15 APRIL 2000, page 43

Going Straight At It

A. N. Wilson MARCEL PROUST by William C. Carter Yale, £22.50, pp. 946 T oweringly great as Proust is, he is the most flawed of all the giants of literary his- tory. His first......

When I Am Old And Gay And Full Of Sleep

Penelope Fitzgerald RAVELSTEIN by Saul Bellow Viking £16.99, pp. 254 O ld age, on the whole, is not a time to be recommended, but very old novelists are allowed to write about......