27 APRIL 2004

Page 6

A referendum on the proposed constitution for the European Union will

The Spectator

be held, the government conceded; the next argument was over the timing. 'Parliament should debate it in detail and decide upon it,' Mr Tony Blair, the Prime Minister, told the...

Page 7

It's about democracy

The Spectator

w intensity,' to use the words of Michael Howard, the Prime Minister ventured into the House of Commons on Tuesday to announce that he will, after all, allow a referendum on the...

Page 9

A s. lead a life of more or less untroubled serenity

The Spectator

and I am in perfect health (except for a slight cough), it was unsettling to learn that I had cancer and that it looked inoperable. It wasn't, thankfully, and a most delightful...

Page 10

Don't worry: the tabloid revolution' is not going to carry everything before it

The Spectator

I , is becoming a commonplace that the 'tabloid wars' between broadsheet titles are transforming the newspaper market. There is a widespread belief that in producing tabloid...

Page 11

T here is sadness for the eminent physicist Professor Stephen Hawking.

The Spectator

Troubled and bothered by many anxieties lately — not least a public family schism over allegations, which he denies, that he has suffered physical abuse — he has decided to give...

Page 12

The man who calls the shots

The Spectator

Peter °borne says that the Prime Minister is a client of Rupert Murdoch's global empire — and he decided to hold a referendum on the EU constitution only because the press...

Page 14

Only Bush can save Europe

The Spectator

Mark Steyn says that the US President's 'transformational' response to Muslim fundamentalism can save the Old World; European `managerialism' can't New Hampshire L ast July,...

Page 15

Ancient & modern

The Spectator

A personal catastrophe strikes, and the et) , goes up 'Why me?' and 'Not fair'. The ancients knew all about this, and the 5th-century BC Greek historian Herodotus supplies an...

Page 16

The cynicism of the defeatists

The Spectator

William Shawcross rebukes Andrew Gilligan and Rod Liddle for their reflections last week on the war in Iraq I suppose it seemed a jolly jape to sandwich Michael Gove's...

Page 20

Wronged by our rights

The Spectator

Theodore Dalrymple says that so-called human rights drive out kindness, decency, tolerance and all sense of mutual obligation p eople who stand on their rights are seldom much...

Page 22

Mind your language

The Spectator

'A light, pleasant, and digestible food,' says the Encyclopaedia Britannica (11th edition: the best). 'Come off it,' said my husband, and for once I agreed with him. The food...

Extremism in the defence of liberty

The Spectator

Paul Robinson says that some well-respected hawks are threatening civilisation by advocating terror tactics in the war on terror 1 C don't know what effect these men will have...

Page 24

Churchill for dummies

The Spectator

Winston S. Churchill is the hero of George W Bush and the neocons. But, says Michael Lind, they know very little about the great wartime leader. If they did, they'd be horrified...

Page 26

Passport to Eton?

The Spectator

Bruce Anderson says the Tories' revolutionary new education policy will devolve power to schools and parents n 1874, Disraeli told the House of Commons that 'Upon the education...

Oh, to be in England, now that April's there

The Spectator

EMMA TENNANT The annual miracle of spring is thrilling everywhere. It is especially beautiful in the Chilterns, where the Prime Minister has a country house courtesy of you and...

Page 28

Recipe for terror

The Spectator

Gerald Kaufman attacks Bush for supporting Ariel Sharon's 'disengagement' plan, which, he says, will inevitably result in more Israeli deaths 0 ne morning this week I got into...

Cry God for Harry, England, and Saint Alban!

The Spectator

GRAHAM CLAYDON This is the time of year when we stop complaining for a moment about the dreadful spring weather and start complaining about the neglect of England's patron...

Page 30

Signs of overheating in the last great stronghold of steam traction

The Spectator

C hina is the last great stronghold of steam traction, so it is suitably cast as the world's locomotive. We certainly need one. The Eurozone is stuck in a siding, while Japan...

Page 32

There is absolutely nothing natural about natural remedies

The Spectator

wo quick sprays to your tongue release the natural energy you need to find i nner calm again. Restoring your centre and focus,

even after you've reached the end of your tether. With

The Spectator

the natural formula created by Dr Bach, in a bottle sized to fit any handbag, Rescue Remedy is the calming exercise you can do any time, anywhere. Look for Rescue Remedy at...

Page 34

Iraqis like elections

The Spectator

From Adrian Weale Sir: Rod Liddle claims that you cannot create democracy in Iraq because 'there is no evidence that many people want it' (Things were better under Saddam', 17...

No appeaser

The Spectator

From Correlli Barnett Sir: Adopting a lofty moral stance that would do credit to the Reverend Blair himself. Michael Gove ('The deadly Mail', 17 April) denounces me and others...

No hard evidence

The Spectator

From Brendan O'Neill Sir: Ann Clwyd claims to have discovered further evidence that Saddam Hussein's regime used an 'industrial' shredding machine to execute prisoners (Letters,...

Page 35

We're no Zimbabwe

The Spectator

From Richard McNeill Sir: Much as I admire Andrew Kenny's writings, especially on the environment, I cannot agree with him that South Africa is on a slippery slope to Mugabedom...

Soldierly Somerset

The Spectator

From Andrew Roberts Sir: Although Byron Rogers is literally correct in stating that Lord Raglan 'had never even commanded a battalion in war' (Books, 17 April), it should not be...

No help from the French

The Spectator

From Sir Robin Dunn Sir: Taki writes (High life, 17 April) It was the British Expeditionary Force under Lord Gort, which first broke and ran while the French covered its...

Unfair to the Don

The Spectator

From Des Withal! Sir: Frank Keating (Sport, 17 April) insults the greatest of all cricketers when he pontificates that Lara has 'out-Bradmanned Bradman' — and I am an...

Moral courage

The Spectator

From Andrew Smith Sir: I have rarely read an article as moving as Charles Spencer's (Arts, 17 April). The graphic description of his mental agony as he fought off the demons...

Expert() credite . . .

The Spectator

From Harty , Mount Sir: I am very much looking forward to sitting last year's Oxford Classics exams which the Dean of Wadham, James Morwood, has kindly promised to send me (The...

Page 36

A hesitant sermon on the subject of pain

The Spectator

I have been thinking about pain, mainly because 1 have been experiencing so much of it recently. It is bone pain, arising from an accident some months ago when I broke my hip....

Page 37

I can't take the strain any more, so I am learning to drive

The Spectator

I , don't know how come the train companies lost me, but they have. And if they've lost me there can't be many people left still travelling by train. I can't drive, for a...

Page 39

Poets under surveillance

The Spectator

Anne Applebaum MOSCOW MEMOIRS by Emma Gerstein, translated by John Crowfoot Harrill, £25. pp. 512, ISBN 1860468837 lyv ithout a doubt, Moscow Memoirs is an extraordinary book,...

Page 40

A voracious collector

The Spectator

Jeremy Treglown JOHN FOWLES: A LIFE IN Two WORLDS by Eileen Warburton Cape, £25, pp. 510, ISBN 0229059513 4 he only novelist now writing in English whose works are likely T...

Page 42

Turning towards the light

The Spectator

Salley Vickers THE SPIRAL STAIRCASE by Karen Armstrong HarperCollins, £20, pp. 342, ISBN 0007122284 K aren Armstron g 's relationship to God has been a lon g and varied one. At...

Rock and soul

The Spectator

Matthew Spencer JOURNEY TO THE HOLY MOUNTAIN by Christopher Merrill HarperCollins, £17.99, pp. 346, ISBN 0007119011 1 f you were a poet returnin g from warrava g ed Yu g...

Page 43

A bungled case for the prosecution

The Spectator

Norman Stone THE BURNING TIGRIS: THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE by Peter Balakian Heinemann, £18.99, pp. 473, ISBN 0434008168 A s the Western world knows all too well, collapsing...

Page 44

Learning the ropes of freedom

The Spectator

Harry Mount THE STORY OF THE SEA, A MAN AND A SHIP by Adam Nicolson HatperCollins, £12.99, pp. 224, ISBN 0007180853 I 'm from the school that thinks boats are caravans on water...

Page 45

A hiding to nothing

The Spectator

Noble Frankland INSIDE HITLER'S BUNKER by Joachim Fest Macmillan, £16.99, pp. 190, ISBN 0405045906 T he story of Hitler's last days in his bunker has been told and retold many...

Page 46

The sight and sound of music

The Spectator

Rupert Christiansen CINEMA'S ILLUSIONS, OPERA'S ALLURE by David Schroeder Continuum, £17.99, pp. 384, ISBN 0826413927 T here have been five notable books on the relations...

Page 47

A tale of suspense

The Spectator

Byron Rogers THE HANGED MAN by Robert Bartlett Princeton University Press, £16.95, pp. 168, ISBN 06911117195 T his account of a public execution in Wales is a delightful book....

Page 48

Talk of the Tavern

The Spectator

Andrew Lambirth A SWEEPER-UP AFTER ARTISTS by Irving Sandler Thames & Hudson, £18.95, pp. 382, ISBN 0500238138 I picked up this book with high hopes. Professor Sandler,...

Page 49

A roving ambassador for culture

The Spectator

Peter Clark FOREIGN STRANDS: A BRITISH COUNCIL JOURNEY by Stephen Alexander Meffiotts Press, 174 Long Ashton Road, Bristol, BS41 9L T, tel: 01275 392347, .110, pp. 262, ISBN...

Page 50

Good Old Africa Hand

The Spectator

Aidan Hartley EVERY MEAL A BANQUET, EVERY NIGHT A HONEYMOON by Peter L. Younghusband Jonathan Ball Publishers, South African Rands, 139.95, pp. 347. ISBN 1868421678 p eter...

A failed kiss of life

The Spectator

Stephen Abell CHAUCER: BRIEF LIVES by Peter Ackroyd Chatto, £12.99, pp. 144, ISBN 0701169850 F or a writer or critic to describe somethin g as 'interestin g ' is, of course,...

Page 51

Outposts of the imagination

The Spectator

John de Falbe ISLANDS by Dan Sleigh Secker, f17.99, pp. 758, ISBN 043620620X T his novel, translated from the Afrikaans by Andre Brink, was offered to me for review with an...

Page 52

Winner of the glamorous granny award

The Spectator

Katie Grant THE SPACE BETWEEN by Rachel Billington Orion, £16.99, pp. 316, ISBN 0752846922 T hin, beautiful, flame-haired fortysomething widows make perfect light-reading...

Dark deeds

The Spectator

on the District Line Judith Flanders A METROPOLITAN MURDER by Lee Jackson Heinemann, f12.99, pp. 320, ISBN 0434012297 1 n 1863, the London underworld was revolutionised — not...

Page 53

Variations on Cleopatra's nose

The Spectator

Nicholas Harman WHAT MIGHT HAVE BEEN edited by Andrew Roberts Weidenfeld, £12.99, pp. 188, ISBN 0297848771 S ince much history is happenstance, what if the happenings had...

Page 55

Cultural glob alisation

The Spectator

Martin Gaylord is reminded why free trade in ideas is a Good Thing C hina is the future, or so many people say these days. Personally, I feel that I've heard that one before...

Page 56

Uninhibited expression

The Spectator

Andrew Lambirth Cy Twombly: Fifty Years of Works on Paper „Sopentine GalIvy, until 13 June A t , the Serpentine is a stupendous retropective of drawings and paintings on paper...

Page 58

A life in suitcases

The Spectator

Elisabeth Anderson A t the time of year when we may be planning a summer holiday, Peter Greenaway's installation of suitcases is perhaps an apt subject for the opening...

Page 60

Italian connection

The Spectator

Stuart Nicholson Njou might think the damp and overcast weather of recent weeks would dull Rome's lustre. It doesn't. You just see it in another way. The rainwater pouring down...

Cataclysmic sound

The Spectator

Michael Tanner The Dwarf; La Vida Breve Opera North, Leeds The Barber of Seville; The Marriage of Figaro Savoy Opera O pera North's season of 'Eight Little Greats' got off to...

Page 61

Comic-book spirit

The Spectator

Mark Steyn Kill Bill Volume 2 IS, selected cinemas Val Bill Volume 1 and Kill Bill Volume 2 ilwere filmed simultaneously and only cleaved in two late in the process. But it...

Page 62

The last taboo

The Spectator

Lloyd Evans The Goat Apollo AmaZonla Bridewell The Quare Fellow Tricycle E dward Albee's new play has a good, strong, taboo-busting storyline. Architect, goat, love affair....

Page 63

Spectacular U-turn

The Spectator

Michael Vestey "Today on Radio Four on Monday was / fortunate in having the meatiest domestic news item fall into its lap from the evening before: the briefing that the Prime...

Page 64

The right stuff

The Spectator

Simon Hoggart I t was good to really enjoy an Andrew Davies adaptation, for once. Too often you feel that our nation's most garlanded adapter is like some annoying Harry...

Time for dreaming

The Spectator

Robin Oakley T he supermarket availability of asparagus at Christmas and raspberries in February may have ruined the modern generation's sense of the seasons. But for racing...

Page 65

Aesthetic appeal

The Spectator

Daniel Hannan B ritish visitors sometimes encounter a certain frostiness when they take their seats in a bullring; the locals understandably assume that we are tourists come to...

Page 66

Loos woman

The Spectator

Taki New York D avid Beckham should use the Agnelli defence: a man can be unfaithful and a very good husband, just as one can be completely faithful but an awful consort....

Tummy trouble

The Spectator

Jeremy Clarke U nder 'large floral patterned chamber pot, used once, slightly damaged, £5 ono' I came across `Abmaster stomach exerciser, boxed, unwanted gift, £10.' I'd been...

Page 67

Bearded folly

The Spectator

Aidan Hartley I n Nairobi I bumped into a friend who was home from running a safari camp for anti-terrorism troops in Kabul, which is where I was headed myself. He wore a...

Page 68

Opportunity knocks

The Spectator

Petronella Wyatt T he Posh and Becks story makes a disgusting spectacle. Not because of the so-called wronged wife, but because of the behaviour of all the participants....

Page 70

SIMON HOGGART

The Spectator

F irst, an apology. Again. The Lay & Wheeler offer two months ago was so popular that Spectator readers cleaned out all the Chateau Musar available in the UK. Fresh supplies...

Page 71

if to north Wales for Easter, as per usual, and

The Spectator

so it's up the M1 and then the M6 and all the way it's 'Are we nearly there?' and 'I need the toilet' and 'I'm hungry' and I'm thirsty' and I'm bored' and 'I feel sick' and 'How...

Page 79

Munster will fight

The Spectator

FRANK KEATING 1 t is tricky to call the outcome of this weekend's European club rugby semi-finals. That both matches will thunderously reverberate is not in doubt, however. The...

Q. As a child I largely complied with my parents'

The Spectator

wishes and there was no question of baiting them ad infinitum as my own children do me. In my day there was still the fear of smacking but, needless to say, my own children, a...

Q. A tiny point of scruple. Charles Glass recently sent

The Spectator

me an email inviting me to attend a concert given by his friend Oliver Gilmour. I was one of about 30 people bidden to attend the event and the co-recipients' addresses were all...

Q. A distinguished journalist whom! have known for several years

The Spectator

has kindly used her influence to enable me to become a member of the Groucho Club. Is it now de rigueur for me to reward her for her creative efforts in proposing my...