5 DECEMBER 1931

Page 1

An Ambiguous Pledge On the general question of tariffs au

The Spectator

answer given by the Under-Secretary of the Board of Trade on Wednesday opens up a grave prospect if it means what it seems to mean. Tariffs in Europe have been carried to such a...

EDITORLII. AND PUBLISHING OFFICES : 99 flower Street, London; 11'.C.

The Spectator

1.—A Subscription to the SPECTATOR costs Thirty Shillings per annum, including postage, to any part of the world. The SPECTATOR is registered as a Newspaper. The Postage on this...

The Round Table' and After - The three outstanding personalities

The Spectator

_ the closing days of the_ Round Table- Conference .were the Prime Minister, Mr. Sastri and, inevitably, Mr. Gandhi. Mr. MacDonald has done a great - piece of work in carrying...

News of the Week

The Spectator

1 1HE Protectionist movement in this country has already acquired all the characteristics familiar elsewhere. Encouraged by the increases in price it has been . possible to...

Meanwhile the Ministry of Agriculture's list of scheduled imports, combined

The Spectator

with the 15 per cent. quota of_ British wheat in the loaf, is going to send food - prices . up. It is no use being merely doctrinaire about food-taxes. Cocoa and sugar have been...

Page 2

France and the German Situation

The Spectator

M. Laval's stiff refusal to admit priority for Germany's private debts over her reparation obligations has been read with considerable concern and some irritation in both...

The League and Manchuria

The Spectator

The League Council is still in session over Manchuria. If the general situation is not appreciably better it is not appreciably worse. And in one respect, at any rate—the...

Setting Back the Clock The unreasonableness trade unions often exhibit

The Spectator

stimulates employers from time to time to show what they can do in the same direction, and they rarely let themselves be outdistanced. The 48-hour week being a canon of...

Flandin, M. Laval's Finance Minister, displayed a greater sense of

The Spectator

realities (perhaps as result of his flying visit to London) when lie observed to an interviewer that Germany could obviously pay nothing now on either account, but that there...

A Judge on Birth-Control

The Spectator

Mr. Justice McCardie, in another of his many striking judgements, has just expressed himself strongly and sanely on birth-control. He had before him at Leeds Assizes a woman...

Page 3

The Price of Milk The .hard-pressed dairy farmers have found

The Spectator

a measure of relief in the decision of the Joint Milk Committee of the National Farmers' Union to 'raise the price paid by the distributor for milk by fourpence a gallon for...

The Traffic in Drugs The great drug trial at Basle,

The Spectator

a city frequently notorious in connexion With the illicit traffic, demonstrates the success of the international co-operation in drug traffic suppression initiated by the League...

In the Service of Humanity Major-General Sir David Bruce, who

The Spectator

died last week at the age of seventy-six, will always be remembered for his discovery of the cause and nature of three widespread diseases that worked havoc among men and...

Bank Rate 6 per cent., changed from 41 per cent.

The Spectator

on September 21st, 1931. War Loan (5 per cent.) was on Wednesday 95 ; on Wednesday week, 981 ; a year ago, 102 ff. . Funding Loan (4 per cent.) was on Wednesday 821 ; on...

The " Guardian" Our old contemporary, the Guardian, is, we

The Spectator

learn, to reduce its price to twopence with this week's issue. The Guardian was founded in the early years of Queen Victoria's reign, when the Oxford Movement was still...

The Canadian Census Canada has now over ten million people.

The Spectator

The precise total yielded by the Census just completed is 10,853,778, showing a gain of 17.82 per cent. in ten years. Of the total increase of 1,565,295 nearly a third is...

Ancient Manuscripts of the Bible . Many others besides students

The Spectator

of biblical texts and ancient MSS. were thrilled a few days ago by the news of the discovery of 190 new leaves of Greek biblical papyri, fragments of the Old and New Testaments,...

Page 4

The Pledge to India

The Spectator

T HE Round Table Conference has closed on a note of disappointment, relieved by a note of hope. After the Irwin-Gandhi agreement, and the decision of the Indian leader after...

Page 5

A National Health Policy

The Spectator

13Y A MEDICAL CORRESPONDENT. (A F all a nation's material assets, the bodily and mental health of its people is the most important. Wastage of this asset cannot be balanced by...

Page 6

The Week at Westminster

The Spectator

A S was anticipated in these notes, the Government has found little difficulty in framing and announcing a preliminary agricultural policy. Sir John Gilmour is an unimpressive...

Most of the Government's supporters were so thankful for an

The Spectator

announcement of some kind that they welcomed this policy enthusiastically ; and only Liberal feelings appeared to be divided. On the one hand, no one has been stronger in...

More immediately troublesome are the duties on manufactured goods. As

The Spectator

might have been expected, Protectionist members are voicing the outcries of every industry so far left unprotected. This barrage reached its culmination at question-time on...

On Friday the Maxton group boldly attacked the administration of

The Spectator

the so-called Anomalies Act, which was one of the last legislative efforts of the Labour Government. The Act applies special tests to married women and to seasonal workers who...

The production of an agricultural policy has delayed the recess

The Spectator

; but it is probable that in any case Parliament would have had to continue in session to clear up the Round Table Conference. Mr. Churchill and a few friends obtained some...

Page 7

New Homes for Old By F. YEATS BROWN.

The Spectator

A PATHY and ignorance caused the infection of the slums : dirt and darkness have encouraged its growth. It is a disease, hideously like a cancer in the human body, spreading and...

Page 8

A League of Religions

The Spectator

By NORMAN BENTIVICH. rilHE passing of the-thirteenth anniversary of Armistice Day and the approach of the World Disarmament Conference afford an opportunity for considering the...

Page 9

Problems of the Christian Conscience

The Spectator

[ We publish here the ninth article of our Theological Series which we hope will throw light on some of the most disputed questions of Conduct.. Commander Cather is an active...

Page 10

Phnom Penh

The Spectator

BY WINIFRED GALBRAITH. T HE name is alluring. It might be a city of romance and fable ; it might be some unheard-of village in the back of beyond. Indeed it has been both, but...

The Theatre

The Spectator

" The Red Rover's Revenge." A Nautical Drama in three acts, adapted by Peter Godfrey from the play written by the late Edward Fitzball, Esq. At the Gate. Theatre. THE...

Page 11

Correspondence

The Spectator

A LETTER FROM VIENNA. [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sia,—Your interview with Mr. Gandhi, which was reprinted in the Neuc lereu Presse, has made a vital impression on people...

MUSIC In America

The Spectator

MUSICIANS in this country are slowly beginning to realize that Mr. Arthur Bliss' Symphony " Morning Heroes " is one of the most notable English works of the past ten years. When...

Page 12

Poetry

The Spectator

Love Discarnate [A Translation front the Bengali Poem] AViiN the fire-burst of thine anger killed the god of lu. e, 0 Divine Ascetic, the world was haunted by his bodiless...

Tax TONGUE AGAIN. , On Sunday, Miss Hall and Miss

The Spectator

Carsdale spoke for several minutes, the former before the sermon, and the latter at the conclusion. The burden of one lady's discourse was " Rejoice," and of the other's "...

THIEF TRAP.

The Spectator

On Friday, a man went into the shop of a Mr. Holmes, near the foot of the bridge in Leeds, and inquired the price of an umbrella. Mr. H. handed him one, and, while in the act of...

A Hundred Years Ago

The Spectator

THE SPECTATOR," DECEMBER 3ao, 1831. SOMNATLSM. An Irishman, in the employment of Mr. Fitzpatrick, Ship Agent, Cork, took on Sunday sennight to the rather rare amusement of...

Page 13

Country Life

The Spectator

A GI:NJ:Rocs BENEFAcrou. Many people spend large suns on farming, but few endow it. In this small body of benefactors is Sir Horace Plunkett, who most generously established...

Such arguments cannot be thrust aside off-hand. My correspondent is

The Spectator

inclined, I infer, to condemn just one animal, the little owl, in part because he found a nest to be " a perfect shambles of blackbirds' legs, &e." He noticed too, as most...

My correspondent makes the point that the worst enemy of

The Spectator

nesting birds is the motor-car. "I saw one pathetic case this summer where a car knocked down an English partridge when accompanied by its mate and killed it. The other bird...

THE MODEL BUTCHER.

The Spectator

Farmers, and yet more vitally consumers. should be concerned as to the latest evidence (roost of it condensed in a lecture to the Model Abattoir Society during the week) on one...

CHEAP LAND.

The Spectator

On the price of land I have quoted from time to time many examples of the loss of value on the heavy clay soils of the Midlands and Essex, and on the chalk of Wiltshire and...

THE SQUIRREL AND TILE SANCTUARY.

The Spectator

I amaikeitbya naturalist greatly interested in a particular bird sanctuary near London to pronounce on the grey squirrel. Shall it be a Peri, forbidden the sanctuary, under pain...

THE DOWSER'S MYSTERY.

The Spectator

The mystery of the divining rod appears to be agitating public opinion on the Continent as well as in England. In France societies and journals have been started, the evidence...

Page 14

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sur,—The letter from Mr.

The Spectator

Green under the above heading, suggesting a parallel between a man defending a woman attacked by a ruffian and a country going to war in defence of a weaker nation, displays a...

WAR AGAINST THE SOUL [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—With regard to your excellent article in the Spectator of October 31st. I have only been babk in England:a year and a quarter after having lived in Italy for a few years....

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sia,—The danger of analogical

The Spectator

reasoning, when the specimens are not in the same species or directly comparable, is illus. trated in the letter of Mr. H. W. H. Green in your issue of November 28th. He brings...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sur, 11ir. Green quotes

The Spectator

Christ's command not to resist evil, but the whole purpose of his life was to destroy the works of the devil (evil), therefore the command must mean " Resist not evil with evil,...

Letters to the Editor

The Spectator

[In view of the length of many of the letters which we .receive, we would remind correspondents that we often cannot gire space for long letters and that short ones are...

Page 15

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] a,—It is admitted that

The Spectator

betting and gambling are rampant in all classes and are a serious evil. It is also admitted that neither anti-betting leagues nor anti-gambling societies, nor sermdns, nor...

ARE THE B.B.C. TOO CAUTIOUS?

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Mr. Harold Nicolson, writing on the above subject, quotes Horace : " Our minds are stimulated less by aural than by visual impressions,"...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR, —The article by Canon Peter Green, M.A., against betting and gambling, in your issue of November 21st, is so excellent that I venture to suggest it should be reprinted in...

BETTING AND GAMBLING [To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,-

The Spectator

-Excessive gambling, like excessive drinking and smoking, is a serious vice which ought to be eradicated. But just as there is no harm in smoking and drinking in moderation, so...

Page 16

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Snt,—" Things," thought he

The Spectator

of Houndsditch, " is come to a pretty pass," as Calverley's friend Sikes remarked when the Spectator (!!!) perpetrates " all the data is available " on page 660 towards the end...

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.]

The Spectator

SIR,—I was startled to read, under the heading of " The Spectator and The English Language," in the Spectator of November 28th, an astonishingly rude remark about Mr. Harold...

TIIE "SPECTATOR" AND THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Twice in the course of the past few weeks I have found in the Spectator a phrase which has long puzzled me. This phrase I have italicized...

THE BRITISH INSTITUTE OF PHILOSOPHY

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—May I ask you to add to your kindness in publishing the appeal of Professor Alexander and others on behalf of the above by permitting me...

Page 17

WHO ARE THE "DEPRESSED CLASSES IN INDIA "?

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—So far as I have seen, this question does not seem to have been answered in the discussion of the Round Table Conference or otherwise. The...

NERVE-CONTROL IN EAST AND WEST

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR, — In your last issue there is an article headed as above by Mr. Yeats-Brown, full of interest and suggestion. He professes to narrate...

FREE TRADE AND PROTECTION.

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SI11,—Mr. James H. Weager challenges my statement that steel sheets and plates are not the raw material of any considerable industry in this...

BRITAIN'S SURPLUS POPULATION

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—Mr. T. P. Walker, whose letter appears in your issue of October 31st, in referring to Mr. Gabriel Wells' suggestion of transferring our...

Page 18

POINTS FROM LETTERS

The Spectator

In answer to A. M. B. There's something in the British after all."

MANCHURIA

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—It is very regrettable that many people seem to be definitely anti-Japanese as regards the present situation in Manchuria. There are...

HOUSING IN LONDON

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—Mr. Orr's wise and experienced statement is especially timely when national economy is the only alternative to national ruin. With an...

THE CAT IN THE ADAGE

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] Sin,—" Here is that which will give language to your eat."— Would it be good for us if the magic draught Shakespeare evidently had in mind...

A RENEWED CHALLENGE TO THE NEW MINISTER OF HEALTH

The Spectator

[To the Editor of the SPECTATOR.] SIR,—In your issue of November 14th you allowed me to point out what serious trouble was being caused in Wands. worth by the failure to secure...

Page 19

"Spectator" Competitions

The Spectator

RULES AND CONDITIONS Entries must be typed or very clearly written on one side of the paper only. The name and address, or pseudonym, of the competitor must be on each entry and...

Page 20

The Making of History

The Spectator

The Whig Interpretation of History. By N. Butterfield. (Bell. 4s.) By Brigadier General F. J. Moberly. (H.M. Stationery Office. 15s.) Documents Diplomatiques Francais...

Heir . Ludwig on Himself

The Spectator

Gifts of Life. By Emil Ludwig. (Putnam. 21s.) . HERR LUDWIG- has not written as good a book about himself as he has sometimes written about other people. His weak- nesses,...

Page 21

The Devil's Picture Book THERE has been, it would seem,

The Spectator

no adequate book on the history of playing cards published in this country since 1865, and Mr. H. T. Morley can therefore say with justice for his Old and Curious Playing Cards...

Doorways to China

The Spectator

The End of Extraterritoriality in China. By Thomas F. Millard. (A.B.C. Press. 7s. 6d.) MANY of our early Chinese friends and acquaintances," writes the late Mrs. Soothill, " had...

Page 22

Fiction

The Spectator

Four Novels Ma. COMPTON Aiwa - Es - ma has always had a particular gift for evoking the past. His first novel was a tour de force, clearing the way for the three that followed...

The December Reviews

The Spectator

ouR troubles are international and the remedies to be applied must be international. Such is, in effect, the text of the series of thoughtful and informing articles in The Round...

Page 23

AMERICAN BEAUTY. By Edna Ferber. (Heinemann. 7s. 6d.)—Miss Ferber once

The Spectator

more proves herself a con- summate story-teller. She takes the very varied fortune; of a Connecticut farm founded by an Englishman in 1700, and tells of all its strange...

ORDINARY PEOPLE. By Rosita Forbes. (ens-sell. 7s. 6d.) —Straightforward middle-class

The Spectator

people in exacting and exciting situations, moral and physical.

THE SPY NET. By -tired White. (Eyre and Spottiswoode, 7s.

The Spectator

6d.)—The American Secret Service at work, described in an effective but melodramatic story set in Switzerland during the last year of the War.

MISOGYNY OVER THE WEEK-END. By Ronald McNair Scott. (Macmillan. 6s.)—A

The Spectator

house-party novel which consists, as Rodney the misogynist observed, " almost entirely of talk." The formula is as old as Peacock, but the guests are well chosen, and the talk...

COLONEL GRANT'S TO-MORROW. By Graham Farm. (Thornton Butterworth. 7s. 6d.)—The

The Spectator

further adven- tures in love and war of one Colonel Grant, who, gallantly opposing the French Legionaries, wins the hand of an Arab princess and independence for her tribe. By...

NONE OF MY BUSINESS. By David Sharp. (Berm. 7s. 6d.)—An

The Spectator

unusual but inconclusive story • of crime where curiosity plays a predominant part in unravelling the mystery. Well written in an easy flowing style.

HOTEL ACROPOLIS. By Drieu La Rochelle. (Nash and Grayson. 7s.

The Spectator

6d.)—Modern European habits and intrigue look particularly futile when staged in Athens and com- petently produced by M. La Rochelle. The soliloquies of which his cosmopolitan...

EASTING DOWN. By Gregory Stapleton. (Nash and Grayson. 7s. 6d.)—Voyages

The Spectator

between England and China are the joy of Commander Stapleton's heart, and he describes several delightfully. The tea-clipper's race home is particularly fascinating. Sandwiched...

New Novels

The Spectator

THE MAN OF SUBSTANCE. (Hurst and Blackett. 7s. 6d. This long, full novel by Mr. Arthur Hodges, an American author, may be said to have all the virtues but one. It is an...

WIND IN HIS FISTS. By Phyllis Bottome. (Collins 7s. 6d.)—A

The Spectator

Tyrolean romance, complete with extravagant scenery, picturesque peasants and nobles, all in the pure Hollywood manner, in which a handsome villain indulges in a few heroics and...

Page 24

It might seem as though enough anthologies of religious verse

The Spectator

existed to satisfy all tastes : but the compilers of The Sundays of Man's Life (S.P.C.K., 6s.) have hit upon an original idea, which should make a wide appeal to all lovers of...

There can surely be few garden lovers who are not

The Spectator

familiar .with the original from which Leaves from Gerard's Ilerball are -published (t. Howe, 7s. 6d.), following Mr. Marcus Woodward's admirable arrangement. Every gardener...

The next best thing to spending a night in the

The Spectator

woods (or possibly a better one, since cramp, midges and weariness are all enemies of the observer) is to spend a day with Mr. Arthur Thompson's Nature by Night (Ivor Nicholson...

Mr. Eneas Mackay is doing a good service to the

The Spectator

growing spirit of Scots nationalism, to furthering its assertion as an operative reality and not merely as something to be alco- holically exalted on nights wi' Burns, by...

Current Literature

The Spectator

A Goon many modest collectors of English earthenware will be glad to have Mr. G. E. Howard's little book on Early English Drug Jars (Medici Society, lOs. 6d.). It is in truth...

We should not think it necessary to mention Personal Letters

The Spectator

of King Edward VII (Hutchinson, 12s. 6d.) if it were not that the title may lead to an expectation of great interest. Colonel Sewell, the editor, has achieved what we should...

Gallant Gentlemen, by E. Keble Chatterton (Hurst and Blackett, 10s.

The Spectator

6d.) is a popular book on the exploits of the Allied Arms at sea. It is written with probably more knowledge than most of them ; the episodes are well chosen, many of them being...

The ethics of limited editions are hard to determine, but

The Spectator

one thing the purchaser of an expensive book has the right to demand ; and that is that the material shall be worthy of its costly treatment. The Magic Forest, by Christopher...

Mr. Massingham's new book, Birds of the Seashore (Werner Laurie,

The Spectator

lOs. 6d.), is concerned entirely with birds that live on the shore or in marshes near the sea. It is a big book with many illustrations, and is arranged in such a way as to be...

Palestine Illustrated (two volumes), by Frank Scholten (Longman. 84s.). This

The Spectator

is a picture-book de luxe. Mr. Scholten's two stunptuous volumes contain a series of excel- lent photographs, faced throughout by what purport to be apposite quotations from the...

Page 25

LITERARY SUPPLEMENT

The Spectator

int Spectator (7701 No. 5,3971 WEEK ENDING SATURDA Y, DECE I BE R 5, 1931. [GRATIS

Page 26

Ernst Troeltsch

The Spectator

The Social Teaching of the Christian Churches. By Ernst Troeltsch. Translated by Olive Wyon. 2 vols. Halley Stewart Publications, No. 1. (Allen and Unwin. 42s.) IN the days...

Mr. Binyon's Poetry

The Spectator

Collected Poems of Laurence Binyon. Two vols. Vol. I., Lyrical Poems. Vol. II., London Visions, Narrative Poems, Translations. (Macmillan. 10s. 6d. each.) Ma. BINYON'S War...

Page 28

Bolshevism in Perspective

The Spectator

Bolshevism in Perspective. By J. de V. Leder (Allen and Unwin. 12s. 6d.) A CONSPECTUS of the history of Russia since the Revolution is the most difficult of all tasks to...

Page 30

Great Wines and Good Victuals

The Spectator

The Festive Board. Edited by Thurston Macaulay. (Methuen. 5s.) THE processes of wine-making have never been more fully, or more accurately, described than in The Romance of...

By-Ways of Classical Poetry

The Spectator

The Poems of L e onidas of Tarentum. Translated into English 7s. 6d.) • A VICTORIAN statesman was fond of dwelling upon the long succession of English poets from Chaucer in...

Page 32

More Horses

The Spectator

Penny Farthing, with illustrations by Mr. G. D. Armour at his best, is a racing story, in which human character does not count for much, though the people are adequately...

Page 34

Christmas Gift Books

The Spectator

Magic Doorways Manx° the reading of some of the innumerable books written for children, we have been reminded of Teimiel's picture of Alice—the one that shows her waiting by...

Children's Verses

The Spectator

THE task of writing verse that will be acceptable to children is a problem so difficult of solution that it is extraordinary that so many people attempt it. It is moreover an...

Page 36

This Year's Boyish Hero

The Spectator

THE fair and confident profile of the boy in Miss Ivy Bolton's Shadow of the Crown (Longman, 8s. 6d.), appears on the jacket, and hints at the string of brave deeds against...

Page 38

INTERNATIONAL FINANCE.

The Spectator

If the home situation shows little sign of rapid improve, ment in industry, the overseas situation provides even less ground for encouragement. Messages from abroad on the...

INCOME TAX DEMANDS.

The Spectator

The change in sentiment since last month almost suggests the reply that the former buoyancy of the industrial share market was based on the expectation of definite currency...

* * * *

The Spectator

BRITISH OVERSEAS BANK. In these days of reduced earnings and, in some cases. lower dividends by even the older generation of financial institutions, shareholders of the British...

LITTLE BENEFIT FROM DEPRECIATION.

The Spectator

Unemployment, another factor contributing to our financial crisis, has also been a potent influence in the industrial share .market, for although the decline in the totals of...

Finance—Public & Private

The Spectator

The Investor and Sterling A SIGNIFICANT change which has taken place in the Stock Markets during the past week or so illustrates the danger, in investment, of always adopting...

Financial Notes

The Spectator

MARKETS AND STERLING. BUSINESS on the Stock Exchange has continued on a very small scale, but the gilt-edged market has shown itself some- what less sensitive to movements in...

Page 40

SOUTH AFRICAN COAL MINLNG.

The Spectator

No reference was made by Sir Edmund Davis, the Chairman of the Wankie Colliery Company, at the meeting on Tuesday, to the effect upon the company or upon the position of South...