25 JUNE 1910

Page 1

The Regency Bill was read a second time in the

The Spectator

House of Commons on Tuesday. Mr. Swift MacNeill contended that the Bill was unnecessary on the ground that the power of the Crown was vested in the bands of Ministers, and that...

In the House of Commons on Wednesday the Chancellor of

The Spectator

the Exchequer stated that the salaries—each £3,000—of the heads of the new Road Board and Development Board were higher than the average because the posts were temporary. A....

A question was asked in Parliament on Wednesday by Mr.

The Spectator

Keir Hardie as to the seizure in India. under the new Press Act of Mr. Mackarness's pamphlet upon Indian Police methods. According to Mr. Keir Hardie, the pamphlet, only fifty...

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

O F foreign affairs there is not much to report this week. The Cretan question still hangs in the balance, but it looks as if before it is finally settled some sharp action...

The passage through the American House of Repre-

The Spectator

• sentatives of the Enabling Act for Arizona and New Mexico, both acquired from Mexico after the war by the Treaty of 1818 and the Gadsden purchase in 1853, raises the number '...

Mr. Roosevelt landed at New York on Saturday last, and

The Spectator

even hostile critics admit that no American ever met with such a reception. In reply to an address from the Mayor of New York, Mr. Roosevelt struck a true note when he said that...

. * * IF The Editors cannot undertake to return Manuscript, in

The Spectator

any ease.

The Spectator

Page 2

The by-election in the Hartlepool division caused by the unseating

The Spectator

of Sir Christopher Furness took place on Monday. The result of the polling was the return of the Liberal, Mr. S. W. Furness, with 6,159 votes against the 5,993 of Mr. W. H....

before the close of the Session for a full debate

The Spectator

and division on the second reading of the Woman Franchise Bill :- "In view of the exigencies of other Parliamentary business, and their own announced decision not to prosecute...

The Surrey Veterans' Parade, which took place on the Horse

The Spectator

Guards' Parade last Saturday, showed that we hare in the trained men with whom the War Office have hitherto failed to keep in touch a military asset of no small import- ance....

What the suffragists will of course do when they obtain

The Spectator

their magnificent division will be to declare that the opinion of the House is so overwhelmingly in favour of the Bill that the Government must revise their decision and go...

The splendid physique of the men was the cause of

The Spectator

universal comment and admiration, for they were only veterans in service to their country, not in years. The majority were indeed in the prime of life, the average age being...

A remarkable proof of the spirit inspiring the men was

The Spectator

conveyed by a voice from the ranks. The Secretary of State for War in the course of a speech which showed plainly how completely and thoroughly he had realised the full meaning...

The Birthday Honours were announced on Friday morning. Seven new

The Spectator

peerages are created, all Barons,—Mr. Richard Knight Canton, Sir Walter Foster, Sir Hudson Kearley, Sir Weetman Pearson, Sir William Henry Holland, Sir Christopher Furness, and...

The King's eldest son, the Duke of Cornwall, wits on

The Spectator

Thursday created Prince of Wales in the old picturesque formula of the letters patent. In offering our congratula. tions to one who, unless he greatly belies his appearance and...

Those who were connected with the raising of the Surrey

The Spectator

Veteran Reserve were well aware of the fine sense of public duty and patriotism which inspired the men. These knew perfectly well that no material advantage of any kind could...

Page 3

On Friday week the inaugural meeting of the Constitutional Free-Trade

The Spectator

Association was held and an address delivered by its president, Lord Cromer. He began by explaining the origin of the Association, which existed in order " to show the leaders...

Under the beading "An Experiment that Failed," the Times special

The Spectator

correspondent in Egypt gives a survey of the period of unrest which culminated in the murder of Boutros Pasha. Lord Cromer, as he reminds us, had already initiated the...

The World Missionary Conference at Edinburgh, briefly noticed in our

The Spectator

last issue, was concluded on Thursday. Attended by twelve hundred delegates and two hundred missionaries, the Conference has been a triumph of organisation. Each day the Session...

The best practical use to make of the Veteran Reserves

The Spectator

when they are formed throughout England, Scotland, and Ireland still remains over for decision. We have our own opinion, but we will only say here that what impressed the...

The exigencies of time and place made it impossible for

The Spectator

the men to go through any evolutions. All that was possible was to form the fourteen companies into which the Veterans were divided into three sides of a hollow square,—a...

Though the murder of Boutros Pasha precipitated the abandonment of

The Spectator

this disastrous experiment in coeciliation, the British Government, in the opinion of the Times corre- spondent, failed lamentably to recognise the true moral of that crime and...

Mr. Marmaduke Pickthall has a good letter in Monday's Westminster

The Spectator

Gazette on the British occupation of Egypt in reply to a characteristic explosion from Mr. Wilfrid Blunt. Mr. Blunt had rashly asserted that there was no difference whatever...

We cannot find space to summarise Mr. Haldane's speech, or

The Spectator

the admirable address of the Adjutant-General, whom we desire to congratulate on his appointment as Inspector of the Oversee Forces of the Crown. We may note, however, that Sir...

The Spectator

Page 4

TOPICS OF THE DAY.

The Spectator

GENERAL SLANDERS AND HOW TO MEET THEM. T HERE is a very sound rule that no man, high or low, should ever answer, or even deny, a general accusation brought against his...

Page 5

THE SPIRIT OF COMPROMISE. T HE meeting of the Conference on

The Spectator

the Constitutional question is valuable not only for the definite agreement which possibly it may secure, but also for the demonstra- tion it gives of the value of the spirit of...

Page 6

THE OPPOSITION TO A RELIGIOUS CENSUS.

The Spectator

I N an age of statistics it is strange that objections should still be taken to the discovery and tabulation of a large and important group of facts. Fresh devices are...

Page 7

THE SURREY VETERANS' PARADE "S EEING is believing." There is no

The Spectator

truer proverb than this when the British people are in question. For ten years we have bombarded our readers with constant, we had almost said weekly, articles on the folly of a...

Page 8

A JEWISH CONCEPTION OF CHRIST, T HE Jewett Lectures for 1910

The Spectator

were delivered by Mr. C. G. Montefiore. They deal with " The Religions Teaching of Jesus," and have just been republished in book form (Mac- millan and Co., 2s. 6d. net). Mr....

Page 10

HOSPITALITY.

The Spectator

W ORKING-CLASS women are by nature extremely hospitable, but the narrowness of their houses and the supreme claims of husband and children often prevent them from gratifying the...

Page 11

ILLUSION.

The Spectator

F IVE roads lie round about the mines on the hilltop, but none of them leads in amongst the quarries themselves. High green hedges enclose the wheel-tracks all their red length,...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.

The Spectator

JOHN STUART MILL AND SOCIALIS1L [To rim Eorros or TIM " sracmrca.1 SIR,—In last week's Spectator Mr. Tillett draws attention to a paragraph in my introduction to "The Letters...

Page 12

THE CRYSTAL PALACE AS A MEMORIAL TO KING EDWARD.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF TER " SPECTATOR:I Srit,—In the course of an interview with a representative of the Pal/ Man Gazette, reported in a recent issue of that journal, Sir Melvin....

THE CARE OF THE FEEBLE-MINDED.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR or Tax "SrEcrAron."] Sin e —There can be little doubt that the cause of this un- fortunate class of the community will be much helped by your influential support....

Tar: EDUCATION SETTLEMENT COMMITTEE'S SCREAM.

The Spectator

[To TER EDITOR OF THY " SPECTATOR. ° 1 Sra,—The proposed scheme raises a large question which, in the old Puritan phrase, lies very near the root of the matter. Doubtless the...

Page 13

THE ADMINISTRATION OF MISSIONARY FUNDS AND SOCIETIES.

The Spectator

pro me EDITOR Of vas "SrEortmal Sin, — In your issue of the 18th inst. Sir Henry Burdett claims that the uniform system of accounts such as prevails in the management of...

Page 14

THE BOOK OF GENESIS.

The Spectator

[TO THL EDITOR OP THE "SPECTATOR. "] SIR,—In your review of "' Genesis,' by John Skinner, D.D." (Spectator, June 11th) it is stated that the water reached fifteen cubits above...

[To THE EDITOR OP THE "SrxcrixoR.1 Sin,—Mr. Poynter produces a

The Spectator

series of facts regarding the Church in mediaeval days which in his opinion (Spectator, June 4th) prove that Church to have been the Roman Catholic Church. With all deference, I...

THE BIBLE ANNIVERSARY.

The Spectator

[To TER EDITOR OF TEE " SPECTATOR.") SIR,—Writing of the three hundredth anniversary of the publication of the Authorised Version of the Bible in 1911, a correspondent suggests...

THE DAYLIGHT SAVING BILL.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR. "] SIR,—I learn that several Government Departments are now among those who have adopted a daylight saving scheme for themselves without...

THE ANCIENT ROMAN CHURCH IN ENGLAND [To THE EDITOR. Or

The Spectator

TER " SPECTATOR."] SIR, — Perhaps we should do well to recognise that Mait- land's work on Canon Law has shattered such theories of Anglican continuity as were based on Stubbs,...

Page 15

THE " STAR " AT YORK.

The Spectator

[To Tim EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR. "] Sin,—In reference to your correspondent " Yorkist " and your puzzle about the Star, I may inform you that the " York " Star is a small...

THUNDER AND LIGHTNING.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR 07 THE " SFECTATOR...1 Sra,—Experts, no doubt, will give scientific and reasoned answers to the two questions arising out of " A. F. P.'s " letter in last week's...

THE SHOREDITCH ASSESSMENT CASE. [To TER EDITOR 07 TILE "

The Spectator

SPECTATOR. "] Sin i —Very wide-reaching results are likely to follow the judgment in the Shoreditch assessment case. The Court of King's Bench has held that in the case of the...

A CORRECTION.

The Spectator

[To TER EDITOR OE THE " SPECTATOR. "] SIR,—I have read your article of last week on the East Dorse: election with interest, but I do not think you know both sides of the...

THE ANTI-FEUDAL SCREW.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THI "SPECTLTOR.1 Sin, — I note in the Daily Chronicle of Friday, the 17th inst., that the Gladstone League is to be amalgamated with the People's League, and...

A "DAILY NEWS" ADVERTISEMENT.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR. " ] SIR,—In the Spectator of June 18th Mr. A. W. Douglas quotes from the Christian World of "a few years ago" an advertisement which he...

Page 16

[To TEE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR:1 SIR, —A few years

The Spectator

ago a man was killed by lightning in a small but or refuge on the bank of the Isis here, a little below Folly Bridge, the lightning hreaking the window, attracted by a brass...

RIFLE-SHOOTING FOR BOYS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR.") BIR,—It may interest your correspondent " E. G. M." (Spectator, May 21st) to hear that aiming with both eyes open is not uncommon in the...

THE SURREY VETERANS' PARADE.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OP THE "SPECTATOR.") SIR, —A propos of paragraph 32 of the official notice of the Veteran Reserve, I think the following incident is typical of the general...

[To THE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR.") SIR, —It may he

The Spectator

true that, as you say, " the want of anything which can be called clear and accurate knowledge in regard to lightning makes it impossible to answer" your question about...

ROADSIDE ADVERTISEMENTS.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OP THE " SPECTATOR") Sin,—In these latter days when everybody who is anybody is also a motorist, casting dust and disdain on everybody else, I fear that one who...

NATIONAL LEAGUE FOR PHYSICAL EDUCATION.

The Spectator

[TO THE EDITOR OP THE "SrEcTATox."1 SIR, —May I call attention to the matinee which will be held next Friday on behalf of the National League for Physical Education P Mr....

Page 17

THE WOMEN'S HOLIDAY FUND.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SPECTATOR."] Srn,—Your readers have been so generous in their response to the appeal you have more than once allowed me to make in the Spectator for the...

POETRY.

The Spectator

THE WANDERER. MY heart is homeless as the wind And dark as Northern waters are, More desolate than midnight pools That never held a star. Yet, like the uncompanioned sun That...

LANDOR'S NAME AND ANCESTORS.

The Spectator

[To THE EDITOR OF THE "SrscrATon."1 -Sra,—One of the statements I made in a letter printed in the ,Spectator of April 30th seems to require correction. Having often heard a...

ALPINES AND NATIONAL SERVICE.

The Spectator

ITo THE EDITOR OT THE " SPECTATOR. " ] you be so very kind as to let the public know that I am a large grower of alpines ? This year, my seeds from Miss Wilmott and M. Carrevon...

NOTICE.—When Articles or "Correspondence" are signed with the writer's name

The Spectator

or initials, or with a pseudonym, or are marked "Communicated," the Editor must not necessarily be held to be in agreement with the views therein expressed or with the mode of...

Page 18

BOOKS.

The Spectator

MR: GLADSTONE'S -RELIGIOUS' - CORRESPOND ENCE.* Mn. GLADSTONE was so conspicuously a great Churchman as well aei a great Statesman that it is only right that this side of his...

Page 19

• • WALTER PATER.*

The Spectator

• SoMe and PKrple: with other Poems. By 'William Watson. London: • The Works of Walter Pater. 10 vols. New Edition. London Macmillan IT is more than fifteen years since Walter...

SABLE AND PITRPLE.*

The Spectator

Evelei g h Nash. 122. 6d. not.] and co.. net per vol.) THIS slim volume, which takes its name from the memorial verses written by Mr. William Watson on the death of King Edward,...

Page 20

WILLIAM BECKFORD.* THE figure of William Beckford would probably be

The Spectator

more satisfactory as the hero of a novel than of a biography. In the world of romance we might be prepared to let him pass with no harsher criticism than that he seemed "a...

Page 21

CHRISTOLOGIES ANCIENT AND MODERN.*

The Spectator

IT is of great service to a thinker to be able to precipitate and clarify his thoughts in the shape of lectures as be goes on his way; but we are not so sure that the lectures...

Page 22

NOVELS.

The Spectator

COUNTRY NEIGHBOURS.* Miss ALICE BROWN is not the first American writer who has endeavoured faithfully to record the charities and graces of rural life in New England. But...

nib, WAR OF SECESSION, 1861-1862.*

The Spectator

Tars book forms number eleven of "The Special Campaign Series," and describes the first part of the American Civil War,—a war about which probably more has been written than any...

PRE-BABYLONIAN HISTORY4

The Spectator

THIS is the first volume of a work in which it is proposed to tell the story of Babylonia and Assyria from prehistoric times down to the Persian Conquest. The regions of Sumer...

Page 23

SOME BOOKS OF THE WEEK.

The Spectator

[Under this heading we noose such Books •f the weak as has. not bests maenad for mins in other forms.] The Epistle to the Galatians. By A. Lukyn Williams, B.D. "The Cambridge...

READABLE NOVELS.--The Duplicate Death. By A. A. Fox Davies. (John

The Spectator

Long. 6s.)—A melodramatic detective story, in which the long arm of coincidence is made to extend very far indeed.— Margaret the Peacemaker. By Walter Wood. (Cassell and Co....

Red Tape. By Austin Philips. (Smith, Elder, and Co. 6s.)—Mr.

The Spectator

Austin Philips gives us in Red Tape a series of stories all founded on life in the Post Office. The little sketches are entertaining, and incidentally throw a good deal of light...

Old Testament Institutions. By the Rev. U. Z. Rule. (S.P.C.K.

The Spectator

5s.)—Mr. Rule is a conservative in Biblical criticism, but ho is ready to make concessions. He holds that Moses wrote part of the Pentateuch, but ho allows that it embodies...

My Work in London. By Arthur W. Jephson. (Sir Isaac

The Spectator

Pitman and Sons. 3s. 6cL net.)—Mr. Jephson is very much in earnest, and sometimes, as is the way with such persons, loses his head a little. Here is an example of a charitable "...

Daisy's Aunt. By E. F. Benson. (T. Nelson and Sons.

The Spectator

2s. net.) —This is the story of an outrageous experiment tried by " Daisy's Aunt," who is fairly young and extremely beautiful, in order to prevent Daisy from contracting a...

Page 24

We gladly record the appearance for the second year of

The Spectator

the Territorial Year Boob (Hodder and Stoughton, Is. net). It contains, among a great variety of information, details showing the growth of the Territorial system. These have a...

Memoir of George Henry Sumner, D.D. (Warren and Son, Win-

The Spectator

chester. 5s. net.)—This is rather a chronicle than a history. It gives us the record of a very busy life, of work with occasional intermissions of holiday,—Dr. Sumner's holidays...

El Conde de Gondomar. By F. H. Lyon. (B. H.

The Spectator

Blackwell, Oxford. 2s. 6d. net.)—Diego de Sarmiento, who was created Conde de Gondo- mar in 1617, acted as Ambassador for Spain at the English Court from 1613 to 1622, and Mr....

Maw Enneozrs.—The Epistle of St. James. Edited by Joseph B.

The Spectator

Mayor, Litt.D. (Macmillan and Co. 14s. net.)—The Dictionary of English History. By Sidney Low and F. S. Pulling. Revised. (Cassell and Co. 9s. net.)—Chapters from the History of...

PUBLICATIONS OF Tab WEEK.

The Spectator

Ashdown (Mrs. C. H.), British Costume during 19 Centuries, 8vo (Jack) net 12/6 Ball (W.) and Varley (T.), Winchester Painted and Described (Black) net 7/6 Barker (A. F.),...

Page 36

Lemnos r Printed by L. Urcorr Gat at the London

The Spectator

and County Printing Works, Drury Lane, W.C. ; and Published by Joan Bsxxa for the "Szeicrsvoz" (Limited) at their Office, No. 1 Wellington Street, in the Precinct of the Savoy,...

Page 37

SPECIAL LITERARY SUPPLEMENT

The Spectator

TO 1/tic *prctator FOR THE No. 4,278.] WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, JUNE 25, 1910. [L , R=TA F B O Ro AD } GRATI S.

Page 39

BOOKS.

The Spectator

THE ROMAN CAMPAGNA.* IT has been suggested that the first settlers on the site of Rome were attracted to the place by its freedom from the volcanic agencies which disturbed the...

Literarp Ouppknitnt.

The Spectator

LONDON : .TUNE 25th, 1910.

Page 40

THE FEDERAL SYSTEM OF POLITICAL ECONOMY.*

The Spectator

AN interesting issue is raised by the sub-title of Mr. Hillier's book, The Commonweal. It assumes that there is a political economy for a State, or a federation of States, as...

Page 41

DAYS IN COURT.* THOUGH it is now a century and

The Spectator

a quarter since our American cousins severed the "last link" which bound them to the Old Country, two ties, impalpable yet indestructible, unite the great Republic of the West...

Page 42

FLOWERS AND THEIR LEGENDS.*

The Spectator

THE authors of The Book of Flowers tell us in their intro- duction that they have made it for their own pleasure, and that being the best way of all of making a book, it is no...

LIGHT COME, LIGHT GO.*

The Spectator

Mn. NEVILL has produced an entertaining, if rather discur- sive, book on a subject which exercises a perennial fascination over the minds of men. There are some fortunate...

Page 43

THE ENGLISH SPOKEN IN IRELAND.* Da. JOYCE'S literary vitality is

The Spectator

as remarkable as his literary versatility. Sixty years ago he was contributing Irish folk- songs and notes on Irish dances to Dr. Petrie's Ancient Music of Ireland. In his spare...

Page 45

1.1-11/ COURT OF WILLIAM III.'

The Spectator

Tun book may be recommended as a wholesome alterative after the surfeit of political reading from which most of us are suffering just now. The remedy is, it is true, of the...

Page 46

HOUSES AND HOMES.* THERE was certainly room for a practical

The Spectator

book dealing with the art of building a house, looked at from the point of view of an architect's client rather than of the architect. It is doubtless true that architects...

A BATHCHAIRMAN'S AUTOBIOGRAPHY.* MR. H. G. WELLS has written about

The Spectator

so many men and things, and has imagined so many heroes for his stories, that when he proclaims that he has met a hero and a genius in real life, we must naturally feel...

Page 47

• CURRENT LITERATURE.

The Spectator

THE RECTOR'S BOOK OF CLAYWORTH, NOTTS. The Rector's Book of Clayworth, Notts. Transcribed and Edited by Harry Gill and Everard L. Guilford, M.A. (H. B. Saxton, Nottingham. 10.....

THE MAKING OF A KING.t THE name of Miss L

The Spectator

A. Taylor is a guarantee of thoughtful, conscientious work on the historical subjects with which she occupies herself. Her new book will be found by many readers particularly...

A TRANSLATION OF CLERY'S JOURNAL* WHEN a King is a

The Spectator

hero to his valet, it generally follows that the valet himself possesses heroic qualities; and if Louis XVL was a. man whose sincere patriotism, courage, and Christian...

Page 48

The Life and Times of Hildebrand (Gregory VII.) By the

The Spectator

Right Rev. A. H. Mathew, D.D. (Francis Griffiths. 12s. 6d. net.)— Hildebrand was chosen Pope in a somewhat irregular fashion turaultuarie. He was officiating as Archdeacon at...

EIGHT FRIENDS OF THE GREAT.

The Spectator

Eight Friends of the Great. By W. P. Courtney. (Constable and Co. 6s. net.)—The gleanings from the field of biography which Mr. Courtney has collected here are not without...

NAVAL WARS IN THE BALTIC.

The Spectator

Naval Wars in the Baltic. By R. C. Anderson. (C. Gilbert Wood. 15s.)—Few students of history, it is probable, quite realise how stubborn and how frequent was the fighting which...

OXFORD FROM WITHIN.

The Spectator

Oxford from Within. By Hugh de Selincourt. (Chatto and Windus. 7s. 6d. net.)—We cannot say that this book helps us much to understand the inwardness of Oxford life, past and...

LABRADOR.

The Spectator

Labrador. By W. G. Gosling. (Alston Rivers. 21s. net.)—We are glad that Mr. Gosling felt himself constrained to abandon his first idea of dealing with Labrador in a few chapters...

Page 49

THE EMPRESS EUGENIE.

The Spectator

The Empress Eugenic. By Edward Legge. (Harper and Brothers. 7s. 6d. net.)—The sub-title of the book is this : " Her Majesty's life since the terrible year,' together with the...

THE CONQUEST OF NEW SPAIN.

The Spectator

The Conquest of New Spain. By Bernal Diaz del Castillo. Translated by A. P. Mandalay, M.A. Vol. U. (Haklnyt Society.) —This narrative includes the march to Mexico, the stay in...

FOUR SONS.

The Spectator

Four Sans. By A. H. Gilkes. (G. A. Synnot, Dulwich Village.) The time of the tale is the second half of what we have been accustomed to call the fourth century B.C., but Mr....

GARDENING BOOKS.

The Spectator

The stream of books on gardening does not cease. In Rock and Water Gardens : their Making and Planting (Country Life, 6e. net) Mr. E. T. Cook edits a series of articles...

TRAILING AND CAMPING IN ALASKA.

The Spectator

Trailing and Camping in Alaska. By A. M. Powell. (Hurst and Blackett. 7s. 6d. net.)—Mr. Powell's " hot-pot " of trailing adventures—he describes in this book not one but many...

THE WYE.

The Spectator

The Wye. Painted by Sutton Palmer. Described by A. G. Bradley. (A. and C. Black. 7s. 6d. net.)—A capital book on a fine subject, a subject only too rich in matter. It is...

MEMORIALS OF OLD YORKSHIRE.

The Spectator

Memorials of Old Yorkshire. Edited by T. M. Fallow, M.A. (G. Allen and Sons. 15s. net.)—This volume is well up to the high standard of the excellent series to which it belongs....

CRETE, THE FORERUNNER OF GREECE.

The Spectator

Crete, the Forerunner of Greece. By C. H. and H. Boyd Hawes (Harper and Brothers. 2s. 6d. net.)—Both Mr. and Mrs. Hawes have done work in the field of Cretan discovery,—the...

Page 50

TURNING POINTS IN THE PRIMIT11 , L CHURCH.

The Spectator

Turning Points in the Primitive Church. By the Rev. W. S. Hooton. (C. J. Thynne. 3s.)—This volume contains essays on important passages in the Book of the Acts, the term "...