24 OCTOBER 1970

Page 4

THE TOWER OF BABEL Babblings of men who speak, but

The Spectator

do not speak the same language The League of Nations was a flop. Has the United Nations, begun twenty-five years ago, been any better? and is it likely that from it will grow,...

Page 6

POLITICAL COMMENTARY

The Spectator

PETER PATERSON Government hurries on apace, mocking all those Labour politicians who only three weeks ago were jeering at three months of drift and inactivity by their...

PORTRAIT OF A WEEK

The Spectator

Canadians were horrified by the murder of Mr Pierre Laporte, Minister of Labour in the Quebec provincial government, and one of the two people kidnapped by cells of the Quebec...

Page 7

'You can't leave the Commonwealth! That's blackmail!'

The Spectator

THE SPECTATOR'S NOTEBOOK

The Spectator

The great Common Market Swindle—it is no less—continues apace. The structure of the swindle, which has been perpetrated by Conservative, Labour, and now Con- servative...

Page 8

Academic freedom and the Socratic ideal

The Spectator

NICOS E. DEVLETOGLOU Some two and a half millennia ago, the charge that 'there is a pestilential busybody called Socrates who fills people's heads with wrong ideas' (Plato,...

Page 10

Mr Nixon's crime bill

The Spectator

LOUIS CLAIBORNE The streets of New York today are perhaps as unsafe as the streets of London in Queen Victoria's time. That would no longer matter much to Mr Nixon, who has...

Our foreign correspondence

The Spectator

AMERICA The last best hope on earth DENIS BROGAN Washington, DC I have been in the United States exactly a fortnight and I leave in exactly a week. This is by no means my...

Page 11

BERMUDA

The Spectator

Another world? DAVID COHEN Having spent a great deal of money on an advertising campaign that proclaimed 'Ber- muda—another world' to attract more tour- ists, the riots in...

Page 12

GOVERNMENT

The Spectator

John Davies and Parliament: Heath's silent verdict ENOCH POWELL The more the new organisation of Whitehall which now confronts the returning House of Commons is studied, the...

CHRISTOPHER HOLLIS

The Spectator

Only a game Who Are the two That Jackie Charlton longed to do? He boasts he'll catch the bastard's shirts And pull at them until it hurts— But only in an international— And...

SOUTH AFRICAN ARMS

The Spectator

Raising the tone By 'a Conservative' The controversy surrounding the decision to sell arms to South Africa has produced much heat and little light. It has induced moral...

Page 13

PERSONAL COLUMN

The Spectator

The Irish idea of justice CONSTANTINE FITZGIBBON The Irish attitude towards the whole concept of justice, and to the whole apparatus of its administration from the policeman...

THE PRESS

The Spectator

Prices and wages BILL GRUNDY The Guardian went up this week by a penny to 9d. Denis Hamilton of the Times Organ- isation recently made a speech in which the question of a...

Page 14

SCIENCE

The Spectator

Death by merger PETER J. SMITH In at least one country in the world, learned scientific journals are offered for sale on railway station bookstalls. Needless to say, it does...

A hundred years ago

The Spectator

From the 'Spectator,' 22 October 1870—There is an idea rapidly gaining ground among our own people, in Germany, and in America which ought to be discussed. Is it not possible,...

Page 16

Mr Worsthorne's memory

The Spectator

Sir: Anthony Lewis's suave letter is another example of what I was complaining about. He argues that I was obviously an unsuitable author of a profile of Enoch Powell for the...

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

The Spectator

From: Brian Inglis, B. Joseph, Pere- grine Worsthorne, Bernard Levin, William Sansom, Patrick Cosgrove, Harry J. T. Blackwood, M. T. Bremridge, J. Reilly, F. P. M. Cook, Ralph...

Jews and fascists Sir: It appears from your colum- nist's

The Spectator

note 'The First Fascist?' in your issue of 9 October, that hoary myths die hard. The Jewish con- cept of a `Chosen People' is poles apart from the Nazi concept of a Herrenvolk....

Porbeagle

The Spectator

Sir : Diana Graves, in her anec- dotage, was right to suspect that the nature of the porbeagle might not be too delicate. Indeed, the por- beagle is sometimes ten feet long, and...

Robert Lowell's public poetry

The Spectator

Sir: I would like to make an obser- vation or two about Mr Martin Seymour - Smith ' s hysterical e ff u- sion which masqueraded, in your issue of 3 October, as a review of my...

Page 17

Nixon's Ego-Politics

The Spectator

Sir: I happened to pick up last week's (3 October) copy of the SPECTATOR and turned to an article of John Graham's about the Ego- politics of Mr Nixon etc. I am afraid that I...

A singular matter

The Spectator

Sir: In re singular/plural, P. N. L. Lycett misapprehends me. Varia- ability and flexibility (highly-prized attributes of English) arc by no means the same thing as mere mental...

Open university

The Spectator

Sir: - The Open University is por- trayed as an excitingly new devel- opment allowing people who never attended a university to study for a degree. There is nothing new about...

Shakespeare and Dr Rowse

The Spectator

Sir: Allow me to protest vehem- ently, if a little belatedly, against your indecent verbal caricature of Dr A. L. Rowse ('Shakespeare and the Elizabethan Historian'), which you...

Palestine

The Spectator

Sir: So much of what is said and written about the Middle East crisis has either an emotional bias or is too complicated to follow. Having studied the complexities of these...

`Conserving the countryside'

The Spectator

Sir: 'It seems to me sometimes that the industrial revolution has left scars not only on England from which her towns and countryside may never recover but also a scar on her...

Page 18

Central Europe and all that

The Spectator

Sir: I was amazed by the para- graph in the 'Spectator's Notebook' (10 October) in which the writer, after recounting highly unflatter- ing anecdotes concerning the Hungarians...

Spiders in baths

The Spectator

Sir: I am intrigued by your correspondent's difficulties in regard to the presence of spiders in his bath. I thought that by now the answer was clear and well known, and I feel...

COMPETITION

The Spectator

No. 627: Fond farewell A fashion which has given so much pleasure to at least half the popu- lation must not go unelegised. Competitors are accordingly in- vited to indite a...

Page 19

Toryism and democracy

The Spectator

JOHN VINCENT The Conservative Party from Peel to Churchill Robert Blake (Eyre and Spottis- woode 60s) There is one aspect to the Conservative party on which fresh thought is...

Page 20

Lusitania

The Spectator

BRIAN CROZIER Salazar and Modern Portugal. Hugh Kay (Eyre and Spottiswoode 85s) It is not, I maintain, a frivolous concern for topicality that makes me start this review of a...

Religion without God

The Spectator

PATRICK COSGRAVE Islands in the Strewn Ernest Hemingway (Collins 40s) Islands in the Stream recounts three episodes in the life of Thomas Hudson, painter. He entertains the...

Page 21

Dickens and the great tradition

The Spectator

JOHN CASEY Dickens the Novelist F. R. Leavis and Q. D. Leavis (Chatto and Windus 50s) The authors ferociously dismiss those critics who 'tell us with the familiar, easy...

Page 22

Bede and the age

The Spectator

of conversion DAVID KNOWLES The World of Bede Peter Hunter Blair (Seeker and Warburg 80s) Bede the Venerable has several titles to fame. He is the first writer (if not the...

Page 23

The imperialism of Red China

The Spectator

TAYA ZINKIN India's China War Neville Maxwell (Cape 100s) Mr Maxwell writes brilliantly. He has made a far better case for the Chinese than they have ever made for themselves....

Page 24

Bourgeois decadence

The Spectator

JOHN BRAINE Bech: A Book John Updike (Andre Deutsch 30s) I can remember the time, discovering Dos Passos, Fitzgerald, Hemingway, Farrell, O'Hara, when the chief feature of...

Page 25

Four lives

The Spectator

MICHAEL WHARTON A.P.H.: His Life and Times Sir Alan Herbert (Heinemann 63s) My Commonplace Book Mary Stocks (Peter Davies 55s) Whatever Happened to Tom Mix Ted Willis (Cassell...

Great Fred for the coffee table

The Spectator

T. C. W. BLANNING Frederick the Great Nancy Mitford (Hamish Hamilton 80s) It would be difficult to write a dull book about Frederick the Great. He lived for seventy-four years...

Page 26

The thrills of politics

The Spectator

DOUGLAS HURD Who Killed Enoch Powell? Arthur Wise (Weidenfeld and Nicolson 30s) Chief the Honourable Minister T. M. Aluko (Heinemann 12s) Political thrillers are so fashionable...

Page 27

Hunting for ideologies

The Spectator

ROGER SCRUTON Exiles and Emigres: Studies in Modern English Literature Terry Eagleton (Chatto and Windus 36s) Except for Conrad, Eliot, and D. H. Law, fence. the 'exiles and...

An acute sense of the general good

The Spectator

A. R. PREST Papers on Planning and Economic Manage- ment Ely Devons edited Sir Alec Cairn- cross (Manchester University Press 60s) Ely Devons first made his mark on a national...

Page 28

A view from the other shore

The Spectator

J. M. ROBERTS The European Renaissance since 1945 Maurice Crouzet (Thames and Hudson 35s) This book must suffer by being launched in the wake of Richard Mayne's tour de force....

Page 29

SAMUEL PEPYS Full of weaknesses empty of priggery

The Spectator

J. H. PLUMB The Diary of Samuel Pepys a new and com- plete transcription edited by Robert Latham and William Matthews (University of California Press) Vols 1-111 (1660-62),...

Page 34

MUSIC Previn on probation

The Spectator

GILLIAN WIDDICOMBE Sometimes I wonder why so much music criticism is so polite. Approximately thirty seconds later I conclude that it must be the side-effects of the...

Cultivating our Garden

The Spectator

or, the Royal Ballet revamped CLEMENT CRISP Am I alone in welcoming the new regime at Covent Garden? I cannot believe so, though the carping, the wailing and gnashing of...

Page 35

THEATRE

The Spectator

Major and minor KENNETH HURREN There are times when I am taken inescapably by the notion that the Royal Shakespeare Company would rather be doing almost anything except...

CINEMA

The Spectator

Bronco bnrcya;Ti PENELOPE HOUSTON It takes some doing these days to bring in a feature film for less than £20,000. (K es, usually and properly saluted as an example of...

ART

The Spectator

Chaff and charm EVAN ANTHONY On the evidence of her work on view at the O'Hana Gallery, Budapest-born Zsuzsi Roboz can be placed firmly in the 'women glib' school of art. Her...

Page 36

TELEVISION

The Spectator

People for sale Patrick Skene CATLING One of the oldest tricks of the journalistic game is to deplore cheesecake while shovel- ling it into the public's insatiable maw. 'Look...

Page 37

MONEY The skeleton at the feast

The Spectator

NICHOLAS DAVENPORT The first ceremonial duty of a Lord Mayor of London is to invite the merchants and bankers of the City to a feast at the Mansion House at which the guest of...

Page 38

ENVIRONMENT,

The Spectator

The making of a Super Minister STANLEY JOHNSON In the big world beyond the basement windows, the environment issue gets bigger and bigger. Both Chataway and Crosland appear,...

Oh Bombay!

The Spectator

From the Financial Times 16 October: LONDON AND BOMBAY £800,000 BID FOR SITA The first deal by London and Bombay In- vestments, which came to the Market only three weeks ago,...

SKIN FLINT'S CITY ). DIARY

The Spectator

I cannot say I shall be sorry if Mr John Davis gives Lord Melchett the push from the British Steel Corporation. He was the appointee of that young buck of the Labour Cabinet...

Page 39

Pamela Vandyke Price

The Spectator

The group of transatlantic tourists in the famous French country restaurant were deferential about the food, knowledgeable name-droppers re wines, gentle in their be- haviour,...

COUNTRY LIFE PETER QUINCE

The Spectator

'How can I stop someone cutting down a tree?' It was the voice of a neighbour which presented me with this question on the tele- phone at breakfast time the other day, and the...

Page 40

TONY PALMER

The Spectator

Someone pointed out to me last week that among the underground newspapers of which I had almost reverentially spoken, there was one that was actually being prosecuted under the...

CLIVE GAMMON

The Spectator

Bailey's Hunting Directory does not have a wide circulation. But, like Wisden and other sporting bibles, it is a compulsive read 'for the dedicated, and it has its moments even...

Page 44

Crossword 1452

The Spectator

DAEDALUS A prize of three guineas will be awarded to the sender of the first correct solution opened on 2 November. (Last week's date should have read 26 October.) Address...