11 OCTOBER 1919

Page 1

On Saturday last the morning papers contained much bluster from

The Spectator

the strikers' leaders and hints from other quarters that tho strike would spread. But the situation was much better than it looked. There were divided counsels in the strikers'...

%* The Editor cannot accept respOnsibility for any articles or

The Spectator

letters submitted to him, but when stamped and addressed envelopes are sent he will do his beet to return contributions in case of rejection.

One word more. We are glad to admit that, in

The Spectator

spite of the wild talk of some of the extremist writers and papers, the strikers showed good temper, and refrained, except in one or two cases, from any criminal acts. The...

With such a statement by the President of the N.U.R.

The Spectator

staring us in the face we should be simply misleading the public if we were to talk as if the strike were a pardonable dispute over wages involving no breach of contract, such...

The great bulk of the members of the Railway Unions,

The Spectator

as indeed of all the Unions in the country, are not revolutionaries, and would regard any such policy with hatred, ridicule, and con- tempt. Therefore an opportunity had to be...

Mr. Lloyd George again proposed a truce. The railwaymen were

The Spectator

to return to work for at least a week, so that the questions at issue might be debated calmly or referred to an arbitrator. If aftes five days the railwaymen's leaders felt...

The Trade Unions directly affected by the railwaymen's strike began

The Spectator

their efforts at mediation on Wednesday week, but after two days of negotiating they seemed to have failed. The Government insisted that the men should return to work before...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

W E describe below the course of the strike. Here we must. say a word of protest, however discordant or unpalatable it may seem It the moment, against the pleasant and easygoing...

To say that the men were not striking about wages

The Spectator

but were engaged in what in fact was revolutionary action is no hostile assertion of ours or of anybody else's. It is no attempted inter- pretation of obscure facts. We take...

Page 2

" We have made it clear," Mr. Lloyd George went

The Spectator

on to say, "that-the-nation means to,be master in its own house." In other words, Parliament and the Ministry responsible to Parliament will not abdicate in favour of Mr....

The military news from Russia is encouraging. General Denikin is

The Spectator

still advancing on a wide front from the Volga to the Polish frontier. Early this week he occupied Voronesh, on the Upper Don, some two hundred miles south of Moscow. His rapid...

President Wilson's serious illness occasioned grave misgivings early in the

The Spectator

week. Later reports are more favourable. The Senate has delayed •its decision in regard to the Peace Treaty, as the President is unable to attend to State affairs. Last week the...

When Sunday came, it was obvious that public opinion, even

The Spectator

among the strikers, insisted on a settlement. The Prime Minister's task was to devise a formula by which Mr. Cramp and Hr. Thomas, as the Chinese say, could " save face " with...

The Prime Minister insisted on the railwaymen returning to work

The Spectator

before the complex negotiations about the new standard rates of wages were resumed. He also made it a condition of the settlement that the railwaymen who broke their contracts...

Mr. Lloyd George, speaking at the Guildhall reception of Sir

The Spectator

Edmund Allenby on Tuesday, summed up the lessons of the strike and its failure. The conflict had shown, he said, that public opinionruled in this country. Trade Unions could not...

Italy has, after all, been the first of the Allies

The Spectator

to ratify the German Peace Treaty. The King of Italy ratified it by Royal decree on Tuesday. The French President is awaiting the Senate's approval of the Treaty, which was...

The Government last Saturday recognized the general desire of all

The Spectator

good citizens to help in preserving law and order by in- viting the Local Authorities to organize Citizen Guards, who would " act in co-operation with the police in the duty of...

The Trade Unionist mediators, seeing the trend of events, renewed

The Spectator

their efforts to bring the railwaymen's leaders to reason, lest the whole Trade Union movement should be compromised and the political Labour Party ruined. They consulted Mr....

Page 3

We regret to record the death of Mr. Alfred Deakin,

The Spectator

the dis- tinguished Australian orator and statesman. He was sixty- three. Mr. Deakin was a native of Victoria, and was by pro- fession a barrister and journalist. He entered the...

The question, Who invented the Tank I seems to be

The Spectator

as difficult to answer as the question, Who invented the steam engine ? Mr. Justice Sargent, presiding over the Royal Commission on Awards to Inventors, began on Monday to...

Something must be done in regard to the Home Rule

The Spectator

Act. It would be absurd to let that measure, for which no one now has a good word to say, come into operation by the mere lapse of time. Still, the case is not so urgent as the...

Field-Marshal Sir Edmund Allenby received the freedom of the City

The Spectator

on Tuesday and was presented with a sword of honour. The conqueror of Palestine made a highly interesting speech, in which he recalled the fine work of the Sixtieth (London)...

In reply to the Allies' demand that the German troops

The Spectator

should evacuate the Baltic Provinces forthwith, the German Govern- ment declared that the troops would not obey their orders to return. General von der Goltz had been...

Many correspondents have asked us for further details of the

The Spectator

Pia) de Terre cottage that is being built at Newlands Corner by Mr. Clough Williams-Ellis. We have therefore arranged to reproduce a plan aad elevation of the cottage, of six...

We are told by the Times that a Cabinet Committee

The Spectator

has been appointed to draft a new Home Rule Bill. Mr. Fisher is to preside ; Mr. Long and Mr. Shortt, Lord French and Mr. Macpherson, are to help him. The Bill is to be capable...

The Norwegian Referendum on the drink question has given a

The Spectator

majority for Prohibition. According to the Times, 385,000 electors voted for Prohibition and 275,000 against it. The proposal, we understand, refers only to the sale of spirits,...

Bank rate,5 per cent., changed lroin 5k per cent.April 5,1917.

The Spectator

The political situation in Russia is still obscure. But it

The Spectator

looks as if Germany had decided to desert the Bolsheviks, whose armies and supply organizations owe such efficiency as they possess to German officers. Tho formation of a West...

Page 4

THE RIGHT TO STRIKE.

The Spectator

A MATTER of vital importance raised by the events of the past fortnight must receive public con- sideration—the limits of the right to strike. We desire to say at once that we...

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

THE STRIKE. T HE strike is over, and over in the best possible way. Here is a settlement w'aich does not maintain the profits of any individuals or give any set of capitalists...

Page 5

A LESSON OF HISTORY.

The Spectator

III. — THE REFERENDUM. M ANY are the lessons to be derived from the strike of last week viewed not only alone but in the light of history. But undoubtedly, the clearest and...

Page 6

THE PRESIDENT'S ILLNESS.

The Spectator

W E are very sorry to read the disquieting bulletins about President Wilson's illness. His collapse in the middle of a very long and strenuous speech-making tour in the West was...

Page 7

RED CROSS WOMEN.

The Spectator

S IR ARTHUR STANLEY, the Chairman of the Joint War Committee of the Red Cross and the Order of St. John, has done notable service throughout the war. His organization of the two...

Page 8

THE EXPECTATION OF SURPRISE.

The Spectator

0 one is ever dull now. Life is lively index' to those who live, as we all live, in the constant expectation of surprise. Like all vivid sensations, this expectation is wearing,...

Page 9

to Germany as " still a monarchy, albeit without a

The Spectator

monarch," or " a republic without republicans." I wish now to show how much justification there is for considering her in this light. Berlin is not Germany, and there are...

Page 10

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

[Letters of the length of one of our leading paragraphs are often more read, and therefore more effective, than those which fill treble the space.] NATIONALIZATION AND THE...

Page 11

(To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.")

The Spectator

fka.—That the obvious often escapes attention was made very clear to me during some electioneering work among candidates at the last General Election, and this must be the...

Pro THE EDITOR or THE " SPECTATOR."]

The Spectator

SIR,—/laving had seventeen years' practical experience in dealing with Liquor Trade problems, I have come by degrees to the conclusion that State Purchase of the whole business...

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.")

The Spectator

Snt,—As a constant reader of your valuable paper I have been much interested in the recent letters and articles on State Purchase of the Liquor Trade. Some years ago Sir Thomas...

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " Gnomon."] Sts,—Owing to the

The Spectator

railway strike your issue of September 27th has only just reached me. The name of Mr. J. H. Thomas, M.P., is given considerable prominence therein, and I am reminded that this...

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.")

The Spectator

Sut,—Having followed with much interest the articles and correspondence on the above subject, I shall be glad of the privilege of adding a little thereto. In his letter in last...

Page 12

CAPITAL AND LABOUR.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF ens " SPECIaTini."1 SIR,—I have for a long time past considered that many of the strikes and misunderstandings between Labour and Capital might be avoided, and...

THE PLACE OF UNSKILLED LABOUR.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] Sia,—In the summary of his policy which was published on August 22nd the Prime Minieter included "adequate provision for and satisfactory...

A MIDDLE-CLASS FACTORY.

The Spectator

CTo THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR, Why could not the middle classes give Labour an example of what may be accomplished by the organization of industry on the wisest and...

THE INDUSTRIAL CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIP.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR,—The present industrial crisis is causing anxiety, suffering, and alarm throughout the country : one can think of nothing but the...

TRADE UNIONS AND THE EX-SERVICE MAN. [To THE EDITOR OF

The Spectator

THE " SPECTAT0112] Sin,—May I again refer to the fierce onslaught by the extremist bosses of the Tiede Unions on the ex-Service men, both Army and Navy ? In my recent letter,...

Page 13

THE UKRAINE AND FOREIGN INTERFERENCE. [To THE EDITOR OE THE

The Spectator

" SPECTATOR."] SIR,—With reference to the interesting and enlightened, article "A Lesson from History" in your issue of August 30th, I beg to state that all new States, sprung...

PROTECTION FOR THE MOTOR TRADE.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.") SIR,—I agree with you that Sir A. Geddes was justified in refusing to prohibit the import of foreign cars, although it must be remembered...

THE RIGHT OF THE COMMUNITY TO EXIST.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] have read with very much interest your article on " The Right of the Community to Exist" in the Spectator of August 30th, and regret that I...

THE CITY CHURCHES.

The Spectator

[To me EDITOR 07 THE " SPECTATOR."I SIR,—The recent reopening by the Bishop of London of the church of St. Edmund King and Martyr after its restoration from the damage caused by...

Page 14

THE EUROPEAN ASSOCIATION AND INDIAN REFORM. (To THE EDITOR OF

The Spectator

THE " SPECTATOR.") Sm,—It will., shortly be the business of all interested in India to judge the recommendations of the Joint Committee of the Commons and the Lords on the...

THE LATE SIR JOHN KENNAWAY.

The Spectator

(To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR.") Set,—I have just read with very great interest and pleasure the letter under the heading signed " One of His Friends " in your issue of...

Page 15

THE R.A.M.C. AND " RED CROSS MEN." [To ism ED/TOR

The Spectator

or Ens " SPECTATOR."] Sus—In your issue of August 30th you have published a letter from "Non-Combatant Soldier " which I cannot allow to pass without criticism. It leads a...

A. SCOTTISH ENABLING BILL.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR Or THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR,—You had the courtesy to print a letter from me on this subject (in the Spectator of August 23rd), and I respectfully claim the right of...

SIXPENCE THE HALF-POUND.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or THE " SPECTATOR.") &a,—Ever since I came 'to Canada thirty years ago the Spectator has been regularly forwarded to me (and handed on —and on—for miles and...

Page 16

POETRY.

The Spectator

THE SONG OF THE PEEBLES PEDLAR. As I cam' doon the water-side I heard the water on the stanes (I saw the brichtly-coloured stanes) But nocht heard I o' kelpies' manes, Nor...

INFANT PSYCHOLOGY.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR."] Sre.,—As your correspondent Mrs. Reid appears to be one of those rare souls who are keenly interested in, and thirst for information about,...

BOOKS.

The Spectator

SOPHIA DE FRANQUEVILLE.* IT is a commonplace of criticism that the best biographies are not written by members of the family. But there are bright exceptions to the rule. Anna...

MARATHAS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE " SPECTATOR."] SIR, —Surely there is one error in General Pilcher's fascinating Pathan story, " In the Andaman Islands," in the Spectator of August 9th. He...

NO _ TICE.—When " Carresixnklenci" or 41.rtieles ate. signal with'rise writer's .

The Spectator

name or peeudvnynt, or are •-• marked " Communicated," the Editor must not necessarily be held to be in agreement with the views therein expressed or with the mode of...

ght S5pErtator

The Spectator

We suggest that there can be no better Present in Peace or War than an Annual Subscription to the Spectator. He or she who gives the Spectator as a present will give a weekly...

Page 17

SPITSBERGEN.*

The Spectator

RUDMOSE. BROWN, Who has been associated with Dr„ W. S. Bruce in his scientific exploration of Spitsbergen, has written an interesting and useful book on that-country....

Page 18

lab CENTAUR'S MANUAL.* CONSIDERING that a genuine i love of

The Spectator

horses is the Englishman's national heritage, it is extraordinary how little, apart from stable management, in which this country admittedly leads the world, the average Briton...

Page 19

EDWARD WYNDHAM TENNANT.* Ltnr GLENCONNER'S memoir of her son, with

The Spectator

his letters and poems and some good portraits, is dedicated to all mothers— and they are many—who have suffered the same loss. It is not a sad book, save in retrospect. The...

Page 20

ON ALPINE HEIGHTS AND BRITISH CRAGS.*

The Spectator

Mn. G. D. ABRAHAM is now a popular lecturer and writer on mountaineering. He has long been known as a bold and skilful climber and a first-rate photographer. His " three-legged,...

THE FUTURE OF MEDICINE.*

The Spectator

IN this volume the author once more puts forward his views on the progress of medicine, explains the reasons for the faith that is in him, and demonstrates, chiefly from his...

Page 21

MR. MILNE'S PLAYS.*

The Spectator

Aurnons are proverbially bad judges of the relative merits of their own work ; they see in their books not So much what is there as what they tried to put there, and they value...

Page 22

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

fir/dim in this column does not necessarily preclude subsequent review.] The National Review for October contains Mr. W. M. Aeworth's valuable address to the British Association...

FICTION.

The Spectator

SONIA MARRIED.* To describe the carnival of extravagance and luxury indulged in by fashionables, decedents, smart intellectuals, and intriguing politicians before the war is...

Page 23

The Royal Engineers' Journal for October (Hugh Rees, Is. 6d.)

The Spectator

contains a well-illustrated article on the bridging operations carried out during the war. It gives the layman some idea of the vast and complex problems which have to he faced...

Escaping from Germany. By Edward Page. (Melrose. 4s. 6d. net.)'—Mr.

The Spectator

Page, a private in the reserve of the Royal Marine Light Infantry, was called, up when the war began, and sent to Dunkirk - in September, 1914, and thence to Antwerp. He was...

We have received the first number of the Jewish Guardian,

The Spectator

a new weekly which " has been founded in order to provide the Jews of Great Britain and the Empire with an organ of their own." The paper is " tied neither to any Zionist...

Hydro-Electric Survey of India : Preliminary Report. By the late

The Spectator

G. T. Barlow and J. W. Meares. (Calcutta : Superin- tendent Government Printing. 4a. 9d.)—The war gave a great stimulus to industry in India, and, as cheap power is essential to...

The Teaching of the Qur'an. By the Rev. H. U.

The Spectator

W. Stanton. (S.P.C.K. 75. net.)—This is a compact handbook to the theology of the Koran with an introductory chapter on its origin. The book consists of 114 distinct...

The hundred and fifteenth Report of the British and Foreign

The Spectator

Bale Society (Is.) as usual contains much curious and interesting information. It is significant of the rapid growth of Chinese immigration into Malaya that more Chinese than...

In the Prison City : Brussels, 1914-1918. By J. H.

The Spectator

Twells. (Melrose. 5s. net.)—Miss Twells, an American, lived in Brussels through the war. Her description of her experiences under German rule is worth reading. It speaks well...

Bolingbroke and Walpole. By J. M. Robertson. (T. Fisher Unwin.

The Spectator

12s. 6d. net.)—This essay in political biography is very readable, but Ms unduly controversial in tone. Mr. Robert. son takes a keener interest in arguing with his predecessors,...

Self's World's Press, 1919. Edited by E. T. Brown. (Sells.

The Spectator

10s. 6d. net.)—The thirty-fifth edition of this familiar and valuable book of reference contains, we are told, over 32,000 entries. A hundred new journals have been started...

Page 24

A Geographical Dictionary of Milton. By Allan H. Gilbert. (New

The Spectator

Haven : Yale University Press. London : H. Milford. 15s. net.)—Readers of Milton will find this scholarly book useful and interesting. The author gives, as far as possible, a...

A Corner Stoneof Reconstruction. By Four Chaplains to the Forces.

The Spectator

(S.P.C.K. 3s. Cal. net.)—This is a manly, wholesome, and practical little book on working for social purity among men. The authors have addressed thousands of men in camp, and...

The Limburg Manoeuvre of August, 1911. By Captain " Candid."

The Spectator

(Utrecht : A. W. Bruna.)—This pamphlet contains a good account, by a Dutch Army officer, of the concentration A the German armies on the frontier in August, 1914, and of the...

St. George and the Dragons : a Comedy in Three

The Spectator

Acts. By Eden Phillpotts. (Duckworth. 2s. fid.)—At first it seems as though Mr. Phillpotts's aim is to insist on the old rule that it is .unwise to marry out of one's class, but...