7 NOVEMBER 1931

Page 1

Such a development should be welcomed. The Opposi- tion could

The Spectator

never become strong enough numerically to cause the Government the smallest anxiety even if every Liberal in the House crossed the floor—which it is certain that the majority of...

News of the Week M R. LLOYD GEORGE, convalescent and combative

The Spectator

at Churt, has written to what he pointedly describes as " a section only of the Liberal members elected to this Parliament "—the Samuel group— declining any office to which the...

EDITORIAL AND PUBLISHING OFFICES : 99 Gower Street, London, 11'.C:1.

The Spectator

—A Subscription to the SPECTATOR costa Thirty Shillings per annum, including postage, to any part of the world. The SPECTATOR is registered as a Newspaper. The Postage on this...

The Rise in Wheat One of the most important pieces

The Spectator

of news the papers have had to record in the past week is the rise in the price of wheat. The 50 cents and less a bushel that was threatening Middle-West farmers with ruin not...

Page 2

The Future of India The fate of the Round Table

The Spectator

Conference will pretty certainly be decided in the course of the next few days. The Prime Minister has talked with Mr. Gandhi, Sir Taj Bahadur Sapru and others, ,the Cabinet is...

The East African Native • The long-discussed plans for closer

The Spectator

union in East Africa have come, not indeed to nothing, but to a good deal less than the Hilton Young Committee of three , years ago re- commended. The Select' Joint Committee...

All this means a certain progress, but all of it

The Spectator

is relatively meaningless while the communal question remains unsettled. That problem will have to be faced, perhaps for the last time, at the Minorities Sub-Committee's next...

Sir Austen's Renunciation Nothing in Sir• Austen Chamberlain's kale and

The Spectator

dis- tinguished Ministerial career has ever become him like his renunciation of it. The letters in which he abandons in favour of younger men any claim he may have to a...

The Sino-Japanese Conflict The Manchurian- situation is still extremely disquieting.

The Spectator

The Japanese claim to have withdrawn some of their troops from Kirin,- but they have moved considerable detachments into other areas of- Manchuria, ostensibly to guard railways...

M. Laval's Intentions- Whatever' undertakings - M. Laval gave or received

The Spectator

at Washington; he has lost no time in fulfilling his intention of taking up the whole question of Franco-German relations, particularly in their financial aspect. On the urgency...

Page 3

An Architect's Slum Crusade We are glad to note that

The Spectator

Dr. Raymond Unwin pressed the question of slum clearance in his presidential address to the Royal Institute of British Architects. He did not hesitate, in that august assembly,...

Empire Films The true Imperialism will -be fostered by the

The Spectator

fine collection of films with which the Empire Marketing Board is seeking to promote a fuller knowledge of the Dominions and Colonies that send -us .much. of our food and raw...

Mr. A. J. Cook Mr. Arthur Cook can only be

The Spectator

adequately characterized through a flagrant mixture of metaphors. He was a firebrand who was steadily mellowing. Trained like so many Labour leaders, particularly of the last...

Flying Youth If Miss Salaman is really " the nineteen-year-old

The Spectator

debutante " the papers unanimously declare her to be (her mother, who calls her twenty-one, must be mis- informed), she might almost be described without dis- respect as the...

Bank Rate 6 per cent., changed from 48 per cent.

The Spectator

on September 21st, 1931. War Loan (5 per cent.) was on Wednesday 968x.d. ; on Wednesday week, 98fx.d.; a year ago, 102-A x.d. Funding Loan (4 per cent.) was on Wednesday 861 ;...

The Spanish Civil Service " Axed " The new Spanish

The Spectator

Premier, Senor Azana, justified his reputation for boldness by decreeing last week that the personnel of the over Service should be reduced by half. O ffi cials of over twenty...

The Thorburn Mystery The Thorburn case, unsatisfactory from start to

The Spectator

finish, has ended a little better than it began. According to the stories current in this country, .a young Shanghai Englishman, seized by Chinese soldiers near the city, was...

Page 4

India The Immediate Task

The Spectator

N OW that the National Government has been returned to power, the Prime Minister will be able to turn his attention to the greatest external task which confronts the nation—a...

Page 5

The Cabinet's First Duty

The Spectator

T ILE personnel of the new Cabinet, which has not been announced as these words are being written, is a matter of obvious importance, but of much less importance than the spirit...

Page 6

The Future of the Labour Party

The Spectator

BY THE RIGHT HON. H. B. LEES-SMITH. [Mr. Lees-Smith held Cabinet rank as President of the Board of Education in the late Labour Government and was among the Ministers who...

A Note on Cyprus N O one will complain that the

The Spectator

sentences on the instig- ators of the disorders in Cyprus have been marked by any undue severity. Whatever grounds the Cypriotes may consider they have for protesting against...

Page 7

Problems of the Christian Conscience

The Spectator

[We publish below the fifth article of a new Theological Series, which we hope will throw light on some of the most disputed questions of conduct. Miss Fry is well known for her...

Page 8

Music for Children

The Spectator

By ROBERT MAYER. -p ROBABLY very few of us who are out of our tevis hold particularly cherished memories of the musical experiences of our youth, which are more often than not...

Page 9

The Kashmir Troubles *

The Spectator

T HE announcement that Mr. Bertrand Glancy, of the Indian Political Service, has been appointed, with the consent of the Government of India, by the Maha- rajah of Kashmir, a...

Page 10

Art

The Spectator

Arts and Crafts Exhibition EVERY working artist knows how necessary it is to stand back, from time to time, and regard his work—lest the general be lost in the particular. One...

Page 11

Gramophone Notes

The Spectator

New Records DuaiNo the past season various types of audience have paid homage to three distinguished visitors, a German tenor, a Spanish dancer and a Spanish mezzo-soprano. Not...

Poetry

The Spectator

Harvest Festival " WE thank Thee now," they heartily repeat For sun and moon and cabbages and wheat." And no one in the congregation sees The heavenly wood for local...

A Hundred Years Ago

The Spectator

THE " SPECTATOR," NOVEMBER Eth, 1831. • NEWS OF THE WEEK. The great city of Bristol, since our last publication, has been t . ho scene of a series of disturbances unparalleled...

The Hill

The Spectator

IN the heather-dips on either side The fallen winds persist ; The big grey bird with the long neb Wheels and cries in the mist ; The moorland river tumbles down With its...

Page 12

A curiously close parallel to the story of the lark

The Spectator

that sought refuge from a hawk between a yachtsman's feet is told me by a friend who is also a singularly accomplished naturalist. He says: "I remember—now, alas ! over forty...

A DAINTY MIDGE.

The Spectator

A curious discovery, of real importance to a small and picturesque native industry, has been made and extended in a more palpable sphere of biology and botany. The best species...

THE FRIEND'S ENEMY.

The Spectator

In all this branch of science the dangers of interference with the balance of nature are realized, and precautions are taken. For example, an insect that eats the young shoots...

Country Life

The Spectator

THE OSLO BREAKFAST. From the household of a distinguished Scandinavian, who owns an English farm, comes a letter suggesting that Norway at any rate is reaching the consummation...

Field experiments have been made, and are being continued under

The Spectator

scientific control, in a number of counties.; and maps have been made out showing the steady expansion of districts. where lucerne will now grow, though it would not in the...

The discoveries go deep into pure science, and at the

The Spectator

same time that in particular details they concern practical pro- duction. This is wonderfully illustrated in the continuing experiments with lucerne or alfalfa the most...

THE NEW AGRICULTURE.

The Spectator

It is a liberal education—or, should I say ?—a National Government education to spend a day or half a day at Rothamsted, that world-famous agricultural station which is as new...

So much for applied science, but the matter does not

The Spectator

end here. Science never leaves Well alone, for it seeks the Better, and, if it may be, the Best. . A scientific station cannot do commercial work. As in the case of Adco, that...

Page 13

FREE TRADE v. PROTECTION

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] STR,—Mr. James II. Weager's sneer that those who favour tariffs do so solely from self-interest cannot but suggest to those who differ from him...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—I was shocked to

The Spectator

see the Spectator omitting the funda- mental cause of the downfall of (not Labour, but) the official Labour Party at the General Election : it was the moral issue. Here was a...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—The one outstanding fact emerging from the recent Polling, is the practical disfranchisement of a large proportion of the nation. While the total Opposition poll is about...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—The true and inner

The Spectator

reason for the signal triumph of the National Government is that, at long last, the electorate has had the almost unique opportunity of voting on a national and non-party issue....

AFTER THE GENERAL ELECTION [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—That the vast Conservative majority does not fairly represent the proportion of votes given to the Conservative Party goes without saying. But would the strength of the...

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

[In view of the length of many of the letters which we receive, we would remind correspondents that we often cannot give space for long letters and that short ones are generally...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR. —Your attitude to the

The Spectator

result of the General Election makes some, at any rate, of your readers rub their eyes in astonishment. You say in your News of the Week columns, under the paragraph headed "...

Page 14

INDIA

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—We much admire your invariable fairness, as exemplified in publishing the letter of Sir Ion Hamilton Benn. May I crave the same indulgence...

ADVICE FROM CANADA

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—News comes to-day of the great majority gained by the Conservatives in the elections, and one must express the hope that they will not,...

" ON THE VERY EDGE OF BANKRUPTCY'.'

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Replying to Mr. Armstrong you give three justifications of the phrase " on the very edge of bankruptcy " as applied to the nation. First...

SPENDING AND SAVING

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—From the moral aspect, I fully agree with Mr. Harold Cox's arguments ; from the economic aspect I feel constrained to express doubt of...

Page 15

MARRIAGE AND SEX [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Dr.

The Spectator

Williams' article in your current issue is good reading, which is more, as it seems to me, than can be said for what the Rev. S. A. MeDowall wrote. Mr. McDowall's conclusions...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—There may be a

The Spectator

good deal to be said for Mr. Yeats- Brown's idea that every European town should be called " by the title its natives have given it." If that were done, however, towns in the...

THE NEED FOR SPIRITUAL RENEWAL [To the Editor of the

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Your correspondent N. A., in your issue of October 31st, must claim the sympathy of many in his aspiration for a spiritual renewal of the national life ; but he...

POLITE GEOGRAPHY [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —Your correspondent

The Spectator

would have all European place- names pronounced and written as in the country of their origin (though he excepts two countries on the ground of special difficulty). But why...

THE "SPECTATOR" AND THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE [To the Editor of

The Spectator

the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—It is a shock to find from your note to Mr. E. C. Owen's letter that you accept with pride the description " protagonist of Free Trade." May I submit that...

A CUT IN EPISCOPAL INCOMES [To the Editor of the

The Spectator

SPECTATOR.] Sia,—Cuts, voluntary or imposed, have lately been made in many kinds of income—in the incomes of the King and the royal family, of Cabinet Ministers, of judges, of...

Page 16

ENGLISH HOTELS

The Spectator

[ To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sia,—One reads with interest the article by Sir W. Beach Thomas in your issue of September 5th, and with sympathy the previous article by "...

THE BRITISH INSTITUTE OF PHILOSOPHY

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—In the multitude of causes that appeal through your columns to the British public, Philosophy might seem to be the last that has a claim...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SI R,—I was much surprised to see in the above article in your issue of October 24th, that the word " judgment," which appeared several times in the article, was spelt "...

MILK

The Spectator

. [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, —An American lady is urging us to drink daily at least a quart , of milk. Before any of your readers follow her advice it might be well...

THE RIGHT TO DIE

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sue—Addington in Note on The Golden Ass, Book X, says : " The office of a physician is to cure not to kill, as I have heard tell. many...

POINTS FROM LETTERS

The Spectator

SHIPS v. AEROPLANES. Your " News of the Week " paragraph might be read that the Cyprus garrison was reinforced first by troops sent from Egypt by aeroplane. Actually,. ships...

Page 17

LITERARY SUPPLEMENT

The Spectator

the Sitrtator No. 5,393.] WEEK ENDING SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 7, 1931. [GRATIS

Page 19

Mortmain

The Spectator

After the Deluge. By Leonard Woolf. (Hogarth Press. 15s.) THIS " Study of Communal Psychology," as the sub-title runs, is only the introduction to a work of several volumes, and...

The Interpretation of Shakespeare IF ever the history of taste

The Spectator

in England comes to be written, one of the most illuminating chapters will be headed " Shakes- pearian Criticism." In the present century there have been three marked phases. A....

Page 21

Francois Malaval. A Forgotten Mystic ALL who are interested in

The Spectator

the literature of the spiritual life will welcome this excellent translation of Malaval's little masterpiece. The book is hardly known to modern readers on account of its...

Page 23

" A Noise of Horns and Hunting".

The Spectator

Jorrocks's Jaunts and Jollities and The Analysis of the Hunting Field. By H. S. Surtees. (Eyre and Spottiawoode. Thoughts upon Hunting. By Peter Beekford. (Cape. 15s.) IT is...

The Development of Science

The Spectator

Advancing Science. By Sir Oliver Lodge.. (Berm. 6s.) Two Thousand Years of . Science. By R. Harvey-Gibson and A. W. Titherley. (Black. 12s. 6d.) SIR OLIVER LODGE is known to...

Page 25

Is Old Age Avoidable ?

The Spectator

TEN years ago, Steinach said : I think the day will come 'hen vaso-ligature, or some other process having a like effect., will be undertaken by the State for every man of fifty,...

Portrait of a Lady

The Spectator

Maid in Waiting. By John Galsworthy. (Heinemann. 75. 6d.) Ma. GALSWORTRY is more than a great novelist : he is a contemporary historian, the chronicler of a certain phase of...

Page 26

Rescuing Hamlet

The Spectator

Hamlet : a Study in Critical Method. By A. J. A. Waldock. (Cambridge University Press. 5s.) " IT is strange," notes Mr. Waldoek, " that a play, which depends so much for its...

Page 28

The Spectator

Page 29

The CHRISTMAS NUMBER, which will appear on November zest, will

The Spectator

contain particulars of a special Competition, outside the ordinary series, for which prizes of Do los. and L5 5.r. will be offered.

"Spectator" Competitions

The Spectator

. RULES AND CONDITIONS Entries must be typed or very clearly written on one side of the paper only. The name and address, or pseudonym, of the competitor must be on each entry...

Page 30

Ellen Terry Ellen Terry and Her Secret Self. By Edward

The Spectator

Gordon Craig. , (Sampson Low. 15s.) " I HAD not wished to write this book," says Mr. Gordon Craig : and, while we cannot go so far as to wish it unwritten, since it contains...

Mr. Churchill's New Volume Mn. CHURCHILL'S sixth volume on the

The Spectator

" World Crisis " confirms the expectation that when his work is finished it will be much the best history of the War. Naturally, he has enjoyed great advantages over his...

Page 31

Diluted Socialism

The Spectator

Can Governments Cure Unemployment ? By Sir Norman Angell and Harold Wright. (Dent. 3s. 6d.) SIR NORMAN ANGELL, with the aid of Mr. Harold Wright, has brought out a little book...

Page 32

The Court of Berlin

The Spectator

PRINCE VON BULOW'S second volume, very admirably trans. lated into English, confirms the expectations aroused by the first. His witty and malevolent memoirs of the Court of...

Paneros

The Spectator

Paneros. By Norman Douglas. (Chatto and Windus. 15a.) Ma. NORMAN DOUGLAS is a puzzling literary figure. The author of three early works, Siren Land, Old Calabria, and Fountains...

Page 34

Fiction

The Spectator

The Short Story Great American Short Stories. Edited by Stephen Graham. (Henn. 8s. 6d.) IT will be a good thing when critics stop arguing about what is or is not a short story,...

Page 36

There is little in Justice for Hungary ! by Otto

The Spectator

Legraq (Offices of the Pesti Hirlap, Budapest) that has not appeared in much the same form in the various books, brochures and leaflets of the Hungarian League for Treaty...

Sir Banister Fletcher's History of Architecture must be the most

The Spectator

popular, as it is certainly one of the most respected, of books of its kind. It has been reprinted since the eighth edition of 1928, and now it appears in a ninth edition, still...

SEVEN THOUSAND IN ISRAEL. By S. Fowler Wright. (Jarrolds. 7s.

The Spectator

6d.) The case against birth control put with much disgruntlement. The thesis is laboured, and it is a shock to find an experienced novelist wasting his talent on the false...

SLEEPING ECHO. By Catherine M. Verschoyle.

The Spectator

7s. 6d.) Although this story of a woman who adopts her divorced husband's child moves in an improbably rarefied atmosphere, it has about it a certain wistfulness and grace.

The Dublin Magazine goes from strength to strength. The October-December

The Spectator

number justly gives pride of place to an article by W. B. Yeats, entitled " The Words upon the Window Pane," in which he discusses various aspects of the character of Swift. No...

A labour of love and, therefore, executed with loving care

The Spectator

and the nicest attention to every good technical detail is Mr. James Maclehose's Glasgow University Press, 1638-1931 (Glasgow University Press, 14s.). This famous Press never...

THE SECOND MERCURY STORY BOOK. With an intro- duction by

The Spectator

Robert Lynd. (Longman's. 'is. 6d.)—In this second volume of short stories collected from the London Mercury, its editor, Mr. J. C. Squire, has once more proved that his...

* * * *

The Spectator

The new edition of Alan Butler's The Lives of the Saints, corrected, amplified and edited' by Herbert Thurston and Norah Leeson, has reached its third volume (Burns, Oates and...

Current Literature

The Spectator

HISTORICAL students, whether amateur or professional, will like to know of the American Historical Association's Guid e to Historical Literature, edited by W. H. Allison, S. B....

FORTY STAY IN. By John W. Vandercook. (Harpers. 7s. 6d.)

The Spectator

An insignificant triangle story against a West African background. This with its fevers, white " Coasters, niggers and Syrians is vividly presented.

THUNDER BELOW. By Thomas Rourke. (Chatto and Windus. 7s. 6d.)

The Spectator

A meaty first novel about Venezuela. Mr. Rourke writes vigorously, in a manner distinctly reminiscent of Mr. Hemingway's " Fiesta."

WHICH WAY ? By Theodora Benson. (Gollancz. 7s. 6d.) If

The Spectator

Claudia had managed her week-end differently what would have happened ? Miss Benson ingeniously sup- plies three samples and convinces us rather excessively that insipid...

THE OLD WOMAN TALKS. By F. 0. Mann. (Faber and

The Spectator

Faber. 7s. ed.) Mr. Mann has cleverly grouped a Cockney family and given us an excellent portrait of them through the eyes of their old mother. He writes with sympathy, insight,...

New Novels

The Spectator

CASSANDRA. By Reginald Berkeley. (Gollancz. 7s. 6d.)— By way of inducing in the human sluggard a less hazy perspec- tive of this insensate world of ours Captain Berkeley has hit...

Page 38

Students of economic history will be grateful to Sir Henry

The Spectator

C. M. Lambert for producing, after some twenty years, a second volume of his History of Banstead in Surrey (Oxford University Press, 16s.). Here, again, he prints in full some...

Mr. D. M. Goodfellow's Modern Economic History of South Africa

The Spectator

(Routledge, 10s. 6d.), beginning with the development of the Rand in 1887, is an admirably dispassionate survey of the three main problems of the Dominion—the better use of the...

Mr. Drinkwater has always confessed to an overmastering passion for

The Spectator

genealogies and personal histories. His poetic muse is indeed chiefly inspired by it, gaining therefrom its flavour for localities and place-names. Sooner or later Mr....

Between personalities so diverse as John Leslie, the fighting Bishop

The Spectator

of Raphoe, the diplomatist Bulstrode, Charles Macklin the actor, and Lady Smith (1775-1877) who is now chiefly remembered by Ope's portrait of her, there is no common factor...

To make an interesting book out of the life of

The Spectator

a successful Chancery lawyer, a popular but humdrum M.P., an exem. plary though not brilliant Lord Chancellor, was not an easy task for Sir Charles Mallet, nor an it be said...

Local patriotism, enlisting the services of half a dozen experts,

The Spectator

has made The History of Scarborough, edited by Arthur Rowntree (Dent, 21s.), a model of its kind. In this large and handsome volume the editor and his contributors— Dr. Mortimer...

The successful accomplishment of The Task of Happiness (Student Christian

The Spectator

Movement, .8s. 6d.) is, in the opinion of the headmaster of Eton, largely a matter of good will. Assuming the truth of the Christian religion, in whose Founder " are all the...

Captain Walter H. Parker went to sea at the age

The Spectator

of twelve as an apprentice in a clipper barque of 603 tons. Forty-eight years later he left the seas, his last command being the ' Olympic,' and the last but one the Homeric,'...

The arrival of Mr. Punch's Almanack is always an event

The Spectator

of importance. This year it is especially so : in the hurly-burly of a financial crisis we had almost forgotten that such things existed. In the present issue Mr. Punch is, in...

Page 40

Finance—Public & Private

The Spectator

The Government's Task THE General Election is over ; the crisis responsible for it is still with us ; the mandate asked for by the National Government has been granted in...

The Modern Home

The Spectator

[Tr e shall be pkased to reply to any inquiries arising from the articles we publish on the Modern Home page. Inquiries should be addressed to the Editor, The SPECTATOR, 99...

Page 44

A SUCCESSFUL UNDERTAKING.

The Spectator

The statements made at the recent annual meeting of United Dairies, Limited, fully confirmed the favourable impression which had been created by the Report itself. That document...

B.A. WESTERN.

The Spectator

After dealing with the unfavourable factors, such as the movement in the Argentine Exchange, which had adversely affected the profit-earning power of the company, the Chair- man...

Financial Notes

The Spectator

INVESTMENT STOCKS WEAK. THE most prominent feature in the financial situation, to which a reference is made elsewhere, has been the considerable relapse in the value of the...