d. net.)—Bishop Wilkinson has for his diocese Northern and Central Europe,- i.e.,...

SAINT CATHERINE OF SIENA.

The Spectator

Saint Catherine of &Ma and her Times. By the Author of "Mademoiselle Mori." With 28 Illustrations. (Methuen and Co. 'Is. 6d. net.)—The fascination that clings round Catherine...

TOURAINE AND ITS STORY.

The Spectator

Touraine and its Story. By Anne Macdonell. With Coloured Illustrations by A. B. Atkinson. (P. M. Dent and Co. .51 la. net.)—Books dealing with Touraine and its bordering...

Page 14

Life and Adventure I3egond Jordan. By the Rev. G. Robinson

The Spectator

Lees, B.A., F.R.G.S. (Charles Kelly. 5s. net.)—Mr. Robinson Lees contributed to Syrian archaeology a valuable addition when he followed the course of the Roman road across the...

Religious Genius. By L. S. (Hodder and Stoughton. 6e.)— This

The Spectator

book is in reality a treatise upon the imMense difficulty of maintaining a proper equipoise between the spiritual and the practical in matters of religion. "L. S." considers...

Page 16

Lennox, Printed by Love Id MALCOKSON (Lilmited) at Nos. 4

The Spectator

and 5 Dean (Limited) at their Office. No, 1 Wellington Street, in the Precinct of the Street, Holborn, W.C.; and Published by Joss Boxes for the "SraCTATOS Savoy, Strand, in the...

Page 17

Yesterday was the day of the first ballots in the

The Spectator

German elections, and the results throughout the Empire will be known by to-morrow. The system is that only that candidate is elected by the first ballot who receives more than...

hi

The Spectator

NO. 4,100.] FOR THE REGISTERED AS • Pans 6e. WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, JANUARY 26, 1907. [ NEWSPAPER. Br Posr...61o. POSTAGE ABROAD lin.

NEWS OF THE • 'WEEK

The Spectator

• __„, _ • nplIE news from Kingston shows an improvement in the genetal situation. Slight shocks of earthquake continue, but though three thousand persons are still homeless,...

In , the absence of full particulars, as to what

The Spectator

actually occurred, we are not disposed to join in. the chorus of unqualified condemnation which has greeted the Governor's action; but the tone of his letter to Admiral Davis...

Prince Billow, repenting apparently his manifesto to General von Liebert,

The Spectator

delivered at a private meeting of the German " intellectuals " last Saturday , a revised statement of his creed. ; His speech was remarkable for, its profession of lofty...

The Spectator

e„. The.Editers cannot undertake to return Manuscript, in any case.

The Spectator

The most interesting contest will be in the capital, where

The Spectator

the electorate has largely increased. At the last Election five Socialists and one Radical were returned, but there is a strong chance of the Socialists now winning also in the...

Page 18

Under the heading of "The Demoralisation of a Greats City,"

The Spectator

the Times correspondent in San Francisco sends a remarkable account of the appalling growth and progress of municipal corruption in the capital of California since the...

It has always been M. Clemenceau's function to sum up

The Spectator

either in the Press or on the platform what he considers the tendencies of the moment. On Tuesday evening at the banquet of the Republican Committee of Commerce and Industry be...

The Conference of French Bishops has come to an end

The Spectator

without so far any good results. They have issued a reply to the Papal Encyclical which satisfies the Vatican, but is no more than a formal tribute. Apparently their delibera-...

The Government of the United States have instituted two actions

The Spectator

at San Francisco to test their rights as against the State of California, and to enforce the provisions of the Japanese Treaty. One is brought in the Supreme Court of the State...

A crisis has arisen in Hungary out of the persistent

The Spectator

attacks on the personal honour of M. Polonyi, the Minister of Justice. They began with the charges brought by M. Halmos, ex-Burgomaster of Buda-Pesth, against M. Polonyi, but...

On Tuesday the Japanese Premier, the Marquis Salmi, speaking in

The Spectator

the Diet, made an important declaration of policy. He began by expressing his great satisfaction with the English Alliance, which was growing in strength and solidity. Reis.'...

Last Sunday the primary elections for the Duma began in

The Spectator

St. Petersburg, in weather of exceptional severity. Last year, it will be, remembered, almo4 the whole Labour Party boycotted the elections, and the Constitutional Democrats had...

Page 19

The appointments of Mr. Birrell to the Irish Chief Secretary-

The Spectator

ship and of Mr. Reginald McKenna to the Board of Education were officially announced on Thursday. In the case of Mr. Birrell, the announcement merely confirmed an open secret,...

The Bishop of Hereford, whose sincere desire to promote a

The Spectator

settlement of the education question has been manifested both in and out of the House of Lords, propounds a scheme in Thursday's Times which deserves sympathetic consideration....

It was announced in Friday's Times that, "in view of

The Spectator

the dubious attitude of the Government towards Home-rule, and the probability that a large measure of Devolution will be introduced next Session," an organisation has been...

The Bishop recognises that it will seem hard to some

The Spectator

Churchmen that in what have hitherto been their own schools distinctive religious instruction should henceforth be relegated to out-of-school hours, but contends that that was...

The Report of the Royal Commission on Trinity College, Dublin,

The Spectator

was issued as a Blue-book on Monday. Of the con- clusions and recommendations of the Commissioners, the most important are the following :— That Trinity College has been and is...

On Friday week Mr. Birrell, addressing his constituents at Bristol,

The Spectator

dealt mainly with the House of Lords, a grievance which is being made the chief cry in the Derbyshire by- election, and which Mr. Bryce and Mr. Lloyd-George also turned their...

Bank Rate, 5 per cent., changed from 6 per cent.

The Spectator

Jan. 17th. Console (21) were on Friday 87—on Friday week 871. Bank Rate, 5 per cent., changed from 6 per cent. Jan. 17th. Console (21) were on Friday 87—on Friday week 871.

On Tuesday Mr. Root, the American Secretary of State, who

The Spectator

is visiting Canada as the guest of Lord Grey, made a notable speech at the Canadian Club at Ottawa before a large gathering of distinguished Canadians. He dealt mainly with the...

Page 20

THE IRISH UNIVERSITY PROBLEM.

The Spectator

T HE final Report of the Royal Commission on Trinity College, Dublin, is a document of great value in the way of furnishing the Government with a large collection of facts and...

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

BRITAIN AND THE UNITED STATES. T HE unfortunate misunderstanding which has arisen between Sir A. Swettenham, the Governor of Jamaica,- and Rear-Admiral Davis, of the United...

Page 21

A REAL "YELLOW PERIL."

The Spectator

- 11 - TE do not believe that the " tension " said to be V V existing between Japan and the United States will produce immediately any regrettable consequences. The Government...

Page 22

RATIONAL CHARITY.

The Spectator

T HERE are few words in the language more misused than charity. If it includes in its connotation many virtues, it also covereth a multitude of sins. Nothing is more delicate...

Page 23

THE EDALTI CASE AND THE HOME OFFICE.

The Spectator

F ORTUNATELY for innocent men, public opinion in this country is invariably aroused to a high pitch of interest whenever there is a suspicion that the wrong man has been...

Page 24

"NOSCITUR A SOCHS."

The Spectator

I F this were quite true, it would be a great deal easier than it is to read character aright. The wisdom of the ages concentrates itself into unqualified assertion, but the...

Page 25

' ABOUT DICTIONARIES.

The Spectator

W HAT is a dictionary ? The question is not one which it is easy to answer off-band. But we may safely say that a dictionary is a book of reference; it is not intended to be...

Page 26

THE OTHER SIDE OF FOG.

The Spectator

I N our at all times and seasons beloved sea estuary, widely open to the west, the appropriateness of the derivation of fog from fyge, a drift, is oftentimes made specially...

Page 27

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

THE STATE OF THE NAVY. [To Tat EDMOS OT TBK SPECTAT08:1 Six,—The letter from Professor Biles published in your last issue shows that be has studied most carefully my letters on...

Page 28

DEVOLUTION AND ROME-RULE.

The Spectator

[To Ts. EDITOR Or TEE SPECTATOR...1 SIE, — It was with the deepest regret that I read your article entitled as above in the Spectator of January 19th, although your notes to my...

Page 29

MR. BALFOUR AND THE UNIONIST PARTY.

The Spectator

Ito THE EDITOR OS TRH "Srscuroa.1 Sts,—The attitude of the Unionist Party towards the question of old-age pensions is likely to become one of such vital importance that I am...

ITO THE BETTOR OF TUE ° SPECTATOR:]

The Spectator

SIE,—Your article upon "Desolation and Home-Hale" in the Spectator of January 19th should be the means of enlightening your English readers upon the present situation in...

Page 30

SCHOLARSHIPS AT SCHOOLS AND UNIVERSITIES. (To THZ EDITOR OF THE

The Spectator

"SPECTATOR-1 Era, — It is to be hoped that the 'influential Committee of Tutors " which (as your correspondent Mr. Merchant in last week's Spectator tells us) is at present...

ITo THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR:1 • Sin,—Is not your

The Spectator

correspondent "H. W. S. " in the issue of January 12th taking a "Protectionist " view P Is it not best for the nation, nay, even for the world at large, that clever boys should...

THE CHANNEL TUNNEL.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE . SPECTATOR..] Stn,—The enclosed lines "from "The Gathered Poems of Ernest Myers" may be of interest to your readers in con- nexion with the proposed...

MILTON ON "FAME."

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE “SPEOTATOR:1 Szn,—An amusing instance of the slipperiness of familiar quotations occurs in a letter in your number of January 19th (p. 87). In my little...

Page 31

MU SI C.

The Spectator

THE MUSIC OF YESTERDAY AND TO-MORROW. THE correspondent of an evening paper, a propos, of the per. formances of German opera at Covent Garden, recently un- earthed an amusing...

TUSKS AND HORNS.

The Spectator

[To Tug EDITOR 07 TWA "SPNCTATOR..] SIR,—Allow me to correct a small error which occurred in the interesting article in the Spectator of January 5th entitled " Tusks and...

THE "SIX MONTHS' " TRAINING OF MILITIA RECRUITS.

The Spectator

[To THY EDITOR 07 THZ . SPEC7A708.1 S,—Last week I was most kindly permitted by the com- manding officer to observe the results of the "six months'" training of Militia recruits...

POETRY.

The Spectator

THE MASTER OF CHARTERHOUSE. IN MEMORIAM. (Switzerland, January 16th.) TEE sun that late lit up our snowy way Sinks, and a sudden chill is over alL The laughter dies. Yonder...

Page 33

BOOKS.

The Spectator

THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE GERMAN EMPIRE.* PIIFFENDOEF, after the Peace of Westphalia, comparing the Germany of his day with the league of Greek States led by Agamemnon against...

Page 34

NEWMAN, PASCAL, LOISY, AND THE CATHOLIC CHURCH.* THOSE who desire

The Spectator

to get 1 better understanding of the Liberal Roman Catholic position should read this book. Mr. Williams not only presses the claims of the Roman Church upon all who profess and...

Page 35

PITT'S CORRESPONDENCE WITH COLONIAL GOVERNORS.*

The Spectator

THE elder Pitt is so mysterious and fascinating a figure that we welcome any scrap of information which increases our knowledge of him. For he has suffered little indeed from...

Page 36

NOVELS.

The Spectator

THE EMPTY HOUSE.* THE art of writing ghost stories, if it cannot be called a lost art, is at least one in regard to which the present generation are hardly in a position to...

Page 37

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

[Under this lusting we =Bee much Books of the week as have net been reserved for review in other forms.] The Russian Government and the Massacres. By E. S6ranoff. (John Murray....

C URRENT LITE RAT URE.

The Spectator

THE QUARTERLIES. The most important article in the Edinburgh Review is a careful study of the, new problem which faces Lord Cromer in Egypt. Formerly the task of the British...

The Penniless Millionaire. By David Christie Murray. (John Long. 6s.)—Though

The Spectator

no story concerning the theft of a mysterious Eastern jewel can claim to be original, Mr. Christie Murray may be congratulated on the great diversity of thrills with which he...

The Fruit of the Tree. By Florence Teignmouth Shore and

The Spectator

William Teignmouth Shore. (Hutchinson and CO. 6s.)—Apart from the extremely conventional attitude of the heroine, Cynthia Keiglaley—which is necessary if we are to believe in...

Page 38

Cruise Across Europe. By Donald Maxwell. (John Lane. 10e. 6d.)—Mr.

The Spectator

Maxwell and the companion of his voyage did their best to confirm the opinion common on the Continent of an Englishman's mental condition. They took their little craft, the...

We have received from Messrs. Blaclde a number of 'Reading

The Spectator

Lone), (H.), Great Golfers lathe Mak,ng. S.o and prices. In the "School and ROMO Library" we have Mared the Unlucky, and other Tales, by Maria Edgeworth (is.)— the "other Tales"...

Willing's Press Guide, 1907. (125 Strand. le.)—This volume, the thirty-fourth

The Spectator

issue of the Guide, gives in its A.B.C. List of "Newspapers and Periodicals Issued in the United Kingdom" a catalogue reaching over two hundred and ten pages, and containing, on...

Late Babylonian Letters. By R. Campbell Thompson, MA. (Luz= and

The Spectator

Co. 15s. net.)—These letters, two hundred and forty- eight in number, belong to the latest period of the cuneiform script. The few that are dated refer us to the years 555-425...

Nzw EDITION8.—Bards of the Gael and Gall. By George Sigerson,

The Spectator

M.D. (T. Fisher Unwin. 68.)—This is a revised and enlarged edition of an interesting book. It givhs "Examples of the Poetic Literature of Erinn " in English translations in...

- Gravesend. By Alex. J. Philip. (J. A. C. Branffil.

The Spectator

la. net.)— This is one of the "Homeland Handbooks," and well worthy of the,excellent series to which it belongs. Mr. G. M. Arnold, who is Mayor of the borough, has contrihnted...